Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell another adult that its bad manners?

211 replies

bluepompoms · 25/07/2021 21:23

I am worried about this as don’t want kids to pick up on it.

DH is into cars, and knows a lot about them.

When we are out driving or if the TV is on and he sees a classic one or one like his or just one he likes he calls out. ‘Porsche!’ ‘Look, a Ferrari!’

Problem is he totally cuts across what you’re saying to do this. Even if it’s something important.

I’ve always hated it as you feel like a massive twat then pausing and resuming what you were saying, but AIBU to tell him it’s really bad manners? Worried about little DCs picking up on it and thinking it’s OK.

OP posts:
OutwiththeOutCrowd · 26/07/2021 18:19

I don't know if my DS's schools have been unusual, but his teachers seemed to positively relish students calling out answers and managing to get their voices heard above others. This was seen as being bold and enthusiastic. If you gave way and were quiet in the classroom, this was a sign of passivity and weakness.

All very different to my own experiences in school.

suspiria777 · 26/07/2021 18:12

@SW1amp

I think I do the same when I see a sausage dog Blush
same, but any dog. Luckily my DP is the same.
bluepompoms · 26/07/2021 17:58

I also think that something that’s really important to bear in mind with children especially is that they often start to tell you something seemingly inconsequential to build up to something important.

So you might get ‘Jake has been moved to sit next to Lucas in school,’ which is obviously unimportant.

But actually it might be he’s trying to build up to tell you that he feels like he’s losing all his friends but hasn’t got that language skill to just blurt it out. So if you cut in with ‘oh a squirrel’ you’ve closed it down. If you ask ‘oh yes? Are you pleased about that, or will you miss sitting next to him?’ you get the next bit of the story if you like.

Just something to bear in mind. And I get we can’t always give kids 100% of our time and attention.

OP posts:
bluepompoms · 26/07/2021 17:54

It isn’t just Ferraris, although I’ve had more than one a year pointed out to me and we don’t even live in a posh area before anyone starts - but in general I am surprised how many people seem to think it’s acceptable just to shout over someone else.

Monologues are equally irritating but I don’t think I do that.

It is not that big of a deal. Annoying when it’s just him and me but I can shrug it off. However I do not want my children’s parents evenings to be recounting how they shout out in class. I really do think it’s so important to model good manners. I mean I’m not trying to sound like a dick here, but the number of people who have responded with ‘well what’s the problem’ has surprised me. It is a problem, it is rude, and I wouldn’t want to spend a lot of time with someone who constantly cut across whatever I was saying to point out a bird on the lawn or whatever.

OP posts:
Fairyliz · 26/07/2021 17:11

@Jux

Not interrupting stifles conversation. I understand that when grown-ups are talking it's usually more important that anything a two year old might have to say, but adults can gauge whether what they're interrupting with is reasonable.

I used to work with autistic children. I studied autism at Uni and beyond. A friend of dh once gave me a lecture about his own theory about autism and it's causes. I tried to interrupt to tell him that his basic premise was inaccurate and a misunderstanding of what theory of mind is, but he talked over me. For 20 minutes. Then he told me off for interrupting him in his own home.

I never went back. I have not had him in my home since. I have not seen or spoken to him since. Dh has recently decided he doesn't want much to do with him any more too, so I guess the next time I see him will be at dh't funeral (if dh predeceases me) and I'm quite looking forward to tell the sod to piss off.

Adults interrupr each other all the time. That's how conversation works.

It's only on the internet that you can't be interrupted. Like you couldn't interrupt my little lecture her.

But your friend was talking about autism so presumably is interested in it, and you interrupted to talk about autism. So clearly you had been listening to him even if you disagreed.
What would have been rude would have been to interrupt and start talking about an entirely different subject like the ops DH does.
picklemewalnuts · 26/07/2021 17:11

Stop talking and listening to him. Ideally he'll notice and ask why you are so quiet. "Because you don't listen when I speak, you interrupt to point out cars that I have no interest in hearing about. It doesn't seem worthwhile to talk to you, or indeed to listen to you.'

Be prepared, he may never notice (DH).

aSofaNearYou · 26/07/2021 17:01

@DottyHarmer

Just went for a walk with ds. He was telling me something and I exclaimed, “Look at that corn!” We stopped, admired the corn swaying in the breeze, and then he resumed his story.

Those saying you can’t interrupt are either saints who can tolerate the most long-winded bore, or are the long-winded bore themselves….

Neither, I'm afraid. There's just a time and a place, sometimes it's ok, sometimes it's annoying. Some people don't pick up on that.
DysmalRadius · 26/07/2021 16:58

My mother has started doing this OP and it is infuriating. She will ask me a question, then two words into my answer, she will start pointing out a building to my son, despite the fact that neither child nor building are going anywhere and SHE JUST ASKED ME A QUESTION!!

It doesn't matter what I'm talking about - whether I'm telling her news, asking a question, halfway through passing on information about arrangements, so I don't think it is related to being bored with my conversation (which she is too polite to draw attention to anyway normally). In her case I think it's her age, because she's worried she won't remember something if she doesn't get it out!

Is your husband doing it for the kids benefit? Do they like seeing them? Or does he do it when it's just the two of you as well?

We all occasionally cut across one another to point out a soon-to-be-gone phenomenon (indeed, I excitedly told a whole train about a rainbow the other day Blush!), but that should be a relative rarity for which you apologise or at least ask the person talking to continue.

Interrupting and cutting someone dead for a game that only you are playing is rude, and not at all the same as what some others are describing.

DottyHarmer · 26/07/2021 16:58

Just went for a walk with ds. He was telling me something and I exclaimed, “Look at that corn!” We stopped, admired the corn swaying in the breeze, and then he resumed his story.

Those saying you can’t interrupt are either saints who can tolerate the most long-winded bore, or are the long-winded bore themselves….

aSofaNearYou · 26/07/2021 16:52

@Donationwitheverypack

I'm not sure why he has to be interested in what you're saying when you have no interest in what he's saying, but if you don't like it, tell him.

It astounds me how many people here don't talk to their partners about the most basic things.

Because she was already talking. If he was half way through a story about Ferrari's and she blurted something out that he would have no interest in, then she would be the unreasonable one.
HP87 · 26/07/2021 16:44

My husband used to do this. I just stopped dead in my tracks and didn't continue the conversation afterwards. He soon realised I felt like he wasn't listening so might as well not bother talking. He doesn't do it now.

Donationwitheverypack · 26/07/2021 16:40

I'm not sure why he has to be interested in what you're saying when you have no interest in what he's saying, but if you don't like it, tell him.

It astounds me how many people here don't talk to their partners about the most basic things.

TheFoundations · 26/07/2021 16:33

SQUIRREL!!!

TheFoundations · 26/07/2021 16:33

@OutwiththeOutCrowd

I think conversation is rather like a dance. When things are going well, something harmonious and flowing is created by the participants, each mindful of the contribution of others and responding to it.

Shouting out Porsche and Ferrari randomly is like stepping on someone's toes when they are mid-glide.

How eloquently expressed Smile
OutwiththeOutCrowd · 26/07/2021 16:28

Context is everything. The OP mentioned that it happened even when she was talking about something important (to her).

But if you are engaged in idle chitchat or the FERRARI! is on the wrong side of the road and heading straight for you, then such an interruption is certainly allowed.

OverTheRubicon · 26/07/2021 16:24

@MoreAloneTime

I think also there are different types of interruptions "sorry do you mean Fred from accounting or Fred who delivers the toilet rolls?" is are more reasonable interruption when your spouse is talking about a colleague's illness than "FERRARI!"
Clearly in this case, he was being an arse. Maybe in many others also, if he didn't see anything wrong with this. Also in those cases, the appropriate thing is generally to say so in the moment, not come on here to have pages and pages of handwringing and passive aggressive suggestions of saying 'did you mean to be so rude'? It's just exhausting.
nokidshere · 26/07/2021 16:23

Haha loving that other people play yellow car 😁. Although we've changed it to purple sometimes as there are now lots of yellow cars 😁

MoreAloneTime · 26/07/2021 16:19

I think also there are different types of interruptions "sorry do you mean Fred from accounting or Fred who delivers the toilet rolls?" is are more reasonable interruption when your spouse is talking about a colleague's illness than "FERRARI!"

OverTheRubicon · 26/07/2021 16:18

How many times do you actually see a Ferrari while driving? Once a year at most? But apparently a car fanatic would have to wait until it had gone past to mention it, even if it's general chat in the car.

It's a bit joyless, isn't it?

Most adults can and do bend and flex conversation occasionally. I don't get excited enough about sights to point them out, but couldn't get worked up about someone else who did, unless he's pointing out every electric car on the road while you're talking about something important and/or he won't let you redirect conversation to your original topic.

If that's the case, then he's being an arse and just tell him directly. If not, then pretending it's concern about the kids talking over their teachers is a bit silly, really, they're presumably intelligent enough to pick up the rules there - just let it go, we all have some slightly annoying habits that our loved ones overlook.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 26/07/2021 16:14

I think conversation is rather like a dance. When things are going well, something harmonious and flowing is created by the participants, each mindful of the contribution of others and responding to it.

Shouting out Porsche and Ferrari randomly is like stepping on someone's toes when they are mid-glide.

TheFoundations · 26/07/2021 16:11

but adults can gauge whether what they're interrupting with is reasonable

This is the bit that the adult in question is failing to do. OP isn't wanting interrupting to be banned, worldwide. Just questioning how reasonable it is to yell 'FERRARI!' over someone who's explaining about an aquaintance who's been diagnosed with cancer.

aSofaNearYou · 26/07/2021 16:10

@HopeForTheBestExpectTheWorst

See if it's something that might be of interest to the listener or others in the car, then I think it's fair enough - we point out things that are unusual or special etc. But this is essentially like me shouting "hair clip!" whenever I see a woman with a nice hair accessory - because I DO in fact think that, in my head, because I like interesting hair accessories - but that would be a really bizarre thing to point out to my husband and kids, right? Especially if one of them was in the middle of talking. So yeah, it's rude unless it's of interest to anyone else in the car imo.
Love this analogy, that's exactly what I think. It's not worth interrupting unless the person you're speaking to would be interested and it can't wait.
melj1213 · 26/07/2021 16:10

I think there is a time and a place for interruptions to be okay and equally when they aren't.

If youre just having a general chit chat then I don't think there's a problem with an occasional interruption for something interesting/unusual but people should acknowledge it as an interruption and apologise.

"So when we get to the supermarket, can you remin-"
"Ooh look, a squirrel! ... sorry, what were you saying about the supermarket?"

If it is a serious conversation then I would expect that their full attention on the other person(s) in the discussion and if they interrupted with something other than an emergency I would be very upset. When this has happened to me in the past I have literally walked away from the other person as they clearly have no respect for the seriousness of the conversation and I will continue when they are ready to give me their full attention.

"So I just got the results back from those medical tests I was referred for and the docto-"

"Ooh look a squirrel!"

TheMoth · 26/07/2021 16:09

There are different types of interrupting though. Most conversations work on a kind of implicit understanding of turn taking: you say a bit, then someone else does.

There's the agreeing/ enthusiastic/talking over and gaining control of a conversion type.
There's the leaping in at an opportune moment, for your input.
Then there's the interrupting to change the subject because you're bored/ not really listening/ have poor social skills (ds is guilt of this)/ think you are more important.

Conversation is a skill and something that needs to be modelled.

aSofaNearYou · 26/07/2021 16:08

@Jux what you're describing is the normal flow of conversation. Of course that's fine, monologists are equally annoying. But that's not the same thing as interrupting just to point out a car.