Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no one helped develop our fine motor skills and we all turned out fine?

139 replies

Maybeitstime2021 · 25/07/2021 19:40

Just had a post on my FB with activities to do with your child to develop their fine motor skills before starting school in September, why is this a thing? I’m pretty sure we all learned to do our coats up and hold a pencil ok when we were kids without these activities?

OP posts:
KingdomScrolls · 26/07/2021 08:29

@RedMarauder honestly I've tried, DH is incredibly patient and we've spent days and days trying over the years, I also went to adult learn to cycle lessons and still can't! There are other things co-ordination wise that make me wonder if I was young today I'd be diagnosed as dyspraxic but there are other fine motor skills I am very good at, I can play piano and guitar for example.

noworklifebalance · 26/07/2021 07:35

Not being able to sew does not mean you didn't develop fine motor skills. It simply means you didn't learn to sew. Sewing uses fine motor skills but not being able to sew doesn't mean you don't have them

That’s my point!

Lack of certain types of skills need to be taken in the context of current situation and the overall ability of the child i.e. is there a need for the child to have ever had to learn to tie shoe laces (previous PPs have mentioned children used to be able to do this by YR whereas now it’s much later)? Is there a specific area they struggle with? Is there global delay in development of fine motor skills? Etc

Nat6999 · 26/07/2021 00:59

My ds has poor fine motor skills, at 17 his handwriting is worse than a 5 year old, he has hypotonia & has to use a laptop for all his coursework & exams. He can build anything out of Lego, has been able to since he was tiny but can't tie shoelaces & can't colour or draw.

TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 26/07/2021 00:24

DS is 6, I think I was lucky in that as a little child he was never a screen watcher player. He'd happily sit in a nappy and post plastic oversized 2p coins down the floorboard holes in the restored hallway 😂 he would also play with anything he could get his hands on and I was never much bothered about "mess" as we had easy to clean floors in the rest of the house. So I'd often give him finger print paints and paper, or play doh. He wasn't a "I want to draw or colour in kind of kid" either though, was all about physical play.

But then my other friend her little one hated to play. Just her personality so mum had to encourage fine motor skills.

Swing and roundabouts, all kids are different. And if someone can share some information on how to help then I don't see the issue.

safclass · 26/07/2021 00:22

Watched a little lad doing an 8 piece jigsaw. Very good at matching the pieces, obviously 'knew' how to do edges, match pics etc BUT he couldnt join them, kept trying to push them together (as in a jigsaw app). Had to be showm to lift them up and join the pieces.

RedMarauder · 26/07/2021 00:21

@KingdomScrolls you can learn to ride a bike. You just need someone patient to teach you.

I tie my laces in two different ways as when I was a kid I had difficultly doing it the more complex way most people do it. One advantage of knowing two different methods is I can teach others who have difficultly tying up laces my easy method.

RedMarauder · 26/07/2021 00:15

I would like to look at a toy in a shop and ask myself if it was going to be fun to play with rather than being hyper-conscious of what skills might be improved by playing with it.

But I've always brought toys on whether they are fun to play with and whether they would last more than a minute in most cases.

KingdomScrolls · 26/07/2021 00:04

Hmmm I still tie laces in an unusual way and I can't ride a bike. Maybe a little more direct intervention would've been a good thing.

Graphista · 25/07/2021 23:45

Yes we turned out fine but we grew up at a different time and with different parenting tbh

I’m pretty sure we all learned to do our coats up and hold a pencil ok when we were kids without these activities?

No we didn't actually. We were taught and encouraged in these things.

I remember my parents teaching me how to tie school tie and shoes. Among other things

My dd is now 20.

When she was about to start school there was an evening held by the future head teacher to introduce everyone but she also had to do a little "speech" saying what the children would be expected to manage and that parents needed to ensure this

This included but was not ltd to :

Children being toilet trained

Children being able to dress and undress themselves for games

Children being able to feed
themselves (and I mean finger foods not complicated cutlery!)

Children being able to recognise their own name - spoken and written

Children responding appropriately to the word no

Children responding appropriately to "please do x"

I was  at first thinking wtf why does she feel the need to say this? Surely parents do ensure this?

Then I overheard SOME parents talking afterwards and COMPLAINING that these were too high expectations! Clearly expecting teachers to literally wipe arses, dress and feed their little cherubs

So no it doesn't surprise me 15/16 years later that SOME parents are needing to be told to do the basics of parenting/child development.

I think it's a combination of laziness, lack of awareness of normal child development, lack of education given on normal child development, families not discussing this/passing on this knowledge.

Things like mn can be useful somewhat for this.

I see threads fairly frequently on pregnancy, birth, bf, settling babies etc where the op clearly hasn't had any experience with babies or children and their families haven't discussed such things with them.

It's sad really especially for the children.

Parenting doesn't happen by accident you need to be engaged and proactive

And is having handwriting that’s not very neat in nursery going to prevent you achieving your academic potential?

Hand writing aids learning in several ways including the creation of neural pathways in parts of the brain where cognitive abilities are developing.

A simple example is you are far more likely to remember something you've handwritten than something you've typed on a phone or computer.

People who physically write more than type have better recall and think more logically.

It’s not the ideas themselves it’s that no one told our parents to do it, grandparents etc to do it,

Yea they did. Older relatives told them, health visitors told them, teachers told them... wider society told them by way of the expectations

I've had this discussion several times with my mum as at one stage it was thought my brother had a learning disability, it turned out he didn't he had a physical issue which was resolved with surgery in the end.

I only found out when i joined MN that I did baby led weaning about years after I did it.

Same

It was just "weaning" when I did it

When I was a kid children were given plasticine - it's much stiffer, you really have to work it with your hands, it's much better for building strength

I agree

I’m in my 40s and have a cross stitch calendar I made at infants - so age 6 or 7

I've recently started cross stitching again, I too was first taught embroidery at school at 6/7, my mother taught me knitting and sewing, my father bike maintenance and woodworking he was actually the person who taught me to make corn dollies.

@BlatantlyNameChanged that will be true for some of them, it's certainly not true for the majority.

I've several friends/family who are teachers and childcare workers and I've been a nanny and childminder myself. The majority of the time it is down to lack of parenting not lack of ability.
There are also too many parents who won't allow painting, water play, stickers etc cos they're "too messy" well frankly shouldn't have had kids then! This is part and parcel of what I consider BASIC parenting/childcare/encouraging child development

but the physically skilled nature of the tasks being attempted would have had value in developing fine & gross motor skills

Exactly

Also agree that many kids don't have a wide variety of toys and agree it's not necessarily down to poverty although that can be a factor.

HangingBasketFuchsia · 25/07/2021 23:38

I spent years using play doh in winter and messing with a bowl of water in summer (with plastic jugs, cups, teapots etc.)

secondbellini · 25/07/2021 23:30

I assume people did know about this stuff when I was growing up in the seventies.

As a preschool child I had those books where you follow the patterns with a crayon, a wooden shoe board for practising tying shoe laces, threading games, threading kits and so on.

Presumably they were mass produced so plenty of other kids had them too.

TableFlowerss · 25/07/2021 23:25

As others have mentioned, you’ve obviously never heard of Dyspraxia? This makes it extremely difficult for children to write. Their fine motor skills can be significantly under developed and it’s not because they’ve not had the opportunity to learn the skills, it’s because they have a neurological disorder!!

Like in other areas, 30 years makes a huge difference to what we understand about development. So back then it would have been unheard of and the many children with what we now know as dyspraxia, would just fail in school because they would have no support.

So you see, before this can be diagnosed, the doctors need to be sure that the child has had the opportunity to learn these skills so classes like this for young kid will help.

Some children are just a bit delayed and will catch up if they keep practicing, whereas those that have dyspraxia won’t catch by as such.

metellaestinatrio · 25/07/2021 23:23

@Scarby9

Many children have hardly held a crayon or a pencil before school, and - as others have said - the advent of screens has given some children only one specialised form of dexterity which doesn't lead naturally into pencil control.

Outdoor play (dighing, hanging from bars, bashing things, sweeping) strengthens the arms and all the things school has listed will help develop the strength and dexterity for a comfortable firm tripod grip to write.

Your chold may well have been doing al those things from the moment they were capable, but you can't blame the school for trying to make sure all children have the same opportunities if their parents had not thought to provide them.

My Reception-age DS loves doing and is fairly good at all the gross motor skill outdoor play things mentioned here, and has never used an iPad or mobile, but still has terrible handwriting bless him 😭!
OchonAgusOchonOh · 25/07/2021 23:20

The women in the generation above me could sew all sorts of clothes, curtains etc but they are not lamenting the lack of my fine motor skills when the best I can do is messily sew on a button and some name labels.

Not being able to sew does not mean you didn't develop fine motor skills. It simply means you didn't learn to sew. Sewing uses fine motor skills but not being able to sew doesn't mean you don't have them.

The increase in screen time and the decrease in free, unstructured play is likely to result in reduced fine motor and gross motor skills.

Thehogfatherstolemycurry · 25/07/2021 23:14

Yes, the gross motor skills need to be developed first. I'm an eyfs educator and we put a lot of emphasis on this so physical play, dance, catching and throwing balls, climbing, large scale painting etc. The shoulder joints and muscles need to be developed first then mark making, treezers, threading, play dough, independent dressing, button fastening, small world play etc to build up finger muscles ready for writing.
I've found in the last 10 years children are less physical and independent and a depressing number don't know how to play. They can work an ipad better than me though..

DoucheCanoe · 25/07/2021 23:09

I was encouraged to do all those things with my 15yo to develop his fine motor skills. He still has low dexterity in his fingers and struggles with the pincer grip so things like zippers, buttons and holding a pencil take a lot of concentration and no matter how hard he tries he can't tie laces which he finds really frustrating/embarrassing.

My 8yo can do all of those things with ease.

noworklifebalance · 25/07/2021 23:00

(I’m just picking up on the shoelaces as it was mentioned a few times)

And yes to whoever said about developing gross motor skills. I remember a teacher telling us all to help our children develop strength in their upper arms through swimming, painting the fence with water (big up & down movements with the arms), using monkey bars etc to help with the fine motor skill development

noworklifebalance · 25/07/2021 22:56

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Droopyclematis

So true. I remember learning to tie laces in reception, but family kids are only learning by age 7 or 8 now.

My 8 year old can’t tie laces because he has never had to but has developed fine motor skills in other ways. I am guessing for most children they just haven’t had the need to learn as most shoes have Velcro. It doesn’t reflect the lack of development of fine motor skills but a shift in some of them skills needed at that age. The women in the generation above me could sew all sorts of clothes, curtains etc but they are not lamenting the lack of my fine motor skills when the best I can do is messily sew on a button and some name labels. I agree - it’s just piling on the parenting guilt. Most parents will naturally be doing these things anyway, those that genuinely don’t card aren’t going to suddenly start and there will be a few that just weren’t aware that will benefit from the advice (hopefully without being made to feel bad about not knowing).
Taswama · 25/07/2021 22:41

Fine and gross motor skills are worse now in children than a generation ago. New Scientist had an interesting article about balance a few months ago and it said they are seeing younger patients with balance issues and it is linked to more time sat on screens and less moving, especially outdoors where there are a variety of surfaces.

chunderwunder · 25/07/2021 22:38

@BrilloSolar

Yes I know we all played with toys that would develop our fine motor skills, but so do kids now surely? In fact they have a much wider range of toys than we ever did.

That right there shows your privilage and your ignorance to many many children's lives today. (I genuinely don't mean that in a rude or goady way - if you've never worked with children then I wouldn't expect you to know).

An awful lot of children start school never having picked up a pencil, used scissors or turned the pages of a book, because many homes don't have crayons, scissors, paper or books, never mind jigsaws or playdoh.

Obviously lots of kids do have a huge range of toys, but lots don't, and it's not always about poverty.

As much as I hate this government, i have to agree with their reasoning for getting young children into preschools early with the funding. I'd love to advocate for the education style in countries where children start formal education much later, but it would leave a lot of children so much further behind.

Oh for goodness sake. The answer to children being left behind because of poverty isn't thrusting them into a formal education setting earlier and earlier, it's preventing poverty in the first place.

That's something this government and Tories in general couldn't give a flying fuck about.

CornishPastyDownUnder · 25/07/2021 22:33

[email protected] bells on!! it perfectly summises both the confidence level of teachers&the sad reality of what they wouldve dealt with over previous years..glad its all behind meGrin

BrilloSolar · 25/07/2021 22:30

Yes I know we all played with toys that would develop our fine motor skills, but so do kids now surely? In fact they have a much wider range of toys than we ever did.

That right there shows your privilage and your ignorance to many many children's lives today. (I genuinely don't mean that in a rude or goady way - if you've never worked with children then I wouldn't expect you to know).

An awful lot of children start school never having picked up a pencil, used scissors or turned the pages of a book, because many homes don't have crayons, scissors, paper or books, never mind jigsaws or playdoh.

Obviously lots of kids do have a huge range of toys, but lots don't, and it's not always about poverty.

As much as I hate this government, i have to agree with their reasoning for getting young children into preschools early with the funding. I'd love to advocate for the education style in countries where children start formal education much later, but it would leave a lot of children so much further behind.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/07/2021 22:21

Children start school younger now and are expected to do more formal work earlier. I have a photo of me at nursery Christmas party I’m 4 almost 5. Now I’d have been in reception not nursery.
Clothes have changed so children don’t need to fasten laces and buckles or buttons.
More finger foods - pizza, nuggets than sit down meals with cutlery every night.
DD had occupational therapy input for disability and lots of things done like threading beads we did at home anyway but I can see some children wouldn’t have access to toys like that.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 25/07/2021 22:14

@Orangeinmybluelightcup

I saw that Facebook post and took a screenshot!

My 4yo is going to school in Sept and is a bit 'behind' on his fine motor skills. I notice some things at home and preschool had picked up on it too.

Lots on here have mentioned technology and tablets as a reason kids may be behind on fine motor. That is not true here, ds uses tech like that maybe once or twice a month, if that.

I think it's just him. Preschool have said that fine motor comes from gross motor. He is a very slight boy compared to his peers, he struggles for strength to swim and push pedals on a bike. His fine motor I had noticed he used a palm grip on a pen, no tripod grip yet.

So yes, I will be spending the summer sneaking things in, dough discos all the way, games with pegs, whatever. He'll think its a game. I don't want him to have his confidence knocked if he struggles with things in Sept. He already thinks he can't do things like drawing.

It might be no harm to rule out a physical problem. My dd can't hold a pen properly. She has absolutely no upper body strength. She has hyper mobility which does affect her skills.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 25/07/2021 22:11

It’s not the ideas themselves it’s that no one told our parents to do it, grandparents etc to do it, perhaps I’m underestimating the impact that screens have.

Some research here shows the negative impact of screens. Our parents/grandparents didn't have to be told because a lot of what we did as children pre-screens by developed our fine motor skills by default. So, for example, collecting stones, making daisy chains, etc. It was called playing. We also ate as a family and our parents taught us table manners and how to use cutlery, which also happened to develop fine motor skills.

Basically, life did the job without it having to be named. Today, life doesn't always do the job so it has to be called out and named.