Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Already given savings, DSS wants more.

520 replies

ScottyandWestie · 25/07/2021 20:09

Posting here for traffic as feeling terribly conflicted and a bit taken for granted.
DSS mid twenties has been round with his girlfriend asking for cash from us toward a house deposit.
Due to covid husband had to take a pay cut and we don't really have anything to give right now.
DSS knows we have a couple of thousand set aside as DSD will be 21 in February and we have approx 5k to give her as we did DSS on his 21st. It's a saving plan we did for each of them since they were young children.
He and his girlfriend were complaining about house prices and I know it's awful, the 5k he had from us seemed to go on holidays and bits for his cycling hobby.
We dont have anything to give and while DSD knows the money is coming to her she has said she will keep it in savings, she has no plans to spend it.
DSS girlfriend was making me feel guilty as her Dad is helping them out, but we don't have the spare cash and we have already given him 5K. It's not our fault he spent it.
I do not want to ask DSD and I feel the money should be protected he shouldn't have any access to it at all but he is pushing my husband, his father to speak to DSD about it.
My husband and myself never had any family financial help, I appreciate getting on the housing ladder was easier years ago but this isn't his money. Also what will happen when DSD needs it?
As I'm not his parent it's awkward but I feel husband should not even entertain the idea of asking DSD to give it to her brother.
Any suggestions?

OP posts:
ozymandiusking · 25/07/2021 22:27

As we all know on mumsnet, NO is a complete sentence.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 25/07/2021 22:26

Looks to me like your DSS and his gf need a lesson in cutting their cloth..

HollowTalk · 25/07/2021 22:25

Hardly anyone in their mid-twenties is on the property ladder and those that are have either inherited and put it immediately towards a home or they've worked incredibly hard and saved everything they have.

I hope her dad is protecting the money he's putting in because sooner or later those two are going to get fed up of each other (selfish people don't exactly get on with other selfish people.)

AnneElliott · 25/07/2021 22:24

Goodness how entitled. What a Prince your H and his ex have raised! And as for the GF - brass neck hardly does her justice!

What about DSS' mum? Has he not tapped her up for money yet?

justasking111 · 25/07/2021 22:22

Friend has a DSS his granny left him enough money to buy a house mortgage free. He did buy a house but had no money to run it so sold and frittered it away. He regrets that now.

Just because they have a glossy brochure for a dream house doesn't mean they'll be able to pay for everything. Her dad is an idiot

Lalliella · 25/07/2021 22:22

This is one of the cheekiest things I’ve ever read. Of course the answer must be no.

Milliepossum · 25/07/2021 22:17

OP technically that money is half yours, until it goes to DSD you can outright say no to the greedy DSS, it’s not just your husband’s decision.

saraclara · 25/07/2021 22:16

@Micemakingclothes

Your husband really should call his daughter and reassure her that he would never consider violating her trust by giving away the money he has set aside for her. Really if he would even think about doing it. It sends a massive signal that she is less loved and less important.
You obviously haven't read the OP's update. Though to be fair, you're not the only one by a long way.

He's not giving DD's money away. They've already had the phone call.

Micemakingclothes · 25/07/2021 22:14

Your husband really should call his daughter and reassure her that he would never consider violating her trust by giving away the money he has set aside for her. Really if he would even think about doing it. It sends a massive signal that she is less loved and less important.

Dogvmarmot · 25/07/2021 22:14

@ScottyandWestie

Husband struggles with not giving in but DSS abuses it and DSD does not. Now husband is furious about the manipulation of DSD. I'm not sure between DSS and his girlfriend which ones worse. His girlfriend gets on well with DSD.
both children had equal amounts. Why should she give up her potential house deposit savings for him. Housing is v expensive but it is not going to be cheaper for her. He had his money, you cannot afford it,. Outrageous that he would ask esp after spending his. Imagine how she would feel if you gave her money to him. Good luck with your house buy, sorry we are not financially able to help you again.. and if he continues turn your phones off and move her money elsewhere. they can get a cheaper house or he could get a second job to put more in if needs be.
ChicChaos · 25/07/2021 22:08

If you say no to the gift/loan that stops it, OP. No need to drag it out, get it over and done with as soon as possible. Particularly unfair to drag your DSD into it as well.

BertiesShoes · 25/07/2021 22:07

Where is DSS’s mum in all this?

Assuming that she hasn’t died (apologies if that is the case) - can they not ask her, or have they already asked her?

Canigooutyet · 25/07/2021 22:05

Is it such a surprise that he doesn't want the money to be loaned. It would involve another person having a vested interest in their property. I mean who in their right mind would do this without getting their money protected properly? Isn't this always the advise when pouring money into a house?

BertiesShoes · 25/07/2021 22:04

Op, why don’t you suggest that DSD opens a Lifetime ISA (LISA) and you transfer 4K to that immediately (the maximum that she can put in per tax year). The Govt adds 25% to that too.

She can only access that money for a house or pension without penalty, so it would prevent any of it going to her brother.

The remaining 1k can be given on her birthday and added to the LISA next April, in the new tax year.

The entitlement of some DC is absolutely astounding, but I shouldn’t be surprised as I had a very entitled sibling!

CarnationCat · 25/07/2021 21:57

Please do not go give your DSS DSD's money. She may be laid back now but this sort of thing breeds resentment, giving one child more than another.

A lot of parents don't have the funds to give any money to their children...ever. To expect you to give money because his girlfriend's parents are giving it knowing about your financial situation is really out of order and quite repulsive.

Canigooutyet · 25/07/2021 21:56

Hope his sister tells him where to go and stop with the guilt tripping shite. Hes had his and can fuck off if he thinks he's getting his hands on mine. Even if I did have spare cash it would be going to my own future or helping dad out. Are you so fucking stupid to think he can magic money out of thin air?

StillMedusa · 25/07/2021 21:56

Absolute no.
My DD1 and her (now) husband ..mid twenties wanted to buy a house.
So they saved.And saved. And worked their arses off. They lived with us for two years in order to scrape together a deposit, and lived very simply.
They moved into their little 2 bed place in March and we helped how we COULD.. by decorating, fixing stuff, moving them in.. and they are now proud new parents, knowing they got their home by saving and working hard.
That's adulting.

Hannayeah · 25/07/2021 21:52

[quote QueenBee52]@ScottyandWestie

Why are you allowing DSS's Girlfriend to walk into your home .. and bully your already vulnerable Husband, into handing over your DSD's 21st Birthday gift of 5K that DSS already had and pissed against a wall...

WTAF am I reading.. why is this even being discussed in your home OP . Confused[/quote]
This is what blows my mind!

What kind of ill mannered little shit goes into the home of someone else’s parents and even listens to this shit? Nevermind participating in it. I’m not sure I’d let her back in the house.

SixesAndEights · 25/07/2021 21:51

Just an echo - fuck off DSS!

Undisclosedlocation · 25/07/2021 21:51

Blimey, if I was in the position of the DSD and found out that my dad was contemplating giving ‘my’ money to my odious, grasping little shit of a brother just because he whined and manipulated I would be heartbroken.

Winchwood · 25/07/2021 21:50

I’ve only read your posts OP but surely this is a no brainier. DSS got his £5,00 at 21 and DSD is due to get her £5,00 when she is 21. What’s the dilemma here?

2pinkginsplease · 25/07/2021 21:50

He has already had his 5k. Do not give into their demands.

They need to learn to live within their means.

lastcall · 25/07/2021 21:50

Tell DSS to get a second job if he needs more money for a deposit for his own fucking house.

Selfish entitled brat.

Akrotiri1 · 25/07/2021 21:48

He had the same money but spent it....tough.

My son is 19 and pays into an special isa designed for saving for a house deposit.

He set it up of his own back and pays in monthly and am very proud of him for forward thinking, and far more likely to help him out if needed when he is already trying to take responsibility for his financial future.

DeciduousPerennial · 25/07/2021 21:42

@ScottyandWestie

Husband struggles with not giving in but DSS abuses it and DSD does not. Now husband is furious about the manipulation of DSD. I'm not sure between DSS and his girlfriend which ones worse. His girlfriend gets on well with DSD.
Pretty sure they won’t get well after this!