Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids need to be bored

35 replies

onelittlefrog · 26/07/2021 18:32

My cousin has been moaning on social media about the 6 week holidays and what she is going to do with her children the whole time.

My mum has interjected and said "Just leave them to it. Kids need to experience boredom. Tell them to go and read a book or make their own fun, that's what I always used to do".

Now this sounds fair enough on the surface... except when I was a kid I remember being so bored in the holidays because she would rarely do anything at all with us kids. I have very few memories of even playing games or going out for a walk with my mum because she usually told me to go off and entertain myself.

Generally I did fine with this and was quite a self sufficient kid. I played out, read, and had friends... but I would also have loved my mum to do more stuff with me as a kid! Some of my siblings used to get incredibly bored and really struggle.

So, is this an excuse for lazy parenting? Or is she right that kids should just be left to their own devices?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DameAlyson · 27/07/2021 23:47

I do think being bored is important. Knowing how to exist without endless stimulation is an essential skill.

And having time to think and reflect and 'stand and stare'.

RandomUsernameHere · 27/07/2021 22:57

Agree with others it's about having a balance. It's great if they can do lots of fun activities but they also need to learn to create their own fun and play by themselves.

NeedNewKnees · 27/07/2021 22:34

I do think being bored is important. Knowing how to exist without endless stimulation is an essential skill. Much of adult life isn't that bloody thrilling; if we raise a generation unable to tolerate bored we are doing them a huge disservice

dottymac · 27/07/2021 22:31

When my boys are bored they wreak havoc 🤦 so that phrase is b.s. And when we were kids you were always out playing and in each others houses. Times are different now, and even though I live in a village, I don't know/trust everyone and I certainly wouldn't let my 2 wander about the streets alone at their age. It's certainly a different era. So I think it's needs to be a balance, it's not easy though - I'm already into week 3 of a very long almost 9 week summer holiday with the kids, due to a 2 week isolation right before they broke up. Running out of steam already 😬

honeylulu · 27/07/2021 07:33

I agree with all the PPs saying there needs to be balance.
My mum looked down on other parents who "farmed out" or "dumped" their children in childcare but in fact she had to work (mainly from home) and in the holidays we had to stay upstairs in our rooms and keep very quiet. When she went on call outs we went with her and had to stay in the car. We were expected to read or play very quietly. I loved reading but all day every day is a bit much! The holidays really dragged and we were desperate to go back to school. We weren't allowed to watch TV in the daytime either because that was "common". We weren't allowed to play out in the street because that was "common". The irony of my mum's views on childcare is that we would have LOVED to go to holiday club.

We occasionally had friends to play (maybe once each holiday) or went on a day out (usually once in the summer holiday). Being taken to the cinema or the park was really rare, I mean less than once a year, because mum found kids' stuff tedious.

I don't think kids should be taken out for treat days all the time as then they get taken for granted and there is nothing special left to do plus it can be very expensive. But they do benefit from getting out of the house. I do take mine out regularly to the park and for a run around in the woods and even if I've got something else to be getting on with I will set aside half an hour or so to do a jigsaw, build a marble run or play Connect 4 etc. They've just got really into card games and Blackjack is a current favourite. Often if I start them off with something they will then stick with it for quite a while without nagging for screens.

I don't always feel I have it entirely right and they probably do have too much screen time overall but they seem much happier than me as a child!

BogRollBOGOF · 26/07/2021 20:08

I agree with balance. I'm at home with the DCs all holiday. DS2 needs more social input than DS1 so he gets some sports club days. We'll have a family holiday and I'll do some bigger days out, but I'll do a mix of smaller outings (like parks, swimming) and mix up the timings so there's not too much rushing or huge blocks of time at home (especially as DS1 has ASD and gets overwhelmed.

They do need tech to be switched off and remotes hidden and that's when the play happens. They love basic items like boxes and sticks.

Last year was too much boredom though. By the time we got to 2-3 months of playgrounds being banned and no external social input, they seemed to forget how to play, and DS2's behaviour was depressed (lethargic, angry, rude) and they lost interest in everthing except screens and seemed to lose creativity. It came back a bit in September and dwindled in the winter, but is really back since life became more stimulating in April and DS2 finally made some new friends.

ObviousNameChage · 26/07/2021 19:57

@Fernando072020

My mum was lazy parent. Unless it was a movie with ice cream, or a cinema trip, she never did anything with me or took me anywhere. i used to feel so sad that my friends we're off out doing these really cool days out and I did nothing. It's ok for kids to sometimes be bored, but all the time is ridiculous and lazy parenting
Cool days out like what? Did you ever tell her? Did you ask her?
Pinchoftums · 26/07/2021 19:52

100% balance. Some stuff with us (caravan in Wales, some day trips, some swimming, games in the garden etc). Some times help them with sort out meeting friends etc and sometimes nothing. No screens, no phones just need to sort themselves out.

chunderwunder · 26/07/2021 19:41

@Fernando072020

My mum was lazy parent. Unless it was a movie with ice cream, or a cinema trip, she never did anything with me or took me anywhere. i used to feel so sad that my friends we're off out doing these really cool days out and I did nothing. It's ok for kids to sometimes be bored, but all the time is ridiculous and lazy parenting
Your poor mum. She took you to the cinema and bought you ice cream yet you wanted a cool mum doing cool things.
Fernando072020 · 26/07/2021 19:20

My mum was lazy parent. Unless it was a movie with ice cream, or a cinema trip, she never did anything with me or took me anywhere. i used to feel so sad that my friends we're off out doing these really cool days out and I did nothing. It's ok for kids to sometimes be bored, but all the time is ridiculous and lazy parenting

icedcoffees · 26/07/2021 19:11

Like everyone has said, it's about balance.

Kids need to learn to be bored, though. Having 24/7 entertainment is no good for anyone. I find saying "if you're bored, you can help me with the housework" to be a very helpful way of getting them to find something to do Grin

RaindropsOnRosie · 26/07/2021 19:03

Boredom encourages their creativity and imagination. It's very unlikely that a child with toys and a parent around will be truly bored. Unless they're sat in a dark, empty room by themselves, they'll be fine.

chunderwunder · 26/07/2021 19:02

Depends on your circumstances doesn't it. I have to work, thankfully still from home, but that means my kid's got to spend time each day amusing himself. I'll take some leave but I can't take six weeks off.

There is no other parent to help so.. what can you do? I can't afford daily holiday camp.

Merryoldgoat · 26/07/2021 18:57

@tigger1001

I lived in a close and we could spend literally all day skipping. Start of the holidays everyone’s mum would get a length of washing line we could use as rope and that was us golden.

We used to drag our bikes up to the top of a hill and the cycle down as fast as we could and skid to a stop on our sides.

Ylvamoon · 26/07/2021 18:55

It's also about developing self motivation.

A child that is constantly entertaned may never learn the process of being bored, looking around for something to do and then getting to do the activities/ tasks.

This can vary from reading to building something with bricks or seeking out friends and meet up in the park to play football (& and do loads of other mischief!).

PumpkinPie2016 · 26/07/2021 18:53

Definitely about balance. I enjoy the summer holidays as I am a teacher so it's lovely to be able to have some real quality time with DS.

I do a lot with him in the holidays - not necessarily anything expensive- might be a walk, playing a board game, simple baking etc. but I do aim to do something with him every day. He does also have periods of amusing himself which he is happy to do.

We are away at the moment and went out to a museum this morning. Then came back to our cottage for lunch and to chill for the afternoon-he has happily played with his minecraft figures for ages!

I wouldn't want to do nothing at all with him.

Baystard · 26/07/2021 18:52

There's a balance, as others have wisely said.

You said you never got to do anything OP and I bet if, amongst days of being left to entertain yourself, you'd had a day out somewhere and done fine things, you'd really remember it. Equally I bet that if you'd done exciting things every day it would just feel normal and they wouldn't stand out.

tigger1001 · 26/07/2021 18:51

@Merryoldgoat

I did barely anything in the summer except played outside with friends and read. I loved it. It was great

Hours skipping, reading, roller skating, on my bike etc.

My DH is of the ‘occupy the kids’ camp and it drives me insane because there’s too much pressure.

This sounds like my summer holidays! Was rarely indoors. Loved being out walking/on my bike/skates etc.
tigger1001 · 26/07/2021 18:50

I do think it's finding the balance. It's not ideal having things planned for every minute and kids do need to realise that parents don't always have a) money to entertain them day and night and b) time to dedicate to endlessly entertaining a child as work etc gets in the way. Boredom lets kids use imagination.

It's also not ideal going the other way and never spending time with them either.

Steelesauce · 26/07/2021 18:45

All about balance. Half a day doing 'something' and the rest relaxed. Or a busy day or 2 followed by a relaxed day or 2. Kids need time to be bored but they also get into mischief if left to be bored for too long!

millymollymoomoo · 26/07/2021 18:44

Kids define need to be bored. They also need time sometimes to make their own amusement and I don’t agree parents constantly entertaining their children
But as above a balance us good - some days they should entertain themselves others have things arranged and go out together or something

Merryoldgoat · 26/07/2021 18:43

I did barely anything in the summer except played outside with friends and read. I loved it. It was great

Hours skipping, reading, roller skating, on my bike etc.

My DH is of the ‘occupy the kids’ camp and it drives me insane because there’s too much pressure.

ObviousNameChage · 26/07/2021 18:43

It depends on the child too. My dad played with me up to a certain age (around 7?) ,mum never did. But I never needed her to. I was either out all day with my friends or happily playing by myself,reading a book etc. Never needed much entertaining.

Did you ask her to do stuff with you? Did she know you were unhappy,lonely, wanting to spend more time with her?

TopOfTheHour · 26/07/2021 18:41

I have given up taking my teen kids out other than to a local cafe. This is because they moaned when I used to take them out for the day on the train or even to something more local. Sports camps were always looked down upon.
They are ok chauffered door to door but seemed to descend into mulish obstinacy the moment anything was slightly more demanding.
So yes they will probably end up saying I took them nowhere. 🤷

VanGoSunflowers · 26/07/2021 18:41

Definitely agree with ‘it’s a balance’

Too much either way can be detrimental.