Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you do if you'd identified someone you know on here (MN)?

108 replies

Samosamo · 25/07/2021 15:50

Would you avoid reading their posts, especially if they are personal?

Or would you read on with gluttony?!

OP posts:
pleasedonttextmyman · 25/07/2021 22:23

cross post Grin

if someone doesn't recognise the baby, they'll recognise the ring!

pleasedonttextmyman · 25/07/2021 22:21

I am guessing a couple of people are likely to recognise the poster who shared her story of giving birth at a bus stop this morning.

BlueSurfer · 25/07/2021 22:11

How ironic that someone has just posted her birth story today and I can’t believe it happened to two people, so that’s someone I know in real life.

SmileyClare · 25/07/2021 22:03

I find that really sad Miraclemagic You sound like a caring sister. It's a difficult situation isn't it? You're probably wishing your sister would name change Sad

RaindropsOnRosie · 25/07/2021 21:59

I didn't tell her but I read her posts which were all complete BS. She'd used her first and last name so it was definitely her -think JaneMadeAnAccount- her real name being Jane Made.

She first posted about a colleague issue which I knew was real, then posted about her husband dying in a fire and her 2 children being killed in a car crash and struggling through miscarriages . She has a wife, no children and no losses.

Purplealienpuke · 25/07/2021 21:59

It hasn't happened on here but in real life. I met with a friend, who was with someone I didn't know. This person was slating their relative, quite personal stuff.
It became apparent I knew the person they were slating in a professional capacity. I did stop them and tell them why. I didn't tell the person they were slating.
Very awkward.

Miraclemagic · 25/07/2021 21:31

I identified my sister on here. I told her, to give her chance to change names, she told me that she doesn't post anything secret on here anyway.

I'm ashamed to say (I have even name changed for this post as I'm so ashamed), I have read all her posts and they make me really sad. I assume that she forgot I told her I'd identified her as she has slagged me and our other sister off a bit, especially over the pandemic. She's also said a few horrible things about our mum. Whilst nothing she said is particularly untrue, it appears that she thinks we don't like her very much. This is completely untrue, we all adore her, (and she comes across on here as lovely to) but MN Sister has always been much more socially awkward than the rest of us, so it's clearly manifested into something it's not.

Weirdly, I don't mind her slagging us off, (I assume she was venting) I just wish there was something I could do to assure her she's loved. But sadly, phone calls are rarely answered, text messages tend to be, and we have a text conversation around once every 2/3 months, but it's never initiated by her. I now tend to read her posts to make sure she's ok, which she seems to be despite having gone through a really tough year. I'd love to be able to be there for her in real life, but she keeps us at arms length and I have no idea why.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/07/2021 21:26

marmitemarinaded No relative wasn’t on mumsnet. OP was someone slagging relative off for a parenting decision and her kids unusual made up names were mentioned. Lots of people responding criticised the names.

hellcatspangle · 25/07/2021 21:25

I would absolutely search their posts 😂 but anyone I've mentioned MN to doesn't seem familiar with it so I doubt I'll ever find anyone I know.

InFiveMins · 25/07/2021 21:11

Oh I'd read every single one I could find Grin

pleasedonttextmyman · 25/07/2021 21:00

@SmileyClare

I'm always a bit amused when some threads get deleted by MNHQ because the Op has expressed fears they are outing. Usually they haven't really given anything identifying away Confused
these only mean that the majority disagree with the OP, it has nothing to do with being identified in real life Grin

Apart from a handful about a specific legal issue with neighbours, where the OP themselves apologies before reporting..

PercyPiginaWig · 25/07/2021 20:59

I've spotted 2 friends on here, one had a nice username and I thought that sounds so similar to my friend's situation, then I happened to read another very specific thread and a few of the details meant I realised a) that it was her and b) that she'd put so much detail that anyone else who knew her would know it was her, she's a very intelligent woman so I think she was posting to raise awareness of some issues and maybe using a specific username for that.

Another friend I recognised due to a very specific sad event and turn of phrase she used when talking to me and then on here. I hod the thread, I was already supporting her IRL for what happened so it felt intrusive to read on.

I may have been recognised but don't post anything horrible (I think anyway!).
I have a health condition and I post about that under a specific username, a few times I have forgotten to name change abd then asked MNHQ Blush

wordsareveryunnecessary · 25/07/2021 20:57

Nothing. This is a discussion forum so I would respect that

SmileyClare · 25/07/2021 20:43

I'm always a bit amused when some threads get deleted by MNHQ because the Op has expressed fears they are outing.
Usually they haven't really given anything identifying away Confused

cookiecreampie · 25/07/2021 20:41

I'd still read them, wouldn't say anything.

SmileyClare · 25/07/2021 20:41

Fair enough Annacondom I must admit that's pretty unique.

I think if you did advance search a poster it'd probably be quite boring reading. Not many posters are divulging salacious secrets about their personal lives are they? I suppose you might be shocked if they held very controversial views on a subject. However, if you knew them, you'd probably be aware of those anyway.

pleasedonttextmyman · 25/07/2021 20:39

Mumsnet has an average 1.3 billion page views and millions of users. For that reason, I think it's very unlikely to spot your friend on here.

it's the timing more than anything.
If you post about a special incident at work or school, or a sporting event, people who are involved in that incident that morning will recognise it, or wonder if it's their event that is mentioned. If you search and get more details from the poster's history, then you can recognise someone.

Millions or not, if you post about an accurate event, you will have neighbours and friends in real life.

Lerram · 25/07/2021 20:38

Someone had posted a thread of the Baby Names thread, asking opinions on an unusual name. One poster replied "That's my son's name! We named him Unusual name James, so that he could use James if he didn't like Unusual Name."

I knew someone whose son's name was Unusual name James, so I did an AS. She had posted several times about a specific breed of dog, which was the breed of her dog, so I knew it was her.

I didn't tell her, but neither did I read her posts after that. Her MN posts were warm, friendly and helpful, which is exactly what she's like in RL.

TheGoogleMum · 25/07/2021 20:36

I'd probably ask them! I don't think I'd bother to search through their post history unless I was feeling very nosy.

annacondom · 25/07/2021 20:33

@SmileyClare

Mumsnet has an average 1.3 billion page views and millions of users. For that reason, I think it's very unlikely to spot your friend on here.

Unless the poster give their name and address, I can't think of any situation in a thread that would be unique to one person?

Smileyclare, I identified someone on here because of a girl my DD knows who was going to be in the Olympics. She had been training at her grandma's house in [EU country] and the gran posted about it on here! Secondly, an old friend contacted me after she recognised something I'd written. So, there you go. Two instances.
pleasedonttextmyman · 25/07/2021 20:29

it's one of the reasons why I name-change all the time.

One person I recognised from a group - say school parents, could have been 1 among 100, but reading through their previous posts made it clear who exactly it was.

Your hobby, plus the breed of your dog.. it really can be just enough.

Sparechange · 25/07/2021 20:26

I’ve found 2, because they both posted the exact same things on here and Facebook

One them was a really boring tax question, the other was a CF story, which I knew from another friend was completely true

But the CF story poster got accused of trolling, making it all up
I really wanted to defend her but couldn’t without outing myself

I had a quick skim through their previous posts, mostly to verify it was them, then promptly forgot their usernames

Don’t think I’d recognise the posters names again if I saw them, so haven’t said anything to either of them

bogoffmda · 25/07/2021 20:24

Yep picked the OW and DCS first SM - spouting shite about me!
Never said anything but used to say to EX - Look I know you think xxx about me and my decisions.

The look on his face was priceless - I knew I had hit the spot! Sadly that turned into a I had broken into their e mails, had put microphones in their new house which I was not allowed to know where it was, put trackers on their cars!!!

It made me realise what a delusional beatch she was, also made me realise how the SM forum believes some ridiculous stuff and the EX /BM is always blamed for everything. Example, it was my fault that they could not afford to my 2 DCS on holiday with her 2DCs because I took them on holiday. What she failed to admit, 4 of them were going business class to Barbados and 6 was too expensive but 6 could have gone economy for less monies - or as my eldest said at the time we could have all gone to Spain /Devon/Wales!

Annietheacrobat · 25/07/2021 20:22

I told them and they completely denied it, and then wrote a couple of ludicrous posts to throw me off the scent.

AngelDelightUk · 25/07/2021 20:21

It would honestly depend on who it was, and how juicy the topic was tbh too Grin