Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blended Families

184 replies

ShrikeAttack · 26/07/2021 01:33

Everything I read about blended families always sounds bad. I honestly have never seen a post on here where blended families work.

I'm nearly 50 and every blended family I've ever been party too, they're not great. They don't work. There's so much anguish and pain.

Why does anyone do it?

Younger women that are considering it, I'd advise them not to.

I guess this post is salutary. If you have a choice, don't.

OP posts:
SteakChips · 27/07/2021 09:16

@Katedanielshasakitty Thank you for your opinion but I'm not pretending, we have a loving family. When we started out we had a conversation on how we wanted this to work etc. Yes, we have the odd row but that is in any normal family. If the mother to my step sons plays up my husband deals with it as it's not my place. All I can say it works for us and giving my experience as we are living the joint family life.

DelurkingAJ · 27/07/2021 09:10

Agree about absent parent making it easier. People simply don’t know that DH’s fabulous Dad started as his step-Dad and then adopted him (as in my DSiL had been dating DH’s half brother for three years before it came up in a conversation about birth stories). DH even forgets (tried to give the midwife his DDad’s genetic information at our booking in appointment until I pointed out it wasn’t relevant). But his bio Dad has been out of the picture since he was a small baby.

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 09:09

I get what you mean: I think the point is that in blended families the starting point is always the failure of a previous family. Even in the best case scenario a separation causes some pain and upheaval for children and they usually have to readjust to life with one parent.

In that situation if you turn around and present a brand new second family as a fait accompli which they just have to suck up they are understandably going to be wary and lacking in trust that this is going to be any more successful than the first. It's therefore imperative that they are allowed to develop trust (both of the new partner and the new partner's kids) at their own pace.

Oh I absolutely get that. My exh has made an attempt at blending 3 times. Last time with a woman who had 5 kids when he isn't that keen on kids to start with.

And I do think anyone in the situation needs to go slow and review the situation and really look at how kids are coping as they go.

Its just the sentence that 'the kids don't get a choice'. Doesn't make sense because kids don't choose any relationship or living situation. They don't even choose their own parents.

I definitely think kids need to be considered and, sometimes, aren't. But their lack of choice is really no different, to their lack of choice if they lived with both biological parents, iyswim.

2andahalfpints · 27/07/2021 09:03

It does work, I think the thing is we're not all going to get on here talking about it when someone else is struggling.
If you knew me in rl, you wouldn't know my family was blended unless we were close. It just doesn't occur to me to explain our situation in detail to everyone I meet.

thepeopleversuswork · 27/07/2021 08:59

@Katedanielshasakitty

While I do agree blended families are not always great. I don't get the 'children have no choice'.

Children never have a choice about who they have a relationship with or who they live with.

I get what you mean: I think the point is that in blended families the starting point is always the failure of a previous family. Even in the best case scenario a separation causes some pain and upheaval for children and they usually have to readjust to life with one parent.

In that situation if you turn around and present a brand new second family as a fait accompli which they just have to suck up they are understandably going to be wary and lacking in trust that this is going to be any more successful than the first. It's therefore imperative that they are allowed to develop trust (both of the new partner and the new partner's kids) at their own pace.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 08:58

Basically I think it can work but it takes effort from all of the adults not just the step parent. It takes effort from the ex, from the step parent and from the parent in the relationship.

Kanaloa · 27/07/2021 08:58

Agree with @Question2149.

That’s why it works in my family, my eldest two don’t see their dad at all, he’s never even met my daughter, so they see DH as their dad, and he’s a great dad to them. However, if they saw their dad, and he possibly had a new partner, or if my dh had kids with an ex to consider, it would all be so much messier and more difficult.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 08:53

I think blended families tend to work best when one of the biological parents is not in the picture. Say for example biological dad doesn't see the kids and they grow up being raised by their step dad. There is no ex drama to contend with, no stepping on toes or what not. Much simpler.

Saying that the only example of a blended family in my own wider family works really really well (and both bio parents are around and involved!).

I also have a step dad who I think is great and I have an awesome relationship with him. He's never tried to parent me though and I think that's the key. I've never felt uncomfortable or unwanted around him and he's a brilliant grandad to my DC now. The woman who my Dad almost remarried though was not very nice to me at all and I'm glad that they never got that far!

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 08:53

[quote SteakChips]@ShrikeAttack I actually had to google what a "Blended Family" is and this phrase is new to me.

After hearing the definition this is what I'm in. I can honestly say I'm enjoying it. Ive gain two wonderful step sons and they have gain a half brother, who their adore and help out. My step sons respect me and there father and is supportive of the family unit.

Also surely this covers all types of family - whether they get on or not. My own family growing up had its struggles no different to a blended one.[/quote]
I would disagree with that. Your blended family may have had just very similar issues to your own family growing up. But I don't think that's the norm.

In a blended family there are extra issues and there's no point pretending they are there.

So if the kids from each side have had different upbringing, it's extremely hard to blend

Or if an ex turns nasty, it can cause issues with the kids and in the relationship.

There can be resentment from the kids who don't live their full time towards the kids that live their full time. Or towards new half siblings who get to live with their own parents.

While I think blended families can work. I don't see the benefit in pretending, it hold no further challenges

Fleetw00d · 27/07/2021 08:44

I'm in a blended family every which way, I have a daughter and my partner has a son from a previous relationship. My parents are divorced and both remarried to people who each have two kids. My partner also only has half siblings from both his parents. So couldn't really get more blended and only good things to report 😀

SteakChips · 27/07/2021 08:41

@ShrikeAttack I actually had to google what a "Blended Family" is and this phrase is new to me.

After hearing the definition this is what I'm in. I can honestly say I'm enjoying it. Ive gain two wonderful step sons and they have gain a half brother, who their adore and help out. My step sons respect me and there father and is supportive of the family unit.

Also surely this covers all types of family - whether they get on or not. My own family growing up had its struggles no different to a blended one.

Dragon50 · 27/07/2021 08:32

Or actually is it a case of early red flags being ignored?

I’ve seen blended families work, I was at a bbq a few weeks back blended kids in 40s, but the parents and new partners were happily all about chatting and playing with the collective grand kids - so original ex partner playing with SGC of second ex type situation.

On the other hand I’ve had to stop seeing a friend because I cannot take her hostility and resentment to her SKs - it’s so hard to watch.

Yes I blame dad (who lets their kids be exposed to hostility and he dumps on DF) but I’ve seen a side to my friend of 20+ years that I hate. Plus she doesn’t realise that her kids are becoming brats due to the environment (Dragon is my friend and not yours, I’ve known her longer type stuff).

Confusedteacher · 27/07/2021 08:31

@Mzombie

And on a practical note we can give them so much more in terms of a bigger house, holidays etc as a couple than either of us could when we were on our own. I have more energy and time for the DC because he is here to lend a hand.

Wow. It's perfectly possible to provide your children with a nice home and holidays etc without a man. How sexist and lame that you believe this is a good reason to be in a relationship!

I grew up with a single mum who never wanted to meet someone else. When I left home and went to uno I really worried about her- I wanted her to be happy and I don’t think she ever was.

Just because you think your mother wasn't happy as a single woman doesn't mean that can be extrapolated to all women. In fact, it's mainly women later in life instigating divorce these days! And evidence suggests that single women are the happiest group of women in society.

I don’t see how it’s sexist- you are assuming that I’m living off him, which is pretty sexist of you! As a single person I could only afford a tiny house with no garden, he had a tiny flat where all three kids shared a bedroom. We sold both places and each put an EQUAL amount into our joint house, which has 4 bedrooms and much more space for all the kids. It’s obviously not the reason we got together, I’m just saying it’s a benefit for the kids.

I’m also not saying you can’t be happy without a relationship. But I don’t think my mum was. She put everything into us kids because we were all she had. She was wonderful and we were very close but it could also be suffocating.

I was on my own with the DC for many years and had a full life and lots of friends (still do!). But I don’t think there’s anything wrong with wanting a relationship. Life as a single parent was exhausting. I was often lonely. The DC spent a lot of time in childcare when I did parents evenings etc. If I needed to pick one of them up from Cubs etc the other one had to come too, even if it was late. Now I think life is better for all of us in so many ways. DP is brilliant with the kids, they love him dearly, and we both pull our weight in looking after all the kids- he’ll do drop offs if I can’t, he’ll tidy up while I’m putting the younger ones to bed.

I also have several friends who are staying together ‘for the kids’ even though they are desperately unhappy. I personally think our kids have a much better deal- they live in a happy house with no fighting or atmosphere, their parents are happy, they have plenty of adults and extended family around who love them (step families on both sides)

Like I said, each to their own, but it works for us. Which I believe was the point of the thread.

Bella43 · 27/07/2021 08:30

It definitely didn't work for me. Two separate families melded together brought issues from the start - each family liked different foods. Even portion sizes were argued about. My ex would serve massive portions (think mansize mounds of mashed potato for a 3 year old) & expect the children to eat it all or no dessert. We couldn't agree on holidays either - his children liked noisy places with lots and lots of activities. Mine preferred quieter places. Days out were hard work. My children love the cinema and visiting the library. His children couldn't sit still or have their attention held long enough to watch a film in the cinema. They'd talk all the way through it. As for libraries, my ex looked at me stupid when I suggested it. Turns out that none of them had ever visited a library in their lives. Again, it was too quiet for them. Me and my children ended up doing things their way time and time again to avoid arguments. One day we were trailing behind them after playing crazy golf at the noisiest, busiest fair ever and I just thought, I've had enough of this. It was like their way or the highway all the time. My children were unhappy, I was unhappy and I knew that this wasn't fair on them. That relationship ended seven years ago. Haven't been in one since and don't intend to. I like it just the three of us. My children are happy and I have quality time with them now. I wouldn't advise a blended family if you can help it. It's very, very stressful.

funinthesun19 · 27/07/2021 08:24

I agree at @funinthesun19 though I don’t understand why people stay then have additional DC?

I guess it takes a while for the problems to arise. Usually blended family problems don’t really get noticed until a baby is born. I suppose by that point the parent’s downsides are magnified.

Dragon50 · 27/07/2021 08:17

I agree at @funinthesun19 though I don’t understand why people stay then have additional DC?

I remember years back a SM proudly stated she didn’t say hello to DC when they arrived because she knew it would be extra work.

It’s punishing the child for the sins of the father.

Nanny0gg · 27/07/2021 08:13

I know a chap with two children who moved in with someone who had three. They subsequently married and had another one. One of his children shared a room when she stayed the other had to sleep on the sofa. They never got 'alone time ' with their dad and definitely weren't on an equal footing with the other kids (who they'd been at school with prior to the relationship). They're not bothered about seeing him now and he's really quite surprised about that

Dragon50 · 27/07/2021 08:13

I think they can work but it depends on many many factors.

One thing I’ve noticed about threads here is that the relationship between the adults isn’t great, men not doing any housework, little regard for the DP/DW etc. However the woman’s resentment is fostered into the kids/step situation when actually he is a shit partner and dad.

If we spilt I highly highly doubt I’d blend. I wouldn’t want to risk my DC being badly treated. Plus the threads here make the home sound like an unhealthy battleground most of the time.

funinthesun19 · 27/07/2021 08:12

In my opinion, I think the foundations of a blended family is the child’s parent.
So in my experience, if the father of the stepchildren is hard work, then the blended family will be hard work. And the less enjoyable the role of stepmum becomes. It’s a slippery slope.

The parent can’t expect to just do very little and expect to have this happy successful blended family. It doesn’t work like that.

I really hope my children don’t involved with anyone with children, especially my daughter.

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 08:01

While I do agree blended families are not always great. I don't get the 'children have no choice'.

Children never have a choice about who they have a relationship with or who they live with.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 27/07/2021 07:59

It’s not something I would ever want for my own children having experienced it as a child. All my friends raised in blended families didn’t like the experience either.

I agree the adults can have a very different view as they want the relationship whereas the children have no choice.

Everydayimhuffling · 27/07/2021 07:47

I think there's a difference between gaining a step family and adding new half siblings into the mix. I think often it's when there's new babies that kids really struggle. It also seems like the earlier in childhood that a divorce/big family change happens the better children recover from it.

thepeopleversuswork · 27/07/2021 07:28

I agree that it is much more difficult and fraught than people would have you believe.

I think the critical factor is time -- ie taking plenty of it and doing the "blending" at the children's pace and not that of the partners. Rushing a new partner and their children in is more or less asking for the children to resent them.

I think children can and usually will come around to the new step family as long as they feel they have some agency in the process and are not having it foisted on them. And that they have their own space to escape to.

Basically I just think people rush into it far far too quickly.

I have a DD and a boyfriend who doesn't live with us -- I've said to him there's no way I would move him in a) under three years and b) without her enthusiastic consent. Why should she have to share space with someone she hasn't chosen?

sailmeaway · 27/07/2021 06:52

I have 2 friends who have blended families and honestly everyone seems fairly happy. The kids all get on well and have gained siblings.
They didn't really 'choose' this though - their DHs in both cases had affairs and their new partners also were separated with children.

Iwastheparanoidex · 27/07/2021 06:33

I’ve been single apart from casual dating and a FWB for absolutely a lifetime.

I’m perfectly happy.

I’m now dating, but I’ll never marry nor will I live with someone in a joint house. I will always always have my own house. I won’t put myself at risk.