Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blended Families

184 replies

ShrikeAttack · 26/07/2021 01:33

Everything I read about blended families always sounds bad. I honestly have never seen a post on here where blended families work.

I'm nearly 50 and every blended family I've ever been party too, they're not great. They don't work. There's so much anguish and pain.

Why does anyone do it?

Younger women that are considering it, I'd advise them not to.

I guess this post is salutary. If you have a choice, don't.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LolaSmiles · 31/07/2021 07:30

Blended families can work, especially when the blend happens when the children are young.

I do think too many people prioritise their love life and a desire to play happy families with their new DP so blend families and have an extra new baby to seal the deal without properly considering the impact on the existing children though.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 31/07/2021 07:25

@MiaMarshmallows

Partner split from his wife and met me a few months on. We got together in the July, I met his kids 6 months later. Some people expressed the belief that it was all moving too fast and that I would get hurt as he clearly wasn't over his ex. Yet here we are 3 years on and couldn't be happier. Annoys me how people say that blended families which are happy are rare. Only on MN but not in the real world.
No offence but 3 years isn't that long really.
Looubylou · 31/07/2021 07:14

05:57 SheABitSpicy - I hope things stay perfect for you, but the dynamic is about to change. Your daughter's perspective is more important, when she is asked in say 10 years time, what the experience was like for her, long term, after sibling was born.

MiaMarshmallows · 30/07/2021 22:15

Partner split from his wife and met me a few months on. We got together in the July, I met his kids 6 months later. Some people expressed the belief that it was all moving too fast and that I would get hurt as he clearly wasn't over his ex. Yet here we are 3 years on and couldn't be happier. Annoys me how people say that blended families which are happy are rare. Only on MN but not in the real world.

Persephonesgrove · 30/07/2021 16:40

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@Persephonesgrove

I know what you're getting at in that kids don't get asked if they want to live with their bioparents and obviously its wrong to assume all birth families are happier than all blended families. But the point you're missing is that for all kids the bio family is the default and usually the goal.

The vast majority of kids want their parents to be together -- even if one parent is abusive or neglectful. That doesn't mean that its the right thing to do to soldier on in a bad relationship. But you are fooling yourself if you believe that the kids wouldn't usually prefer that.

This isn't to say that you can't recreate a family with a better set of parents. But the burden of proof is on the parent to demonstrate to the child why, having already separated the initial family (potentially for good reasons) they should be happy to simply accept a brand new family. The parent has to make a bloody case as to why that's going to be better, and at the heart of that is ensuring that the kid can see its going to benefit them. Rather than just saying "right, here's your new dad".

This is why its all about time and sensitivity and consultation.

I don't think its "desperate" or "sad" for a single parent to want to move on and find love. I have to say I do think its a bit "desperate" for a single parent to rush a new parent in quickly.

I don't think there has to be a hard and fast timetable to it - its common sense: two years before you introduce a partner seems a bit OTT. But I certainly think anyone who is blending a family based on a relationship of less than a year is not putting their kids interests first.[/quote]
For Many kids the bio family isn't the ideal at all. That's the point.

Except on these threads if you aren't with the other bio parent, it's assumed that your kids is definitely unhappy.

But if you are with their bio parent its assumed they are happy.

How many people tell someone, still with the other bio parent 'I bet your child isn't happy, they just aren't telling you they are' even though all the evidence points to the being perfectly happy.

It just doesn't happen.

And the parents that just go 'here's your new dad' didn't put their kids first before and have always just done what they wanted. They could be with the bio parent and still be like that.

See you say not desperate or sad. Then use the word desperate. Putting " " doesn't make it any less derogatory. Are there no other words?

You have chosen the emotion that you think they based this decision on and give it a derogatory name which as long been attached to, mainly, female single parents.

Thats the problem. Introducing new partners too quickly isn't a great idea. It's ill advised. But I wonder how many male single parents are called desperate either in general OR when they move from one women to the next.

Dragonn · 30/07/2021 16:28

Blended families hatred is all built around stereotypes. The deadbeat dad, the desperate single mum, the evil stepmother who wants to get rid of the children, the sour ex wife, the neglected first children, the spoilt new half sibling. Its damaging and erodes.

Dragonn · 30/07/2021 16:20

thepeopleversuswork you sound like you are assuming anyone entering into a new relationship is going to say "right, here's your new dad" and that those other people are not as considered and as thoughtful as you. It's very patronising.

Part of me thinks that many adults put their wants before their children’s needs

Surely every adult puts their wants before their child's by deciding their child must be born. When you have a child, you have to accept certain unpleasant things may happen, including the risk your relationship may break down and you have to subject your children to divorce proceedings and split custody and yet we all have children anyway, as we all assume it won't happen to us.

People on MN really do struggle with the idea that blended families can work, yet most people in RL are just getting on with it.

I guess it goes in line with those who think parents shouldn't be over a certain age or you shouldn't have children if you're on benefits or a low wage, or live in a small house. Short sighted and ready to make judgements on people's lives.

thepeopleversuswork · 30/07/2021 12:53

@Persephonesgrove

I know what you're getting at in that kids don't get asked if they want to live with their bioparents and obviously its wrong to assume all birth families are happier than all blended families. But the point you're missing is that for all kids the bio family is the default and usually the goal.

The vast majority of kids want their parents to be together -- even if one parent is abusive or neglectful. That doesn't mean that its the right thing to do to soldier on in a bad relationship. But you are fooling yourself if you believe that the kids wouldn't usually prefer that.

This isn't to say that you can't recreate a family with a better set of parents. But the burden of proof is on the parent to demonstrate to the child why, having already separated the initial family (potentially for good reasons) they should be happy to simply accept a brand new family. The parent has to make a bloody case as to why that's going to be better, and at the heart of that is ensuring that the kid can see its going to benefit them. Rather than just saying "right, here's your new dad".

This is why its all about time and sensitivity and consultation.

I don't think its "desperate" or "sad" for a single parent to want to move on and find love. I have to say I do think its a bit "desperate" for a single parent to rush a new parent in quickly.

I don't think there has to be a hard and fast timetable to it - its common sense: two years before you introduce a partner seems a bit OTT. But I certainly think anyone who is blending a family based on a relationship of less than a year is not putting their kids interests first.

OlympicProcrastinator · 30/07/2021 12:04

It's difficult for children and teenagers to be honest and open in these circumstances, even when they have a good relationship with the adults involved

That’s such a huge generalisation. There are so many projections and assumptions there.

Datingandnoideahowto · 30/07/2021 11:45

I’m not bragging.

My ex fucked up and my kids suffered. It’s the responsible and right thing to have done not to have added to the stress my kids were under.

The things that my ex and his new wife did were awful and the kids didn’t need the stress.

Persephonesgrove · 30/07/2021 11:38

@thepeopleversuswork it's the wording.

Words like desperate, sad, lonely, weird.

Some people even suggesting people are desperate to live with someone, even if they have known them years. And people bragging that they never had a relationship because they 'put their kids first', as though that's THE only right way. As though you can't have a relationship and live with someone AND put your kids first.

People manage to be in relationships AND put their kids first everyday. But there's an automatic judgement that 'the kids probably aren't happy' if one parent isn't the biological kids.

Some suggesting it should be a minimum of 2 years before even think about introducing a partner.

If a single parent being in a relationship or living with someone is proof they are desperate. Why aren't couples who are the kids parents but staying together, even when it's not working not labelled desperate? Does anyone say 'my god are you that desperate for a shag?'

Its wording on these threads. Certain words used for parents who are together. Much more derogatory language if the parent is not with the other parent.

I have chosen him, not her. And I'll only integrate him into her life if she's comfortable with it.

A child doesn't choose its own parents. YOU choose who the child's other parent will be, when you make a baby with them. And according to this thread, even if you daughter is comfortable. She is lying and just saying what she wants you to hear. Couldn't possibly be that she is comfortable.

Does anyone assume kids are unhappy, if they live with both parents?

All parents should be trying to do their best. Most do. But their relationship status, doesn't make that more or less likely.

thepeopleversuswork · 30/07/2021 11:18

I see this thread has, as usual, just descended in to thinly veiled insults at single parents who choose to enter another marriage or relationship. Of course this thread has stories where its not worked out. Words like weird and desperate thrown around.

I don't think its a thinly veiled insult at single parents. I'm a single parent and I didn't take it in that way.

I think its more about people who kneejerk to the assumption that a relationship always has to include a rush to cohabit and to recreate the family unit.

I think cohabitation is really hard in a best-case scenario -- even for the traditional biological family its often less than ideal. I hate cohabitation and my personal view is that women and children do best in life when they don't live with a man. But clearly that's not a view most people will share and not workable for everyone.

At the same time, though, I want to and will continue to have relationships. I just don't feel the need to make my partner the centre of my child's life. I have chosen him, not her. And I'll only integrate him into her life if she's comfortable with it.

Its not that people are asking single parents not to date or have relationships. It's suggesting that if they are going to have a new relationship they reimagine in in a new light instead of charging to create a carbon copy of their old family. And that if and when they do introduce a new partner and kids to a child's life they do so slowly and with great care for the kids' sensitivities.

Washimal · 30/07/2021 10:01

Who wouldn’t discuss something like that with their children? Ask their opinion and how they felt about it?

It's difficult for children and teenagers to be honest and open in these circumstances, even when they have a good relationship with the adults involved. Kids aren't stupid, they know that when they are consulted about these things there is a particular response that their parent is hoping for. It can be extremely tough for a child to say " actually I don't like your boyfriend/girlfriend as much as you think I do", or "I don't want them to move in" when they can see this person is making their parent happy.

Dragonn · 30/07/2021 09:13

You can leave the unhappy relationship amd then put your children first - provide them with a stable, happy home - and simultaneously find a new relationship if you wish to without moving a new partner into your children's home

Yes, this is a valid choice. As is starting a new considered relationship and letting it move at the correct pace and eventually 'blending' it. I know it's a bit shocking, but children can learn a lot from good healthy relationships. I much preferred, as a child, living with DM and DSDad. And I am so greatful he is still there for her now as she becomes less mobile. I'd glad she was able to ensure her happiness while maintaining our happiness as children.

Dragonn · 30/07/2021 09:01

*lockdown

Dragonn · 30/07/2021 09:00

Yep, my dad came to my mums second wedding. My dad and stepdad came to each others 70th. My now adult stepsons spent hours playing online with DD to help out during kickdown, and play with my nephews online too.

OlympicProcrastinator · 30/07/2021 08:59

I also notice the many posters who were step children themselves and have said it was a wonderful experience have been largely ignored. It doesn’t fit the MN narrative.

Let’s face it, selfish arsehole parents are going to make their children miserable whatever the family set up and those that centre the needs and feelings of their children will have more successful families.

Abigailandthefoxes · 30/07/2021 08:56

I’m from a blended family. I have/had both a Stepmum and a Stepdad. My Mum was at my Dad’s second wedding. When my Stepdad died my Dad and Stepmum were the first people to arrive at my Mum’s house.

Mine and my sisters children call both step parents Nan and Grandad.

Dragonn · 30/07/2021 08:55

For there to be so many blended families, suggests non blended families are not working for many people either.

Based on my experience as a stepdaughter, stepsister and stepmother, it has worked for the ones I have been a part of. No, we weren't skipping around, holding hands and singing songs together, it wasn't perfect, but it worked.

I had an older stepmother as a friend who guided me. And my mother, who had a bad experience as a stepdaughter, used those situations to be a good stepmother. I also had a non stepmother friend I could be completely honest too with no judgement. Essentially, a good support network.

I think it is damaging to say blended families don't work because blended families are a large part of our society. This narrative filters down to children. No one needs the negativity. Many families, of all different types are just trying to do their best.

Persephonesgrove · 30/07/2021 08:37

I see this thread has, as usual, just descended in to thinly veiled insults at single parents who choose to enter another marriage or relationship. Of course this thread has stories where its not worked out. Words like weird and desperate thrown around.

Its a thread saying blended families don't work. That's what it's going to be full of, stories where it hasn't worked.

And no one can say it has for them because people just come back with 'bet the kids don't think that though'. There will be many kids, living with both parents that also pretend everything is fine when it's obviously not.

A few weeks ago, there was abtgread about staying together for the sakebofbteh children. Stories were horror stories about people whose parents had stayed together for their sake and how it's caused them issues.

In reality, many do work. Even to a point where people, don't actually realise they are blended unless they know them well. People only really know when there's a problem.

Unfortunately some parents, put their needs in front of their kids needs they make decisions they know aren't a great idea in regards to their kids and do it anyway. But, not all of them are single parents.

Plenty of parents that are still with the other biological parent, don't put their kids needs first, ever. Plenty of single parents who don't have another relationship, also fuck their kids up. That's what fucks kids up. Not the 'blended' family. There's examples of all these on this thread.

Its people consistently putting their needs in front of their children's. That doesn't need to be in the form of a new partner or new family. It can take many many forms. Who the parent is with, isnt the main factor.

OlympicProcrastinator · 30/07/2021 08:33

Are you joking? You must be extremely naive to think that this is what happens every time a family blends. Did you not read pp experiences below

Wasn’t really any need to be so damn rude was there? I didn’t think for a minute that happens every time. I’m talking about the general assumption that children are never asked of that it happens purely for the sex life of the parent. As if there is no other possible scenario.

MrsN100 · 30/07/2021 08:27

Who wouldn’t discuss something like that with their children? Ask their opinion and how they felt about it?

Are you joking? You must be extremely naive to think that this is what happens every time a family blends. Did you not read pp experiences below Confused

OlympicProcrastinator · 30/07/2021 08:25

The common theme I keep seeing cropping up on this thread is, “it’s for the parents sake and the kids don’t get a say”

That’s a really weird way to look at it. Who wouldn’t discuss something like that with their children? Ask their opinion and how they felt about it? Only move in with someone they intended to marry / be with indefinitely and after a long time dating? In addition, not moving someone in ‘for sex’ as has been said, but because living together means pooling finances and can provide a better standard of living the whole family.

Datingandnoideahowto · 30/07/2021 08:15

It’s nothing to do with me being good or bad at relationships in general.

I made a conscious choice to put my kids first because my ex is a dick and introduced another woman and her children within a very few weeks and made a complete Horlicks of the blending because he didn’t do it slowly.

And yet I’m being characterised as the one who is bad at relationships?

cauliflowerkorma · 30/07/2021 08:14

I am from an unblended family of parents who should have got divorced and didnt. I am currently in therapy. Having to be good all the time and keep the peace and not upset anyone and try and make everyone happy and keep everyone together felt like my job. And it puts me under a lot of pressure as an adult with depression and anxiety. So i agree with pp that families and people are imperfect even when traditional.

My own experience of blending is quite positive so far. However, i suspect thats because i think blending should be a spectrum ranging from noone meets anyone at all to we all move in together because the parents want to and everyone has to lump it and enjoy it. And you choose what works for your family and put your children first. Therefore we have two homes. My partner is here part time. He has a dedicated time and space for his kids and me for mine. We do spend time together and enjoy it. The age of the kids is very different meaning full blending would likely be unsuccessful. Id also love a baby with him but we won't have one because it would be too disruptive for the children we already have. And we will probably also have to support my kids when that happens in their dads new little unit.

Its unconventional and we miss each other sometimes and long for an easy life. But we are a very united team and support each other and our kids.

I think too many people think the only way you can love someone and be committed is to have one home and all be under one roof and i think thats a little outdated.