Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that all men are a bit shit?

181 replies

Vitallyli · 25/07/2021 21:32

I love DH, he's intelligent, generous, loves me, our DS, our dog, my family, he's not a cheater, not a gambler, but he also has low self esteem, can get paranoid about me cheating, can get depressed, drinks more than I think is okay, we are in our mid 30s, can shout at me sometimes, doesn't help me around the house much would rather make me a massage. He tells me compliments daily though, boosted my self esteem after birth for which I'll be eternally grateful. I hope I paint a fair picture. AIBU to think that all men are flawed and there is no perfect relationships and women have to put up with one thing or another or is there a beautiful loving, caring and respectful relationships out there?

OP posts:
TheDevils · 26/07/2021 09:26

Yes exactly that ! I think most men would have arranged their own household differently and don't appreciate being nagged into doing everything the woman's way.

Well, a household should be run jointly. Decisions on how to arrange your household should be made together.
I ever have and never will 'nag' ( awful misogynistic term btw) my DH to do something. We decide together how to approach something and sometimes that means compromising. I certainly don't think that everything should be done my way.

thepeopleversuswork · 26/07/2021 09:03

I can rephrase my question to is co-living a bit shit?

Yes exactly. To which my answer is a resounding YES.

Love men to bits and wouldn't want to be without them.

But I hate living with them and I think as a general rule and where affordable, women and children do far better living independently from men.

Vitallyli · 26/07/2021 08:56

@thepeopleversuswork

I think some of you are missing the point.

It’s not so much that “all men are any more shit then women” intrinsically.

But I do think quite a lot of men are fairly shit to be in long term relationships or cohabiting with.

Because society has been structured for millennia to benefit men at the expense of women and while it’s changing, a lot of men subconsciously still see themselves as top dog in a household and act accordingly.

The question isn’t really whether men are shit in themselves, the question is whether a woman actually benefits more than she loses by setting up home with one.

I would argue personally that aside from the advantage of having more household money in nine cases out of ten the answer is no.

Men are lovely and fine on their own terms and in their place but they are often a bit of a burden to live with and on a cost/benefit analysis often not worth the grief.

Yes exactly that ! I think most men would have arranged their own household differently and don't appreciate being nagged into doing everything the woman's way. I can rephrase my question to is co-living a bit shit? But then I've got single female friends who want** babies, families, being loved, companionship and are lonely without these things.
OP posts:
lovelybitofsquirrell · 26/07/2021 08:52

All people have a few shit qualities.

I'm certainly more flawed than my DP

thepeopleversuswork · 26/07/2021 08:49

I think some of you are missing the point.

It’s not so much that “all men are any more shit then women” intrinsically.

But I do think quite a lot of men are fairly shit to be in long term relationships or cohabiting with.

Because society has been structured for millennia to benefit men at the expense of women and while it’s changing, a lot of men subconsciously still see themselves as top dog in a household and act accordingly.

The question isn’t really whether men are shit in themselves, the question is whether a woman actually benefits more than she loses by setting up home with one.

I would argue personally that aside from the advantage of having more household money in nine cases out of ten the answer is no.

Men are lovely and fine on their own terms and in their place but they are often a bit of a burden to live with and on a cost/benefit analysis often not worth the grief.

LostThings · 26/07/2021 08:40

If you're not happy with some of the things your DP does, then you need to address it with him OP. Of course you can't say "All men are ..." any more than you can say "All women are ..."

notanothertakeaway · 26/07/2021 08:39

My DH isn't perfect. Nor am I. And that's fine

But we treat each other with respect, do our best to be good partners and talk openly and honestly. We never raise our voices, and have shared values and expectations

You describe some quite major issues..... drinking to excess, shouting, not doing his share of household tasks, accusing you of infidelity

LunaNorth · 26/07/2021 08:29

All human beings are flawed, but your bar is pretty low, OP.

Your DH shouldn’t shout at you.

DrSbaitso · 26/07/2021 08:29

It's a really annoying feature of MN, the "I picked a shitty man so I'm going to keep saying that all men are shitty to make me less stupid about my choice".

Harsh but fair.

DrSbaitso · 26/07/2021 08:27

AIBU to think that all men are flawed and there is no perfect relationships and women have to put up with one thing or another

Well, of course this is true, but it's only half the story, isn't it?

or is there a beautiful loving, caring and respectful relationships out there?

There are, but they're not perfect either.

My marriage isn't perfect. How could it be? But it's beautiful, loving and caring. I much prefer life with him to life without him and I don't want anyone else.

You're unhappy in your relationship. There are options for addressing that. Maybe it's fixable, maybe it's not.

ComDummings · 26/07/2021 08:23

My husband isn’t perfect but he’s a better person than me 100%. The funny thing is he would say the same about me because for some reason he doesn’t see my flaws the same way I see myself. Humans are, to varying degrees, great but awful.

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 08:22

It's a really annoying feature of MN, the "I picked a shitty man so I'm going to keep saying that all men are shitty to make me less stupid about my choice".

Sorry, but no dice. My DH is not a shitty man, neither are my brothers, and nor or my sons. And on that point, I hope you don't have any sons, because your attitude is appalling for them.

dottiedodah · 26/07/2021 08:13

I think all men are flawed obv ,however drinking too much and not helping around the house seem to be fairly serious flaws tbh!. I have never gone in for this my husband is perfect yours isn't that some women play . I think you have maybe accepted this behaviour, but he should help around the house really unless he wants to pay for a cleaner!

TheDevils · 26/07/2021 08:07

As other people have already pointed out -people are flawed.

I'm in a very happy relationship but of course we both put up with each other's flaws and annoying habits. However, these are little things not big things which make either of us feel upset regularly or disrespected in anyway.

FlowerArranger · 26/07/2021 07:58

@Just10moreminutesplease

As PP have said all people are flawed. My DH is no more flawed than I am.

Are you asking if it’s normal for your partner to be jealous, shout at you, drink too much, and not pull his weight around the house? Whether this is ‘normal’ or not doesn’t really matter... it’s not a healthy way to live and not gambling or cheating doesn’t make up for it.

Agree - @Vitallyli - you've set yourself a low bar if you are willing to accept this behaviour.
Lessthanaballpark · 26/07/2021 07:54

Mumsnet has a lot of women who hate men. I hate that aspect of it

Oh please! Most of the replies on this thread have pushed back on the OP and stuck up for men.

Are you that naive that you think a similar “I hate women” post on a male dominated forum would be met with “oh no women are great”. You only have to venture outside mumsnet to see the internet is crawling with incel philosophy yet sure, it’s women who hate men!

Bagelsandbrie · 26/07/2021 07:38

I couldn’t cope with anyone shouting at me.

But yes I think all people have faults.

Mumsnet has a lot of women who hate men. I hate that aspect of it, it reminds me of my Mum who raised me believing that all men are shit and it took a long time for me to shake that off so that I could have healthy relationships. It’s really not good for children to be raised with sexism, either way.

I’m not perfect and neither is dh. It’s just whether you can learn to live with each other really.

Maskless · 26/07/2021 07:37

@IonaLeg

"his amazing bits."

I'd definitely like to hear more about them!

LOL

SimonJT · 26/07/2021 07:31

Everyone is flawed.

Your husband however sounds a bit of a twat, being flawed is completely different to being someone who shouts as their partner.

Lessthanaballpark · 26/07/2021 07:31

This isn’t an ‘all men are shit’ problem, it’s a YOUR man is a bit shit problem

Kind of like John Stuart Mill in reverse then? Wink

But seriously. I don’t think men are shittier than women, but their shitty behaviour seems to get a pass more than women’s. And they are less aware of their flaws because women are taught to second guess themselves.

Go to the porn thread and watch that video about the effect of porn on boys and girls. Boys thinking it’s ok to ejaculate on a girl’s face (without even asking) and girls feeling like they have to put up with it because it’s normalised.

YouShouldLeave · 26/07/2021 07:27

@dewisant2020

I've never understand why woman constantly put men down, as a mother of a son I am mortified to think he's going to be constantly judged just because he's a man. All humans are 'shit' to a degree, we all have flaws no matter what's between our legs. I know some amazing men and some utterly terrible woman and vice a versa.
DON’t worry, your son will be fine. Most women still panders to men.

Also, are you also upset/worried what and how men talk about women?
That is a much bigger concern.

LemonRoses · 26/07/2021 07:23

Yes, despite all women being pretty perfect, all men are lazy, toxic numbskulls.

What a ridiculous idea.

Porcupineintherough · 26/07/2021 07:20

@feelingmehtoday men are not supposed to show any negative emotion and very few positive ones. Therefore any man who does is broken and letting the side down. OP no doubt thinks her dh should stiffen his upper lip, or possibly is annoyed that he is reluctant to seek help which he has been conditioned not to do because see point 1.

Unhomme · 26/07/2021 07:19

Never heard of the phrase 'nobody's perfect' OP?

bumblingbovine49 · 26/07/2021 07:16

DH has many fewer flaws than me. I'm lazier than DH and much more impatient and irritable sometimes. He is the stoic type , more.naturally organised than me, less discouraged .

To be honest I don't know how he puts up with me sometimes. I am not all flaws ( I hope) but I have some pretty big ones. DH has them too but in all honesty.I am.far more flawed than he is .

I think you get some.people who are just better at life than others.

I.do.exclude those men who are physically and mentally abusive to their partners from this . There are of course more men like this than women, though some women can definitely have this tendency too

Swipe left for the next trending thread