Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no one helped develop our fine motor skills and we all turned out fine?

139 replies

Maybeitstime2021 · 25/07/2021 19:40

Just had a post on my FB with activities to do with your child to develop their fine motor skills before starting school in September, why is this a thing? I’m pretty sure we all learned to do our coats up and hold a pencil ok when we were kids without these activities?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Spanielstail · 27/07/2021 14:13

It's not just fine motor activities. You need good gross motor skills to have good fine motor skills and modern living is terrible for that.

First up people use those car seats that clip onto a frame to become a pushchair so baby is cocooned rather than stretched out in a pram and later sitting using their core strength. Those things are terrible.

People put babies in those awful jumperoo's. They encourage tiptoe walking, poor hip position and time spend in that means they aren't on the floor pushing through their arms, learning where their body is and developing core strength.

They then get older and aren't sat at the dining table for meals so it's harder to develop cutlery skills. They spend time lying down playing on iPads so aren't activating their core. They aren't outside climbing, bike riding etc.

Then there is all the fine motor things already mentioned.

Also though it is spatial awareness. So building in Minecraft isn't the same as building with Lego where you have to workout size, space and relationship to other items.

canigooutyet · 27/07/2021 13:07

You would be surprised how many start school without knowing how to use cutlery. How to hold a pencil. How to wipe their own arse. How to put their own coat on/take it off. Never seen a crayon or paint. And I don't mean children with additional needs.

I quickly left working in early years because it was so hard to keep quiet listening to parents saying this is why they go school to learn these things.

picklemewalnuts · 27/07/2021 12:55

Being a mother was considered a full time job and involved keeping your child busy without a lot of stuff. They'd help with matching and pairing socks, play with clothes pegs, sit and fiddle with gravel, scribble lists while mum was making a shopping list etc. They had shoes with laces or buckles, shirts with buttons etc etc. Make peg dolls from fabric scraps etc.

Nursery rhymes with actions develop motor skills.

All soul destroyingly boring in many ways, there weren't many places to go so there was lots of time to kill.
It was undervalued and gone by the wayside.

Now, with tv and phones and reduced input from parents, children have a less rich physical environment- unless they get it at nursery.

MySecretHistory · 27/07/2021 12:37

Great holiday task for 4 and 5 year olds

Bowl of uncooked rice. Empty bowl. Pair of tweezers.
Move the rice using the tweezers from one bowl to the other.

RedMarauder · 27/07/2021 09:30

@BigPyjamas

Apologies if someone has already mentioned this but I read a few years ago that new surgeons coming through are lacking the fine motor skills needed for stitching and other surgical procedures. Academically excellent, but they're not used to using their hands / fingers in this way and need extra training.

The article quoted a senior surgeon saying that children's hobbies have changed and so be felt this was the root cause of the lack of these critical skills.

I saw this as well.

There are skills that current kids learn from playing console games so many have better hand to eye co-ordination than older adults, but there are other skills we learnt from sewing, knitting, cutting things up, colouring etc that they don't have.

Ideally you want your kid to do a good mixture of things.

35andThriving · 26/07/2021 21:35

That's really interesting about new surgeons lacking fine motor skills.

This thread has made me buy some play doh for ds, for over the holidays. I know they play with it in his class at school.

Postparty · 26/07/2021 16:34

@Maybeitstime2021 it sounds like this has touched a nerve with you. Are you worried your DC is struggling with fine motor skills?

I am a children's physiotherapist and I can see changes in children's gross and fine motor skills even in the last 2 years with the effect of lockdowns. Hugely increased screen time and lack of opportunity for outdoor play. There are exceptions, but generally the children i see are heavier and unfitter than ever.

Gross motor (crawling, walking, jumping, cycling) needs to be developed before fine motor so this year more than ever I think kids will struggle in reception. I have a DC starting reception this year. The pandemic started when she was still 2yo. She had way more screen time than her older siblings at that age. She missed 6 months of nursery, months of playgrounds, swimming etc at a vital stage. We are lucky, we have a decent sized house, a garden with a climbing frame and slide, she inherited older siblings bikes and live semi rurally. I still think her skills are a little behind what they could be. The poor kids at the same age cooped up in flats with limited space for exercise and toys will have suffered far more.

The issue with screens is what they are missing out on whilst they are starting at screens. The fine motor skills for screens are very simple compared to cutting/ sticking, colouring for the hand muscles.

I even think modern playgrounds are tame compared to older fashioned ones. They seem to lack more challenging play equipment.

BigPyjamas · 26/07/2021 15:42

Apologies if someone has already mentioned this but I read a few years ago that new surgeons coming through are lacking the fine motor skills needed for stitching and other surgical procedures. Academically excellent, but they're not used to using their hands / fingers in this way and need extra training.

The article quoted a senior surgeon saying that children's hobbies have changed and so be felt this was the root cause of the lack of these critical skills.

RedMarauder · 26/07/2021 15:12

No harm in practicing things like carrying a tray or changing for PE. We did lots of pretending to go to school activities with our DC.

Not heard of dressing up?

We use to put on old adults clothes at playgroup as children not special costumes.

My DD, who is 2, can take of and put on her own clothes as long as they are slightly too big for her. She could put on and take off her own shoes - wellies and velcro straps - from about 19 months though it would take ages at the beginning.

Doubledoorsontogarden · 26/07/2021 14:00

No harm in practicing things like carrying a tray or changing for PE. We did lots of pretending to go to school activities with our DC.

Our reception TA has found the last intake harder to manage as many hadn’t been away from mum much, nurseries closed etc. Took a lot more time doing care rather than teaching. Do what you can or think is appropriate. Enjoy the last summer before the school run

junebirthdaygirl · 26/07/2021 13:40

I began teaching over 40 years ago and we heard lots in college about fine motor skills and they were very much part of infant classrooms even back in the 80s. Families were often bigger then and you wouldn't give mothers extra tasks as they would think l haven't time for that. Nowadays a lot of parents like to know how they can help and it is surprising how many don't think when buying birthday presents etc to give consideration to these skills. A lot of children just get the biggest flashier toy which actually does nothing after a day or two. I am shocked at how many children say..l am not allowed to use a scissors at home and have never seen a child's scissors. Getting ideas of things to do can be helpful to parents and they are free to ignore too!!

Hardbackwriter · 26/07/2021 13:37

Even in a highchair, toddlers learnt to feed themselves with a spoon. When you graduated to a cushion on a chair, you ate at the table with a spoon and pusher. Once you'd mastered the spoon and pusher you graduated to a fork and pusher then child-size knife and fork (age 3-ish)

That's still how it's done, if by 'pusher' you mean something spoon-like? That's certainly how we've done it with our three year old!

2bazookas · 26/07/2021 13:26

I forgot "cats cradles" (string game), "tracing" ( copying picture outlines on greaseproof paper ) and scrap books.

Scrap books were pictures cut out of old xmas cards or magazines or catalogues, (scissor skills) then glued on to pages ( any old paper, first we made the glue by mixing flour and water) . Oh the thrill when my Dad gave me a pot of Gloy ( real glue).

2bazookas · 26/07/2021 13:06

Actually, my childhood activities did develop fine motor skills; here's a list of the basic skills expected before we started school age 5.

Even in a highchair, toddlers learnt to feed themselves with a spoon. When you graduated to a cushion on a chair, you ate at the table with a spoon and pusher. Once you'd mastered the spoon and pusher you graduated to a fork and pusher then child-size knife and fork (age 3-ish).
As soon as breast or bottlefeeding ended, babies drank from an ordinary open cup. Then learned how to pick it up, hold it and drink and put it back down on the table without spilling.
On a rainy day, common acitivities were drawing. "colouring books" ( "colouring -in" inside the lines).
Wax crayons, then coloured pencils. If your pencil tip broke (often) you used a pencil sharpener.
Threading beads.
Cutting out paper dolls with child scissors (blunt )
Jigsaws.
Plasticine.
Playing with the leftover bits of pastry until it was grey.
Sandpies.
Chalking (outside, usually on pavements.)
Learning to do up our buttons, shoe buckles and tie shoe laces.

    Nobody knew it was "learning fine motor skills" .
firstimemamma · 26/07/2021 12:54

Early years teacher here. Back when we were children fine motor skills development happened without anyone realising it because the world was a different place. Less technology, children generally more active. Stuff like plasticine more popular, I could go on. Fine and gross motor skills development is really important whether it's achieved through set activities, an active lifestyle without too much screen time or some sort of combination of the 2.

SunSeaSurfGin · 26/07/2021 12:51

I did but I was diagnosed with dyspraxia at a young age so it was part of my development plan. My peers didn't have help as such that I can remember

user1471538283 · 26/07/2021 12:47

I did all the things I did with my DS to encourage independence before nursery but it wasnt called fine motor skills training.

Tying laces, doing up coats, baking, picking up raisins, doing up clothes, using silverware. Also independence in the bathroom and being familiar with the way lunch is. Teachers are there to teach not to dress and undress 20 children.

RancidOldHag · 26/07/2021 12:40

I don't know which 1980s some of you grew up in but it seems different to my experiences

I didn't grow up in the 1980s, I was fully adult by then

I agree with previous posters about the names changing, but the actions being the same.

I did what is now called 'baby led weaning' as did many others, but it seems like the juggernaut of modern spin wants to erase folk memory. Same for many other things.

But things have changed. We are living in an obesogenic society, and one in which the nature of 'play' for children has changed completely. Games were things you did, together in RL, not a solitary screen activity. The country was not so crowded, and the traffic far less dangerous. The changes in what children do is a response to a whole set of changes in wider society.

And because of those changes children, in numbers far greater than a generation or so ago, might need interventions (which come with their own jargon) which were rare beforehand

garlictwist · 26/07/2021 12:30

I don't know which 1980s some of you grew up in but it seems different to my experiences.

I had velcro shoes, playdough and lots of screen time. Never played outside because of the traffic. So not that different to today.

I also remember learning to write in nursery school. I must have been 3 because I started school at 4 and my birthday is in August.

So I don't think the "past" was this great utopia when we were all rustling up a pair of curtains on the sewing machine in reception.

Notcontent · 26/07/2021 12:26

Let’s be honest - this is MN and most of the people in here are reasonably well educated and so their children are sling things like drawing, playing outside etc. Sadly this is obviously not a reflection of the whole of society. There are so many parents who think that giving their toddler a tablet to play with all day is the best thing ever - it’s technology, right? Who wants to mess around with dirty crayons, wooden blocks, mud, sticks etc... Sad but true. Just like the parents who wonder why on earth anyone would be giving their child water and fruit when they could be having lemonade and crisps...

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 26/07/2021 12:18

Was a child before screens but still have crap fine motor skills because I'm dyspraxic - my Reception teacher's report said "scissors - useless!" Although I could write well before starting school.

Terrazzo · 26/07/2021 12:11

They did, it just wasn't labelled so.

BogRollBOGOF · 26/07/2021 12:10

DS1 has dyspraxia (and ASD which affects his willingness and tolerance for doing things not on his priority list, especially when they're frustrating and painful.

So with shoe laces, he already has a disadvantage, plus having small feet, shoes in his size have always been velcroed. DS2 has recently learned how to do his first lace-ups (his feet are bigger!)

Natural exposure to fine motor skills has declined. The DCs' Happy Land set was far clunkier than my 1970s "choke hazard" Fisher Price village. Gone are the micro machines (DS would have loved them) and Polly Pocket has supersized.
We did try years of crayons when out, but to avoid meltdowns it ended up with DS dictating to us as he found it too frustrating to make marks himself. Ironically he holds pencils well but with his processing issues he struggles with pressure and his hands hurt very quickly. We never got much out of paint/ dough, but he had an early talent for Lego.

At least being aware of all these issues, it was relatively easy to get a dyspraxia dignosis, and he had been exposed to the skills he needed and it wasn't deemed a parenting issue.

The past 16m have been bloody tough for parenting and especially over the winter, we had far, far too much screen time. Over last summer, my two lost inspiration on how to play and getting more normality back for a few months has inspired them again and they are playing better having got fresh external input.

The world has changed quite rapidly in a generation, and if you're not aware of these kinds of skills, have limited resources and are focused on easy survival then children do slip through especially where there's a localised culture of it. The opportunities are less natural than they were for previous generations, and need more effort for development.

TotorosCatBus · 26/07/2021 11:40

In my experience parents evenings and reports can sometimes use technical terms that parents don't understand or query because they don't want to look stupid. So they'll know that weak fine motor skills are not a good thing but need help knowing specifics. When they look at a list like that they may feel reassured that actually child does things like sort little objects or plays with little Lego rather than Duplo so is on the right track. Our parents wouldn't necessarily know terms like gross motor skills.

Modern technology has made things easier to use with less physical effort eg playdoh rather than plasticine and modern parents are more likely to introduce skills later eg expecting children to cut their own food

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 26/07/2021 11:27

Once you get outside or at least away from screens, you really appreciate what an inadequate ersatz version of reality screen life is. But it provides immediate gratification and with all the lockdowns and social distancing, it’s easy to fall into the habit of living through electronic devices. That goes for children and adults.

I’m not sure about the use of all this technical terminology when it come to discussing children, though. If mothers from earlier times could eavesdrop on the conversations about fine motor skills and socialisation that mothers engage in nowadays, they would feel like they were listening to attendees at a conference on early childhood.

Society has definitely encouraged mothers to take a more ‘scholarly’ approach to child-rearing recently, to live more in their left brain hemispheres, the left being the hemisphere that likes to compare, categorise and compete.