Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To mention some water safety issues we all need to know?

356 replies

Northernlurker · 26/07/2021 16:56

Having read of some awful tragedies over the weekend with open water I thought I would start a thread with a few points and others can add. Because not everybody has had the same exposure to open water risks so what is common sense to one person is utterly unknown to others.

Open water in the UK is cold. Really cold. Even on sunny days. The deeper you go, the colder. This can take even fit and well people by surprise.

Don't jump in to unknown water ever. We are a rocky country populated by messy people. Water hides rocks, logs, metal and all manner of hazards.

Piers and jetty lead out from the shore to deep water so boats can be accessed. Don't regard them as an extension of the shore. The water will be both deep and cold.

Swim parallel to the shore, not out to sea.

No inflatables in the sea ever.

Tides move faster than you can walk, know what your exit route is.

If you can't swim, don't go out of your depth. Don't try and help people in trouble. You help just as much by fetching help or fetching items people in the water can hold on to.

Make sure your teenagers know these principles.

And remember 'float to live'

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
LuxOlente · 26/07/2021 20:29

I wonder if the recent fad encouraging people to go wild swimming could be to blame for people thinking open water isn't so dangerous?

If people do their research and know what they're doing then maybe 'wild swimming' is alright, I don't know. But now we've got entire families diving into lakes and drowning. It can't be all that safe to condense the activity into pithy Pinterest quotes.

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/07/2021 20:29

I really wish people (and by that I mean authorities as well as just normal people) would not spread lies.

These lies about 'all water outside in the UK is barely above freezing' which I hear repeated so often I've lost count - it isn't true, the river temps near me this last week have been over 19C, thats a LONG way off freezing and it's higher in still water with full sun on it, much much higher.

What is true is that water will sit in layers of different temperatures and if you dive into water even if you have acclimated to the surface layers, in some places you can dive into some pretty cold water. Still no where near freezing of course.

Then theres the bullshit discussed about mysterious currents and undertows and whirlpools in lakes and quarries that fill from rainwater or springs and have no such things.

Might as well discuss monsters and man eating prehistoric creatures too...

What these lies do is switch peoples brains OFF to the truth. Tell people lies that they can easily determine for themselves are lies, and they are not going to believe anything else you say either.

If we educated people on some simple stuff to stay safe in the water, things like checking entry and exit points, swim with a friend, acclimate slowly, swim within your physical capabilities, build up swim fitness gradually, don't dive into water you don't know VERY well... we'd save a lot more lives than the posters telling lies to frighten people into not swimming.

We have excellent models for safer outdoor swimming from much of europe and also canada - why on earth can't we follow it.

TSSDNCOP · 26/07/2021 20:26

I miss the horror safety films we used to have before every summer holiday.

You LEAVE that frisbee on the pylon

You NEVER run a level crossing

Etc

It's 45 years later and I still think "Charlie says" when I see an electricity substation

SweetPetrichor · 26/07/2021 20:25

We do water training for our job and our trainer - a rescue diver - basically said his role is 99% recovery rather than rescue. Unless professional help is right there, you’re screwed. Do not swim in open water, do not try to rescue anything from water at all, basically, stick to paddling!
The most common issue is people swimming out into a body of water, then finding how cold it is, your body struggles in the cold, you flounder and drown. He strongly emphasised that you should never try to go in and rescue someone, because you will experience the exact same and now there’s two tragedies. Stay on dry land and throw something to the person in difficulty. We have rescue divers on hand, and I still have a healthy fear of ending up in open water!

CorianderBee · 26/07/2021 20:22

[quote Nicknacky]@CorianderBee That’s horrific, where?[/quote]
Oh, just looked again and I got the year wrong. It was today's date but a few years ago actually!

Wantingtogetitright · 26/07/2021 20:20

@Grenlei happened to me in a hotel in Scotland as a child!

@roguetomato did you lose your dad? :(

viques · 26/07/2021 20:19

My scariest swimming moment was as a non swimmer aged about 11. I had a rubber ring around me, I was trying to swim with it and it slipped down around my legs, legs went up, head went down. I can still remember the panic as I tried to kick the ring off, it was harder to do than you would think. And this wasn’t in the sea, a river or a busy public pool. It was a school swimming pool , teacher in attendance, she didn’t even notice that one of the three red hatted non swimmers was having problems. Thanks a bunch Miss Williams!

roguetomato · 26/07/2021 20:16

I totally agree with BashfulClam.
I went to a lake when I was 8. Someone got lost in water, lots of people volunteered to look for the child, including my dad. It was undercurrent that sucked him into the water. It was very scary to know calm water isn't really calm. But I've learned the great life lesson.
I am a good swimmer, but I am also very cautious around water.

Grenlei · 26/07/2021 20:15

Such a valuable thread, thank you OP.

My grandfather was on a boat which was sunk in wartime. He was a non swimmer. He managed to tread water for many hours in the cold and dark til rescue came. It must have been terrifying. He never went near any expanse of water after that, it made him physically ill.

Could I add also please keep an eye on your children in pools even if they can swim? A little girl nearly drowned in the pool of a UK hotel I stayed at as a child (small pool, no lifeguard). She was about 9, a competent swimmer, but got cramp and got into difficulties in the deep end. My dad saved her, her parents hadn't even noticed she was struggling.

The Ingham's (one of those YouTube families) recently filmed their kids on paddle boards on Loch Lomond without any form of buoyancy aid, and rightly came on for a lot of criticism. Apparently their excuse was they didn't know. 🤷🤦‍♀️

Tealpink · 26/07/2021 20:11

I didn’t know that @FlyingFlamingo, thank you.

Nicknacky · 26/07/2021 20:05

@Badgerforbreakfast I agree, while life goes on it just seems so soon when it’s so high profile in the news and the news cameras are still there.

Badgerforbreakfast · 26/07/2021 20:03

@Nicknacky yes it was strange to see people having fun in water that people lost their lives in just hours ago really. Not that you can expect people to never go in again but didn’t sit right with me tbh.

OldTinHat · 26/07/2021 20:02

Following on from @FlyingPandas, never swim in a pool wearing a blue swimsuit. You become invisible when under water.

I also second dogs on leads when walking near cliffs. We have a lot of cliffs where I live and the coastguard is out frequently attempting to rescue dogs that have gone over. Sadly they are rarely found alive, if at all.

Clymene · 26/07/2021 19:59

@Hollyhead

I am very fearful of any open water, and I’m really strict with the dc. Is it safer to paddle in the sea when the tide is going out so you don’t get caught in deeper water?
Any beach which has lifeguards is safe to paddle in. That's a good rule of thumb.
QuestionableMouse · 26/07/2021 19:56

A teen lad died recently in my town. Got caught in a rip tide and had no chance. There's signs all over, saying not to swim but people ignore them.

Hollyhead · 26/07/2021 19:55

I am very fearful of any open water, and I’m really strict with the dc. Is it safer to paddle in the sea when the tide is going out so you don’t get caught in deeper water?

FlyingFlamingo · 26/07/2021 19:55

@Tealpink

Remember the RNLI is a charity not a funded organisation. They’re an emergency service, it’s so wrong they’re not funded isn’t it
I believe that they choose not to be government funded in order to remain completely independent
GrumpyMiddleAgedWoman · 26/07/2021 19:49

Don't swim in millponds, other than well away from the weir or mill where the water is steady again. Someone I vaguely knew as a child drowned in a local millpond.

I learned the tough lesson about not jumping into to really cold water as a student: go in gradually. Make allowances for the current. If longshore drift is sweeping you down the coast, don't fight the current, just keep swimming towards the land. It doesn't matter if you come out a mile from where you went in, you can walk.

MildredPuppy · 26/07/2021 19:49

This is such a useful thread

maxineputyourredshoeson · 26/07/2021 19:46

I have nothing useful to add, but what a good idea for a thread.

We have recently had a 13yo girl die very close to where I live, my heart absolutely breaks for all of her friends and family, some of which were actually in the water at the same time.

I admit, I’m not a strong swimmer I hate water and only ever stay where my feet touch the ground in the swimming pool. DH on the other hand is a very strong swimmer who adores the water and he taught our DD’s at a young age. I genuinely think it’s an important life skill to have but I will also drum home the importance of the FLOAT advice that was posted earlier - although we have never allowed them to properly swim in open water.

CatAlice · 26/07/2021 19:43

Another useful link about riptides. Someone drowned last week near Filey in a riptide.
m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1998045470353477&id=451224748368898

CatAlice · 26/07/2021 19:41

Drowning doesn't look li,e drowning.
There was a long thread on here a few years ago. This poster on Twitter posts this every year. Worth a look because lots of examples of how a drowning person looks. It's not at all what you expect.
twitter.com/trishgreenhalgh/status/1418896428177444865?s=19

NeonStones · 26/07/2021 19:40

With tides it’s also really important to look at how the tide comes in. If you are near a river or there are sand banks you might find the tide comes in behind you and you end up cut off. Sand banks can make it really hard to tell you don’t actually have a route back to shore anymore. It can also come in really fast. I’ve been at Minnis Bay before and seen people nearly get all their stuff wet because they don’t realise how fast the last bit of tide comes in.

Tealpink · 26/07/2021 19:39

Absolutely tragic @CorianderBee

A friend’s young son drowned some years ago. They’d visited a new man made swimming lake before it officially opened, no lifeguards on duty yet which was made plain. Her son couldn’t yet swim and he wandered off, no arm bands. She’s never forgiven herself

Nicknacky · 26/07/2021 19:38

@CorianderBee That’s horrific, where?

Swipe left for the next trending thread