Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Is Alcoholics Anon pushing religion

161 replies

BabieDriver · 25/07/2021 23:59

I have a hunch that a friend is "stuck" in 12 step programmes. He attends Alcoholics Anon and 2 other step groups. He has a lot of serious mental conditions and is starting NHS psychotherapy this month which is good news. He is very low and seems to get progressively worse doing lots of homework as part of the step work. It busies him up, keeps him thinking about his problems imo, and he hardly goes out and he's low most of the time. I've known him 3 years, but he's been in these programmes for over 10 years.

I never researched it before but I see that the wording of the 12 step for AA are mainly about God and that other 12 step orgs use roughly the same wording. I'm not against God, I believe in a God, but I don't follow any religion. I was brought up in a church religion and I strongly believe that support for vulnerable people and people with mental health issues should be secular - my church wanted to spread the word, it preached a lot of fear and I feel there is a similar angle in these steps and they are harmful and guilt-inducing, mentioning defects, atonement and giving up power.

Link: AA 12 Steps

My church liked people to stay for life. I hear that some people can stay in the step programmes all their lives too - vulnerable people. Yes, it does say that you don't have to believe, but if that's the case, why not re-write the steps and make it secular? Is it because religions are too powerful? I can't help but wonder how he would have fared in secular programmes that might not have an interest in keeping him long term? AIBU?

OP posts:
Lepetitpiggy · 26/07/2021 10:22

@cassandre

Lepetitpiggy that's awful, the people who told you to stop taking your meds were 100 percent wrong and are giving AA a bad name Angry

Nowhere in AA literature are you told to stop taking prescribed drugs. I've had one AA member mansplain to me that I didn't need my antidepressant meds. I told him politely to fuck off. In fact my antidepressants seem to work a lot better now that I'm not mixing them with alcohol.

There are nutters in 'the rooms' unfortunately, but I've found them to be a minority. I gravitate to the people I like/identify with in recovery and give the rest a wide berth.

I felt constantly pestered and 'love bombed'. It was very unsettling. I tried all the meetings in my city and the same people were there so I chose to go alone!
Teeturtle · 26/07/2021 09:54

[quote BabieDriver]@FlappyFish

I've not seen that the steps have been re-written when I look on other 12 step websites - where did you see them re-written?

"In AA, God can mean whatever you want it to be. It’s simply a power greater than yourself. The point being your best intentions couldn’t help you get on top of addiction, so perhaps something bigger than you can."

This is a much better explanation - but I still have a problem with the word God being used. It would be better if they used your words.[/quote]
Why have you started a thread about something you obviously have zero knowledge or experience of? Your ignorant thread could put somebody off from seeking the help they need.

The AA is not Christian, it is not religious at all and this would be very clear to anybody from their very first meeting. This point and the explanation of a higher power is made each and every time and your friend could not possibly have missed this.

cassandre · 26/07/2021 09:49

Just saw Qwerty's post. Yikes. Yes, the founders were very religious. But most members today are not, at least not in my experience. Yes, there are many references to God in the original literature. I and many others interpret them metaphorically. If you would find that difficult, then AA is probably not the recovery group for you. Something like Smart would be better.

I don't think anything should be forced down people's throats, especially not AA, so I think the Supreme Court decision was bang on point.

cassandre · 26/07/2021 09:35

Lepetitpiggy that's awful, the people who told you to stop taking your meds were 100 percent wrong and are giving AA a bad name Angry

Nowhere in AA literature are you told to stop taking prescribed drugs. I've had one AA member mansplain to me that I didn't need my antidepressant meds. I told him politely to fuck off. In fact my antidepressants seem to work a lot better now that I'm not mixing them with alcohol.

There are nutters in 'the rooms' unfortunately, but I've found them to be a minority. I gravitate to the people I like/identify with in recovery and give the rest a wide berth.

Lepetitpiggy · 26/07/2021 09:09

I tried AA, really didn't like it - as the groups I attended seemed very pushy and tried to suggest my mental illness was 'only' alcoholism and i should stop taking my medication. I would tentatively use the word 'cult' for these people.
I have stayed sober with no outside help for 8 years now. However, I also work with substance abusers who have no supportive family or friends and find the fellowship amazing.

Personally, sitting in a room twice a week talking about drinking isn't my bag but many people do find it works.

So many opinions on the 'A's abound

cassandre · 26/07/2021 09:03

I might add that I hope anyone struggling with drinking doesn't avoid AA because the think it's going to be too religious! I avoided it myself for that reason for ages. Once I actually tried it out, I found out that most members weren't religious. And it gave me the support I needed to get sober.

In parts of the US I'm sure the meetings are more god-centric, but that's because parts of the US are culturally very evangelical.

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 09:01

I have been sober in Alcoholics Anonymous for over 18years.It has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with Religion

That's simply not true and you know it. If it had absolutely nothing to do with religion there would no be so many religious references in it! It was founded by fundamentalist christians, and even the US Supreme Court declared it to be religious, and that it was unconstitutional to mandate people to join as you can't force people into religion.

It's rather cultlike in many ways. If you're telling us AA is nothing to do with religion, you;re either deluded or lying, and neither looks good for AA.

lljkk · 26/07/2021 08:26

@NiceGerbil

That's how I feel clumping.

To teach people with addictions seeking help that they are powerless to stop is pretty rubbish tbh and also not true.

And then once you've accepted you're powerless. Then comes handing over your life to God, being open and Frank with God. Praying and meditating on him. And trusting He will sort out your problems.

That feels like the antithesis of how to go about it. To me anyway.

That's a misinterpretation.

Step 3-11 are essential they are about the things the person isn't powerless over: becoming willing to change, and taking responsibility for their actions. Free Will still exists in AA. Free Will means accepting that the disease is ruining your life, it's a problem bigger than your ability to fix by yourself, so you need all the help you can get to change. And you have a duty to make amends & try to be a better person. You always have Free Will it's always your decision to be willing to get better and to try to be a better person. Not powerless over everything, just powerless over alcohol (or narcotics or gambling or binge eating, etc)

Often the "higher power" is the programme itself & the 12 step process.

OP: if you went to Al-Anon, as a "supportive friend of an alcoholic" that might help you understand the 12 step process better. Beware you'll hear some harrowing stories and be frustrated by people who don't know how to set good boundaries. But is a good way to figure out for yourself how to keep your sanity & still be a good friend.

ArabellaStrange · 26/07/2021 08:02

Just wanted to say thank you OP for starting this thread. It has given me knowledge that I did not have before.

cassandre · 26/07/2021 07:52

Al Anon isn't the same as AA, AA is for alcoholics and Al Anon is for the friends and family of alcoholics.

I've been in AA for about 5 years now, and honestly, my take is that it is what you make of it. Yes, the founders were patriarchal and religious. However, you don't have to be religious to get help from it. The most powerful aspect for me has been listening to other people's stories and being able to talk frankly about struggling with addiction to other people who have been there. Yes, there are some toxic people in AA, but that's true of any group with open membership. It's not a cult, whether and how often you want to go to meetings is entirely up to you. The honesty and vulnerability that people regularly demonstrate when talking about their lives are very moving.

Some people in AA think it's the one true path to sobriety, I disagree. There are lots of tools for recovery out there and AA is just one. It won't suit everyone, but for me it was a lifeline. Where I live, there are loads of meetings and you slowly get to know the ones that suit you. I tend to avoid the big meetings that are more 'by the book' and go to the smaller, quirkier meetings.

I also like NA because its vocabulary is more secular than the AA vocabulary. NA sees alcohol as just another drug, so alcoholics are welcome at NA meetings.

AA has been around so long that there are plenty of more nuanced and secular versions of the 12 steps, as people have said. A Woman's Way Through the 12 Steps, for example, is a feminist take on AA. It acknowledges that the discourse of powerlessness is not v helpful to women, whose self-esteem is often low to begin with, so redefines powerlessness in a more empowering way (ha). To me, powerlessness means that I can't control what other people do -- instead of pouring all my energy into making them happy, I can look after myself. Another excellent secular version of the 12 steps is in Gabor Mate's extraordinary book about addiction, In the Realm of Hungry Ghosts.

Personally I attend AA meetings but have read a lot of other literature about addiction on the side. Other people in AA are quite religious and stick to the AA Big Book (which I find old-fashioned and patriarchal, but to each their own).

If your friend has been going to AA so long, he has likely built up a support network that is very valuable to him. But if the meetings are making him unhappy, that's a different story. Maybe he needs a different sponsor (does he have a sponsor?) or a different approach to recovery. Only he can answer that question.

CeciledeVolanges · 26/07/2021 07:09

@Ozgirl75 I heard it at AA, actually. My aunt has heard the same thing, as has my sponsor.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 05:20

@milkyaqua

I'm not goading you, OP, only pointing out the facts. You don't know anything about AA. That is very clear.

I have tried to provide alternate and possibly helpful insights to you.

You seem only interested in people who will back you up on how terrible it is your friend/boyfriend is spending time in the dreaded AA, and from a position of knowing nothing about AA, positing wild theories. Perhaps you would rather your friend relapse? Have you spent much time around active alcoholism or drug addiction? It is not pretty.

I've not claimed that I know anything about AA - you will see that in my original post. I never expected to be told off 4 times now - and there you go again! I've been polite to everyone else because everyone else was polite to me. I didn't come here spoiling for a fight. You seem so annoyed about everything and it's getting quite dramatic and you are insinuating he is my boyfriend and calling it dreaded AA.

Your words, your tone, not mine. Come on, it's not clever.

OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 05:08

The percentage recovering might be better in the UK, because we don't have the system of court-ordering people to attend AA meetings that the US has, which would no doubt result in lots of people attending who have no real interest in doing the programme.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 05:04

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

I also agree with your discomfort about the emphasis on the helplessness and impotence of the addict. They might as well explicitly say "you have to join AA and stay in it for the rest of your life, you're too weak to manage without us and leaving is an act of doomed arrogance".
Yes, for some people who are really broken and vulnerable and lacking in confidence, it could keep them like a hamster on a wheel. Personality plays a part - stronger personalities might adapt things to suit them.
OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 05:03

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

Which unsubstantiated claims Oz? The "thirteenth step"?
If you mean re: efficacy, this article explains some of why it's so hard to get good data: www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/04/the-irrationality-of-alcoholics-anonymous/386255/

Quote: Lance Dodes, a retired psychiatry professor from Harvard Medical School, looked at Alcoholics Anonymous’s retention rates along with studies on sobriety and rates of active involvement (attending meetings regularly and working the program) among AA members. Based on these data, he put AA’s actual success rate somewhere between 5 and 8 percent.

To be honest most substance use treatments have pretty shitty recovery rates though.

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 05:01

'Perhaps you would rather your friend relapse?'

Yikes.

And.

Wow. Nice!

NiceGerbil · 26/07/2021 04:59

'There’s plenty you can do to find out more about it if you’re interested,'

Yes indeed. Google has loads of info.

milkyaqua · 26/07/2021 04:57

That's perfect!

Good. I'm glad I was able to offer something.

milkyaqua · 26/07/2021 04:56

I'm not goading you, OP, only pointing out the facts. You don't know anything about AA. That is very clear.

I have tried to provide alternate and possibly helpful insights to you.

You seem only interested in people who will back you up on how terrible it is your friend/boyfriend is spending time in the dreaded AA, and from a position of knowing nothing about AA, positing wild theories. Perhaps you would rather your friend relapse? Have you spent much time around active alcoholism or drug addiction? It is not pretty.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 04:55

@milkyaqua

Russell Brand's explication of the 12 Steps, as he sees them, for those who are uncomfortable with the original wording:
  1. Are you a bit fucked?
  2. Could you not be fucked?
  3. Are you, on your own, going to ‘unfuck’ yourself?
  4. Write down all the things that are fucking you up or have ever fucked you up and don’t lie or leave anything out.
  5. Honestly tell someone trustworthy about how fucked you are.
  6. Well that’s revealed a lot of fucked-up patterns. Do you want to stop it? Seriously?
  7. Are you willing to live in a new way that’s not all about you and your previous, fucked-up stuff? You have to.
  8. Prepare to apologize to everyone for everything affected by your being so fucked-up.
  9. Now apologize. Unless that would make things worse.
10. Watch out for fucked-up thinking and behavior and be honest when it happens. 11. Stay connected to your new perspective. 12. Look at life less selfishly, be nice to everyone, help people if you can.

HTH.

That's perfect!
OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 26/07/2021 04:50

In conclusion - some people find AA works for them (millions of people), some don’t.
In answer to your question about religion: no, it isn’t explicitly religious unless you want it to be.
Hope that helps.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 04:49

@milkyaqua

The OP knows nothing about AA - hasn't even got the name right. It's Alcoholics Anonymous, not Alcoholics Anon.

If she'd met her friend eleven years ago, rather than three - therefore, only knowing him in his sobriety - she might have a very different 'feeling' about it, this thing she doesn't know anything about.

Meanwhile, it is none of her business how he spends his time, or what other issues he may be feeling the need to address in other fellowships.

Goodness! The last time I got corrected for abbreviating something was from one of those teachers I was talking about.

That is a perfectly reasonable abbreviation too - I didn't want the title to be too long - you are being pedantic?

So you have told me off 3 times in once post above: "OP knows nothing/she doesn't know anything/it's none of her business." Oh no!

Unfortunately you won't get the satisfaction of goading me if this is something that entertains you. You're funny. Have a good night @milkyaqua!

OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:49

Which unsubstantiated claims Oz? The "thirteenth step"?

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 26/07/2021 04:48

*or linking to info

milkyaqua · 26/07/2021 04:48

@NiceGerbil

Milky

A. That's not what they say
B. I'm glad it helped RB
C. Why is RBs version more relevant than the actual 12 steps?!

It was just an example of how different people interpret the same steps, written in language that bothers some.

The OP is bothered by seeing the word 'God', not noticing the phrase 'God as we understood him' - ie, as we as individuals interpret this idea - or realising there are many cultures with no concept of God at all in their religions who also find benefits and recovery in AA, etc, and also many atheists in AA.

Also, how can you - not in AA or NA, like Russell is - say that's not what they say? How could you possibly know the nuances of meaning in these words that have no meaning to you?