Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blended Families

184 replies

ShrikeAttack · 26/07/2021 01:33

Everything I read about blended families always sounds bad. I honestly have never seen a post on here where blended families work.

I'm nearly 50 and every blended family I've ever been party too, they're not great. They don't work. There's so much anguish and pain.

Why does anyone do it?

Younger women that are considering it, I'd advise them not to.

I guess this post is salutary. If you have a choice, don't.

OP posts:
ohthatbloodycat · 27/07/2021 06:28

We're going to end up with so many kids in therapy because of these situations.
I am no longer with the father of my children, and I won't live with another man while my children are still living at home with me. They are my priority.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/07/2021 06:28

@Confusedteacher

Ours works! I have 2 DC, he has 3. All very close in age ranging from 9 to 14. Been together 6 years, moved in together 2 years ago.

We’ve been lucky that they all get along, we introduced them slowly. Mine are with their dad EOW, his are here EOW and 2 nights in the week. My youngest and his youngest share a bedroom when she is here.

We both have civil relationships with our exes. We happily discipline each others’ children over minor everyday things (eg tidying up!) but we leave the big decisions to the biological parent (eg I’ll decide on DD’s curfew).

Works for us! Those people who say ‘if me and DH split up I’d never get together with someone else’ I say you absolutely have no idea what you would do until you are in that situation. Our kids are happy because we are happy. And on a practical note we can give them so much more in terms of a bigger house, holidays etc as a couple than either of us could when we were on our own. I have more energy and time for the DC because he is here to lend a hand.

I grew up with a single mum who never wanted to meet someone else. When I left home and went to uno I really worried about her- I wanted her to be happy and I don’t think she ever was.

I've been divorced for 7 years and don't want another relationship. I'm perfectly happy, I think the idea that you need a relationship to be happy is pretty pathetic to be honest!
Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 06:26

I voted yabu. Mainly because telling people they shouldn't do something is never going to work. I have seen blended families work.

But I do agree the odds aren't in their favour.

I do think it's a really bad idea to blend families when there's already back ground problems. Kids not happy or exs that cause trouble or a new partner not happy with how much is being paid to an ex.

Its sounds hypocritical. But when I was a single parent, I wouldn't date people with kids. I was also perfectly happy if someone didn't want to date me, because I had kids. I had always been clear, I wasn't having anymore. I had no interest in having anymore and I wanted to concentrate on my kids and getting them through the aftermath of a split. That bits takes a long time.

Just after the divorce was finalised, exh announced he was seeing someone. He introduced fast. I kept my nose out because it was obvious he had been seeing her a while. 12 weeks later he moved in with her and her 2 kids. And my kids were expected to refer to these kids are their brothers. It lasted 4 months, with exh announcing it just wasn't for him Confused

Dd, who was 12 by this point. Absolutely refused to meet the next woman. And hasn't really stayed at his house since. Exh has been engaged twice since then. Ds, had also recently stopped going as much.

My, now dp, does live with us. We took it slow, introduced him slowly. He has no kids. Though he does have an adult step son from his marriage. They are still close.

This has worked for us. One of my favourite things about dp is that when one of the kids is moody, he can calmly tell them it's not ok to be rude. But then let it go and they are laughing and joking with him 5 mins later. He tries not to take their dad's place, but (given their dad has basically checked out) tries to be someone they can talk to that's not me. He is happy for them to take the lead on what type of relationship they have with him.

But I can Absolutely say that if it got any whiff that it wasn't working for one of the kids, we would split. I am the higher earner and we live in my house. I actually enjoy being single. I just wanted to be with dp more than I liked being single.

I can (financially & emotionally) go back to being single. To the above poster who thinks their mum was never happy, that doesn't mean a relationship would have made her happy.

I won't ever get married again and do thing very carefully and pragmatically about these decisions. I had some pity thrown my way yesterday on a thread because I clearly think about relationships with my head too much and don't follow my heart enough. Grin

So from my own situation I would say blended families hasn't worked out for my kids. My daughter, is already very against ever dating someone with kids. It's really left a mark on her.

Mzombie · 27/07/2021 05:31

And on a practical note we can give them so much more in terms of a bigger house, holidays etc as a couple than either of us could when we were on our own. I have more energy and time for the DC because he is here to lend a hand.

Wow. It's perfectly possible to provide your children with a nice home and holidays etc without a man. How sexist and lame that you believe this is a good reason to be in a relationship!

I grew up with a single mum who never wanted to meet someone else. When I left home and went to uno I really worried about her- I wanted her to be happy and I don’t think she ever was.

Just because you think your mother wasn't happy as a single woman doesn't mean that can be extrapolated to all women. In fact, it's mainly women later in life instigating divorce these days! And evidence suggests that single women are the happiest group of women in society.

Mzombie · 27/07/2021 05:14

There's lots of evidence showing how detrimental it is to both children dragged into a "blended family" and any new half siblings born in that situation as well, even if they have both of their own parents living with them while they grow up. Utter selfishness really on behalf of the parents and totally unnecessary to put kids through that who've already been through a family separation.

cabingirl · 27/07/2021 03:53

Ours works from my perspective but I think if given the choice my DSC who are adults now would have preferred their parents stayed together initially. Everyone seems to have made the best of the new blended arrangements and we are all fairly cordial with exes and new partner etc. We can all be together for big family occasions and even the occasional family BBQ - and I mean everyone DH's Ex, her new DH, her parents, my MIL etc, my DSDs and their new half siblings on both sides.

Confusedteacher · 26/07/2021 23:55

Ours works! I have 2 DC, he has 3. All very close in age ranging from 9 to 14. Been together 6 years, moved in together 2 years ago.

We’ve been lucky that they all get along, we introduced them slowly. Mine are with their dad EOW, his are here EOW and 2 nights in the week. My youngest and his youngest share a bedroom when she is here.

We both have civil relationships with our exes. We happily discipline each others’ children over minor everyday things (eg tidying up!) but we leave the big decisions to the biological parent (eg I’ll decide on DD’s curfew).

Works for us! Those people who say ‘if me and DH split up I’d never get together with someone else’ I say you absolutely have no idea what you would do until you are in that situation. Our kids are happy because we are happy. And on a practical note we can give them so much more in terms of a bigger house, holidays etc as a couple than either of us could when we were on our own. I have more energy and time for the DC because he is here to lend a hand.

I grew up with a single mum who never wanted to meet someone else. When I left home and went to uno I really worried about her- I wanted her to be happy and I don’t think she ever was.

Ulelia · 26/07/2021 23:54

I agree, we (me, sister, brother, mum) moved in with my stepdad and his two kids who are very similar ages when I was 14. It worked brilliantly, now I have four siblings and lots of nieces and nephews, who don't differentiate between who's a bio cousin and not, and neither do we. My relationship with my stepdad is far far better than with my dad, who I'm close to but infuriated by!

QueenofLouisiana · 26/07/2021 23:44

I’m in my mid-40s. I met my step-dad when I was 7 or 8, he has 2 children.

I’m not super-close to my step-siblings, but not very different to DH and his brother. Whenever we really need someone, the others are first in line, but we don’t chat in the phone weekly.

My step-dad is amazing, completely my non-bio dad. DS has always known that he isn’t my dad but he is totally his grandad. DSD held DS at just a few minutes old and they are very close.

Preparations are in place so everyone is treated fairly in our parents’ wills.

So, I think they can work.

TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 26/07/2021 23:41

Yeah I'm a lone parent. Just me and DS and I just couldn't blend. To be honest I don't even want to bring a man in to the situation even if he had no children of his own.

We're happy as our little double act.

My fears would be;

the relationship breaking down and DS experiencing loss once again.

Biological mother of step children and constantly worrying I may or may not be stepping on her toes.

Children's general attitudes towards step parent.

Basically it's not worth it. I'm haply to date and what not but I'll never have another relationship or introduce DS to anyone. It's just not for me/us.

EeeppP · 26/07/2021 23:36

In my limited experience, I'm glad I got a step-mother and two step-sisters when my father remarried. SM since divorced him (and he since died), and I much prefer her to him and my birth mother. I also much prefer my SS to my bio siblings.

TrainspottingWelsh · 26/07/2021 23:13

Dp and I have one biological child each, but we think of both of them as our own dc. Dsd's mother was a part of her life and is still alive and well, but I'm her mum in every true sense. It wouldn't make a very interesting thread.
I have a friend that grew up happily in a similar set up to us. And friends and wider family with more typical shared care arrangements that also work extremely well.
None of which make for particularly exciting discussion.

Ime the issues occur either when the first child is fucked over emotionally or financially for the benefit of a second family, when it's been done too quickly, or when finances/ time/ parenting styles etc are clearly going to cause problems but the adults plough on regardless.

Fernando072020 · 26/07/2021 22:41

I worked with someone ten years ago who had split from her partner and father of her two kids. She told me that she would never have kids with another man, or get together with someone with kids because she never wanted to risk her kids being unhappy with a step family or if some of her kids had a good dad and the others had a shit dad, she couldn't live with that.
I was 21 at the time, and didn't think much of it cause I was in the partying, about to go study abroad phase of life. But I'm 32 now and it really does make a lot of sense to me and I know I'd do the same if I ever divorced my husband now I have Ds.

rosegoldivy · 26/07/2021 06:54

*adores

rosegoldivy · 26/07/2021 06:53

Ours works. One DSD13 and 3 kids of our own, (dd3 and 10 week old twins)
I'm friends with DH ex and she was on my hen do and at our wedding.
We all coparent well and all get along for the most part.
DSD adored her brother and sisters and loves being here as well as at her mum's

Waxonwaxoff0 · 26/07/2021 06:31

YANBU. I'm sure it can work but I think it's a rarity. I'm divorced and will never live with another man.

Iwastheparanoidex · 26/07/2021 06:30

I am also In my 50s

My ex remarried and my kids have step siblings. No joint kids.

It has been awful for them. Really truly awful. Partly Because their dad insisted she was their mum equal to me. And they should all spend time together as one family unit even though none of the kids particularly wanted to.

I, on the other hand, have only recently started dating now the youngest is at university because they didn’t need any more shit in their lives.

I would never date a man with kids still at home. No way.

Themostwonderfultimeoftheyear · 26/07/2021 06:22

IME blended families that work are the exception. I certainly would never do it. If anything happened to DH I would either stay single or only have pretty casual relationships where we lived apart.

I do have very strong opinions however as my personal experience of blended families was epically awful and has left me with lifelong damage. Appreciate mine was particularly bad but it is always a risk and I would never take that risk with my DS.

CiaoForNiao · 26/07/2021 06:03

It can work. My family works. I have a step Mum and a step Dad. I have brothers and step siblings. I have nieces, nephews and step nieces and nephews. I don't refer to them as step though. We are just family.
I mean, sure there have been issues, and sometimes it feels like one sibling might be getting more than another. But tbh I feel that about my bio siblings as much as my step siblings so it isn't a blended family thing.

Having said that a man would have to really special for me to consider blending families because I've seen how shit it's been for my dc having a blended family on their dads side. I wouldn't want to put them (or potential sc) through that.

SheABitSpicyToday · 26/07/2021 05:57

My husband has raised my child and she calls him daddy. We have our first together due in a few months. In all honesty our life is perfect.

Blackhawkdown2020 · 26/07/2021 05:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BootsScootsAndToots · 26/07/2021 04:23

@Willyoujustbequiet

It was the opposite for us.

Ex DH was violent and abusive to me and dc, who he then abandoned. DP has taken them on as his own and is the only real father they have ever known. If we hadnt blended they would have never known a good male role model.

We didnt have children of our own though and he hasnt any biologically which makes a huge difference. Imo the problems start when a man marries again and the step mum wants her own dc and resents the children of the first marriage. She then also discovers hes useless as a father. It's always the same.

That's not a blended family though.

And as it was, no DC together or DP DC it worked.

In my experience of friends and family trying to blend, it doesn't work and it's the adults that won't give up or call it correctly.

HerrenaHarridan · 26/07/2021 04:21

I’ve seen it really work but it’s rare

I don’t do step parents

Sometimes liking to get genital to genital with me does not infer authority over my kid

A lot of relationships have ended at this boundary

I think it’s for the best.

You can have a relationship with my kid, build whatever you can sustain, the more people children have in their lives investing in them the better... no new lover will ever be allowed to view themselves as her parent

Harriedharriet · 26/07/2021 03:56

I agree OP. In my 50 odd years I have met very few who had a good blended family experience.

My parents split, a very bitter split at that. About the only good thing they did was not move anyone else into the family. It just kept a layer of difficulty away from us as children I think.

ShrikeAttack · 26/07/2021 03:54

I'm not going to disagree with any of that @Willyoujustbequiet . I wouldn't call your situation a blended family though.

And my father was and is very good Dad to all of his children. The blending of a new family, when a new woman with HER child/ren always leaves a father diminished. It's a fact really. I've not seen a situation where this doesn't play out this way.

And that goes for women too, when they have children with a new man that they live with. The previous children are not primary in their own mother's house.

OP posts: