Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would a £50 McDonalds voucher encourage people to have the jab?

279 replies

KhalliWhalli · 25/07/2021 18:46

This is my colleague’s proposed solution to the issue of anti-vaxxers and others who don’t want to have the jab. He figures that as these people are generally of low intelligence, they fit the demographic of people who eat McDonald’s. Ergo if you bribe them with a £50 McDonald’s voucher at the time of vaccination, you would have hordes of people turning up for their jab.

He has a professional interest in this, so I have given it a bit more thought than I would usually.

I dunno, what do you guys think?

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 26/07/2021 08:18

@allthestripeys

I wouldn't take the 50 voucher for McDonald's as a giveaway for nothing never mind for not getting the vaccine. I have been educated to masters level and I have two degrees. Oh and I work in pharmaceuticals. I have opted not to get it...I know doctors, nurses and several well educated ppl who have not/will not be having the vaccine.
You're an intelligent person, so you'll be able to answer this - why?

Most academic people who work in pharmaceuticals would be able to follow up your post with a simple explanation of why you won't be having it. You indicate that it's because of your intelligence and knowledge that you've come to this decision, so I assume your explanation will be rational and won't involve a link from a Dr Michael Yeadon youtube video. I would love it to be something I haven't heard before because I've yet to hear a convincing argument so far.

Many thanks.

Maggiemay92 · 26/07/2021 08:17

@RampantIvy

I know doctors, nurses and several well educated ppl who have not/will not be having the vaccine.

Yet everyone I know, including medical professionals (apart from SIL and her family, none of whom are very well educated) has been vaccinated.

And what can we learn from this?

That people are free to make a choice.

Some well educated people and medical professionals are choosing to have the vaccine, despite potential risks, for the greater good - in the hope that having the vaccine can reduce covid risk for everyone, and help life get back to normal. Very noble.

Also, some well educated people and medical professionals are choosing NOT to take the risk, because many short-term side effects are still unknown, and long term side effects are totally unknown, and they don't wish to be a part of an experiment. Very sensible.

In summary - well educated people and medical professionals are making up their own mind about what they prioritise, and what is best for them. They have chosen what they want to do with their own bodies. Both choices are fine. We all need to make this decision for ourselves.

What is NOT fine is attempting to bully and undermine those who have made a different decision to you.

I understand that a lot of people got vaccinated before a lot of the risks and side effects started to became apparent, and even though we still have no idea of the full scale right now, I expect it must be quite scary and worrying for those who are already vaccinated. Of COURSE nobody wants to believe that they might be at risk, so many people are simply mocking those who speak about the risks and side effects because mocking them means they don't have to confront what they are saying.

I also understand that if you had a potentially risky vaccine "for the greater good", it might be frustrating that others haven't potentially put themselves at risk "for the greater good". I can totally understand why this might cause bitterness and feelings of frustration.

BUT, it is not those who are cautious of this vaccine who are to blame for this situation, but the people who pushed everyone to get this vaccine while reassuring everyone that it was totally safe and ignoring the cries of scientists and medical professionals around the world who are extremely concerned about mRNA technology and don't think it's morally right for people to be vaccinated on a mass scale without being made aware of the risks.

Of course, a lot of people who have had the vaccine will be fine. But some people won't. Some people have already had horrible side effects. Some people have already become permanently disabled. Some people have already died. Just because not EVERYONE experiences this, doesn't mean it's any less real or serious.

Someone said the other day, "It's like with a peanut allergy. Some people have mild allergic reactions, some people life threatening allergic reactions, and some people die. A lot of people are totally fine. But these people don't say "Well, I ate peanuts yesterday and I was fine! So there's no risk! Don't be so ridiculous and uneducated, just eat the peanuts!" Things affect people differently. Just because you have been fine, isn't proof of the safety of the vaccine.

The thing with the vaccine is, nobody knows before they get it if they're going to be one of the ones who gets the awful side effects or whose life is ruined by taking it. And they won't know until it's too late. Even if a vaccinated person has had no short term side effects experienced so far, doesn't mean there won't be any long term side effects - as doctors and scientests all over the world are saying (despite it being dramatically underreported in the mainstream media).

Like it or not, there IS a risk. And avoiding risk doesn't make you uneducated. Just like taking a potentially dangerous vaccine doesn't make you uneducated. We all make our own decisions.

Bluesheep8 · 26/07/2021 08:16

So people who eat McDonald's are of low intelligence? Alrighty then!!

What a ridiculous statement he's making. I'd question the intelligence of the person making this narrow minded assumption to be honest.

RampantIvy · 26/07/2021 08:02

Finally, when obesity has been recognised as a major issue in our Covid struggle, vouchers for any fast food outlet would seem a bad idea

Good point

listsandbudgets · 26/07/2021 07:43

Perhaps they could have a range of choices

McJab is brilliant Wink

M and S .. This is not just any jab this is an M and S jab

John Lewis Never knowingly under jabbed

Tesco Every little jab helps

etc. etc.

ShadowInVain · 26/07/2021 07:39

I doubt it. The jab is free and easily obtainable. People who don't have it are either acting on principle (anti-vaxxers) or suffering from something that prevents them having it, whether that be a chronic physical illness or a MH issue that affects functioning. A voucher isn't going to change that.

If the government did go down the voucher route, they'd be better choosing something universally spendable - those 'Love to Shop' vouchers, for example. Not everyone likes McDonalds, especially not to the tune of spending £50 there, and it might be totally useless to someone with food allergies, cultural dietary restrictions etc.

Finally, when obesity has been recognised as a major issue in our Covid struggle, vouchers for any fast food outlet would seem a bad idea.

RampantIvy · 26/07/2021 07:35

I know doctors, nurses and several well educated ppl who have not/will not be having the vaccine.

Yet everyone I know, including medical professionals (apart from SIL and her family, none of whom are very well educated) has been vaccinated.

Tresal · 26/07/2021 07:35

I would do a lottery system. Chance to win big cash prizes once you have had your second jab.

kowari · 26/07/2021 07:32

@Vitallyli

In my surroundings it's intelligent people who follow alternative medicine /nutrition as medicine advice and they won't be bothered with fast food vouchers.
I agree. In Australia, children can't attend childcare unvaccinated (childhood vaccines, not covid) and their parents can lose a portion of the equivalent of tax credits. This mainly impacts low income disorganised parents who just hadn't got around to it. Many unvaccinated children are middle class with a stay at home parent, usually the natural parenting types, so 'no jab, no play/pay' does not affect them.

It's similar with the other people I know who are not vaccinated against covid, they avoid things like McDonald's.

MissTrip82 · 26/07/2021 07:15

@allthestripeys

I wouldn't take the 50 voucher for McDonald's as a giveaway for nothing never mind for not getting the vaccine. I have been educated to masters level and I have two degrees. Oh and I work in pharmaceuticals. I have opted not to get it...I know doctors, nurses and several well educated ppl who have not/will not be having the vaccine.
Your first sentence makes no sense; odd for someone with your level of education.

I pretty much only know doctors and nurses. Not a vaccine-refuser amongst them.

brokenbiscuitsx · 26/07/2021 06:49

@NotJustACigar

A £50 McDonald's voucher is insulting. A £200 "love to shop" voucher would be much better. Plus entry into a competition to win more. Much easier than arguing and debating with people who won't listen to reason. I do have some sympathy with people who are afraid of needles etc but those that are spreading and repeating misinformation online from dubious sources generally are of low intelligence, yes. Those of them that claim to be "health care providers" usually turn out on further prompting to be homeopathic medicine providers or reiki practitioners or the like.
I don’t agree!

Why should they get a £200 "love to shop" voucher would be much better. If this happened there would be outrage. I can imagine social media now!

It’s like the good children in the class having nothing and the naughty ones being bribed with gifts to be good. All it would do is cause resentment in the well behaved kids.

I can see the thought behind it but it comes across as rewarding bad behaviour and I honestly think it will cause such outrage amongst those who did it with no resistance, no bribe etc.

NotJustACigar · 26/07/2021 06:33

A £50 McDonald's voucher is insulting. A £200 "love to shop" voucher would be much better. Plus entry into a competition to win more. Much easier than arguing and debating with people who won't listen to reason. I do have some sympathy with people who are afraid of needles etc but those that are spreading and repeating misinformation online from dubious sources generally are of low intelligence, yes. Those of them that claim to be "health care providers" usually turn out on further prompting to be homeopathic medicine providers or reiki practitioners or the like.

brokenbiscuitsx · 26/07/2021 06:25

Why should people who don’t want it benefit though? It seems like it’s rewarding them for not wanting it?

Farevalah · 26/07/2021 02:16

BIL is a GP partner and he hasn't had the vaccine. Not all people who haven't been jabbed are of low intelligence and its really poor form to infer this.

Surely not questioning anything you're told shows less intelligence anyway?

feelingmehtoday · 26/07/2021 01:45

@Maggiemay92

These people aren't of low intelligence though. A lot of medical professionals are refusing to have the jab until more side effects become clear. This isn't unintelligent - in fact, given the side effects that are being discovered, I think it's very intelligent. How sad it is that people are so cruel and bitter over this issue. It's truly divided people to the point that people who want to be cautious are being bulliwd and insulted. So sad. Your post is really awful and your colleague sounds like a really ignorant person.
Agree entirely
Iquitit · 26/07/2021 00:32

Well as I had to be done for my job, both were my days off and I had to travel in to work do so, paying me for my time would have been a nice touch.
But then as I've been traveling in on my days off to do covid tests for over a year, at a dictated time so my day has to run around that, and don't get paid for that either, I don't know why I'd expect any different.

I think a bit more education and information around it and maybe an incentive to pay expenses or a little give away with each jab, not a McDonald's voucher, not everyone who hasn't got the jab is a burger munching thicko.

Maggiemay92 · 25/07/2021 23:40

FYI, if you contact any of the vaccine providers directly and query side effects, the staff you speak to will openly tell you that the vaccine is experimental. I know a woman who deveoped GBS as a direct side effect from the vaccine (yes, confirmed by doctors) and she was told this.

Doesn't seem so unintelligent to hold back from being part of an experiment, in my opinion.

(Also not unintelligent here, medical anthropologist background.)

Maggiemay92 · 25/07/2021 23:36

These people aren't of low intelligence though. A lot of medical professionals are refusing to have the jab until more side effects become clear. This isn't unintelligent - in fact, given the side effects that are being discovered, I think it's very intelligent. How sad it is that people are so cruel and bitter over this issue. It's truly divided people to the point that people who want to be cautious are being bulliwd and insulted. So sad. Your post is really awful and your colleague sounds like a really ignorant person.

Vitallyli · 25/07/2021 23:33

In my surroundings it's intelligent people who follow alternative medicine /nutrition as medicine advice and they won't be bothered with fast food vouchers.

Jumpjumpjumper · 25/07/2021 23:28

Surely it'd make them even more resistant to it?

The coercion (won't be allowed anywhere without vaccine) is certainly pushing me further from the vaccine.

It makes me even more skeptical.

I'm also a medical professional so I'm not stupid.

BridgetGetTheGin · 25/07/2021 23:27

That's disgraceful. I have a Masters degree and a PHD, currently pregnant with my second and won't be having the vaccine until my baby is here. I have done an antibody test and have antibodies after having Covid a year ago.

I find this threat very insulting. I have chosen not to have the vaccine because it's still a trial vaccine until 2023, with no pregnant women having been tested on either. No one knows the long term effects it will have had on a foetus in 3, 5, 7 years etc.

FakingMemories · 25/07/2021 23:16

@Dogvmarmot that’s a terrible analogy. Most car accidents are the result of someone doing something reckless, be it speeding, drinking and driving, texting and driving, driving too tired, crossing the road at an unsafe place or without looking, not wearing a helmet when cycling, etc, etc. For a true comparison you’d have to remove all of those who were somehow at fault, even pedestrians, cyclists, etc and use the stats of only those who were completely “innocent” and the true accidents (such as a heart attack or stroke at the wheel). With the COVID shot there is nothing you can do to mitigate the risk. It’s not a case of “oh well the blood clot wouldn’t have happened if you had done it like this” as can be said of many accidents.

And using road accidents kind of proves the opposite point. Young healthy people are far more likely to be in a car accident than die of COVID. That’s why many feel the vaccine is unnecessary.

Conchitastrawberry · 25/07/2021 23:14

He’s an idiot. The people that i know that don’t vaccinate in general, I dint mean just covid are intelligent people. No amount of money or bribes could convince them to vaccinate themselves or their children.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 25/07/2021 23:09

The people I know who aren’t are mainly saying ‘I won’t put junk I don’t know about in my body’. For them that includes McDonald’s

FakingMemories · 25/07/2021 23:06

So she’s planning to encourage people to do something that is supposed to be good for the general health of the population by giving them something that supports bad health habits. What next? Encouraging people to stop smoking by giving them bottles of vodka?