Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blended Families

184 replies

ShrikeAttack · 26/07/2021 01:33

Everything I read about blended families always sounds bad. I honestly have never seen a post on here where blended families work.

I'm nearly 50 and every blended family I've ever been party too, they're not great. They don't work. There's so much anguish and pain.

Why does anyone do it?

Younger women that are considering it, I'd advise them not to.

I guess this post is salutary. If you have a choice, don't.

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/07/2021 13:55

@Youdiditanyway

Does blended mean both parents already have children to previous marriages then have a child together too? I never really know what ‘blended’ means.

Personally think having a step-parent who doesn’t already have children works out fine. Having a step-parent who also brings along their own children is where it gets messy.

Disagree, I have a step parent with no children, as such he had no idea how to deal with me as a kid and expected me to behave like an adult all the time. It was not great.
thepeopleversuswork · 27/07/2021 13:12

@BlueLenka

It's like a divorce...not ideal but relationships break down and people have a right to move on, remarry and be happy..it's not ideal but the children will be making those choices too when they grow up. Once they go to uni, get in a relationship, move away etc they won't think twice about their parent..
It's much fraught than a divorce.

Generally speaking, as long as the parents remain more or less civil and the children are not uprooted, children make their peace with divorce (I realise those are big ifs but they are achievable). The relationship carries on with one or both parents and stability is maintained.

Having an entire other family imposed upon you is profoundly destabilising and takes away children's feelings of security and control.

Yes people have a right to move on and no-one should remain in an unhappy marriage "for the sake of the children". But I don't think a parent's right to arrange their romantic life for their convenience automatically trumps the child's right to feel secure. Most of the time children are not thrilled about having new step brothers and sisters forced on them, at least initially, and it has to be done with great care and sensitivity.

That doesn't mean you can't ever move a partner and their children in, just that you need to listen, take your children's concerns seriously and proceed VERY VERY slowly. I think anyone who does it inside a couple of years after the start of the relationship is asking for trouble.

I see and hear of so many people rushing to reassemble the family without any care for the sensitivities of the children or the family dynamics.

BlueLenka · 27/07/2021 12:24

It's like a divorce...not ideal but relationships break down and people have a right to move on, remarry and be happy..it's not ideal but the children will be making those choices too when they grow up. Once they go to uni, get in a relationship, move away etc they won't think twice about their parent..

NeedNewKnees · 27/07/2021 12:06

The blended family I know best, the parents would say it’s great and it works and they’re all one family.

The teens involved would say it was difficult; one left and went no contact for a few months. The younger children are happy with it, but then, like a PP mentioned, the other birth parent isn’t on the scene for them.

The decision was definitely made with the wants of the adults having more weight than the needs of the children.

Youdiditanyway · 27/07/2021 10:51

Does blended mean both parents already have children to previous marriages then have a child together too? I never really know what ‘blended’ means.

Personally think having a step-parent who doesn’t already have children works out fine. Having a step-parent who also brings along their own children is where it gets messy.

MrsN100 · 27/07/2021 10:48

I took agree with you op. I have never seen this work in RL. Expecting children who have no relationship whatsoever to each other to magic up a sibling relationship, share their space and life and all be happy very rarely works. I've seen this too many times.

Wannakisstheteacher · 27/07/2021 10:34

I had a blended family as a child. It was shit. Watching my Dad play happy families with my Step brothers and half siblings whilst I hardly saw him. I’d never, ever, force my DC to life like that.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 10:23

do think though that stepdads in general have an easier job than stepmums

Agree with this as well.

MsAwesomeDragon · 27/07/2021 10:22

DH took on dd1 as his own. We moved in together when she was 7, and she's never actually met her biological father so he's the only dad she's ever had. Dd2 was born when dd1 was 10 and they adore each other. They're definitely sisters rather than half anything.

I'm not sure I'd really call our situation blended though, as it was just me and DD, then DH moved in with us. He didn't have kids with an ex, I didn't have an involved ex to butt his nose in.

My sister tried blending her family. Her and her 2 girls (50/50 with ex) lived with a new partner and his son (lived mostly with them, eow with his mum). It was a nightmare for all involved. My sister had to do too much parenting of his son, the son was unpleasant to her girls (as teenage boys might often be to younger siblings but they didn't have the sibling bond already there, it was just an older boy in their house being nasty to them). They lasted 2 years living together then when the landlord sold the house they rented she told him she wanted to live separately again, still dating but not living together. He went mental, they split up properly, she moved town, they've not seen each other since. The girls are significantly happier now.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 10:21

@Confusedteacher

I think blended families tend to work best when one of the biological parents is not in the picture. There is no ex drama to contend with, no stepping on toes or what not. Much simpler.

In our family, all the parents are very much involved! The DC go back and forth between us and their other parents, they have step parents on both sides. But there is no ‘ex drama’ and no stepping on toes. Everyone is friendly and gets along fine. Maybe because we are all just normal, reasonable people who get along and want the best for our kids?

I'm sure that is the case. I said tend to not always.
Handsoffstrikesagain · 27/07/2021 10:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Handsoffstrikesagain · 27/07/2021 10:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Handsoffstrikesagain · 27/07/2021 10:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

feelingmehtoday · 27/07/2021 10:10

Of course everything you read sounds bad - because people only post on here when they have difficulties! In the same way that everything you read on here about relationships is bad too. That doesn't mean all relationships are bad though 🤷‍♀️

StarryNight468 · 27/07/2021 10:01

It shouldn't be called blending. Blending something makes it smooth.

I am a step mum, my dc are step children, I am also a step child on both sides. I get on well with my step dad, I don't get on with my step mum, she is an awful person and her insecurities ruined mine and my siblings relationship with my dad.

I was a 'step mum' when with my dc dad. We weren't married but exes eldest ds lived with us and his dd stayed every weekend. I loved our family life and ex was not a Disney dad, in fact he was the strict one and we were a team around all the dc. I got on well with his ex wife and we're still friends now. His dc had no loyalty binds or confusion where they belonged.

I'm now a legally binding through marriage step mum and it's hard work. My dss has two conflict ridden parents who fight about him. His mum drips poison in his ear about dh and me which translates into anxiety and controlling behaviour. Dh feels guilty and gives him decision making power which doesn't translate to a happy child. I find it extremely hard to deal with a child who's behaviour towards me is rude and resentful. I do feel like marriage was not the best decision for dss (things were totally fine before we got married) but we're here now and its finding a way to make sure dss is happy and secure along with the rest of us. I'm not going to leave my dh because of dss challenges but if I could turn back time I'd have put off marriage and living together until dss was older. I thought I'd be a great step mum, having experienced an awful one and played a step parenting role before successfully but it's not worked out that way.

thepeopleversuswork · 27/07/2021 09:40

All too often people jump straight into ‘blended’ families at the expense of their own children, because they’re selfish.

I think its a bit more complex than that. A lot of it comes down to good old societal gender standards.

I've seen this happen a lot: there's a huge amount of pressure on women to be coupled and in families and often that over-rides what is actually best for their children. They are so focused on finding and keeping a man because society tells them that's what's best for them that they ignore the fact that in most cases they and their kids would do better as a family unit without foisting a man and his kids in.

And then they repeat to their kids like a mantra "we're going to be a family again". As if the word "family" magically makes everything better.

Men very often do it because they are lazy and want a domestic helpmeet.

I don't think this is true of all blended families by all means but I think quite a lot of the time people do it by default because they think they need to be part of a family for its own sake really.

Depressing really.

TicTacHoh · 27/07/2021 09:36

Agree, OP. I love my husband more than anything, but if I had known how hard blended families was going to be, I would have thought twice.

Handsoffstrikesagain · 27/07/2021 09:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Confusedteacher · 27/07/2021 09:26

I think blended families tend to work best when one of the biological parents is not in the picture. There is no ex drama to contend with, no stepping on toes or what not. Much simpler.

In our family, all the parents are very much involved! The DC go back and forth between us and their other parents, they have step parents on both sides. But there is no ‘ex drama’ and no stepping on toes. Everyone is friendly and gets along fine. Maybe because we are all just normal, reasonable people who get along and want the best for our kids?

thepeopleversuswork · 27/07/2021 09:25

I think blended families tend to work best when one of the biological parents is not in the picture. There is no ex drama to contend with, no stepping on toes or what not. Much simpler.

I think there's some truth in this. Might be sad for the children but much less tension to manage.

My DD is in sporadic contact with her biological dad: she sees him maybe once every three weeks to a month and won't ever do overnights etc. His choice as he won't/can't agree to a visit schedule. I notice that her relationship with my (non live in) boyfriend, who is far more reliable and more of a constant in her life than biodad, suffers after she's seen her father. While I don't think dad is actively bad-mouthing the boyfriend it tears my DD's loyalties.

Katedanielshasakitty · 27/07/2021 09:22

[quote SteakChips]@Katedanielshasakitty Thank you for your opinion but I'm not pretending, we have a loving family. When we started out we had a conversation on how we wanted this to work etc. Yes, we have the odd row but that is in any normal family. If the mother to my step sons plays up my husband deals with it as it's not my place. All I can say it works for us and giving my experience as we are living the joint family life. [/quote]
I didn't give an opinion on your family. Confused

I gave an option on the fact that you think the issues are just the same for blended and non blended. In YOUR family, they may have been. But in most there are additional issues to deal with.

Odd that you assumed I was saying I don't believe that your family is great and its posed no issues for you. How would I even know that?

Kanaloa · 27/07/2021 09:22

I don’t think anyone’s suggesting getting rid of the ex to facilitate a blended family. My kids wouldn’t have a relationship with their dad either way, but a side effect is that it makes a blended family easier.

Question2149 · 27/07/2021 09:21

@topwings

I think blended families tend to work best when one of the biological parents is not in the picture. There is no ex drama to contend with, no stepping on toes or what not. Much simpler.

Well it's easier for the adults but what about the children who grow up without a relationship with their other parent?

I think you're misunderstanding my point, the children wouldn't have a relationship with their other biological parent regardless. But instead they do end up with a father / mother figure in the form of their step parent.
topwings · 27/07/2021 09:19

I think blended families tend to work best when one of the biological parents is not in the picture. There is no ex drama to contend with, no stepping on toes or what not. Much simpler.

Well it's easier for the adults but what about the children who grow up without a relationship with their other parent?

funinthesun19 · 27/07/2021 09:18

I think blended families tend to work best when one of the biological parents is not in the picture. Say for example biological dad doesn't see the kids and they grow up being raised by their step dad. There is no ex drama to contend with, no stepping on toes or what not. Much simpler.

Totally agree with that 100%. One of my relatives is very happy in his blended family and I think it’s been made so much easier for him from the get go because his wife’s ex isn’t in the picture anymore. They function just as a nuclear family would and everyone is happy. 16 years and still going strong.

That situation is worlds away from a blended family where the ex is heavily involved and is a constant influence over everyone’s lives. Things just don’t run as smoothly.

I do think though that stepdads in general have an easier job than stepmums, and it’s those blended families that tend to be more successful. Probably because they are in a relationship with the mum, who is much more hands on with her children.