Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL buying ridiculously expensive baby clothes..

230 replies

JimHairy · 26/07/2021 07:30

My MIL keeps buying my 4 month old insanely expensive baby clothes. We’re talking £120 pairs of jeans that are really stiff so he can’t wear them anyway (not comfy) all the way down to £40 sleepsuits that don’t have feet or fold over mittens so aren’t practical for him.

This sounds like such a non issue and usually I’d be of the thinking ‘let her crack on, it’s her money to burn’ etc but she gets REALLY offended when she visits and DS is wearing something cheap (usually George at Asda stuff, it’s cheap and comfy!).

Every time she comes over she brings a new batch of clothes but doesn’t listen when we tell her he’s wearing 6-9 months at 4 months old. She thinks he’s not actually that size it’s just because we buy cheap clothes and they shrink. She’s buying him 3-6 months and none of it fits even before it’s washed.

Yesterday she turned up with £680 worth of stuff (I know the price because she told us, she always does) including 2 outfits at £140 each that are way way too small and I couldn’t put him in anyway because they both look really impractical. He’s also in reusable nappies so if the crotch on things isn’t cut for cloth nappies, they won’t fit. She demanded DS got changed into one of them immediately and when I said no, she tried to take him off the floor where he was happy playing. DH said ‘no mum don’t do that, he’s happy how he is’ and then she got really angry and said (word for word) ’ ‘he looks like he lives in the children’s home like no one cares about him. Someone has to make him presentable’

Sad

He was wearing a vest, a pair of socks, leggings and a dribble bib. Fairly standard baby clothing I thought?

The other problem is that MIL isn’t well off at all. She doesn’t come from money either, totally working class through and through so I don’t know where this is coming from. She retired 5 years ago and doesn’t have any savings at all. Her retirement payout had to be used on the house which was falling into disrepair. Her pension is ok but she’s always complaining she can’t afford a holiday etc etc. She really can’t afford what she’s spending on DS and I suspect is paying for it on store cards.

Wtf do we do? I don’t want to take a nuclear option and NC or anything like that, but I do want to put a stop to her buying impractical expensive clothes for DS for her sake, and also somehow stop the judgement she has about cheap baby clothes??

OP posts:
Littlekittyscupcake · 26/07/2021 10:12

If she’s spending money like water when she doesn’t have the funds in the bank then obviously something is very wrong. Does your DH have any concerns about his mothers wellbeing? Maybe she does have a little nest egg and wants to spend it on her grandson. Her wording isn’t great and sounds quite brash and expecting you to put your son in clothes that don’t fit is ridiculous but I do detect a touch of inverse snobbery in your post to be honest. But then you’d probably judge me because as well as Sainsbury’s I also bought my children clothes from Jojo maman Bebe and the white company

MiamiPants · 26/07/2021 10:12

My advice is be honest about the comfort and about the money.

But also how grateful you are that she wants him to have lovely stuff but that it needs to be a bit softer. (Even maybe invent an interest in organic cotton etc?)

Make an event of it maybe? Go to John Lewis shopping with her. Make it an outing.

Get her addicted to the stuff that mums get addicted to.

The expensive (not compare to what she's spending but for me it was) yet comfy stuff. Show her Frugi, JoJo, Mini Boden etc.

Best of both worlds then! I'm lucky in that my MIL has a Boden addiction anyway and most of my girls favourite baby outfits were MiniBoden gifts from Nanny-with-the-Dogs.

Crazycatlady83 · 26/07/2021 10:06

I think she likes being fawned over by the shop staff, spending lots and being made a big deal of. She wouldn't get this in Asda, Next etc. She wants to have the pleasure of shopping, to get the ego boost. Because of this, I don't think there is any use in suggesting alternative shops and putting money aside.

All you can do is keep saying that you don't want the clothes, any they don't fit. Keep it simple and rinse/repeat.

Maggiesfarm · 26/07/2021 10:05

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor

Do nothing, just do what you're doing now. She'll give up eventually.
I think so.

She has a problem, needs some professional help. This is an obsession.

Irritating as it is, just be kind. It won't last forever.

TheRebelle · 26/07/2021 10:04

OP I’ve got a similar problem but the other way around, MIL will see the kids dressed in M&S, John Lewis or Joules and ask where the outfits are from then turn up the next week with bagfuls of stuff from Matalan in the wrong size, say they’re 5 months old she’ll buy ten outfits in 3-6 months, but won’t buy one outfit from M&S because it’s “too expensive”. And she doesn’t keep the receipts so if we want to return it we have to hope the store will do it as a good will gesture.

I took all the stuff back once because I’d reached the end of my tether, and ended up with a Matalan store credit for £120, but to be honest I’d struggle to spend £120 in Matalan over a year.

Now it just goes in a bag for two months then dropped off at the charity bin in the supermarket. Like you I wish she’d just put the money in a savings account for them rather than handing it to a shop for nothing but she will not be told.

Summercleaning · 26/07/2021 10:02

haven't read every message so may be repeating but from experience(told I was lower class wanting a sit down meal at our wedding and insisted on shopping at Harrods for baby clothes!!) I know how difficult this can be.
I saw someone mention that if she wanted she could put money aside for university.
We have always been lucky enough to have a very good income but I have always shopped at George, Sains, Tesco, Next etc for babies and young children. We then put extra money into child savings accounts for uni so locked away until they are 18. Now means they each have enough to cover uni or something else if they choose not to go.
Only now mine are teenagers that Nike, Hollister, Addidas etc creeping in. Certainly with babies I loved George and still buy for lots of friends over the years. The soft and comfy sleepsuits are fantastic.

I would try to explain you are grateful for her generosity but it could be used better for the future.

Just saw that this may be beyond her means. If that is the case then her son really needs to talk to her if she is coming around with £680 worth of baby clothes.

Kanaloa · 26/07/2021 10:02

I would be telling her in advance that you will no longer be accepting baby clothes from her, and if she brings them you won’t take them. Then if she brings them, give them back and refuse to take them. It’s mean but in the long run it’s kinder as she’ll no longer be wasting her money, and it is wasted money if he isn’t wearing the clothing.

It’s kind to give gifts to someone, but when you’ve been told they don’t want those gifts it becomes for you rather than for them.

Potpourri23 · 26/07/2021 10:01

If she's wanting to put them straight on him I'd let her crack on. It'll be the easiest way to let her know she's buying sizes that are way too small.

mayblossominapril · 26/07/2021 10:00

Its also more of a working class thing to have immaculate baby clothes and posh pram almost to prove you can provide for the child, a bit like to immaculate home thing. That is a generalisation but it is broadly right.

Hadtocomment · 26/07/2021 09:59

This sounds very compulsive and like it's answering some emotional need or very deeprooted insecurity like others have said. And the idea of opening a bank account doesn't sound like it'll work because it sounds like going to this particular shop and the actual purchasing is part of the addiction (as that's what it's coming across like) somehow - putting money in a bank account is not exciting and does not contain an activity in it with all the associated things to that she is enjoying. We don't really know what is feeding her need - whether it's the shopping itself, the personal experience of the particular shop telling her those clothes are superior or giving her very personal treatment or the items themselves. So maybe it takes a bit of experimenting to work it out. The fact she gets so angry may well be an indication that this is related to insecurities or things that are very sensitive to talk about so I'm not sure if it'll be that easy to just chat it through with her - even for your partner. People don't always know why they do things. Sometimes people seem to get reflected attention through babies wearing particular things. Perhaps she wants to get approving comments or be able to show her friends pictures to impress them? Perhaps she is simply terrified of people judging the baby as being poorly dressed due to things that maybe happened when she was young as people have said. Maybe she was bullied badly or felt shame as someone said. Which can be a very powerful emotion and perhaps make it even harder for her to have self-awareness or be open about.

You might not find what works straight away but I think as she's really struggling financially you need to try and do something - for her, let alone yourselves. Maybe try and work out what it is about the buying that is so important to her and seeing if you can redirect or get that experience another way that doesn't cost the earth. Perhaps if you and your DH went on some shopping trips with her and if that's enjoyable she might keep it up going to those places and cut out the boutique? Or if she does get something more appropriate you can immediately dress the baby in it so she can feel she made an impact? And maybe making it clear you are not going to accept the snobbish sounding remarks but being gentle if you can as it sounds like she has a proper emotional issue surrounding this that she's not completely in control of.

mayblossominapril · 26/07/2021 09:57

@Lockdownbear

Point her in the direction of M&S or Next or somewhere in between Asda and the £££ boutiques. She's desperate to spend on the baby and shop for cute clothes.

Let her try the outfits on him so she can see they don't fit, seeing is believing. Grandmother's are daft and become smitten by baby stuff.

Watch out for the he'll grow into it nonsense too. Won't be the first time we've had character on clothing be outgrown before it actually fitted.

This is exactly what I was going to suggest. M&S does have much nicer and better looking baby clothes than the supermarkets. I do dress mine in a lot of george and nutmeg clothing but the M&S stuff still looks good after two babies. If it is brand new without tags you should be able to ebay it.
diddl · 26/07/2021 09:54

"‘he looks like he lives in the children’s home like no one cares about him."

I'd find that very hard to get past tbh.

What a completely horrible thing to say.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 26/07/2021 09:54

After the jeans incident she would not be left alone with him again. I'd take the children's home comment personally. I'd really just bag up the whole lot and sell it on ebay. My younger 2 DC are 13 and 9, certainly old enough to choose their own clothes. I've explained to DM that the clothes she buys aren't to their taste. She reads this as "You're so strict about the clothes they wear." Now she refuses to buy anything and gives me the money instead, even though I've told her what kind of things to buy. Stuff from the boys' range for DD2, and anything with Marvel, Jurassic Park or Star Wars on for DS2. I now feel like she can't be bothered to look for the things I've asked for.

TimeIhadaNameChange · 26/07/2021 09:53

Wrt sizing, why don't you pick up something he was wearing (maybe change of trousers at nappy time) and hold them against something she's bought. Demonstrate that it really doesn't fit.

I suspect she felt embarrassed and guilty she couldn't buy expensive stuff for her children and is trying to make up for it. The fact you're happy with cheap clothing is throwing her and she can't actually cope.

SpeakingFranglais · 26/07/2021 09:49

Is she buying them nudge nudge wink wink ie fallen off the back of the lorry and can’t take them back so she’s irritated that you won’t put him in them because she’s stuck with them? Another reason why she “knows” the price but takes the labels off. Also why they come in sizes that don’t fit, that’s all the “seller” had?

NeonDreams · 26/07/2021 09:48

*bit, not big

NeonDreams · 26/07/2021 09:47

@Iwonder08 Also perhaps keep your attitude under control. See now you are being so ridiculous. It's ok for the MIL to become angry, aggressive, abusive and insulting, but it's the OP that has to 'keep their attitude under control'? Wtf? That suggestion can fuck right off. It's not the OP (who seems quite passive imo) who needs to 'keep their attitude under control'. Maybe the OP needs to get a big of an attitude. Maybe that's the problem.

NeonDreams · 26/07/2021 09:44

@Iwonder08

OP, your response is disproportionate to the problem. You are considering NC because she is buying not suitable clothes for your baby? Do you see how ridiculous it sounds? She is probably over compensating for all the times in her life where she had no opportunity to buy anything nice for her babies. There is a very simple solution - tell her you appreciate she wants the best things for your baby, but he is really a very big baby and needs different sizes. Measure him in front of her so she knows he now fits in a bigger size. Let her buy a couple of outfits..ask her to buy something soft otherwise he is not going to want to wear it. Also perhaps keep your attitude under control. Not everyone believes supermarket clothes are the only sensible choice. She is not asking you to spend your own money on more expensive stuff, she just buys her own. And don't tell her to open a savings account. It is really your job to do it.
@Iwonder08 The OP NEVER said they are considering going NC. In fact, they pre-empted other posters by saying "I don’t want to take a nuclear option and NC or anything like that". Re-read their OP.

However, I personally think threatening the MIL with going LC may be something that just may make her wind her neck in a bit, and if it works, then good. When the MIL is insulting the parents, suggesting the child looks like it lives in a children's home and is neglected, well I think that level of abuse and disrespect qualifies for LC at least.

FilthyforFirth · 26/07/2021 09:43

Does no one read the bloody OP. She very clearly states she doesnt want to go NC. So why are so many posters jumping on her claiming she is suggesting this?

pinkcircustop · 26/07/2021 09:39

Surely this is illegal? You can probably report them for this!

@onelittlefrog Why would that be illegal? They can sell whatever they want for whatever price they want.

If MIL is happy to buy at an overinflated price rather than doing the research herself and buying online then there’s no issue.

Yes, you could say she’s being taken advantage of, but if she’s not willing to shop around that’s on her. It’s not illegal.

Iwonder08 · 26/07/2021 09:39

OP, your response is disproportionate to the problem. You are considering NC because she is buying not suitable clothes for your baby? Do you see how ridiculous it sounds?
She is probably over compensating for all the times in her life where she had no opportunity to buy anything nice for her babies. There is a very simple solution - tell her you appreciate she wants the best things for your baby, but he is really a very big baby and needs different sizes. Measure him in front of her so she knows he now fits in a bigger size. Let her buy a couple of outfits..ask her to buy something soft otherwise he is not going to want to wear it. Also perhaps keep your attitude under control. Not everyone believes supermarket clothes are the only sensible choice. She is not asking you to spend your own money on more expensive stuff, she just buys her own. And don't tell her to open a savings account. It is really your job to do it.

LookItsMeAgain · 26/07/2021 09:35

Can I ask what your DH said to his mother (who is clearly who they were talking about when they came up with the saying "A fool and their money are soon parted") when she said this:
"DH said ‘no mum don’t do that, he’s happy how he is’ and then she got really angry and said (word for word) ’ ‘he looks like he lives in the children’s home like no one cares about him. Someone has to make him presentable’"

LuxOlente · 26/07/2021 09:35

Sell them on Ebay. She's off her trolley for doing it, but you may as well get some benefit. Imagine having hundreds in the bank for selling baby tat.

IdblowJonSnow · 26/07/2021 09:28

Do nothing. It's for your DH to resolve. His mum, his problem.

Is she usually pleasant/sane?

GingerScallop · 26/07/2021 09:26

As others suggest, talk to her and then receive n ignore those that don't fit. But also from several of your posts I sense an undercurrent. Do you like her at all? Do you like each other? Not a Biggie but I sense there is a back story and she's just your bitch eating crackers