Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To advise my soon against an apprenticeship in customer service?

136 replies

BoltonDoowar · 26/07/2021 17:07

DS dropped out of college at 17 and is now 18. He has average GCSE’s. His girlfriend is 14 weeks pregnant.

Despite applying to loads of full-time ‘starter’ jobs, he can’t even secure as much as an interview for a 9-5 call centre type thing. Due to having a child on the way he does not want part-time. He wants to be able to afford a flat to rent with his girlfriend. If they can’t do that by the time baby is born me and the girlfriend’s parents will still have them of course but they actively want their own place with their baby. And I think me and the girlfriend’s parents both mutually agree that while we won’t kick them out, we’d like them to actively start putting plans in place as we both have younger teens to think about as well.

DS is becoming disheartened. There are plenty of hospitality jobs about but he’s had a couple of interviews where they’ve been listed as full-time waiter and then at the interview he finds out it’s 15 hours a week. He wants an office day job.

He’s now looking at apprenticeships and has been offered one at a local office. It will be a mix of customer service and sales. Except it pays the apprentice wage of £4.30. The job description also basically says he’ll be a normal worker at the office and then will do one day a week at a training centre. It sounds like the office will do bugger all training themselves. He’ll get “Level 2 Customer Service” afterwards. I feel that’s basically meaningless, for roles like that they don’t want specific qualifications!

Before people say it’s not up to me, DS came to me frazzled asking for advice. I think it’s all a bit of a ploy for some cheap labour. He will be earning about bugger all a day for 7.5 hours work. DS’s plan is to use it for the experience and then once closer to baby being due he’ll apply for other office jobs.

I feel it’s a complete waste of time. If he wants to do that he might as well do one of the hospitality jobs for 15 hours a week and earn more than the apprenticeship and then move on in a few months. That way he’d have much more time in the day to support his girlfriend who is having a hellish pregnancy so far and apply for more suitable jobs to support them.

I’ve told DS I only think he should do it if he explains he has a baby on the way and therefore needs minimum wage because he’s not a typical ‘school-leaver’ who can get by fine on £4.30 for the experience. I think they may still end up taking him because they stupidly let slip at interview that DS is the only person who applied (and tbh, I’m not really surprised because I bet even kids can see right through them). We also both had a chat with his girlfriend today because obviously she should get a say as well and she agrees with me that’s it’s only worth doing if he explains his circumstances to negotiate being allowed minimum wage. If it was a proper apprenticeship which would help him get his foot in the door in a good sector and be an investment for the future of his family it’d be a different matter. But it isn’t.

Any thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yellowhighheels · 29/07/2021 11:33

OP, I'm really glad you've come round to the idea of the apprenticeship. When you're starting out, very few options are perfect (unless you get on some stellar grad scheme) and it's a question of looking at what will be the most solid first building block for a successful career, then starting at the bottom and proving yourself. I think out of his choices, this has the best potential and would be a wise decision. Really hope it goes well for him and his GF feels better soon Flowers

BoltonDoowar · 28/07/2021 18:22

He’s doing the hospitality job to help pay for baby things alongside the apprenticeship and reckons he’ll sack that evening iob in once baby is here. GF has had to go on the sick from her job due to awful pregnancy symptoms but will still get some kind of government income.

At least once he’s done the first year he’ll get minimum wage.

OP posts:
Angrycat2768 · 28/07/2021 17:28

The Customer Services apprenticeship at L2 will give him a good grounding and work experience in the area, which is invaluable. Do his 'average' GCSE's include grade C or equivalent in English and Maths? If they don't, he will have to do the equivalent Functional Skills qualifications in order to get the apprenticeship. Without English and Maths at grade C he won't be getting very far in even entry level jobs, so just on that basis the apprenticeship is worthwhile. The L3 Customer Service is also a good next step and the equivalent to A Levels. I agree the wage isn't great and after a few months I would be asking to be put up to minimum wage. He should also be doing some training at work, as if it is done correctly, his apprenticeship coursework has to relate to his work, and he will be observed at work by an external assessor. People on Mumsnet seem to think anything that isn't a University degree is a load of crap, based on no information or experience whatsoever.

Scottishshopaholic · 28/07/2021 17:25

It’s a really difficult situation and it sounds like he is prioritising the ‘sociable’ hours above anything else. I get that he wants to be home on the evenings, because that’s what the rest of world wants. But even if he is working 2-10pm he’ll still get to spend time with his gf and baby in the morning.

The fact that he is already saying he will use this as experience and apply for something better once the baby comes is telling that he knows he won’t be happy there. And if he leaves so soon he won’t be getting the qualification (even though it’s questionable if this is any use). I have had only sticking at a place for 6 months and then trying to move onto somewhere else turned against me in an interview and it’s really difficult to convince them you’ll be loyal (especially if that’s the only job he’ll have had).

I take it because of the terrible wage he won’t be looking to find his own place whilst working there? I’m sure you are already encouraging him to save every penny he can and getting him to get his name on lists for social housing etc.

BoltonDoowar · 28/07/2021 17:19

I still don’t think a job like this needs an apprenticeship, but some posters woke me up to the fact that these are the options we have before us and that’s that, so to speak. I think it’ll be great for him to get in an office at 18

OP posts:
BoltonDoowar · 28/07/2021 17:14

I have warmed to the idea of the apprenticeship thanks to some posts on this thread. My worry was just that he was being taken advantage of for cheap labour.

OP posts:
BoltonDoowar · 28/07/2021 17:12

@Scottishshopaholic It’s 8:15 to 4:45. So not 9-5 but same thing really. The office shuts at 5, it’s not a call centre as such and is quite a small team.

OP posts:
Scottishshopaholic · 28/07/2021 17:03

Is your son 100% sure that this office apprenticeship is 9-5? It sounds like his motivation for taking this is based purely on the basis it’s 9-5 so he can spend money with the gf and baby.

I’ve worked in call centres for both sales and customer service and it was nowhere near 9-5. Finishing up at 8:30pm most of the time. If you think most people work 9-5, so they’ll be calling their energy supplier after work to sort something out. Or outward sales get most people picking up the phone once they’ve finished work.

Sales is honestly a cut throat environment and as an inexperienced 17 year old I I can imagine he’d find it quite tough to start up in, as welll as having the added pressure of a baby on the way.

Can he drive? Has he thought about working for water/gas board, telecoms contractor? These jobs are generally 9-5 with the option of OT at weekends or nightshift.

I know people have mentioned trades such as plumbing etc, but let’s be honest they are really competitive and the fact he has dropped out of college will go against him.

I know people have mentioned hospitality and in some areas they are crying out for staff. Has he specifically thought about working in a hotel? I believe there are lots of opportunities for progression in that industry.

But most importantly, whatever he choose now does not define the rest of his life! I love my job currently, but I hadn’t Even considered it when I was 17. I had no qualifications which were helpful towards my current job either.

RhonaRed · 28/07/2021 15:23

Sounds like a plan.
Good luck to him!

BoltonDoowar · 28/07/2021 15:21

He’s doing the apprenticeship and his friend is trying to get him some bar work at his evening job.

OP posts:
Sickoffamilydrama · 28/07/2021 10:48

I would go for the apprenticeship, you say it's an easy job and doesn't need a qualification but being able to do both sales and customer service properly is a real skill. It will also open up other doors and means he can then go for an NVQ level 3. It's a stepping stone unfortunately at the moment on paper he's not very employable. He maybe a good kid with a great work ethic but employers will be looking at what is tangible which is that he's a school drop out with only average GCSES.

It may sound harsh but that is the reality and what people will see. Also lots of employers have had their fingers burnt over the last few years regarding apprentices/ young employees, they seemed to funnel the troublesome kids into apprenticeships rather than getting to the route of the problems which leaves employers dealing with them. Certainly his current record would set alarm bells off for us and we probably wouldn't offer an interview as we've now had 4 apprentices with similar backgrounds who struggled at school everyone of them has been loads of work and very work shy.
We will probably be sacking number 4, number 1 disappeared to a "better job" came back 1 month later asking for his old job back, number 2 didn't do the college work for the apprenticeship then just disappeared. Number 3 just vanished after seeming to come in whenever they fancied. Number 4 keeps asking for last minute holidays leaving us short and if we refuse says he's Ill with stress (but hasn't accessed any support for his stress), but wants a payrise as he works so hard.

We are a good employer, who wants to support the next generation and help them, we also pay well, however we aren't there to babysit them and hand everything to them on a plate which seems to be the expectations of these kids.

Getting some kind of qualifications will show employees he's worth taking a risk on.

ikeepseeingit · 28/07/2021 08:11

Tbh if I were him I would take it. After a year he will be on minimum wage with a full time job and a level 2 that he didn’t have, as well as being able to put office work experience on his CV. Office work is in such high demand that graduates and part timers with experience will snatch their hands off for a full time job. It’s also a great way for him to get his foot in the door. Could he go into a more specialised level 3 and get an a level equivalent after a year? I think that is more useful long term, and would show future employers that he’s motivated.

I think long term he is far better off with this apprenticeship, even at £4.30. He will be 19 and on minimum wage in a year, and he could save up for 6 months and move out afterwards. He is so much better off going for something he wants later down the line that isn’t perfect now.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/07/2021 07:45

Well, this is what's on offer, it's what he's been able to find and get. It doesn't sound brilliant but it's something.

He might be able to do the job without qualifactions but getting the qualification is the solid evidence employers need that he can do the job - not just that he can do data entry etc but also that he can be reliable and stick with it.

It's not ideal and I understand your doubts but for goodness sake don't let him know about them! You are not doing him any favours by putting down the work and qualification that he can sign up for.

21Bee · 28/07/2021 07:41

@IamtheDevilsAvocado it was in administration. I didn’t need anyone to tell me how to file or type notes realistically but the apprenticeship and experience gained from it helped me get into university.

When I was applying for graduate jobs my apprenticeship job was constantly asked about and helped me to get a job many months before I graduated.

Gaining a qualification can only benefit OP’s son, having a child may well be the motivation he needs to aim higher. Getting some dead end, part time waiting job isn’t going to help him. The minimum wage is about £4.50 anyway so for the difference of .20 an hour he’ll be throwing away a good chance to further.

girlmom21 · 28/07/2021 06:57

@Rudeppl how's he going to support his young family?

Rudeppl · 28/07/2021 00:34

Keep him at home and encourage him to go back to college

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 28/07/2021 00:22

@21bee
Well done on earning 60k before you're 25 and doing this on the back of a modern apprenticeship.
Was this apprenticeship in customer care? If it was, I stand corrected.

I can 'judge' as I see many companies exploiting young people for jobs where there isn't an awful lot to learn... It's not a trade or profession, unless the definitions have massively changed.

I also did loads of customer facing work in my teens....we were expected to learn on the job quickly and we did. I certainly didn't need /expect an apprenticeship and neither did the dozens of other busy people around me... We were paid the going rate. For people who wanted to get promotion they did evening classes. It's what I did and then went off to university and completely changed career.

Wheresmrpenguin · 27/07/2021 07:55

I've got 15 years of strong retail and office experience and struggling to find those ' easy entry level' jobs he's been applying to and you seem to think he is above. He's better off applying for small hospitality jobs and gaining experience that way, working his way up for a bit and they usually have lots of over time and sick cover to get enough hours.
NVQs usually need you to be doing the job and using the experience you gain as your evidence so he'd probably need something to start with.

StatisticallyChallenged · 27/07/2021 07:48

"I don’t understand why it can’t just be a minimum wage job"

Chances are if they had instead advertised a minimum wage admin/customer service job then he wouldn't even have got an interview. They'd have been inundated with applications from grads who can't get a grad role, people with experience but currently working part time, people made redundant during covid, folk leaving roles like hospitality, people (mostly women) returning to work after a career break...he wouldn't have been in the running.

abstractprojection · 27/07/2021 05:17

I was once asked at a cinema if I there was there for an apprenticeship, no I wasn’t, but thought this has got out of hand apprenticeships are supposed to be for trades and professions not selling popcorn on the cheap

With a baby on the way I’d be trying to guide him (as I’m sure you are) towards something that can support a family even if not right away rather then trap him in low wages.

ThisIsSylviaDaisyPouncer · 27/07/2021 00:25

I don’t think many people on this thread realise how demanding customer service roles can be. I’m sure there are some smaller companies where all that is required is a great phone manner and the ability to write down order entries. However most modern call centres require a high level of sales or problem solving ability, wide ranging product and technical knowledge and most importantly the resilience to deal with the general public (who hold views similar to the OP, very often). An easy job it is not and that is why some of the largest contact centre employers in the country take on approx 1 out of every 15 people who apply. Similarly while there is no doubt wages can be low at the start, there are many well paid rungs above it on the ladder. Contact centre staff can go into jobs like training, internal comms, knowledge management (ie the people who write the scripts and support for the agents), workforce planning, and so on, as well as other business functions like digital sales and service, marketing etc. It’s one of very few functions as well where it’s quite possible to go from an entry level position to managing a team of hundreds or even thousands of people.

OP I agree the salary is unappealing and that’s important to your son right now but long term I think there are very decent prospects in customer service and it’s a shame to read you being so dismissive of it.

whatsmyusername · 26/07/2021 23:26

We have taken on lots of apprenticeships over the years at work in Customer Services at the apprenticeship wage. I can honestly say that the young staff are hard work, it really is not the same as taking on somone who has experience in a job and has confidence to speak to people on the phone etc. While I do understand the point about the rate of pay as its already been said they do have to do training which is being paid also and they are more of a drain on the resources while being trained up. If Customer Service is something you want to do, do it, its a foot in the door and for the staff at work it has as lead onto bigger better things both internally and externally. The key thing is that finishing the apprenticeship with good attendance and a good reference shows commitment and will make him more employable in the future. He needs to work hard at the job to prove he is a valuable asset to ask for a higher wage or long term employment. He could hold out for a job Mon Fri 9-5 but in all honesty they are a rare for his specific situation in this field (no experience young etc), alot of Customer service jobs are evenings and weekends too. Persoanlly I'd take it and if he needs more money get a part time job in hospitality or simular along side.

Also worth joining all the local agencies as they may have something that comes up but most companies will want experience which he currently doesn't have, as good as you think he is they don't know him or if he will bother to even turn up.

On the positive the actual apprenticeship is fairly easy and everyone I've worked with passed without problem.

thevassal · 26/07/2021 23:07

@BoltonDoowar

The thing is I’ve done similar work myself, basic customer service and I don’t see how an apprenticeship is necessary.

He’ll need to be trained up on the system they use for putting orders on, that’s hardly rocket science. Basic data entry. Even the customer service aspect is mainly forwarding them. A bit of product knowledge etc. Just because he’s young doesn’t mean it’ll take any longer for the information to sink in than a 25 year old who’s coming from a non-office job.

I don’t understand why it can’t just be a minimum wage job. Also to the poster who called me cheeky, I never said I expect DS deserves me because he’s knocked somebody up Hmm I said that there is no incentive for anybody to take the apprenticeship, especially not DS, when they could do something that will help build a better paying career and earn the same doing an evening job on the side, so they can’t be surprised that they only got one application.

Op as well as the "additional circumstances" (excellent euphemism for "got my teen girlfriend knocked up") comment you also literally said "I’ve told DS I only think he should do it if he explains he has a baby on the way and therefore needs minimum wage because he’s not a typical ‘school-leaver’ who can get by fine on £4.30 for the experience." What is that if not saying "the amount you're offering would be fine for a normal 18 year old but my son should be paid more because he's going to be a dad?"

You keep saying that the work will be simple but that doesn't matter. Basic entry level office jobs often ask for degrees these days. Your son doesn't even have a levels. It's probably not a choice of the office choosing minimum wage vs apprentice wage for the same job, but apprentice vacancy or not having that job filled at all, because at apprentice wage they can just about afford it and probably claim some sort apprentice subsidy, at minimum wage its not worth it.

BoltonDoowar · 26/07/2021 23:05

Yes I suppose one thought is using the office apprenticeship to get his foot in the door and then an evening bar job (there’s plenty of those types of jobs round here). Best he does that now rather than when baby is here.

OP posts:
WeebleGirl · 26/07/2021 22:59

Myself and a couple of friends did this after leaving school. Quite a long time ago admittedly. All of us went on to sales / sales admin roles within IT/ Tech.

The apprentice salary is rubbish. That's what we were on give or take a few pence 15 years ago.. (South of England). I'd expect it to be a bit more than that now. Worth negotiating a bit, but I would say he should take the job regardless and keep applying elsewhere. 6 months in the role should be enough. A Customer Service NVQ is ultimately useless, but good to say he's passed some modules in it when applying for other jobs.

If he's desperate for money a second part time cleaning job / bar work would top him up to save for baby things. I don't think that a hospitality job alone is going to be the best experience to land a nice office role later.

Swipe left for the next trending thread