Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no one helped develop our fine motor skills and we all turned out fine?

139 replies

Maybeitstime2021 · 25/07/2021 19:40

Just had a post on my FB with activities to do with your child to develop their fine motor skills before starting school in September, why is this a thing? I’m pretty sure we all learned to do our coats up and hold a pencil ok when we were kids without these activities?

OP posts:
AutumnLeafDance · 26/07/2021 11:14

Some of the five year olds my friend teaches struggle to turn the pages of picture books.

Celyon · 26/07/2021 11:10

UnRavellingFast Thanks. I feel bad about it, but they've been pretty forgiving and are all good at making something from nothing, which they're beginning to appreciate more as the world moves on.

I agree with you about the increasing push to be reliant on tec, and how it saps older skills, but at the risk of tin hats I think we're needed to in order to keep a future form of capitalism that's heavily A1 based, on track.
What's really noticeable to me is the low concentration levels, and difficulty moving between screen and real interaction I see in a lot of people.

Celyon · 26/07/2021 10:54

Howshouldibehave Yes. I grew up with 'seen but not heard' and stay sat where sat with permission required to move from it. There weren't generally things allowed to play with, so I fiddled quietly and discretely with small pieces of rubbish, little stones, and fingers and tongue (inside closed mouth) I wasn't taught the fingertips to thumb game, but automatically did it, sometimes both hands at the same time, sometimes opposite. Also did it running up and down the thumb joints, crossing fingers over as far as they'd go, splitting and pairing them, anything that the movements were small enough not to irritate, but large enough to do something with. Also wiggling ears while looking stationary!

CoffeeWithCheese · 26/07/2021 10:54

[quote RedMarauder]@KingdomScrolls my DP is dyspraxic and can ride a bike. Plus I know people with balance problems who have learnt. It has taken them longer to learn than other people e.g. years. Some cycling instructors have shown they simply don't have the ability to teach them so they have been taught by extended family members or friends.

Oh and if you have room to store a tricycle then get one of those instead. You will be able to have a basket between the back wheels so should be able to carry a decent amount.[/quote]
DD2 is dyspraxic and cracked riding a bike this year (aged 8). Steering and pedalling together can be a bit of a work in progress but she can ride it. She has phenomenal amounts of resilience though - absolutely terrifyingly determined - she'll either run the world or be a supervillain.

She's the sort of child for whom all these fine motor skills activities are really useful though - poor upper body strength, really poor hand and finger strength (low muscle tone) and then dyspraxic motor planning difficulties on top of that. I'd have screenshotted the post purely as I'm always on the lookout for different things to do to mix it up a bit and help her - her current favourite thing is to set up those puzzle balls for us to solve and trying to make them "really hard" and that's doing wonders for her hand strengthening without us having to formally work at it.

Notjustanymum · 26/07/2021 10:53

@Howshouldibehave, well, it was when I was growing up: me and my siblings used to compete to be fastest! It was a bit like a physical version of a tongue-twister, which was another favourite game when the weather was too inclement to play outside... I’m sure we also played it in Primary School, along with clapping/chanting games.

DdraigGoch · 26/07/2021 10:46

I’m pretty sure we all learned to do our coats up and hold a pencil ok when we were kids without these activities?
Of course we did. But we all grew up before the iPad was invented.

UnRavellingFast · 26/07/2021 10:45

@Celyon Flowers I’m sure your kids appreciate all you did. Your post made me want to give you a hug.

Celyon · 26/07/2021 10:42

Grey12
I hate these kind of "I turned out alright" comments. The truth is YOU turned out alright but other people didn't! They struggled a lot! And that is where these ideas come from Hmm

Agree.

I developed dexterity but not in circumstances people would want to hear about. I survived childhood by a narrow margin and had little to offer my earlier children because I had no clue about 'normal' and had been pushed into very early marriage that was equally abnormal.

I was so proud to put them into school with coats, I'd never had a coat. It rained you got wet. You got wet, you stayed wet until enough evaporated. Next morning you pulled the damp clothes off the floor next to you pulled them on and wore them till either dryer or wetter again. Hanging them wasn't even an option.

I worked so hard for them to have coats and spent so long finding second hand that looked like it might not be, it never occurred to me to teach them how to button them up! I used to get down on my knees and button them in as part of ready to go inspection, in an act of misplaced love; your mum says, you're clean enough, and good enough, and your buttoned up with that all around you.
I couldn't teach them laces or ties or plaits, I had no idea my self. They went dexterous by chance because I gave them every small skill I had. I'd taught myself basic sewing and drawing, so they got needle skills, scissors, and pencil through that, and random things because I thought playing was their right, but I would have been so grateful to have known what I could have done, and how, and where I could get help.
I learnt by trial and error, having enough children to practice on until I started to understand but no one ever really said, just some criticisms from school, to guess from.

The internet's a game-changer, and yes it can add to worry as well, but over time I see more and more clueless parents with plenty of gear and no idea, and what happens as their kids grow up.

Yes some families need social skills as well as other things actively spelling out to them, some because they're neglectful, some because they've been neglected, but sadly both seem to be often the one's least likely to have anyone actually do it.

Gladimnotcampinginthisweather · 26/07/2021 10:33

My father was born in 1917. When he went to the Technical School at 14 he and a couple of other boys were given extra handwriting lessons. He always used a semi print style (lower and upper case) as an adult, but we could read it!

Howshouldibehave · 26/07/2021 10:30

I attended a lecture for piano teachers where some examples were described of what children used to do in play to develop their motor skills in general, and which are not commonly part of modern play. These include touching the tip of each finger to the thumb in turn as fast as possible

Was that one ever a part of play children used to do routinely?!

UnRavellingFast · 26/07/2021 10:29

Firstly, the phrase pencil control made me laugh for no reason.

I think screens have blown kids’ worlds to shit actually. I believe this will be recognised in time to come. I know many people will say that there’s a lot to learn on screens. But I think all our brains are being turned to mush- mine included! I used to have sat nav and reversing cameras on my car and when I downgraded, I’d lost some of the driving and mapping skills. They’ve come back now but it is frightening how we are slowly being drugged into mindlessness by increasing reliance on tech. This is reflected first on the very young and as they grow up, on the world in general. We are the last lot to have known a pre tech world.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 26/07/2021 10:26

DH has rubbish handwriting (he's 36). He was told it was because he was a boy and he didn't try hard enough. He had to do his exam papers at GCSE and A Level in block capitals so they could be read. I do any formal written stuff for him now (his job requires hand written letters occasionally, in fountain pen on unlined paper...)

DD has terrible handwriting. She is 10. She is given lots of opportunity to practice, was given a pen when it was realised her handwriting was better in pen than pencil. They are looking for a reason for it and its never been presumed to be laziness or carelessness. Her hands aren't strong enough. Incidentally, she can sew, tie knots and other fine motor skills.

The knowledge of problems is better now. Its not presumed all children are the same.

The issue of us expecting less of our children is completely different.

Notjustanymum · 26/07/2021 10:17

I attended a lecture for piano teachers where some examples were described of what children used to do in play to develop their motor skills in general, and which are not commonly part of modern play. These include touching the tip of each finger to the thumb in turn as fast as possible, bending the hand to try to touch the inside of the elbow, crossing fingers (all) with the ones next to each one, playing “Here’s the Church, here’s the steeple” and getting around a room without touching the floor, standing on one leg with eyes closed, skipping, braiding, shoelace tying, buttoning up clothes, crochet and knitting.
These examples were given to explain why a lot of modern piano pupils might need to work on their hand flexibility as most piano teachers wouldn’t have given this loss of dexterity any consideration before, and needed to think about ways of developing it in their pupils.
Thinking back, one of my earliest memories was my Grandma teaching me how to do blanket stitch, running stitch and cross stitch, and my Dad taught me how to tie shoelaces before I went to school. We had plasticine, wool and dolls with tiny clothes and associated small fastenings Etc. I suspect most pre-schoolers these days have far more sophisticated toys (and screens) to occupy them - sadly these don’t all help develop the skills needed for school...

humadum · 26/07/2021 10:04

I don't know whether pre-school groups for developing fine motor skills are a good thing or not. I think they could be a great way of socialising and if they are fun for the children, then why not?

However, I do tend to agree with the poster who said that certain aspects of parenting have become a little like a profession. This again is fine, as long as they are not mistaken for specialised provision.

My eldest son , for example, really struggles with fine motor skills, and did not learn to tie his shoelaces until he was 16. He was seriously challenged by colouring (in fact, he used to eat the crayons) and, when he got a little older, he would destroy his work because he could not do what the other children could do. He really did need help from a variety of sources, including an OT.

I am really thankful that tablets and computers were around for him, because this meant he could type his work instead of struggling with illegible handwriting and, with some adaptive hardware, he could design fantastic images on the laptop.

So yes, perhaps the groups can be fun and useful, however, if children really struggle with fine motor skills, they will need more personalised and specialised support

JudgeJ · 26/07/2021 09:41

@gogohm

Years ago they assumed parents were preparing their children for school but alas some parents to not teach them basic skills. My friend teaches reception and every year they have one or two kids who are in nappies (not special needs), can't use cutlery or a hold a pencil, unable to do up their coat or put on shoes BUT can operate a mobile phone and computer. Basic social skills need to be spelt out for those families. My friend is a teacher, if they have to to these basic things that are normal for 4 year olds to do themselves they aren't teaching the class.
Children still in nappies for no good, verified, medical reason have no place in Infant school, it's down to lazy parents. Yes, I know they're supposed to be 'ready' etc etc, all the waffle, but children in nappies at 5 for no good reason is definitely a current trend.
MySecretHistory · 26/07/2021 09:36

It frustrates me to see children in restaurants on iPads

Last night a family nex to us were playing verbal games, colouring in small books and chatting to their children. Very rarely see that anymore

MySecretHistory · 26/07/2021 09:32

balls to roll and catch, beanbags to catch, balls to throw and catch, clapping games, climbing stairs, jumping

All need to come before fine motor

Talk to your children, talk alongside your children (it isn’t performance parenting/ it is part of language development), model back correct vocabulary and grammar

RustyBear · 26/07/2021 09:28

I wasn't very well coordinated as a small child, and nowadays would probably have been labelled dyspraxia. To help me, my mum made me what became known as 'the button-fixer' before I went to school. It was over 60 years ago, but I can still remember it - it was made of two strips of mauve and white gingham with little bunches of flowers on, and it had all kinds of buttons, toggles, press-studs, hooks and eyes and laces to fix the two parts together. My mum was an amazing crafts woman who could turn her hand to anything and my dad was an electronics engineer with excellent technical skills, and I was the only one of their four children who didn't inherit their dexterity. It didn't really help much with my handwriting, which is still pretty bad, but at least I was able to do up my shoes & clothes when I went to school!

OchonAgusOchonOh · 26/07/2021 09:24

@noworklifebalance

Not being able to sew does not mean you didn't develop fine motor skills. It simply means you didn't learn to sew. Sewing uses fine motor skills but not being able to sew doesn't mean you don't have them

That’s my point!

Lack of certain types of skills need to be taken in the context of current situation and the overall ability of the child i.e. is there a need for the child to have ever had to learn to tie shoe laces (previous PPs have mentioned children used to be able to do this by YR whereas now it’s much later)? Is there a specific area they struggle with? Is there global delay in development of fine motor skills? Etc

I read your previous post as saying just because they can't do certain things, there is no need to worry. However, I think that because daily life doesn't provide the opportunities to develop these skills that it used to, we need to look at ways to ensure children can develop them.

If children have developed fine motor skills, they will be able to learn how to do certain things like hold a pencil much more quickly and easily than if they haven't developed those skills.

ReceptionTA · 26/07/2021 09:17

It's not about not having neathandwriting in reception- it's about not having the strength in your hands to hold a pencil correctly.

Fine motor activities are far more fun for a child when incorporated into their play in early years, then being taken out of class in Y2 for intervention because they still can't hold a pencil and need their hand muscles building up.

My youngest DD just didn't have the fine motor skills her older siblings had at the same age. I recognised that and was able to give specific activities to help her. Other parents might not be aware their child is behind or what activities might help, so I think it's useful information for parents who wouldn't otherwise be aware.

Also, my parents smoked, smoked me and I didn't use a seatbelt as a child and I turned out OK. It's not the way I've chosen to parent my own DC though Grin

RedMarauder · 26/07/2021 08:59

@KingdomScrolls my DP is dyspraxic and can ride a bike. Plus I know people with balance problems who have learnt. It has taken them longer to learn than other people e.g. years. Some cycling instructors have shown they simply don't have the ability to teach them so they have been taught by extended family members or friends.

Oh and if you have room to store a tricycle then get one of those instead. You will be able to have a basket between the back wheels so should be able to carry a decent amount.

grey12 · 26/07/2021 08:40

@Maybeitstime2021

Just had a post on my FB with activities to do with your child to develop their fine motor skills before starting school in September, why is this a thing? I’m pretty sure we all learned to do our coats up and hold a pencil ok when we were kids without these activities?
I hate these kind of "I turned out alright" comments. The truth is YOU turned out alright but other people didn't! They struggled a lot! And that is where these ideas come from Hmm

The same thing, for example, with carseats. I also didn't use a carseat after 3 years old and didn't even use a seatbelt. However I was also incredibly lucky to never have been in a serious car accident and many other children have died or been left severely injured. So I'm going to strap my kids tightly! And my parents would have done the same if they had known

RancidOldHag · 26/07/2021 08:37

We were all taught to tie our shoelaces in reception, and we had zero screen time.

Other than the three channels on the telly - two of which had about 2 hours of children's programming on weekdays early evening, and on starurday mornings.

It was a different world, and different expectations. There wasn't any need to 'develop skills' because life was set up to do that.

Also the jargon wasn't used, because most people just got on with child rearing. You maybe had a baby book, but that was about it.

PrettyLittleFlies · 26/07/2021 08:35

*any

PrettyLittleFlies · 26/07/2021 08:35

Ask my primary teacher and they'll tell you why it's become a thing.