Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Is Alcoholics Anon pushing religion

161 replies

BabieDriver · 25/07/2021 23:59

I have a hunch that a friend is "stuck" in 12 step programmes. He attends Alcoholics Anon and 2 other step groups. He has a lot of serious mental conditions and is starting NHS psychotherapy this month which is good news. He is very low and seems to get progressively worse doing lots of homework as part of the step work. It busies him up, keeps him thinking about his problems imo, and he hardly goes out and he's low most of the time. I've known him 3 years, but he's been in these programmes for over 10 years.

I never researched it before but I see that the wording of the 12 step for AA are mainly about God and that other 12 step orgs use roughly the same wording. I'm not against God, I believe in a God, but I don't follow any religion. I was brought up in a church religion and I strongly believe that support for vulnerable people and people with mental health issues should be secular - my church wanted to spread the word, it preached a lot of fear and I feel there is a similar angle in these steps and they are harmful and guilt-inducing, mentioning defects, atonement and giving up power.

Link: AA 12 Steps

My church liked people to stay for life. I hear that some people can stay in the step programmes all their lives too - vulnerable people. Yes, it does say that you don't have to believe, but if that's the case, why not re-write the steps and make it secular? Is it because religions are too powerful? I can't help but wonder how he would have fared in secular programmes that might not have an interest in keeping him long term? AIBU?

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:03

AA UK site just now.

We admitted we were powerless over alcohol - that our lives had become unmanageable.

Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.

Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.

Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

Admitted to God, to ourselves and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.

Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.

Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly admitted it.

Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.

Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics and to practice these principles in all our affairs.

Mockolate · 26/07/2021 04:03

Why have you just reeled off the steps?
That has no bearing on what I actually said so not sure why you've quoted me Confused

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:01

@Mockolate

One obsessive behaviour (addiction) is replaced with another 'crutch'. To me that doesn't feel like getting over it.

That's got nothing to do with the twelve steps though.
Which is what the original post was about.

The original 12 steps (can't imagine the gist will have changed):

The following are the original twelve steps as published by Alcoholics Anonymous:[11]

We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become unmanageable.

Came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.

Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.

Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.

Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.

Continued to take personal inventory, and when we were wrong, promptly admitted it.

Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.

Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 03:59

@Mockolate

Also some religions do a lot of harm to people in the name of God. My parents, teachers, schools - really negative experiences - that's a valid point.

OK, fair enough, can see that - however I just don't see what it's doing wrong for others. Why make others waver or doubt themselves.
What works for someone won't work for someone else.

I wasn't sure how they were being run. If they were run the way my parents/teachers/schools ran things there would have been a manipulative element to them. However, it sound mainly positive and I'm genuinely pleased to hear that.
OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 03:58

I've no intrinsic objection to the concept of AA-type groups, apart from the inherent safeguarding problems built into the model. What I do have a problem with us the behaviour of some of the adherents.

I've had great success with medication for psychiatric illness. Imagine if I rushed into any thread where someone was worried about a friend's potential side effects, demanded that the thread be deleted in case it put people off trying meds, and told somebody off for linking to a patient information leaflet. That's what posters here have done with AA.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 03:57

[quote BabieDriver]@milkyaqua

But he feels it's right for him, and has been helping him for the last ten years. Would you rather he relapsed?

Last sentence: That is a really silly question?!

He has a lot of mental health problems, he's very vulnerable, I felt he might not be the best person to judge what is right for him because it seems to have taken over his life so he's become absorbed in his step work with no time for much else.

But the positive responses from others are here encouraging. It sounds like it depends on where you go and who good the sponsor is.[/quote]
10 years?

Loads of MH problems?

He's not a boozer any more i am assuming.

It consumes his time...

In the end what can you do.

But I think you're right.

Glad he is seeing NHS.

But to me like I said. It's his crutch now. So he's not actually sorted is he. And his MH probs persist.

Poor bloke.

You're right though what he's doing with AA is not healthy.

Mockolate · 26/07/2021 03:57

One obsessive behaviour (addiction) is replaced with another 'crutch'. To me that doesn't feel like getting over it.

That's got nothing to do with the twelve steps though.
Which is what the original post was about.

milkyaqua · 26/07/2021 03:56

The OP knows nothing about AA - hasn't even got the name right. It's Alcoholics Anonymous, not Alcoholics Anon.

If she'd met her friend eleven years ago, rather than three - therefore, only knowing him in his sobriety - she might have a very different 'feeling' about it, this thing she doesn't know anything about.

Meanwhile, it is none of her business how he spends his time, or what other issues he may be feeling the need to address in other fellowships.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 03:53

None of this is new it's been in the news etc from time to time for years.

In the end if it suits you then good.

Googling just now I did see s few things about those who can't leave- it becomes a key part of their life. I don't think that's particularly healthy.

One obsessive behaviour (addiction) is replaced with another 'crutch'. To me that doesn't feel like getting over it.

I do sometimes wonder how it has become the usual treatment.

NHS had a link.

I was looking at the priory the other day they do it.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 03:51

@milkyaqua

But he feels it's right for him, and has been helping him for the last ten years. Would you rather he relapsed?

Last sentence: That is a really silly question?!

He has a lot of mental health problems, he's very vulnerable, I felt he might not be the best person to judge what is right for him because it seems to have taken over his life so he's become absorbed in his step work with no time for much else.

But the positive responses from others are here encouraging. It sounds like it depends on where you go and who good the sponsor is.

OP posts:
Mockolate · 26/07/2021 03:51

Also some religions do a lot of harm to people in the name of God. My parents, teachers, schools - really negative experiences - that's a valid point.

OK, fair enough, can see that - however I just don't see what it's doing wrong for others. Why make others waver or doubt themselves.
What works for someone won't work for someone else.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 03:47

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcoholics_Anonymous

There's no doubt that it was religious at the start.

Different groups and orgs may not stick exactly to the original obviously.

'AA marks 1935 as its birth year when the newly sober Bill Wilson first met a detoxing alcoholic Dr. Bob Smith in Akron, Ohio. Wilson put forth that alcoholism was not a failure of will or morals, but an illness from which he had recovered as a member of the Christian revivalist Oxford Group (first known as First Century Christian Fellowship). '

'The Twelve Steps are intended as a non-coercive self-improvement program of admitting to powerlessness over alcohol and its damage, acknowledging and striving to correct personal failings, making of amends for past misdeeds, and continued spiritual development while helping other alcoholics to get sober through the Steps. The Steps suggest the healing aid of an unspecified God "as we understood Him", but are nonetheless accommodating to agnostic, atheist, and non-theist members.[4]'

Ozgirl75 · 26/07/2021 03:45

@Harmonical I don’t think it is the only solution although it is the solution for lots of people. I think CBT would probably work very well too. I don’t have the knowledge of that, I only know a bit about AA.
The good thing about AA as well is that it’s totally free and you’re encouraged to go to meetings every day at first. I think CBT/counselling would be great but the cost would put lots of people off.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 03:42

AA started in USA didn't it? So that's a point of context.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 03:41

Not RTFT sorry.

OP-

If you Google etc there is s whole load of stuff about the religious thing.

Also stuff about women attending being targeted.

Graphista · 26/07/2021 03:34

If he's in AA then he's an alcoholic - that's going to have FAR more impact on his life and mh than the 12 step programme designed to help him resist his addiction.

Addicts are ALWAYS addicts WILL always be addicts whether they're actively participating in their addiction or not

Quite honestly it sounds far more like your issues with religion and your religious upbringing are colouring your view on this than anything else - and I speak as a lapsed Catholic!

AA works for a lot of people - not everyone - but a lot

I have tons of addicts in my family and the ones that have achieved and MAINTAINED sobriety are the ones that not only joined recovery programmes but have remained in them.

Is your friend sober and clean?

Many addicts become addicts via self medicating mh issues. I've certainly seen that be the case in my family, I believe the issue is a genetic predisposition to severe depression - from which I also suffer. In my case it's manifested in ocd and agoraphobia

The addicts in my family have that have achieved sobriety have done so in different ways according to what approach works best for them. Some with AA, some with church based groups, some through more traditional psychotherapy, some through less conventional methods - if it works for them who has the right to criticise that?

Addiction is a bastard of an illness, it wrecks not only lives but whole families and communities.

We've still so much to learn about it eg it's now believed that addicts brains developed differently to others

It's not always substances either. It's gambling, spending, exercise...

The latter 2 of these still barely recognised in the Uk certainly not properly recognised within the nhs in my experience

Harmonical · 26/07/2021 03:27

The problem is @Harmonical the recidivism rate for all alcohol treatments is very high. It’s a very difficult addiction to treat.
Yes, which is all the more reason why people should be aware of the different treatment options available and there's no one-size-fits-all treatment.

And in fact the main thing should be not to treat the addiction itself, but the underlying reasons for turning to alcohol in the first place. But it can be very difficult for the alcoholic to be self aware enough to deal with this, and then they have to find a good sponsor who is also self aware and able to help the sponsee.
Why does that have to be done via a 12-step program with a sponsor? Why not, for example, CBT?

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 03:26

@Mockolate

I just find it unhelpful that it is such a major 12 step organisation and it has to mention God in the step's - that it isn't neutral in it's wording.

If that works for others though, so what?
Their way is just as valid as those finding comfort from Mother Nature or whatever.

It would put someone like me off if I had an issue. About 10 years ago, I had some issues and if I'd seen the 12 step programme for my issue I wouldn't have pursued it any further. So I can see that it can work for some people, like Mother Nature, but I would have seen the wording and not gone any further.

Also some religions do a lot of harm to people in the name of God. My parents, teachers, schools - really negative experiences - that's a valid point.

OP posts:
milkyaqua · 26/07/2021 03:23

[quote BabieDriver]@Harmonical - yes it's not for everyone. That why I don't feel it's right for my friend but I feel that he is very vulnerable.[/quote]
But he feels it's right for him, and has been helping him for the last ten years. Would you rather he relapsed?

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 03:18

Ozgirl I haven't really commented about the religiosity or otherwise. I'm aware that people are invited to conceptualise "higher power" in the way that's most useful to them. What concerns me is that people on this thread who are coming over as AA evangelists seem to be keen to discourage people from looking into that aspect of it before joining, whereas I'm a believer in informed consent. What concerns me more about AA is the number of people who've fallen victim to predators within AA because it's not set up in a way which allows for effective safeguarding, which attracts exploitative individuals, and the fact that the best guess anyone can make for the efficacy of AA is in the low single digits (and it's a guess because it's very difficult to do good science on AA). Nevertheless, there are many people who say it's helped them, so people who are thinking of joining should be given all the info they need to come to a decision. HTH.

Ozgirl75 · 26/07/2021 03:14

The problem is @Harmonical the recidivism rate for all alcohol treatments is very high. It’s a very difficult addiction to treat.
And in fact the main thing should be not to treat the addiction itself, but the underlying reasons for turning to alcohol in the first place. But it can be very difficult for the alcoholic to be self aware enough to deal with this, and then they have to find a good sponsor who is also self aware and able to help the sponsee.

Ozgirl75 · 26/07/2021 03:11

@CeciledeVolanges I’m not sure where you’ve got the idea that the higher power can be a doorknob from, I’m guessing you don’t know a huge amount about this?

Harmonical · 26/07/2021 03:11

Yes, but surely you can see that if anyone is seeking help from alcoholism, they don't need to be put off just because others think it's dubious because they might have a religious slant?!
AA has become almost synonymous with alcohol addiction treatment, despite there being mixed evidence as to it's effectiveness vs other treatments. It is also can be harmful to some people, particularly when those people don't realize that there are other treatment options out there. I wouldn't tell someone not to go, but I think that people should at least be more aware that it is just one of many options. I don't think the OP is unreasonable to worry that AA might not be helping her friend.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 03:11

@480Widdio - yes, he does have a lot of mental health problems. I was worried he was putting all his eggs in one basket with the12 step programmes because he doesn't have a life really. I wanted to get advice here first and it's actually good to hear that most comments are positive and posters don't feel it is pushing religion. It would be likely to be a very difficult conversation which he might be very defensive about - obviously it's up to him what he wants to do.

OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 26/07/2021 03:09

ClumpingBabools not Babboons Grin