Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Is Alcoholics Anon pushing religion

161 replies

BabieDriver · 25/07/2021 23:59

I have a hunch that a friend is "stuck" in 12 step programmes. He attends Alcoholics Anon and 2 other step groups. He has a lot of serious mental conditions and is starting NHS psychotherapy this month which is good news. He is very low and seems to get progressively worse doing lots of homework as part of the step work. It busies him up, keeps him thinking about his problems imo, and he hardly goes out and he's low most of the time. I've known him 3 years, but he's been in these programmes for over 10 years.

I never researched it before but I see that the wording of the 12 step for AA are mainly about God and that other 12 step orgs use roughly the same wording. I'm not against God, I believe in a God, but I don't follow any religion. I was brought up in a church religion and I strongly believe that support for vulnerable people and people with mental health issues should be secular - my church wanted to spread the word, it preached a lot of fear and I feel there is a similar angle in these steps and they are harmful and guilt-inducing, mentioning defects, atonement and giving up power.

Link: AA 12 Steps

My church liked people to stay for life. I hear that some people can stay in the step programmes all their lives too - vulnerable people. Yes, it does say that you don't have to believe, but if that's the case, why not re-write the steps and make it secular? Is it because religions are too powerful? I can't help but wonder how he would have fared in secular programmes that might not have an interest in keeping him long term? AIBU?

OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 26/07/2021 04:47

I’m guessing you have very limited experience of AA @ClumpingBambooIsALie - and that’s fine! There’s plenty you can do to find out more about it if you’re interested, but just baldly making unsubstantiated claims about an organisation that has helped millions of people (for free!) is odd. If people don’t like it, and it doesn’t work they don’t have to stay in it.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:47

@NiceGerbil

The reaction to this thread from some reminds me of the old stei**r schools threads.

No shut up they're great.

Thread deleted.

Yep exactly. People should put their opinions and others can make their own minds up. Like with the meds example I gave above. I just can't conceive of a situation where I'd read a thread by someone concerned about whether meds are working well for their friend, and instead of giving my experience or looking to info, go wailing to the mods about other people being mean and nasty about my wonderful tablets.
Ozgirl75 · 26/07/2021 04:45

But @ClumpingBambooIsALie loads of posters have explained that it doesn’t need to be explicitly religious, although it can be taken that way if you wish. It’s not that hard to understand.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:44

Basically:

AA isn't effective for very many people and is almost impossible to properly study for evidence of efficacy in order to make improvements.

Those for whom it is effective for have signed up to a very time-hungry, possibly lifelong commitment to a religiously-slanted organisation.

Significant numbers of people have been victimised within AA because its structure is such that it's an ideal hunting ground for predators, sexual and otherwise.

However, there do seem to be a few people for whom AA works when other treatment methods either haven't worked or are inaccessible to them. So, fair dos for those people I guess. It's just frustrating that the dominance of AA has potentially stymied other, safer, evidence-based interventions and approaches.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:38

The reaction to this thread from some reminds me of the old stei**r schools threads.

No shut up they're great.

Thread deleted.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:37

Posters were complaining that this thread might put people off AA, wanting to report the thread and have it deleted, berating people for having their own opinions, getting upset that somebody linked to the steps. I just think if they really wanted it to be a positive thread for AA, they'd explain why the Goddiness of the steps isn't necessarily an issue. Of course, it's possible that they can't do that very well, and all they can think of to try and get people to join is to try not to have people find out about the God stuff. Which is foolish, given it's right there on the AA site.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:37

Milky

A. That's not what they say
B. I'm glad it helped RB
C. Why is RBs version more relevant than the actual 12 steps?!

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:36

And this bloke has been going for 10 years. It consumes his thoughts and time.

And he is still struggling with his MH.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:35

That's how I feel clumping.

To teach people with addictions seeking help that they are powerless to stop is pretty rubbish tbh and also not true.

And then once you've accepted you're powerless. Then comes handing over your life to God, being open and Frank with God. Praying and meditating on him. And trusting He will sort out your problems.

That feels like the antithesis of how to go about it. To me anyway.

milkyaqua · 26/07/2021 04:34

Russell Brand's explication of the 12 Steps, as he sees them, for those who are uncomfortable with the original wording:

  1. Are you a bit fucked?
  2. Could you not be fucked?
  3. Are you, on your own, going to ‘unfuck’ yourself?
  4. Write down all the things that are fucking you up or have ever fucked you up and don’t lie or leave anything out.
  5. Honestly tell someone trustworthy about how fucked you are.
  6. Well that’s revealed a lot of fucked-up patterns. Do you want to stop it? Seriously?
  7. Are you willing to live in a new way that’s not all about you and your previous, fucked-up stuff? You have to.
  8. Prepare to apologize to everyone for everything affected by your being so fucked-up.
  9. Now apologize. Unless that would make things worse.
10. Watch out for fucked-up thinking and behavior and be honest when it happens. 11. Stay connected to your new perspective. 12. Look at life less selfishly, be nice to everyone, help people if you can.

HTH.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:32

Why the concern about damage limitation?

This is one thread on a huge site.

12 steps is widespread. NHS. I mean there's no danger of this thread damaging the reach of the 12 step program!

Also plenty of addicts are capable of reading considering info. Especially any reading Mumsnet.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:30

I also agree with your discomfort about the emphasis on the helplessness and impotence of the addict. They might as well explicitly say "you have to join AA and stay in it for the rest of your life, you're too weak to manage without us and leaving is an act of doomed arrogance".

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:26

Clumping the second 12 steps I posted are from the UK AA site.

Yep I saw what you were trying to do by posting both sets and agree that it's surprising that the religious part is still so explicit even in the UK. But I do know that in practice, UK people will… work around religious stuff if necessary. I think if the AA enthusiasts wanted to do damage limitation here, they'd be emphasising ways in which UK AA members interpret those rules in practice to foster a more inclusive environment, rather than trying to shut down people who have questions, concerns or opinions.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:22

From my POV the thrust of the first 3 or 4 steps is just really unhelpful.

Essentially you have to accept that there is NOTHING you do. No way. Not even worth thinking about. For you to escape addiction.

Not for yourself. Not for anything. Not even if you want to.

It's impossible.

Not that you will always be in recovery and have to watch yourself.

No. That it is impossible for you to stop.

The only way is to turn yourself over to a higher power (god). Only he can help.

That is to me fundamentally totally.. not right.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 04:15

@NiceGerbil

That list of steps to me is more like s religion or even a cult.

10 years and he's still going. Still has MH problems.

The step things he does take up s lot of his time and preoccupy him.

That's not s man who has got better. Is it.

I really struggle reading the steps. They surprise me - they don't feel like they belong in 2021.

I've also seen posts elsewhere about AA being cultish - but if all the responses here had confirmed that, then I would have been worried. I just think it's genuinely antiquated wording and obviously that will offend some posters here.

He's not well, he's really struggling. Glad he has NHS therapies.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:13

Clumping the second 12 steps I posted are from the UK AA site.

Yes very 'goddy'.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:12

In the end it's up to him.

I don't think saying anything will help.

Support him with his NHS treatment obv.

I agree with you that in the end. This has not has not essentially addressed his issues.

I'm sorry. For him and for you worrying.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:12

It is very Goddy-sounding. And that alone would, at first glance, put me off, since I'm non-religious. If pro-AAers want to encourage non-religious people to join, they'd be better off explaining how it works in practice in UK groups for non-religious people than stomping about demanding thread deletions and insulting people.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:10

@Mockolate

NiceGerbil think your internet's playing up, you've just posted that lol
Lol?

The first 12 steps is the original ones in the USA.

I must admit i expected to find some big differences in the current uk ones esp with the god stuff.

I was very surprised that they're essentially the same.

As you obviously noticed as well!

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 04:08

@Mockolate

One obsessive behaviour (addiction) is replaced with another 'crutch'. To me that doesn't feel like getting over it.

That's got nothing to do with the twelve steps though.
Which is what the original post was about.

@Mockolate - actually @Nicegerbil does make a good point.

My OP was about concerns about the 12 steps being connected with God but ALSO the way it has consumed my friend's time and it does feel like a crutch or a second addiction.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:08

That list of steps to me is more like s religion or even a cult.

10 years and he's still going. Still has MH problems.

The step things he does take up s lot of his time and preoccupy him.

That's not s man who has got better. Is it.

milkyaqua · 26/07/2021 04:06

I'm not quite sure what the point about "10 years" is. Some people find they need to continue to attend meetings for the rest of their lives.

A lot of people with mental health issues self-medicate with alcohol and drugs, and some also find after a period of sobriety that they have traumatic issues from their past to deal with - some via a therapist, psychiatrist, or counsellor, and others that lend themselves to another 12 step group if they are comfortable with that model. eg Al-Anon, if the problematic drinking of a family member has left them with unhealthy behaviours, presenting in recovery and leaving them confused and miserable; or GA for gambling, or whatever - finding support and hope in others who've worked on or are working on the same stuff.

What's it to anyone else? Just because you don't understand it and have a limited ability to imagine what it's like doesn't mean it's wrong.

Mockolate · 26/07/2021 04:05

NiceGerbil think your internet's playing up, you've just posted that lol

Coyoacan · 26/07/2021 04:05

I know quite a few people who not only have managed to give up alcohol and stay off it, but have also managed to grew as human beings to become very wise.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:05

Oh sorry.

My point is- and also seems to be plenty of stuff out there about it.

Is that finding it impossible to leave is not uncommon.

And that is not successful treatment. Is it.

You're still not free. Not really.