Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To mention some water safety issues we all need to know?

356 replies

Northernlurker · 26/07/2021 16:56

Having read of some awful tragedies over the weekend with open water I thought I would start a thread with a few points and others can add. Because not everybody has had the same exposure to open water risks so what is common sense to one person is utterly unknown to others.

Open water in the UK is cold. Really cold. Even on sunny days. The deeper you go, the colder. This can take even fit and well people by surprise.

Don't jump in to unknown water ever. We are a rocky country populated by messy people. Water hides rocks, logs, metal and all manner of hazards.

Piers and jetty lead out from the shore to deep water so boats can be accessed. Don't regard them as an extension of the shore. The water will be both deep and cold.

Swim parallel to the shore, not out to sea.

No inflatables in the sea ever.

Tides move faster than you can walk, know what your exit route is.

If you can't swim, don't go out of your depth. Don't try and help people in trouble. You help just as much by fetching help or fetching items people in the water can hold on to.

Make sure your teenagers know these principles.

And remember 'float to live'

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Alannawhorideslikeaman · 26/07/2021 21:08

@Nicknacky

I don’t know about other posters, but I have noticed a definite craze, for want of a better term, for people I know doing cold water swimming. More and more people entering water and being caught unawares.
Cold water and open water swimming is a hugely beneficial activity - great for physical and mental health and can really help with water safety. The more used you are to cold water, the less your body reacts by going into shock. When I first started swimming in our nearby lake i couldn't breathe, and struggled to swim 50m. I now regularly do over 1km, 4 months later. However. And this is an enormous however. People need to be encouraged to do this is managed facilities. So my lake has lifeguards. We must wear tow floats and bright coloured hats. They ask you to use a buddy system when you first go out. They regularly run safe open water techniques. We should be encouraging more people, especially children, to take part in these lessons rather than just swimming in heated indoor pools.
frumpety · 26/07/2021 21:08

I have always taught DS a few golden rules passed down from my childhood.
Don't jump or dive into water you can't see the bottom of, if you can't see the bottom, you have no idea what else is under there.
Get used to the water slowly, wade in and dip down a few times to get a feel for the cold, don't go beyond waist depth until you no longer gasp when you do.
If you get caught in a rip or get pulled out of your depth, don't fight it, you will get knackered very quickly, float on your back, if just out of your comfortable depth just kick back towards the shore until you can touch the bottom, if its a rip, I will be watching you like a hawk and someone will be coming to get you asap, just keep floating and shouting if you can.
Personally, I usually only allow DS in the sea if the tide is coming in and I prefer small bays or really shallow shelving beaches with lifeguards and make him swim between the flags. I also make him wear really bright swim stuff to make him easier to spot in an emergency.

Nicknacky · 26/07/2021 21:07

@TheFairyCaravan I hadn’t heard of them until this thread then found the vide. I can’t bear to watch their video where they give their version of events.

They should be thanking him and putting a video out applauding him for making them aware.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 26/07/2021 21:04

We have excellent models for safer outdoor swimming from much of europe and also canada - why on earth can't we follow it

I agree. The OMG IT"S ALL SO DANGEROUS approach is counter-productive - and I say that as an A&E doctor/urgent care GP who has sadly seen many victims of drowning.

We need to instil respectful confidence, not terror. Using the water is like driving: occasionally, accidents occur that are outside anyone's control, no matter how skilled, but most accidents are preventable with the right skills. Teach children skills to empower them to survive - like floating - not a long list of don'ts, which no teenager has ever listened to.

I'm not saying this because I don't take drowning seriously. I have worked in NZ and Australia, so have seen more than my fair share. I am saying it because an overly risk-averse approach doesn't work. Australia is the example to follow. They do have a higher drowning rate that the UK but almost the entire population lives within easy reach of the coast, and almost 100% are in easy reach of a pool, so their rate "should" be way higher than it is. Their drowning rate per hour spent on or near water is way lower than ours. How do they manage that? By teaching kids to enjoy using the water safely. and with confidence. From kindergarten age, kids are in surf club, learning to use the ocean safely, while enjoying it.

TheFairyCaravan · 26/07/2021 21:04

@Nicknacky

I wonder if that YouTube family are still continuing with their “legal action” which will be extremely inappropriate given the recent deaths.
They should be apologising to the man who highlighted how dangerous it was for their kids to be on paddle boards without buoyancy aids. And they should be telling their cultish followers that they think their behaviour towards him, especially the death threats, was disgusting.

They won’t though. They just don’t care.

User5827372728 · 26/07/2021 21:04

There was a primary school trip today at Bournemouth beach and 2 teachers must have had about 20 7 year olds in the sea! Really surprised me

Lbnc2021 · 26/07/2021 21:04

A family friend died a few years ago in Loch Lomond. One of the children in their group kicked a ball into the loch and he went in to get it and disappeared. All these drownings are just heart breaking.

Sockbogies · 26/07/2021 21:03

I almost drowned off the coast of Suffolk aged 15. I could swim, and was with a couple of other teens who were also good swimmers. I remember being able to touch the ground one minute, the next it was gone. I was moving out to sea (fairly slowly but steadily) in a rip current. Panic hit as I tried to swim back to shore but against the current. I remember not even being able to scream or shout, fear and exhaustion just took my voice. My older brother swam to help me and (I'm still ashamed too think of this) I just grabbed him and pulled him under in my panicked attempt to stay above the water. Wave after wave seemed to hit us. Luckily my dad had decided to walk back along the beach from popping to the shops and saw us - he ran into the sea fully clothed to pull us both out.

If he hadn't done that, I have no doubt we would both be dead.

  1. Swim sideways if you get caught in a current
  2. If you swim to help someone approach them from behind, they will be in a state of panic and grab anything to stay afloat
  3. Watch for currents. You can sometimes see them (either waves breaking at slightly different times, or a river effect on the surface heading out to sea).
UndertheCedartree · 26/07/2021 21:02

@JustLyra

I also think people need to remember that they've - kids especially - have done very, very little swimming for the last 18 months.

Many people have done much less exercise and are considerably more unfit than they were two summers ago and they really need to take that into account.

This is a good point. When DD started back with school swimming lessons this Summer term she found it much harder than she had before.
Seadragonusgiganticusmaximus · 26/07/2021 21:02

Talking about horror safety films, this one, “Lonely Water”, is not for the faint hearted:

Happyhappyday · 26/07/2021 20:57

For under 4s, drowning is #1 cause of injury related death, for under 18s, it’s #2 (behind vehicle related deaths).

Happyhappyday · 26/07/2021 20:54

Don’t look away from your children in the water. Ever. Former lifeguard here and I can tell you if they go under in open water, it is EXTREMELY hard to see them. Searches will be recovery, not rescue. A friend had a “water watcher” lanyard the adults passed around at a recent gathering, great idea to make sure everyone doesn’t think “someone else” is watching the water.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 26/07/2021 20:52

@Diverseopinions

Tealpink

Was it the quicksand that they got stuck in?

I don't know where you are, but I thought Camber Sands was dodgy when I went there, and weird currents sweeping across the sand cut off different bits of it into islands. I can't understand for the life of me why it is viewed as a family-friendly beach.

Parts of The Gower Peninsula, where I used to go, have strong currents, but the beaches are rocky and look a bit scary some of them, so you are warned somewhat.

There are some very nasty rip tides at Camber. Every year people (mainly day trippers) drown because they don't heed basic water safety advice
SwanShaped · 26/07/2021 20:50

What do you do if you can’t float? My legs sink. They always have and no one has been able to show me a way where they don’t sink.

Hollyhobbi · 26/07/2021 20:50

We live near a canal and my daughter has saved two lives by throwing a lifebouy/life belt to the person in the water. If you are walking by a canal or river and notice that the lifebelt is missing or damaged please report it.

Boatingforthestars · 26/07/2021 20:45

@MrsCremuel

How cold is too cold? Our local beach (north Kent, more Thames Estuary) is apparently 16 degrees this time of year which feels cold but totally fine once you’re in it.
It's not necessarily too cold that's the issue, people swim in the sea year round. It's cold water shock that is the problem, don't sit in the sun get hot then jump in over your depth, that's when problems happen, your muscles tense and you will find it hard to breath. Its not the actual temperature, but more the sudden change of temperature.
gogohm · 26/07/2021 20:43

@ChazsBrilliantAttitude

Hear hear. My neighbour is is lifeboat volunteer, he's been out 4 times this week to people who didn't read the tide timetable!

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 26/07/2021 20:43

Don't swim at Camber

gogohm · 26/07/2021 20:41

We swim in open water - it's ok but you need to acclimatise getting in and never swim alone

MrsCremuel · 26/07/2021 20:41

My toddler would throw himself in head first if he could and cold water shock terrifies me.

MrsCremuel · 26/07/2021 20:40

How cold is too cold? Our local beach (north Kent, more Thames Estuary) is apparently 16 degrees this time of year which feels cold but totally fine once you’re in it.

MrsRockAndRoll · 26/07/2021 20:37

Great thread OP. It's heartbreaking that so many people have lost their lives

Nicknacky · 26/07/2021 20:35

@LuxOlenteni I said similar unthread. I have loads of people on my social media doing it.

@CorianderBee While it’s a relief that wasn’t today, it was still a tragedy on that day, and shows the dangers are not decreasing. Where was it if you don’t mind me asking?

Boatingforthestars · 26/07/2021 20:33

@Poshjock

Drowning is a form of suffocation. Injury of death is caused by lack of oxygen. The most important thing that you can do for someone pulled unconscious from water is BREATHING. Mouth to mouth is more important than chest compressions. CPR is different for immersion/submersion incidents and it’s not often taught on first aid courses!
This is mis-information and potentially dangerous. I agree that drowing is suffocation, but you breathing into a non breathing casualty alone will do nothing, their heart will not be beating. Lack of blood flow to the brain does serious brain damage in minutes and gets worse all the time the blood is not circulating.

If you feel you can or are happy to, 2
Rescue breaths should be given then commence CPR.
The likely hood Is the chest compression will expell most of the water from the lungs anyway.

Another thing to add, don't try putting an AED (defib) kit onto a wet person, you will be in for a bad time!

Nicknacky · 26/07/2021 20:30

I wonder if that YouTube family are still continuing with their “legal action” which will be extremely inappropriate given the recent deaths.

Swipe left for the next trending thread