Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'When are you having another baby?'

37 replies

hopefulmamaofone · 25/07/2021 18:07

Hi everyone,

I'm a mum to one DD 26 months. Recently I've been having so many comments about having another baby and am so fed up of it! I have posted previously about being on the depo and not having any cycles since coming off it. It's been such a source of stress for me as I was really hoping to TTC immediately. I've finally had my first period and am on CD6 and so hopeful that I will ovulate this month but obviously it could be a long time for us yet.

But I've been getting so many comments from people recently, my FiL made comments just last week 'are you having any more kids then? You're leaving it a long time', just today a woman who works with DH and has never met me has commented on a photo I posted of us saying 'it's time for baby no 2 now don't you think?' And to top it off, a group of women I work with have made similar comments telling me 'you should have another one now, you don't want too big of an age gap!'

For reference, I'm 27 so no rush due to age. I'm so fed up of these comments, they're really getting me down at a time when I'm senstive about the topic and very aware that my body isn't working as it should. I would love another and am praying it will happen soon for us but don't feel like I should explain this to these people, I feel like telling them we want another asap will just encourage these comments and increase the pressure on me.

I am aware that I may be oversensitive on this topic due to my current situation!

AIBU to be fed up of these comments and ask what on earth you say to them?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hopefulmamaofone · 26/07/2021 07:52

I'm absolutely astounded at somw of your experiences, why are people so insensitive?!
I'm so sorry to those of you who've had such awful experiences, it seems as though I'm actually getting off pretty lightly!

Will definitely be questioning people's interest in my sex life from now on 😂

Also thank you so much for the good wishes with TTC, fingers crossed it happens soon before I lose my shit with the next person who asks about baby #2!

OP posts:
Arsebucket · 25/07/2021 20:55

I had an eleven year gap between my first two.

11 years of being asked when I was going to have another.

It got right up my arse.

7wondersofthewold · 25/07/2021 20:50

'Are you offering to help us?'

'I wish it was as easy as you seem to think it is.'

Mumtotwofurbabies · 25/07/2021 20:44

I am now pregnant with our second after 2 miscarriages. A family acquaintance (BIL new girlfriend) is child free by choice (which is fine!) and constantly moaning about how many people ask when she’s going to have children, posting passive aggressive Facebook posts about people asking when she’s going to have kids etc. For the record I’ve been to big family events with her and have never, ever heard anyone ask her why she doesn’t want kids, or comment on it at all 🤷‍♀️. Anyway, imagine my shock when she asks me several times about my plans for another child, before I was pregnant, even saying that my PIL have bought a new large house ‘for grandchildren’. I was in the TWW after trying again after my second miscarriage and she gets me on my own and proceeds to lecture me about how I need to hurry up and have another child due to my age (35) because she apparently sees loads of women in her job at hospital over 35 booked in for terminations for birth defects 😞. I wish I’d said something but was too hurt and was just gobsmacked. She wasn’t aware of the miscarriages but still, you just don’t say that. Very rude particularly as she doesn’t like being on the receiving end. Unless she thinks that as I have a child already I must be fair game?! Was tempted to interrogate her about why she doesn’t want kids at the next family dinner mwahaha...but no, of course I didn’t!

fairgame84 · 25/07/2021 20:39

I've just got married and get it all the time. What people don't realise is that we've been ttc for 8 months.
I always reply with "well we're trying but its not happening". It shuts them up every time. Well for about 10 minutes then they come back with "have you tried xyz".

SemiFeralDalek · 25/07/2021 20:35

If they're a pleasant person and I know they don't mean anything by it I usually say "we'd love another but we have had a lot of loss"

If they've pissed me off ill say something like "my second son died at birth and I've had two miscarriages since" and then just wait for the look of horror on their face.

RavenclawsRoar · 25/07/2021 20:26

I can top this. I'm currently pregnant with my THIRD dc and have already twice been asked when I'm having my fourth! Both people looked quite perplexed when I said we were stopping at three Grin Some people are weird. Ignore!

AlfieandAnnieRose · 25/07/2021 20:23

I have one child and weirdly I never get asked if I’m having another! I can understand how frustrating it would be though

RainbowMumzy · 25/07/2021 20:19

I had this. I wanted to make them squirm. I looked them straight in the eye and say "if they didn't keep dying inside me we'd have another one already" and hold eye contact for as long as it took for them to look away. I'm sure they'd think twice about asking other people and I'm sure word soon spread within our circle to not ask me that question as it soon stopped 😊

LadyCatStark · 25/07/2021 20:10

@MrsApplepants

I have an only child by choice. People finally stopped asking when we were having another when she was about 8. It was so annoying and intrusive as it’s no one’s business but yours, sympathies.
Lucky you 😂 I’m the same and I still get it and DS is now 12!! We’ve recently got a puppy so I tell them he’s instead of a baby and that shuts them up 🙄.
Odile13 · 25/07/2021 20:08

Yanbu. It is a sensitive topic but I think some people are a bit sheltered from what others go through and they don’t realise it.

To be honest people have said the same thing to me and I just don’t let it bother me. I had three miscarriages before my baby was born and I am just so happy to have one baby. When someone says “are you going to have another one?” I just say “I don’t know yet”. Occasionally if I feel close to the person I will mention about the miscarriages and then they usually say something apologetic and back off.

Good luck OP, I hope you have success in ttc.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 25/07/2021 19:59

Urggghhh, I remember this so well. I was only able to have one and I really hated having to explain to nosey feckers why.

I'm really glad I'm too old now and people don't ask any more .

Maray1967 · 25/07/2021 19:56

Respond firmly and directly if you can - practice some phrases. Make them so embarrassed that they will not do it to anyone else. One who asked me got ‘ I don’t know , you tell me.’

WeatherwaxOn · 25/07/2021 19:47

I would respond with 'Well, that's an insensitive question, isn't it?". I have one DC. Had a rather difficult birth - DC's heart rate plummeted, emergency CS and I lost a lot of blood. One woman I see locally used to ask me pretty much weekly when I was going to have another. I eventually shut her up by saying that I nearly died during DC's birth and didn't think it was fair to have another child and risk leaving them without a mother.

MiloAndEddie · 25/07/2021 19:24

‘When you fuck off’ works if they are particularly persistent Grin

sayanythingelse · 25/07/2021 19:18

People think it's just small talk, especially the older generation. I would never ask the question as I realise that women have careers/fertility issues/traumatic births/only want one child etc. Also it's none of my business.

I just tend to say "well it took us 6 years and fertility investigations to conceive DD, so I'm not sure we'll be having one soon". Sometimes I pepper in a bit of "it was very stressful and I'm not ready to go through that again". People don't tend to keep questioning you after that.

I'm actually pregnant again though Grin

PumpkinPie2016 · 25/07/2021 19:00

I have an only child by choice and used to get asked when I was having another a lot.

A big part of the reason we stuck at one is because I had a very traumatic birth and was really affected by it.

Eventually, I started telling people that I couldn't have any more. That usually shut them up and made them feel really embarrassed. My reasons for being unable to have more may be mostly psychological rather than physical but they are still valid reasons.

The good news is, people do stop asking eventually. DS is 7 now and I haven't been asked for a while.

ZeldaPrincessOfHyrule · 25/07/2021 18:58

I always wonder who it is that still asks this question, and other similar questions, because I've never ever spoken to a real life woman who likes being asked. EVERYONE seems to find it rude, because it is.

A man I didn't even know (one of my sister's work colleagues), upon meeting me and my baby of 9 days old, said, "when's the next one coming then?" with added wink and nudge. I said the first time round was so traumatic I wasn't ever having another thanks. I wish I'd also referred graphically to my horrible birth injuries, the blood transfusion, and the haematoma that almost resulted in yet more surgery. All of which I went through largely alone due to the swine flu thing stopping visitors except birth partners. At the time I was young, timid and traumatised, but nowadays I'd have no problems verbally ripping him a new one for even asking. It's rude. It'll never not be rude.

KillerFlamingo · 25/07/2021 18:58

I'm still coming to terms with only being able to have the one child. I know I'm very lucky to have one and try hard to be happy with this but it bloody hurts when people go on about it. Especially the "You need a little brother or sister, don't you DS?" comments to my bloody child! Angry

RoseAndGeranium · 25/07/2021 18:54

I was asked this by my uncle whilst having my second miscarriage in a row. People should just stop with the questions. It’s not as though infertility and miscarriage are super rare so there’s no reason for people not to be aware of those possibilities and show a bit of sensitivity — quite apart from the fact that it’s not their bloody business anyway. So YANBU!
On that occasion I didn’t say anything — we rarely see my uncle and I didn’t see any mileage in making everyone uncomfortable — but on similar occasions I’ve been very direct. I just say, very deadpan, ‘you really can’t ask personal questions like that’, and then, after an awkward pause, I change the subject. One particularly awful friend of DH chirping replied ‘yes I can’, so I sighed heavily and said ‘fine, ask away, but I don’t have to give you an answer’ and then turned away and started talking to someone else. He seems slightly frightened of me now, which is absolutely fine by me.

GrandTheftWalrus · 25/07/2021 18:54

OP 26 months isn't too bad, it's when people put random ones like 37.5 months and I need to work it out.

And yes it was me that said it in the first place.

MashaPotato · 25/07/2021 18:52

I completely sympathise OP, I’m in a very similar boat. We’ve been trying for a year now for our second child, and comments really get me down. I’m very aware the age gap is getting bigger, I don’t need people pointing this out! We’re doing everything we can but it’s just not happening sadly.
I started off by laughing off the comments, but now I just say “we’re not having much luck unfortunately” and that soon shuts them up. In fact they often look guilty for asking. It’s just so insensitive though! I have so many friends going through fertility problems, I wouldn’t dare ask people these sorts of questions because you just never know what they’re going through.
Good luck to you OP xx

hopefulmamaofone · 25/07/2021 18:41

Thank you so much for all of your responses! I truly appreciate you all taking the time to help ☺️

Thank you for making me laugh! I definitely have some more creative responses to give now and I look forward to making them all feel so awkward.

I'm so sorry to hear of those of you who suffered losses, I can't imagine having to deal with these dimwits at a time like that! It's the reason I've never even considered questioning anyone on their reproductive choices!! My mum could never have another after me due to being so so ill, she was told she was unlikely to survive another pregnancy, thankfully due to her being late 30s having me, most people didn't comment.

People can be so frustrating. Also sorry for the 26 month comment, I humbly correct myself to I have a DD aged 2 🤣🤣

OP posts:
Waspsarearseholes · 25/07/2021 18:35

It's incredible how people really appear to believe that a couple's family planning is public business. I'm one and done by choice and had no trouble conceiving so I can only imagine the pain and desperation felt by those who long for a/nother child and it really fucks me off that people still believe it's an appropriate topic to flippantly comment upon! I think the only way you can deal with it is to have a stock phrase that you respond with every time. Something scathing/designed to make them feel uncomfortable if possible but I think just prepare yourself with a comeback and you hopefully won't be caught out by surprise. I get this nonsense all the time but I can laugh it off as I am not desperate for another but if I were I know I would be very upset by these stupid comments from randoms.

TiredMummyZZZ · 25/07/2021 18:32

When people ask me I say why do you ask, are you volunteering as a surrogate?