Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to sell a gift

308 replies

Lastsundayinjuly · 25/07/2021 20:10

I was bought an expensive present a few months ago, worth over a thousand pounds.

I don’t use it and won’t have many opportunities to.

I want to sell it but the person who gave it to me is clearly against this.

Is this horribly ungrateful of me or makes sense? (I could really, really use the money.)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
josbd · 02/08/2021 18:04

I am of the "once given, it's yours to do whatever you wish with it" opinion. £1k is a lot of money, nevertheless, I don't understand the situation where someone feels personally insulted when someone does not appreciate a gift. We are all different. we all like different things. Frankly, I would (if only I could!) give the person a cheque. Sell, and be prepared for friend to contort into death throes every time she sees you!

BBOA · 31/07/2021 16:24

Is it a puppy?! Come on you are just teasing us knowing that everyone on here are nosey gits!😂

KormasABitch · 28/07/2021 11:28

@MyOtherProfile LOL!!!!! Funnily enough, my parents are the same! They have this really weird mismatch of bizarre items that they've been given over the past century or so.

Maybe that's why they always urge me not to be sentimental about such things!

beautifullymad · 28/07/2021 11:18

I get the disappointment with expensive gifts that you then must keep.

I'm a keen hobbyist and have a small time hobby income, and really need a number of things that cost between £500-£1000
These are out of my price range but I always look and dream.

For a special birthday I was given a very very expensive pair of shoes and designer lingerie.

How I wished that it had been my hobbyist wish item(s).

I'm still dreaming.....

You can't sell the item, not ever, your relationship with the giver will be changed and damaged forever.
If they are truly this generous, start dropping hints as to what you really need whist thanking them for their generous gift already given.

MyOtherProfile · 28/07/2021 10:26

@KormasABitch

If I'd given something expensive to a friend and they didn't want it, but could achieve something they really did want by selling it, I would want them to say so.

"I'm really sorry Korma, I know you thought I'd love that genuine tortoiseshell toilet seat because it goes so well with the elephant's foot umbrella stand, but I have outgrown my taste in recycled dead animals. However, this would help pay towards my trip of a lifetime to Mars. Do you mind if I trade it in? I will think of you all the way to Mars and shower you with blessings and thanks for your generosity."

Regardless of the costs involved, we can't give things to people and expect them to keep them, even if they don't want them. And in fact no one does, do they? Otherwise, imagine what the interiors of our homes would look like by about the age of 35.

My mum does! Her house is full of stuff given by other people which she is too sentimental misguided to ditch. We have had many conversations about this. She doesn't love most of it. We should feel no obligation to keep something just because it is a gift.
impossible · 28/07/2021 09:52

Late to this but just a thought... Could you decide something you would spend money on and ask gift giver if that would be ok - in effect you would be making a swap. You could offer gift giver any excess cash.

Hope you resolve it.

KormasABitch · 28/07/2021 09:29

If I'd given something expensive to a friend and they didn't want it, but could achieve something they really did want by selling it, I would want them to say so.

"I'm really sorry Korma, I know you thought I'd love that genuine tortoiseshell toilet seat because it goes so well with the elephant's foot umbrella stand, but I have outgrown my taste in recycled dead animals. However, this would help pay towards my trip of a lifetime to Mars. Do you mind if I trade it in? I will think of you all the way to Mars and shower you with blessings and thanks for your generosity."

Regardless of the costs involved, we can't give things to people and expect them to keep them, even if they don't want them. And in fact no one does, do they? Otherwise, imagine what the interiors of our homes would look like by about the age of 35.

LynetteScavo · 28/07/2021 09:00

Of it's a piano tell your DH you need to sell because it makes financial sense, and you can buy another on the future. Then don't buy another.

Just be glad it's not a Peleton.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 28/07/2021 08:50

I don’t know if you have left the thread. You absolutely don’t need to tell anyone what the item is.

If it helps, I think there is a kind of algorithm here. Only you can work out the answer. The questions at the heart of it all is for too to do your own assessment of

(A). The extent of hurt/damage to your relationship that will be caused if you sell the item

(B). How much you need the money.

And see how those 2 factors play out.
Some things that might influence your analysis of these 2 crucial issues are how personal was the item gifted, how “invested” in the gift is the giver, how easy is the gifted item to store away given it’s not presently in use, whether you will lose a lot of the original purchase price on second hand sale (this is quite important as the giver is likely to be annoyed as well as hurt if you only get back half what they paid) and I suppose perhaps most crucially of all, how much do you need the money (is it the case that you can’t pay your rent without it or would the sale proceeds go towards an alternative luxury item).

If your analysis is that your relationship with the giver would be damaged by you selling it (which I get a sense of here) and the sale proceeds are to fund an alternative luxury item then, unless you don’t care about the relationship, I think you would be unreasonable to sell it. But your analysis might lead you to a different view. In principle it is not unreasonable to sell a gift. But so much turns on the facts.

Snog · 28/07/2021 08:38

For most annoying thread of the day 🏅 🎖 🥇

Don't even try to get rid of it!

VK456 · 28/07/2021 07:43

Not read entire thread but had read enough to see the range of advice offered.
It has made me realise though, that if ever I’m in the position of being able to buy someone a very expensive gift, I’ll give them the money instead!

PhantomMyOpera · 28/07/2021 06:26

My opinion would change based on the bulkiness and pain in my arse level of the gift.

Example 1. Well meaning present is a kitchen aid mixer. I know I will never use it and could sell it on for a decent sum (although nowhere near RRP) and put that money towards something I desperately want or need......I would probably say to just suck it up and keep the useless thing as it doesn't take up THAT much room and can be easily trotted out and put on display when gift giver comes to make them happy.

  1. Example two. You once mentioned you'd quite like the idea of giving sex on a swing a try and someone has turned your spare bedroom into a sex dungeon complete with a swing from the ceiling. This is massively inconvenient as your DP doesn't know you fancied swing sex and now there's nowhere to keep the kids. You know you could sell the stuff on as you've googled it and there's a niche market.....you would get a good return and could buy something useful.......I would definitely sell the gift in this scenario.

I realise that this is in no way helpful to your dilemma though.

CatsnCoffee · 28/07/2021 05:58

Considering you came on here for advice, you’re taking a rather odd and hostile attitude to those who want to help but need more clarity and context. Is there more to this than you’re letting on?

Nannamia · 28/07/2021 04:42

@MySecretHistory

Grin
karenjkayjay · 27/07/2021 23:20

Was there actually any need for this thread? Or just a tease to get people asking what the item was? So strange

TrickorTreacle · 27/07/2021 22:02

OP is BU due to their 'vaguebooking' approach (and thus not getting the intended responses), and for insisting people leave the thread such as @SleepingStandingUp

SherbrookeFosterer · 27/07/2021 21:28

Depends what it is.

Is it a Tracey Emin or a Shani?

If you need money, might be worth hanging on to for a bit.

HarrietsweetHarriet · 27/07/2021 21:20

If it's a beautiful guitar, please dm me as my DH finds it hard to resist guitars..

patkinney · 27/07/2021 21:08

@DrRichardBurke

MacBook?
The OP is obviously Rachel, so why don't you ask Monica to ask Rachel what it is and then tell us?
KormasABitch · 27/07/2021 21:04

Look up "white elephant." An expensive unwanted gift, especially when it could be converted into something useful, is almost a curse.

My parents brought me up to believe that you give to someone on the understanding that if they think it's crap, they are under no obligation to keep it. Anything else is just pure ego trip for the giver.

occa · 27/07/2021 21:04

I would want to sell it but unfortunately OP I don't think you can under these circumstances without causing a lot of aggro if you can't persuade the giver to agree.

How you approach depends slightly on what type of thing it is: if it's something that will depreciate quickly and be almost worthless in a few years (electronics etc) then I'd push the sell idea a bit harder, or make myself use it.

If it's more of an investment piece (designer gear, art, antique, rugs etc) then I'd put it away quietly and keep it safe and in good nick then revisit the selling idea in a few years when feelings have subsided a bit.

LunaBunaTuna · 27/07/2021 21:02

@HaveringWavering

I suppose I was thinking of how shops don’t allow pierced earrings to be returned, they always warn you that at the till. So I kind of thought that by extension nobody would buy pre-worn ones. But if you said specifically yours were never worn *@Merryoldgoat then I guess that’s different. @WrongWayApricot* were you a child yourself when you received that gift?!
@HaveringWavering I’ve bought antique (2nd hand) diamond stud earrings before now as much better value than new. I assume they were cleaned before but the shopkeeper cleaned them in front of me with an antiseptic wipe anyway so I was happy to try a few pairs on.
QueeniesCroft · 27/07/2021 20:30

What are the consequences of not selling? Would it mean a missed mortgage payment, or just no holiday this year? Do you need expensive glasses, or just struggle to find the cash for new clothes?

My husband isn't allowed to choose things after he bought me pigs (real, living ones!), but if he had, then he is the one person I would feel that I could talk to and explain why the thing had to go.

I have sold gifts in the past, that I knew were given in bad faith and in order to upset or humiliate me. Usually by my sister, who would give me clothes that she knew were far too big for me (while heavily hinting that I was a massive porker, despite being about 5 stone lighter than her!), or a coffee machine when she knew I hated coffee, wine glasses when she knows I don't drink etc, etc. I didn't sell the sex toys that she thought were somehow appropriate gifts from my sister, I just binned them.

altiara · 27/07/2021 20:25

Can you still return it or would it have to be sold as used?
Maybe just sell it, if DH is hurt then say you’re hurt at him slinking so much money on something you don’t want that’s collecting dust.

Other questions / what size is it? Can you get a copy or a cheap version instead to pretend you still have it?

burritofan · 27/07/2021 20:07

I think if it’s a DP who you live with and it’s family money, you can have the conversation, sell even if he gets the hump, and live with the brief hurt/fallout while also feeling relieved about the money crisis.

If you don’t live together, or have separate finances, I think it would be a little weird to sell a valuable gift and pocket the money. A bit transactional. Technically you’re allowed but if I bought a boyfriend something and he sold it to pay his gas bill, or whatever, I’d be deeply weirded out.

Would you still want to sell it or get rid of it if you were solvent/awash with money/not in need? Or would you keep it for sentimental “DP gave this ornamental frog to me, thus I love it despite it being a bugger to dust” reasons?