Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell another adult that its bad manners?

211 replies

bluepompoms · 25/07/2021 21:23

I am worried about this as don’t want kids to pick up on it.

DH is into cars, and knows a lot about them.

When we are out driving or if the TV is on and he sees a classic one or one like his or just one he likes he calls out. ‘Porsche!’ ‘Look, a Ferrari!’

Problem is he totally cuts across what you’re saying to do this. Even if it’s something important.

I’ve always hated it as you feel like a massive twat then pausing and resuming what you were saying, but AIBU to tell him it’s really bad manners? Worried about little DCs picking up on it and thinking it’s OK.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 26/07/2021 12:25

[quote Alannawhorideslikeaman]@aSofaNearYou I've obviously found my people then because we all do it when in conversation to each other. I'm pretty certain my friends and family don't find me rude, or they'd stop trying to spend time with us, and I doubt I'd have been so successful in work if I was regularly rudeWink

I actually think it's a proven thing that there are two main styles of conversation. In fact I read about it on Mumsnet. Where some people expect and want to talk in a monologue, whereas others prefer a more varied and flexible style of conversation. Can't remember the name of it though![/quote]
I like flexible conversation too. I'm not advocating for people speaking in long monologues, people chip in during natural pauses, conversation moves on, sometimes dips back to the previous topic etc. People might cut across a bit to say something relevant to the topic, this is all part of normal conversation. But interrupting mid sentence to point out something totally unrelated you've spotted to do with your hobby, that you know the other person isn't interested in, is really poor conversational skills, and makes it appear that you did not think what they were saying was worth listening to.

icedcoffees · 26/07/2021 12:23

If someone was talking about something they wanted you to listen to, and what you interrupted with was only of interest to YOU, not mutual, then it is rude, yes. He's an adult, he knows OP isn't also interested in cars so wouldn't appreciate the interruption. He should have just said it in his head, he knows full well that information would be of zero interest to her so the interruption would be nothing but irritating.

It sounds to me like he didn't want to listen to her just as much as she didn't want to listen to him.

aSofaNearYou · 26/07/2021 12:19

@Donationwitheverypack

Oh, is it that weird to point out something of interest, monentarily, during a conversation?

"Look a woodpecker/vole/orchid" would be my thing, but it could just as easily be a car or a building or interesting shoes.

It's quite rude to dismiss his interest IMO.

If someone was talking about something they wanted you to listen to, and what you interrupted with was only of interest to YOU, not mutual, then it is rude, yes. He's an adult, he knows OP isn't also interested in cars so wouldn't appreciate the interruption. He should have just said it in his head, he knows full well that information would be of zero interest to her so the interruption would be nothing but irritating.
3beesinmybonnet · 26/07/2021 12:17

I know someone like this and I also find it very rude. Is he the type of person who always wants to be the centre of attention and this is one of his tactics?
Re pps if it's adhd etc he'll do it to his boss etc not just you. If it's just you then it's rude.

I've found the only thing that works with this type of person is to give them a taste of their own medicine ie when he's talking randomly shout out "Tree!" and if he complains tell him that's what he does to you.

Donationwitheverypack · 26/07/2021 12:12

Oh, is it that weird to point out something of interest, monentarily, during a conversation?

"Look a woodpecker/vole/orchid" would be my thing, but it could just as easily be a car or a building or interesting shoes.

It's quite rude to dismiss his interest IMO.

Sarahlou63 · 26/07/2021 12:12

@percheron67

I hope he pronounces Porsche properly in front of the children.
How do you pronounce Porsche?
TiddyTidTwo · 26/07/2021 12:10

"Excuse me for talking whilst you were interrupting" is my go to

MoreAloneTime · 26/07/2021 12:09

Surely there is a healthy medium that is two people talking back and forth on a topic. It doesn't have to be either a long wittering monologue or one person ignoring the other to bellow out unrelated words.

MissyB1 · 26/07/2021 12:09

Dh does this if sport is on in the room, he pretends to be listening to the conversation, might even be taking part in it - then suddenly interrupts someone to spout off about what just happened in the match. Really bloody annoying!

It caused a row once at the In Laws because his brother was talking to us all about something that had upset him at work and Dh suddenly interrupted him in a loud voice to tell us all why the ref had got it wrong! Bil was very pissed off!! I was very embarrassed.

Yanbu OP

CaptainThe95thRifles · 26/07/2021 12:08

The day I don't interrupt a conversation to point out a Lamborghini on the road is the day I've given up on life.

In fairness, though, I don't really spend much time with people who wouldn't also be interested in the car, and I'm just as likely to interrupt myself to point it out.

My mother does with dogs. Literally any dog. The OP would hate us.

diddl · 26/07/2021 12:08

Even if he's excited to see something, he's an adult & if he knows no one else is interested he should just stfu imo.

Rude, boring fucker!

DiscordandRhyme · 26/07/2021 12:08

I have a friend who has ASD who does this.

He's very excited about transport and also certain instruments in songs.

In his mind he's not being rude, he's sharing something he thinks is really exciting.

I mean social norms are great and thet but not every person is neurotypical and they shouldn't be ashamed of that.

Obviously if you're upset I'd mention it when you're not busy and just explain how it makes you feel.

I'm visually impaired and many of my friends interrupt or do other perhaps socially not ok things. Not because they want to offend anyone, but because they can't see social cues.

Alannawhorideslikeaman · 26/07/2021 12:07

@aSofaNearYou I've obviously found my people then because we all do it when in conversation to each other. I'm pretty certain my friends and family don't find me rude, or they'd stop trying to spend time with us, and I doubt I'd have been so successful in work if I was regularly rudeWink

I actually think it's a proven thing that there are two main styles of conversation. In fact I read about it on Mumsnet. Where some people expect and want to talk in a monologue, whereas others prefer a more varied and flexible style of conversation. Can't remember the name of it though!

icedcoffees · 26/07/2021 12:05

@bluepompoms

But that’s exactly it *@icedcoffees*

Either someone’s saying something that’s worth listening to, or not.

I was telling DH about a colleague I worked with ages ago who I’d just found out had terminal cancer so OK not a close friend but still - and he still bellowed FERRARI (or whatever the hell it was!)

That just seemed grossly insensitive to me. And on that occasion I said something. But generally I just think it’s a horribly rude thing to do and I’m surprised so many people do if, tbh. I’m not trying to sound like a prissy arse but I wouldn’t dream of shouting across someone talking.

I'm really torn here, to be honest.

If DH started to talk to me about someone they worked with years ago (and that I didn't know), I don't think I'd be paying all that much attention to what he was saying, in all honesty.

He often says to me "I saw Mark today and he said xyz" and I'm sat there thinking "Who the bloody hell is Mark and why do I care what he said?!"

DH is what I call a "witterer" and he will talk about absolute nonsense to pass the time, fill in the silence during an ad-break etc.

I appreciate you were probably a bit upset/shocked about your ex-colleague, but to be honest, I can totally see why he wasn't listening.

bluepompoms · 26/07/2021 12:04

The other thing is I think you should apologise if it absolutely has to be interrupted. obviously there are instances when that happens like when a dog is misbehaving or a toddler is reaching for something they shouldn’t be. But then surely the polite thing to do is ‘so sorry Mary, you were saying, Jim has moved out?’ or whatever?

OP posts:
iklboo · 26/07/2021 12:04

Whenever he starts talking shout out a random word. Every time.

Shall we get a

SOCKS!

..takeaway for

GERBILS!

...dinner or

CRUMPETS!!

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 26/07/2021 12:04

He’s excited?

Aren't adults allowed to be excited?

MoreAloneTime · 26/07/2021 12:03

I get what you mean about it making you feel small and unimportant. When people do this to me I just give up on the conversation as it's too awkward for me.

You wouldn't be unreasonable to tell him it's rude and setting a bad example for your children.

bluepompoms · 26/07/2021 12:02

But that’s exactly it @icedcoffees

Either someone’s saying something that’s worth listening to, or not.

I was telling DH about a colleague I worked with ages ago who I’d just found out had terminal cancer so OK not a close friend but still - and he still bellowed FERRARI (or whatever the hell it was!)

That just seemed grossly insensitive to me. And on that occasion I said something. But generally I just think it’s a horribly rude thing to do and I’m surprised so many people do if, tbh. I’m not trying to sound like a prissy arse but I wouldn’t dream of shouting across someone talking.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 26/07/2021 12:02

@Alannawhorideslikeaman

I don't really see it as rude. If we were eatingunch with my parents and talking but one of us saw a goldfinch outside, for example, we'd certainly pipe up about it, and then return to the original conversation. We also regularly interrupt to say "ddog, stop that xyz" or "sorry to interrupt, do you want the kettle on?" And then carry on. Same with groups of friends, we often have several conversations on the go and flick between them. I also say "cows!" When passing a field of cows in the car, no matter what the current conversation is Grin So tell him you think it's rude if you want but I personally would think you're were being very prescious about it. Its not a huge change of conversation, just someone pointing out something briefly before you go back to you original point. He wants to share something that excites him.
Well I think you might be underestimating how often people think you are being rude. Interrupting to tell a dog not to do something is entirely different to interrupting to point out something that makes absolutely no difference to the day or conversation, especially if it's something you know is only of interest to you and not the speaker. Cutting across them mid flow might not bother you but it IS a rude habit, and it can be very irritating.
bluepompoms · 26/07/2021 11:59

My dad definitely started doing that as he got older @Alannawhorideslikeaman

I gave up talking to him in the end as it would go something like ‘oh dad, I’ve got some great news, I’ve seen a -‘

‘Ooh! OOOH! There’s a robin.’

It was constant and I realised in the end he wasn’t arsed about talking to me, so I just used to say yeah fine thanks when he asked how I was. I do think it was an age thing as he was always very strict about me not doing that when I was little!

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 26/07/2021 11:58

It’s always been drummed into me not to interrupt. I mean, I get this is an extreme example but would you still do it if someone was talking about something really serious, like saying they had lost their job or they were on the brink of the house being repossessed?

That's really not a fair comparison.

DottyHarmer · 26/07/2021 11:57

Yes, interrupting because you’ve suddenly seen something unusual, “OMG, look! A flying pig!!!!” surely is ok? You are not allowed to point something out?

Also, frankly, OP, are you droning on? We all drift off a bit if our spouse is telling us for the umpteenth time about the situation with Val from Marketing or where John and Sarah are holidaying.

If someone interrupts to start a new conversation, then that is quite rude, but I do think that some people hold on to the “talking pillow” for rather too long…

icedcoffees · 26/07/2021 11:57

@SW1amp

I think I do the same when I see a sausage dog Blush
I do it when I see a beagle @SW1amp Grin

OP - if it upsets you then by all means talk about it, but I can't say it would bother me. It's pretty normal to point things out that you've spotted and if the car is moving, he can't really wait five minutes to point it out.

bluepompoms · 26/07/2021 11:57

I get that it’s a game, @Jaichangecentfoisdenom but I’ve said honestly that I would find it really rude.

It’s always been drummed into me not to interrupt. I mean, I get this is an extreme example but would you still do it if someone was talking about something really serious, like saying they had lost their job or they were on the brink of the house being repossessed?

I’ve never had conversations of such gravity with dh but there have been times I’ve been talking about something important and he’s done it, and it is rude, and it’s definitely not something I want my children to do.

OP posts: