Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Is Alcoholics Anon pushing religion

161 replies

BabieDriver · 25/07/2021 23:59

I have a hunch that a friend is "stuck" in 12 step programmes. He attends Alcoholics Anon and 2 other step groups. He has a lot of serious mental conditions and is starting NHS psychotherapy this month which is good news. He is very low and seems to get progressively worse doing lots of homework as part of the step work. It busies him up, keeps him thinking about his problems imo, and he hardly goes out and he's low most of the time. I've known him 3 years, but he's been in these programmes for over 10 years.

I never researched it before but I see that the wording of the 12 step for AA are mainly about God and that other 12 step orgs use roughly the same wording. I'm not against God, I believe in a God, but I don't follow any religion. I was brought up in a church religion and I strongly believe that support for vulnerable people and people with mental health issues should be secular - my church wanted to spread the word, it preached a lot of fear and I feel there is a similar angle in these steps and they are harmful and guilt-inducing, mentioning defects, atonement and giving up power.

Link: AA 12 Steps

My church liked people to stay for life. I hear that some people can stay in the step programmes all their lives too - vulnerable people. Yes, it does say that you don't have to believe, but if that's the case, why not re-write the steps and make it secular? Is it because religions are too powerful? I can't help but wonder how he would have fared in secular programmes that might not have an interest in keeping him long term? AIBU?

OP posts:
OliveToboogie · 26/07/2021 15:05

I attend AA. It was founded by 2 ppl who felt only God could break their addiction. However at ever meeting we talk about your Higher Power as you understand it. Many in the group agnostic and atheist.

lljkk · 26/07/2021 14:27

AA isn't supposed to be evangelical. Programme of Attraction not Promotion.

Some people, mostly newbies, go obsessive about it but that's because of their character & stage of recovery, not that 12 step programmes encourage that.

I was wondering for people who have found recovery from alcoholism with other programmes, what they found was the core reasons why the alternative worked well for them. fwiw, one thing I like about 12-steps is that it doesn't necessarily require huge introspection beyond what you need to understand to stop the crappy attitudes that got you in trouble. 12-steppers spend a lot of time monitoring their inner demons, but that's about being honest with self not focusing on the past any more than necessary.

Keepemguessing · 26/07/2021 13:45

I found AA cult-like and very unhelpful. What helped me was therapy with trained professionals, not carrying out the steps through my (lovely but amateur) sponsor.

AA has kept my XH sober for 6 years. I have yet to receive any apology from him about the way he treated me.

cassandre · 26/07/2021 13:18

You have not been in the slightest bit honest about the actual programme.

Sigh. I think part of the confusion here stems from people thinking that the 12 steps as they were written 80 or so years ago somehow sum up AA today. In fact they don't. AA has morphed hugely over the past century. There is a big gap between the way the original literature is written and the way AA members practice and understand the programme today. It would probably be better if this gap didn't exist, but it does. With all due respect, Qwerty, you don't seem to have been to AA meetings, so you know very little about how AA recovery works in real life, outside the literature. If you walk into any AA meeting and ask any AA member whether AA is a religious programme, they will tell you no. They may well tell you that 'the only requirement for membership is the desire to stop drinking', which is true. It's the only criterion. Whether or not you want to get a sponsor and work the steps, and how you work the steps, is completely up to you. Accepting the validity of the 12 steps is NOT a criterion for membership.

For some members, just going to meetings is enough; it's like a kind of group therapy. But if you do decide to work the steps, it's an intense programme of self-exploration. There's a lot of list-making. For example, you list everything you're resentful about. You list everything you've done that you're ashamed of -- and believe me, most alcoholics carry around an absolutely massive burden of shame. You share these lists with a trusted person. And it's incredibly cathartic. You look at all the resentment and shame, and realise you don't have to let it dominate your life. You don't abdicate responsibility, but you realise that you have the capacity to change if you want to. For me, one of the most powerful elements of AA is the belief that people can change: that your past doesn't have to condemn your future. That's where AA is rather like existentialist philosophy. (Note that it's all very focused on self-change though; it's not a recipe for political revolution, even though Russell Brand would like to make it that, ha.)

Not everyone wants to do that kind of intense self-examination, but for me, it was very freeing and life-changing. The thing is, just stopping drinking isn't enough. You need ways to deal with the anxiety and sadness that made you drink in the first place, and that's what the steps try to help you do. Some people might fare better with CBT-type strategies, which I think are used in programmes like Smart.

There's also a huge cross-over between mental illness and addiction (addiction is often an attempt at self-medication), and for some people, AA on its own isn't enough. They need professional therapy too, and/or medication. So I think it's good that the OP's friend is getting NHS psychotherapy. If he's dwelling for too long on the negative aspects of the step work (resentment/shame etc), that's not helpful either. The whole point is not to wallow, but to get all that stuff off your chest so that you can move on and live a freer, more authentic life.

Sorry for all the long posts. This thread has really made me reflect about the AA framework and how it looks to outsiders, especially non-alcoholics. I guess I've become so used to the inclusive ethos of the meetings I go to and the members I know, that I forget how full-on the religious language is when you look at it on its own, and how alienating that appears to some people. I do understand why it would be alienating, believe me!

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 12:15

@Mantlemoose

Once you're an alcoholic you're one for life so would make sense you're a member of AA for life? I guess it's swapping one addiction for another.

If you really cared, you'd have researched what being an alcoholic means. You aren't one and can't understand. Leave it alone.

I did some research but there were mixed opinions about whether people stay for life with AA. I'm a bit weary of being told I don't care - these are just digs for the sake getting reactions - I'm not going there. Some people on this thread haven't stayed for life. It's really useful to hear everyone's lived experiences and hear all the positive experiences and viewpoints.
OP posts:
BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 11:51

@fucknuckle - thank you I really appreciate that and huge respect to you for how you've coped and the way you explained this.

OP posts:
fucknuckle · 26/07/2021 11:50

i would add that i was 41 when i got sober. i was a rock-bottom alcoholic who lost everything due to drink. i went from being a successful professional to a recluse in a grotty flat, bingeing for days then suffering withdrawals. alcohol withdrawal can kill you, it’s a serious business. i was in AA for about 6 months before i finally stopped drinking. when i got serious about getting sober and actually put the work in, i just never picked up that first drink again and haven’t since. i’m an alcoholic who is very, very grateful that AA was there when i had tried and failed to get sober any other way.

dangerrabbit · 26/07/2021 11:48

@NiceGerbil

None of this is new it's been in the news etc from time to time for years.

In the end if it suits you then good.

Googling just now I did see s few things about those who can't leave- it becomes a key part of their life. I don't think that's particularly healthy.

One obsessive behaviour (addiction) is replaced with another 'crutch'. To me that doesn't feel like getting over it.

I do sometimes wonder how it has become the usual treatment.

NHS had a link.

I was looking at the priory the other day they do it.

Good point, this critique of the alcoholic taking another "role in the game" was actually raised by the psychiatrist and psychotherapist Eric Berne in his 1964 book "games people play" which conceptualises the social role of alcoholism. More information is available here:

climbtothestars.org/archives/2002/09/22/games-people-play-alcoholicaddict/

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 11:47

@cassandre

I give up Qwerty, I've been as brutally honest as I know how to be about my experience with AA. If you perceive me to be lying, that's your prerogative.
You have not been in the slightest bit honest about the actual programme. I am not interested in your personal experience, other to understand why you are pretending that blatantly religious elements are somehow not.

I do not percieve you to be lying, it can be seen objectively that you are. I suggest you have another look at step 10

fucknuckle · 26/07/2021 11:46

i’m an alcoholic. i first got drunk aged 8 and spent my life as an alcoholic, gradually getting worse and worse until i was genuinely on the verge of dying.

i got sober with AA and have stayed that way for over 7 years. i was very sceptical at first as i am against any form of organised religion.

the thing is, if you strip out the bits that seem religious, what the steps actually are, are therapy. you work through all the shit that’s gone on in your life and then get rid of it. i got a sponsor, did the steps and it saved my life.

i have a higher power. it’s not the same as anyone else’s but anyone in AA who has got sober by working the steps has one.

even the Serenity Prayer that closes most meetings is prefaced with ‘using the word God as you do or will come to understand it’.

i dip in and out of meetings, but i still go because i will always be an alcoholic. i also live with mental illness and nobody has ever suggested that i stop taking my meds.

AA isn’t for everyone. but it does save lives. it’s not some sinister cult, it’s a lifeline for people who can’t manage their own lives any more due to their alcoholism.

BabieDriver · 26/07/2021 11:39

@ArabellaStrange - it's been very informative for me too. I generally think comments have been positive.

OP posts:
Mantlemoose · 26/07/2021 11:37

Once you're an alcoholic you're one for life so would make sense you're a member of AA for life? I guess it's swapping one addiction for another.

If you really cared, you'd have researched what being an alcoholic means. You aren't one and can't understand. Leave it alone.

MrsMillhouse · 26/07/2021 11:37

Both parents have been sober for over 40 years due to AA. So, it works.

cassandre · 26/07/2021 11:33

Thanks for the book rec, CousinKrispy!

cassandre · 26/07/2021 11:31

I give up Qwerty, I've been as brutally honest as I know how to be about my experience with AA. If you perceive me to be lying, that's your prerogative.

CousinKrispy · 26/07/2021 11:31

p.s. I always recommend a great book by Charlotte Kasl called Many Roads, One Journey. It's kind of a feminist critique of the 12 steps, and would probably be enjoyed by everyone here who is steamed about the religious side of AA Smile. Kasl's take is very much "If AA works for you and you're happy with it, that's fine" though; she doesn't feel the need to tear it down just because because of its patriarchal/religious underpinnings and because there are other approaches that are more helpful for some people.

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 26/07/2021 11:30

One of the AA meetings I attend uses "Group Of Drunks" to mean G-D, which I like, as that group of drunks I count as some of my closest and dearest friends are absolutely key to my ongoing sobriety.

AA is free to attend, there are thousands of meetings up and down the country, at all times of day. You take what you need from it, and are free to leave the rest.

I've never had a sponsor, and I never worked the Steps - I simply didn't feel the need to.

I wonder how many people on here who are castigating AA have actually attended a meeting? There are open meetings for friends and family members to join in and support the alcoholic in their lives.

CousinKrispy · 26/07/2021 11:28

A close friend has been keeping sober with in AA for several years now. He is not religious but doesn't find the references to religion problematic (he is in America, so his local chapter probably has more of a religious slant than any AA group over here would do!).

Much of the value in the programme is having a community of other people who understand what he's been through and are there for him; he has a really good relationship with his sponsor and has found it life-changing.

AA specifically isn't the right fit for everyone, and there are other recovery approaches worth trying if this one doesn't seem to be working for your friend. But please don't rubbish AA in generalit helps many people struggling with addiction and it's very defeatist and unhelpful to flounce around saying, "Oh, it mentions god and I don't like that, so I don't think people should do it"let each individual find out what works best for them.

Everyone should remember there are many paths to recovery.

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 11:28

Qwerty, as I keep saying, the original programme was religious. The programme now isn't religious unless you choose to interpret it that way

And as I keep saying, that is an outright LIE.

3.Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.

  1. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

6.Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

  1. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

These are not steps that you need to CHOOSE to interpret as religious, they are blatantly and obviously religious.

The question is why are you lying about this? That's disturbing.

cassandre · 26/07/2021 11:20

Qwerty, as I keep saying, the original programme was religious. The programme now isn't religious unless you choose to interpret it that way. Some people do and some people don't. If you don't like the religious phrasing, no worries: find another recovery group. The heart of the programme for me isn't the official, old-fashioned AA literature; it's about what people in the rooms are actually saying and doing.

FWIW I grew up in an ultra-fundamentalist Christian church and if I did consider religion to be at AA's core, I couldn't stomach it. If you go to meetings, what you will mostly get is a lot of people sharing about their private lives, and a lot of practical wisdom: 'One day at a time.' 'Live and let live.' 'Easy does it.' 'First things first.'

As a result of my fundie background though, I am repelled at the notion of proselytising for anything, so proselytising for AA is the last thing I want to do. If it's not your bag, as someone said above, no worries!

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 11:08

So what you are saying is that you took a blatantly religious program and somehow managed to make it feel non religious for you. Which is great, if that worked for you...but why are you pretending that its not actually religious?
It's honesty one of the steps?

cassandre · 26/07/2021 11:03

I agree, the original language is absolutely steeped in religion. I don't find it helpful either. But for me, the point of AA is finding other people who are supporting one another to stay clean and sober, one day at a time. AA has helped me despite the religious vocab, not because of it, and I know I'm not alone. (See the Russell Brand version of the steps cited above!)

I've worked through the steps with a sponsor (also non-religious) and for the steps you quote, I interpreted them as something like: 'Decided to listen to and trust my best self rather thinking I needed to numb my emotions with drink in order to cope with daily life.' 'Was ready to think about the painful side effects of my addictive behaviours, and get to the root of the insecurities that were making me drink.' 'Decided to listen to my best self and make a conscious effort to find other coping strategies instead of resorting to my familiar addictive behaviours.' 'Took time out of my ultra-busy daily life to meditate/go for a walk/have a bath/read a novel or whatever I need to find a bit of serenity.'

So for me, it was entirely non religious. I don't pray. My sponsor was supportive. I know that what I've said above about my interpretation of the steps is wildly different to what the steps actually say (!), but again, I know many others have used the programme as I have, as a method of soul-searching that doesn't involve God. In some ways AA is quite similar to Stoic philosophy, and also to existentialism, though AA purists might be horrified at those comparisons.

If AA were being invented today, the steps would certainly read very differently. And I don't think it's a bad thing that so many other recovery groups have sprung up in addition to AA. There's nothing magical about the steps. It's a lot of hard work: facing up to truths about yourself and ultimately being compassionate in the face of your own imperfections.

Sniv · 26/07/2021 10:33

This thread has been a real eye-opener for me. I've heard about '12 step' programs, but it turns out those steps are nothing like I assumed they were.

Even if you are advised to replace the word 'god' with whatever works for you, I honestly can't fathom what sort of concept an atheist could logically replace god with in the steps like: "Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him," "Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character," "Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings." " Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out."

This 'higher power' needs to have a 'will for us' and be able to 'take care of us' and 'remove our shortcomings'. The majesty of space or lovely old oak tree in my garden or the memory of my granny or whatever else people are implying I can replace 'god' with can't do these things unless I deify them and, in a way, become religious.

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 10:30

@cassandre

Just saw Qwerty's post. Yikes. Yes, the founders were very religious. But most members today are not, at least not in my experience. Yes, there are many references to God in the original literature. I and many others interpret them metaphorically. If you would find that difficult, then AA is probably not the recovery group for you. Something like Smart would be better.

I don't think anything should be forced down people's throats, especially not AA, so I think the Supreme Court decision was bang on point.

It's not just in the original literature, its in the current literature. You can interpret the religious references however you want, but to deny they are religious references is to lie.
cassandre · 26/07/2021 10:26

That's such a shame, Lepetitpiggy, if the meetings in my area had been like that, I would have run a mile too. Sad

Congratulations on your 8 years of sobriety by the way, what a fantastic achievement Flowers