Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The concept of a break - single parent vs together

116 replies

afriusaenghather · 25/07/2021 18:41

I’m a single parent, other parent lives very far away. So during term time, he has/sees the children for 4 nights per month.

I am responsible for every school drop off, pick up, all boring school and PTA/WhatsApp communication, all ferrying to and from clubs, all clothing, clubs, finances etc . I work full time. I do not have a partner, my ex does not get involved in any admin, or even payment of supporting their lives.

I however get 4 nights per month child free. I also get approx 4-5 weeks per year child free, where the children stay with him in the holidays.

Who do you think has it easier or harder? No trick question, I want to see what people really think here. Eg

  1. A single parent in my situation (4 nights per month ‘off’ plus 4-5 weeks per annum with no children)
  2. A parent couple, who align to 50:50 responsibilities and benefit from shared care 24/7

Thank you

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 25/07/2021 20:33

It depends on what the other parent is like as a co-parent.

I know of several of my DD's friends where the parents are separated and have 50/50 residence arrangements: they are aligned in terms of the roles and responsibilities etc and it works well. This is the optimal situation for separated parents and if you have this I think you have the best possible scenario.

On the other hand if you have a co-parent who is unco-operative, bad at communicating, ill-tempered or irrresponsible then this scenario would be a total nightmare and you would be better off in your situation.

My DD's father simply isn't responsible enough to do 50/50 residence and frankly I wouldn't trust him even with a one-off overnight stay. So although I have almost no support and its more or less impossible to have any kind of break, I'd much rather be in this situation than constantly be worrying about whether the other parent will step up and do what they are supposed to do.

It's swings and roundabouts.

HorriderHenry · 25/07/2021 20:28

(If you did 50:50 custody, it would be a comparison of half the responsibility all of the time, or all of the responsibility half of the time. And I think that depends on your mindset).

HorriderHenry · 25/07/2021 20:27

It ought to always be easier for the couple. In reality: It depends on how (dys)functional the relationship is for the couple.

I know several couples where one parent (who am I kidding, it’s always the Mum) who does the full mental, most of the physical load, and never even gets a reasonable break for a shower, never mind an evening off. In that case, where they’re doing the parenting and carrying the partner, I think you have it easier. For all that you have to make all the decisions, at least you’re not carrying a deadweight.

I have a very good relationship and compatible parenting styles with DH. It would never dawn on him to have a weekend away or even a night away, so I feel constrained that I can’t make those choices without appearing/feeling selfish.

afriusaenghather · 25/07/2021 20:27

@BillyRaywasapreachersson

Why do you need to compare? What does it matter?
I didn’t compare, someone compared to me.

It’s not a big deal, but wanted to get external opinions.

OP posts:
afriusaenghather · 25/07/2021 20:23

@BeenThruMoreThanALilBit

Such an odd question.

How many DC?
How old are the D.C.?
How much do you earn?
What are your work hours?
Do you have a support network?
What is your DC like? Easy or difficult?
Where do you live?

It’s such a petty question. Why do you need to win this argument?

I don’t need to win anything. I was questioning /garnering external opinions, due to someone else’s comment on my life in comparison to theirs.

It’s not a competition, I just feel like I may have missed something, as I feel like I do have it a bit harder, that’s all.

I’m not perfect, and don’t want to cause any massive arguments I assure you

OP posts:
afriusaenghather · 25/07/2021 20:20

@chunderwunder

Didn't realise it was a competition but having a dead other parent probably wins.
I’m really sorry if I upset you. Not my intention.

I was asking as a comment was made to me, and I was a bit dumbfounded

I hope you are ok

OP posts:
lollipoprainbow · 25/07/2021 20:19

I'm a single mum and I don't get financial help from her dad or any time to myself. I so envy those who get the odd weekend off. It's relentless.

megletthesecond · 25/07/2021 20:18

Option 2 parent couple have it easier.

afriusaenghather · 25/07/2021 20:18

@Aloethere

I hate these questions. It isn't some kind of competetion. There are so many variables that go into it it is impossible to say unless you are talking about the same adults and the same children. Some kids have more difficult than others, some adults have more challanges than others when it comes to coping with life, it isn't black and white.
I’m sorry, it wasn’t meant as a competition.

Something was said to me, about my situation, and I wanted to seek a greater/wider view. That is it, I assure you

OP posts:
afriusaenghather · 25/07/2021 20:16

@babycorn123

Oooh do I win the pity party?

Single parent, work FT, zero family support, deadbeat ex who isn't allowed contact with child and who contributes the princely sum of £6 a week through collect and pay... I have had three evenings 'off' in four years, and one of those I was in hospital for an operation!

Mind you, I think I'd rather this than have to put up with him, and his abuse and accompanying bullshit so 🤷‍♀️

I’m sorry. You have it shit.

I hope life gives you back something soon

You’re doing great x

OP posts:
afriusaenghather · 25/07/2021 20:15

@User5827372728

I share the mental load with my OH and miss his support when he’s away

But I would love 4-5 weeks a year without my kids 😱

I get that! There’s no clean ‘off’ time for you
OP posts:
babycorn123 · 25/07/2021 20:00

Oooh do I win the pity party?

Single parent, work FT, zero family support, deadbeat ex who isn't allowed contact with child and who contributes the princely sum of £6 a week through collect and pay... I have had three evenings 'off' in four years, and one of those I was in hospital for an operation!

Mind you, I think I'd rather this than have to put up with him, and his abuse and accompanying bullshit so 🤷‍♀️

blubberball · 25/07/2021 19:56

My exh was like a 3rd child and a dead weight. I find things easier now. Can buy what I need with out arguments, make my own decisions with out arguments. I'm cleaning up after 1 less person, and I'm not living on egg shells.

I'm far better off as a single parent, personally. Even though my ex takes zero financial responsibility for the dc. Or any responsibility really. I deal with their schools, medical appointments and activities. I pay for everything. He's never bought them a stitch of clothing or a pair of shoes since they were born.

Sorry.... Accidentally vented a little.

Wjevtvha · 25/07/2021 19:47

My DH works massively long hours but I never imagine I have it harder than a single parent because even though I do 95% of the practical stuff I can rely on him if I need him to come home early, financially I’m not on my own, we talk things through and I have his moral support. I don’t feel like I’m doing it on my own

Aloethere · 25/07/2021 19:46

I hate these questions. It isn't some kind of competetion. There are so many variables that go into it it is impossible to say unless you are talking about the same adults and the same children. Some kids have more difficult than others, some adults have more challanges than others when it comes to coping with life, it isn't black and white.

NotMeItsThem · 25/07/2021 19:46

I'm in a similar position to you but ExH won't have DD extra in holidays so I get 27 nights per year break that's it. Oh and he lives 10 minutes from me but won't have her anymore Hmm

I actually find it easier being on my own than when I was with ExH. But that's just me and my situation (DV and walking on egg shells when we were together, much much nicer home now he's not here).

But I do love my break of 1 night EOW where I can kick back and not be a "parent" for a bit.

Mumteedum · 25/07/2021 19:44

@chunderwunder

Mumteedum · 25/07/2021 19:43
Flowers
BeenThruMoreThanALilBit · 25/07/2021 19:43

Such an odd question.

How many DC?
How old are the D.C.?
How much do you earn?
What are your work hours?
Do you have a support network?
What is your DC like? Easy or difficult?
Where do you live?

It’s such a petty question. Why do you need to win this argument?

chunderwunder · 25/07/2021 19:39

Didn't realise it was a competition but having a dead other parent probably wins.

likeafishneedsabike · 25/07/2021 19:33

@Mumteedum

Situations are not comparable.

Married with abusive partner = shit
Separated with responsible and amicable ex partner= good
Separated with no ex partner doing anything but family support = ok
Separated with useless volatile ex and no family support and therefore 100 % mental load plus earning the money and doing everything with possibly 2-4 nights 'off' but worrying about child because ex is a dick = shit

Very wise words. I have learned this in twelve years of parenting. There are so many variables in family set up that it’s very difficult to compare.
Mumteedum · 25/07/2021 19:27

Situations are not comparable.

Married with abusive partner = shit
Separated with responsible and amicable ex partner= good
Separated with no ex partner doing anything but family support = ok
Separated with useless volatile ex and no family support and therefore 100 % mental load plus earning the money and doing everything with possibly 2-4 nights 'off' but worrying about child because ex is a dick = shit

WeAllHaveWings · 25/07/2021 19:20

@BillyRaywasapreachersson

Why do you need to compare? What does it matter?
Agree. There are so many variables too. From single parents who don't need/want a break, to couples who feel they do. There are dc who are easy and those that are extremely challenging. There are single parents with great support networks and couples with none. There are just too many different circumstances competitive comparison of who has it worse achieves nothing.
endofjune · 25/07/2021 19:18

I always think the financial load must be very difficult for many single parents.

NakedAttraction · 25/07/2021 19:15

I saw a statistic once that said the happiest parents were those who are separated but co parent well. I assume because they get a break more often and time to pursue other interests, holiday with friends, etc.

I think for 90% of cases option 1 has it harder, but it could very much depend on the kids. And let’s face it, hardly any couple has true 50-50 responsibility for everything.