Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no one helped develop our fine motor skills and we all turned out fine?

139 replies

Maybeitstime2021 · 25/07/2021 19:40

Just had a post on my FB with activities to do with your child to develop their fine motor skills before starting school in September, why is this a thing? I’m pretty sure we all learned to do our coats up and hold a pencil ok when we were kids without these activities?

OP posts:
3ormorecharacters · 25/07/2021 22:11

A family friend is a surgeon and says he has noticed a big decline in medical students' abilities when it comes to the kind of extreme fine motor skills required in surgery. So it's not just 5 year olds.

babybythesea · 25/07/2021 22:08

@obviousanonymous

Believe me when I say there’s nothing worse than at age 12 having to get your teacher to dress you after swimming lessons, or having to ask your GP to help you button your coat at 25 - both situations I’ve been in - ANY intervention early enough has to be a good thing .
I've sent you a pm, obvious.
Siameasy · 25/07/2021 22:00

I find these ideas helpful and the activities can be calming and help with concentration. The way it’s “packaged” can seem pretentious but really many parents just want fun things for their kids to try

Jarstastic · 25/07/2021 21:46

I wish it had been a thing when I was young. Just not something my mother thought to do. (And I’m from a “omfortable middle class background”)
It took a Scandinavian friend to comment on my motor skills when I was in my 20s. I had never heard the expression. Apparently this is something the Scandinavians have been thinking for years.
I have been doing stuff with beads teaching children to tie shoelaces since young, but never done for me. And I didn’t turn out fine.

HarrisMcCoo · 25/07/2021 21:12

@Gardenista

Also agree in the uk we try to get children to write too young.
Ridiculously young. I am all for the kindergarten stage being introduced. Let them start formal education aged 7 🤷
LauraFlashley · 25/07/2021 21:11

There will be children who haven't developed those skills before starting school. They'll be unable to do buttons or zips or do up their shoes.

It's just another way of saying 'get your kids to do lots of activities that use their hands' and practise those essential skills. Some parents will let their kids play on screens and nothing else.

I wouldn't take it seriously. Most parents have got it right.

Orangeinmybluelightcup · 25/07/2021 21:10

I saw that Facebook post and took a screenshot!

My 4yo is going to school in Sept and is a bit 'behind' on his fine motor skills. I notice some things at home and preschool had picked up on it too.

Lots on here have mentioned technology and tablets as a reason kids may be behind on fine motor. That is not true here, ds uses tech like that maybe once or twice a month, if that.

I think it's just him. Preschool have said that fine motor comes from gross motor. He is a very slight boy compared to his peers, he struggles for strength to swim and push pedals on a bike. His fine motor I had noticed he used a palm grip on a pen, no tripod grip yet.

So yes, I will be spending the summer sneaking things in, dough discos all the way, games with pegs, whatever. He'll think its a game. I don't want him to have his confidence knocked if he struggles with things in Sept. He already thinks he can't do things like drawing.

Hardbackwriter · 25/07/2021 21:07

I'm 34 and I'm sure I was older than reception when I learned to tie my laces, though perhaps I was unusually slow at it?!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 25/07/2021 21:06

Droopyclematis

So true. I remember learning to tie laces in reception, but family kids are only learning by age 7 or 8 now.

chunderwunder · 25/07/2021 21:04

I do wonder how much of a problem it would be for kids with dyspraxia or other challenges if we didn't have such stringent expectations around what is 'normal'.

All behaviour is a spectrum and you could argue that people aren't 'disabled' by their skillset unless we've all previously agreed what 'able' means.

I do think a less homogenised approach to achievement and a greater embracing of all sorts of ability might help lots and lots of children.

I also recognise that that is not how things are and so correctly identifying additional needs and putting in support where necessary is critical.

DroopyClematis · 25/07/2021 21:03

When I started work as a TA in YrR , twenty years ago, hardly any children needed help to tie their shoelaces , though to be fair , Velcro had been invented.
Now , most children need help with their laces ( on PE days,) as they come to school with trainers.
Cannot get over how many children now, cannot hold a pencil or use scissors.

Don't get me started on their cutlery skills.

Much of it is to do with under developed gross motor skills, as these need to develop first.
I had training on this some years ago.
Trainer said that most fine motor skills problems stem from poor gross motor skills from birth.
Babies are put into constricting car seats that are then placed into supermarket trollies.
Baby falls asleep, baby stays in that position. Baby's seat is taken indoors and baby stays there while food is out away.
Baby can spend hours in that seat , bar changing. Baby is then taken to, say, a friend's or grandparents and still left in that seat.

Also, babies are now placed on their backs which inhibits the initial crawling motion that , traditionally helped the 'cross motion' crawling stage.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 25/07/2021 21:02

Gardenista

Exactly this.

It's not too late though. When I realised this with my son I took a step back and went a bit low tech. Back to the wax crayons and the plasticine, and actually it's making a noticeable difference already.

obviousanonymous · 25/07/2021 21:01

Believe me when I say there’s nothing worse than at age 12 having to get your teacher to dress you after swimming lessons, or having to ask your GP to help you button your coat at 25 - both situations I’ve been in - ANY intervention early enough has to be a good thing .

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 25/07/2021 20:59

Throughout human history children would have developed these skills by playing all day long outdoors. Probably until adolescence.

I just don't think this is true. In most societies throughout human history children have actually been expected to accompany parents and learn how to do things as they go. Lots of this might have been mimicking and essentially play, but the physically skilled nature of the tasks being attempted would have had value in developing fine & gross motor skills. Imagine a child trying to copy a parent:

  • making a clay pot or a mud brick
  • helping to shell peas
  • grinding grain with a mortar
  • picking berries or cracking nuts
  • cutting leather pieces for shoes
  • plaiting rope or twine
  • even just helping to carry tools

Compare that to the things a child might imitate a modern parent doing around the home and there would probably be a lot of screen time & pressing buttons and not a lot of things requiring manual dexterity and hand strength.

PinniGig · 25/07/2021 20:59

I went all the way through primary, secondary school and college without knowing my maths problem i.e. being spectacularly shit and unable to add up the cost of two items for 70p each without having to use my fingers – it's now recognised as Dyscalualia.

Not until my 30's did I even discover there was such a thing and all the way through school teachers didn't pick up on or bother to give a shit about me never doing any work, constantly finding ways to be a pain in the arse during tests and get myself booted out and off the hook.

I found ways to get by and little things that made life easier but it would have made life so much easier it wasn't that I was just a thick bitch and I didn't need to blag and wing my way through things.

We're a family of musicians and I have natural ear for music, play numbers instruments and can pick up and follow along with anything on the hop but I can't read sheet music. I can sit down at the piano, play and find my way to whatever key or chord I want to pick up and start work with but I still have to lean in, squinty and look at sheet music like “E... EVERY.. GOOD... EVERY GOOD”

Head of music ripped the piss out of me and got mad cos I could not grasp how to read music and I still can't to this day.

Again there's a reason for it, I'm not a thick bitch, my brain just can't work with it all.

Interestingly I did learn how to properly touch type in secondary which is probably the only thing I actually took and used as an adult but it was painful learning to get your fingers into the muscle reflex and endlessly feeling your way over the keys to type another half hour about a quick fucking fox jumping over some shit.

Took the full two years in school and one of my first jobs was working as office junior for a law firm and I started doing audio typing for one of the junior partners, picked up the speed through time and repetition and eventually it became second nature.

Maybe it's with the QWERTY keyboard layout being fixed and constant that let me learn and develop that natural reflect for touch typing. Music changes consistently throughout and you have to read and translate it from sight to hands I guess.

I can hold a conversation make a brew, type out a long ass report and not even need to give thought to what my hands are doing they just crack on without me.

But yeah if I knew or the world knew back then about this being a thing, life would have been a lot less stressful. I see nothing wrong with checks, assessments and just making sure children starting school don't end up slipping through the net and small areas that might need just a bit of extra help before the window of opportunity to help is missed.

obviousanonymous · 25/07/2021 20:59

I’m dyspraxic - i.e didn’t learn to use cutlery properly until age 12, couldn’t tie laces until age 26, still have an awkward pencil grip at 30 - I honestly don’t see why it would be so wrong to give children exercises and ideas to help?

I’d have felt so much more confident in myself if I’d known that other children were also doing similar stuff to me - I felt like a total numpty most of the time as I had to attend OT a lot, was singled out continually at school for having ‘motor disabilities’ - it normalises these things, surely that can’t be a bad thing !

ExhaustedFlamingo · 25/07/2021 20:57

Maybe it's because more is known now about child development, and what helps children.

If your child is a bit delayed in this area, having access to activities which help could make a difference.

If you don't want to do it - then don't?

We're all constantly bombarded with ideas for parenting and suggested activities; we'd be spinning if we tried to take them all on board. Just pick and choose things which are appropriate and helpful for your lifestyle, parenting style and child's needs.

I have a DD who's autistic and has excellent fine motor skills.

I have a DS who's autistic and dyspraxia and struggles severely with fine motor skills.

Creative ideas about activities which might help my DS practice his fine motor skills are always very welcome in this house. Other parents might find them unhelpful and unnecessary. Our children are not identikit. Pick the stuff that works for you.

If you're really suggesting that it's nonsense just because it wasn't mentioned 50 years ago, give your head a wobble.

wordsareveryunnecessary · 25/07/2021 20:55

Some kids - dyspraxia/ADHD have fine motor skill problems. My DS still struggles a lot with writing/tying shoelaces/ using scissors etc

Gardenista · 25/07/2021 20:55

Also agree in the uk we try to get children to write too young.

chunderwunder · 25/07/2021 20:55

I think a lot of it is about hitting arbitrary targets based on whatever's fashionable with the government of the moment rather than having any real connection to what helps children develop lasting useful skills.

I remember my kid's year check with the HV (he wasn't yet walking) and she asked me what I was doing to encourage his walking, eg. standing him up and holding his hands, putting things at the back of the sofa out of his reach etc.

I asked whether there were studies showing that doing these things translated in to some sort of lifelong advantage. I wasn't being an arse or rhetorical. I was genuinely curious. I really thought kids would just walk when they were ready. Which of course they do (barring some sort of problem of course).

So if our one year olds are under pressure to meet targets that's only going to increase exponentially at school age.

BlatantlyNameChanged · 25/07/2021 20:53

Re: kids starting reception in nappies and with no cutlery skills, unable to dress themselves, etc with the "and no specials needs" tacked on the end - a fair proportion of those children will actually have special need but just aren’t diagnosed yet due to their age.

Gardenista · 25/07/2021 20:53

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland - exactly this! I’m in my 40s and have a cross stitch calendar I made at infants - so age 6 or 7. Every child did this, we were also taught to knit, tie our shoe laces. I have a 6 year old who loves crafts but this level of sewing/knitting is beyond her because she’s always had easy toys. She makes Pom poms in a plastic Pom Pom maker - I had to cut out circles of thick corrugated card. She’s not strong because she’s always used tools designed to mage things easy for children - kids scissors. She uses felt tips because pencil crayons and wax crayons don’t give instant results. If an activity is difficult for her she goes and does something easier.
It’s ok - that’s the world she’s growing up in but my goodness she would not be able to use a tin opener, or light a fire or any of the normal skills a 6 year old child would have had in the 1980s.

chunderwunder · 25/07/2021 20:46

Agree wholeheartedly, @waterrat

Maybeitstime2021 · 25/07/2021 20:46

@MaskingForIt

Maybe if your parents had tried a bit harder you’d have learnt that it’s “seem” not “seam”.

Seem is how things appear to be.

Seam is the thing holding your trousers together.

Yes, yes, of course you’re dyslexic.

Maybe yours should have tried harder and you would have learned not to be so rude.
OP posts:
chunderwunder · 25/07/2021 20:45

Perhaps we should go with it and focus on teaching kids to touch type etc. rather than agonise over their cursive writing skills. Humans and their environment constantly change innit