Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not inviting MIL?

143 replies

thatllberight · 26/07/2021 09:25

DD1 has a performance for her hobby soon. We've been told 3 people can go to watch. On the day of the performance DM is coming up to visit, this was planned before we knew the date of the performance but works out well as she likes the same hobby and will be interested to see it, so makes sense for her to come along with DH and I. Yesterday PILs were over and DD mentioned the performance, MIL said "great, let me know what time it is", I explained DM would be coming as she's visiting that day, MIL nodded, conversation moved on. Then last night FIL called DH saying I'd really upset MIL by "excluding" her. I don't see it that way, there's no reason MIL would go ahead of anyone else and she's never shown an interest in DD's hobby before, plus DM rarely comes up so hasn't ever gone to any of the DC's shows/school plays/etc whereas MIL has been to a couple. AIBU? MIL is coming over later and I don't know what to say.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 26/07/2021 10:24

@Sssloou

Urgh…..getting the FIL to call to complain on her behalf……I suspect that she is emotionally inadequate and has form for entitled tantrums, sulks and manipulating others into drama she manufactures.

Is she not capable of communicating like an adult there and then to say something like - I would have loved to go - hopefully there will be another opportunity. etc

Or maybe, she didn’t show she was upset in front of the OP because that would be bad manners, then at home her husband saw she was very upset and phoned his son up without her knowledge. She may well be more upset now that her dh has told them she was upset about it! Not all MILs are horrible you know.
C8H10N4O2 · 26/07/2021 10:22

Limited tickets.
The DGP who has an interest in the hobby and has the track record of interest in the child's activities gets the ticket. The DGP who is less interested and involved doesn't.

Doesn't stop less interested DGP going to a future event or getting more involved in future. As PP said - these are grown adults, not kids bickering over who gets the last sweet.

Soberanne · 26/07/2021 10:21

The way i read it was that MIL asked to go before she knew the OPs mum was going so I dont understand why people think shes trying to get one up. And again the OP said that MIL wasn't interested in The DDs hobby but she has been to be previous shows and offered immediately to go to this one.

I always feel sorry for MILs on mumnet they can never win. A granny is upset that shes missing her grandaughters event and shes accused of point scoring and all sorts.

TeaDrinker98 · 26/07/2021 10:19

@ineedaholidaynow

Would it be possible to find out whether there are any spare places? Although if MIL is just having a hissy fit as DM is going instead of her and she isn’t actually interested in the performance I wouldn’t go out of my way to try and find a solution.
Can we all just take a moment and try to recognise that this isn't actually about OP, DM, or MIL.

Try and get more tickets, if possible, for your lovely DD. I'm sure she would be delighted to have both DGMs there watching her.

No need to be spiteful (not you, OP).

Mulhollandmagoo · 26/07/2021 10:18

@thatllberight

I think in hindsight I feel bad about saying "oh sorry DM is up that day, so she's going" rather than properly explaining the limit on numbers etc. DH explained this all to FIL but MIL is still upset with me.
so, your HUSBAND explained all this to her, yet she's upset with YOU??? why?
thatllberight · 26/07/2021 10:16

Yeah I realise now that not explaining the tickets thing at the time was a mistake, the conversation just moved on and I didn't think about it properly. And trust me, a grandparent can turn up to shows etc while still not being hands on or involved.

OP posts:
ineedaholidaynow · 26/07/2021 10:12

Would it be possible to find out whether there are any spare places? Although if MIL is just having a hissy fit as DM is going instead of her and she isn’t actually interested in the performance I wouldn’t go out of my way to try and find a solution.

pommepommefrites · 26/07/2021 10:10

You contradict yourself in your posts, op. In one you mention that mil has been to all dd's shows whilst your own mother has been to none, then in another post mil has no interest in dd and your own DM is more of a hands-on gp despite living further away.

Wimpeyspread · 26/07/2021 10:06

@JudgeJ

Is your mother always allowed to be involved for more than your mother in law? That's the usual way things are done, my mother was never involved in things for my brother's children, unless money was wanted, and she was very hurt on occasions, it was the reason that we always made sure that we involved both grandmothers whenever possible.
Read the OP
Holly60 · 26/07/2021 10:05

I find it hard to understand that you wouldn’t have led with the fact there are only three tickets. ‘Oh bum sorry MIL but there are only three tickets because of Covid and I’ve asked DM to come along as she is down’ would have been a very natural thing to say IMO. You probably do need to apologise for not explaining properly. Just a ‘sorry MIL I didn’t explain it properly before, hope I didn’t upset you too much’. Is your MIL possibly still upset because of the way you spoke to her - were you a bit dismissive in the moment, or a bit sharp?? Only throwing ideas around as to why she might still be upset …

Freddiefox · 26/07/2021 10:04

@thatllberight

DD1 has a performance for her hobby soon. We've been told 3 people can go to watch. On the day of the performance DM is coming up to visit, this was planned before we knew the date of the performance but works out well as she likes the same hobby and will be interested to see it, so makes sense for her to come along with DH and I. Yesterday PILs were over and DD mentioned the performance, MIL said "great, let me know what time it is", I explained DM would be coming as she's visiting that day, MIL nodded, conversation moved on. Then last night FIL called DH saying I'd really upset MIL by "excluding" her. I don't see it that way, there's no reason MIL would go ahead of anyone else and she's never shown an interest in DD's hobby before, plus DM rarely comes up so hasn't ever gone to any of the DC's shows/school plays/etc whereas MIL has been to a couple. AIBU? MIL is coming over later and I don't know what to say.
So you mil didn’t know that there were only 3 tickets? and you didn’t tell her? It’s not surprising she feels about excluded. But it’s was just a mistake so tell her that there are 3 tickets and hopefully maybe she’ll understand. Once you’ve explained the ticket limit, move on.

Any more phone calls just keep getting dh to Say the same thing. If there’s any strops ignore them.

Freddiefox · 26/07/2021 09:59

@pleasedonttextmyman

she's never shown an interest in DD's hobby before

sounds like she wants to score points and be the "first" and more important grand-parent, and it's all about her, not about the child.

People like her are exhausting.

Why does it sound like that? I don’t think it does at. I’m not particularly interested in my children’s hobby but always go along to support them.
Sssloou · 26/07/2021 09:59

DH explained this all to FIL but MIL is still upset with me.

Oh she’s one of those.

Poor you.

Don’t allow her to unsettle you or put you down with any sulky moods. If she brings it up - refer her directly back to DH and FIL convo. If she continues to push or continues to be moody or sulk - don’t tolerate it - call her out on it and give her a consequence - “It seems you are still in a bad mood - maybe you should take some time out and go home to process that in private as we are having a fun day doing x,y and z and don’t want the atmosphere”

TeaDrinker98 · 26/07/2021 09:56

I agree with you that you should have explained things better to MIL regarding the limited tickets. However, this has been explained and she's still upset, so she needs to learn to be more understanding to be honest. Surely she understands that she isn't the most important grandparent? Your mother has to be involved too.

It would be very different if your mum was going to every event and you were excluding your MIL, but I don't get the impression that that's the case.

Be kind to your MIL about this (as I'm certain you will be because you sound lovely Smile), but don't pander to her. Try to find the middle ground ❤

We have to pander to my MIL because we've been warned that she "doesn't handle criticism well. Whilst I've tried to be kind and understanding, there are definitely times when she tests my patience, so I know how exhausting it can be. Though, saying that, I'm fairly certain I test her patience too lol

HelloDulling · 26/07/2021 09:51

You say she has no interest in horse riding/skateboarding/whatever it is, but her interest is in her granddaughter.

Anyway, you should have explained that there are only three tickets, not just told her you are taking your mum so she can’t come along. I’d feel excluded in those circs too. What you are doing is entirely reasonable, but you/DH needed to tell her why.

PamTheSpam · 26/07/2021 09:48

Bloody hell @WithloveFromMyselfToYourself talk about putting the cart before the horse
She hasn't spoken to her yet, everything may work out fine

Soberanne · 26/07/2021 09:47

@sorrywoman sorry i dont think i was suggesting that she wrack her brains to find a solution i was merely suggesting some solutions. The OP and her daughter obviously have a good relationship and i am sure if there was a solution the OP would prefer that.
I understand why the MIL might seem left out and was trying to point this out.

At no point in my post did i say the OPs mum should not have the ticket.

Icecreamsoda99 · 26/07/2021 09:47

I didn't think of explaining the situation further to MIL at the time

So she didn't know tickets were limited? If that's the case of course she was upset. Basically from her point of view you told her she couldn't come because your DM was going, no wonder she felt confused and rejected. Try and put yourself in her shoes, hopefully now your DH has explained she understands, but to be honest I'd apologise in your position for not explaining the situation fully.

Maray1967 · 26/07/2021 09:46

Just tell her that she’s been to X number of shows/plays but your mum hasn’t been to any yet so she’s going this time.
If she still thinks it’s not fair then you have a problem as any normal person would see that you are being fair.

pleasedonttextmyman · 26/07/2021 09:46

she's never shown an interest in DD's hobby before

sounds like she wants to score points and be the "first" and more important grand-parent, and it's all about her, not about the child.

People like her are exhausting.

SorryWoman · 26/07/2021 09:45

@thatllberight
Well she needs to get over herself. Dont lose any more thought over it

TwoLeftElbows · 26/07/2021 09:45

YANBU and although it's a pain this time, it is so lovely for your daughter that they both want to see the performance. We gave up inviting GPs years back.

pleasedonttextmyman · 26/07/2021 09:44

@vivainsomnia

I think you went about it in a way that would indeed be seen as rude and unkind. How involved is she normally in DD's life? Likely more than your DM if she lives further away.

You say she isn't interested in her hobby yet she asked to go as soon as your DD mentioned it, so she is interested.

In your shoes, the first thing I would have done is contact the organiser and ask if in exceptional circumstances, they would agree to one more person. If not, I would taken the initiative to explain to her the situation and why it meant so much for your mum to go, and that she would otherwise be home alone.

It was obvious your DD would mentioned in at some point. It really wasn't nice to be told about it and then when saying you'd love to go, to be told, no sorry, my mum is more important.

you know we are talking about. grown-up woman, don't you? No need to go into ridiculous lengths like that.

The OP was nowhere rude or unkind!

And it's puzzling that you think being closer means she is more involved Confused
If nothing else, it explains why the grand-parent living further has priority on the one time they are around.

thatllberight · 26/07/2021 09:44

I think in hindsight I feel bad about saying "oh sorry DM is up that day, so she's going" rather than properly explaining the limit on numbers etc. DH explained this all to FIL but MIL is still upset with me.

OP posts:
SorryWoman · 26/07/2021 09:44

@Soberanne
Sorry why do you think the OP should be wracking her brains trying to come up with a solution to placate this woman? Her MIL lives local and has loads of opportunity to see her grandkids. Her mum lives further away and has an interest in this hobby therefore she gets the extra ticket, end of. The MIL needs to grow up.