Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bill Splitter

163 replies

Queynte13 · 25/07/2021 12:28

AIBU to think that the person who suggests splitting a bill evenly is usually the person who benefits from it the most?

Went out for a meal last night. I was driving so I wasn't drinking. I've not been very well lately, which means I'm struggling to eat large amounts so I just had a starter and a side dish. Genuinely not a budgetary issue, I didn't even finish all my food.

The others at the table were drinking bottles of Prosecco and pints.

The bill comes and someone says "that's £30 each". Mine came to £10! This person was drinking and I noticed their portion of the bill was the highest out of everyone (others refused to split evenly in the end).

The worst bit was that everyone scarpered and the waitress returned to the table and told me the bill was short!

OP posts:
VanGoSunflowers · 25/07/2021 16:46

@TheLovleyChebbyMcGee

Depends on thd friends! I have friends and we gently argue over splitting the bill in order to not underpay!!

So they'll point out they had an extra beer, but then I'll point out we had an extra side, but they had a more expensive main, but we had an extra pint of soft drink. Its a much nicer way if arguing over a bill. Once we did splint every penny equally and it was about 40p difference so I we usually split it.

We do have friends we don't split with mind as we've been stung before by them!

My friends are mainly like this. I usually only suggest to split the bill if I know my friend isn’t as well off as me so I pay more. Which makes me sound like an utter tosser but some of them have suffered financially during lockdown whereas I haven’t.
VanGoSunflowers · 25/07/2021 16:44

@OnTheBoardwalk

I'm liking the app ordering we are doing now on the back of the Covid restrictions. Makes it so much easier to pay for your own food and drink

I always split equally unless I have a steak or something and I’ll put a few quid in extra although it tends to get given back to me so gets added to the tip

I did have dinner a few times with a couple I’d known for years. Bill (him again) came and I was asked for x amount. I thought bloody hell that’s expensive. 2nd time I thought the same again

On the 3rd time (over many months) I asked to see the bill. Turns out for them 2 and me they were charging me 50% of the total. They really couldn’t see this was wrong. I had a chat with them 🤣

Cheeky fuckers Shock
TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 25/07/2021 16:44

Depends on thd friends! I have friends and we gently argue over splitting the bill in order to not underpay!!

So they'll point out they had an extra beer, but then I'll point out we had an extra side, but they had a more expensive main, but we had an extra pint of soft drink. Its a much nicer way if arguing over a bill. Once we did splint every penny equally and it was about 40p difference so I we usually split it.

We do have friends we don't split with mind as we've been stung before by them!

Nohomemadecandles · 25/07/2021 16:35

@FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop why should someone order cheaper because they're out in a group? If they're happy to pay they can order 3 bottles of champagne. What an odd idea

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 25/07/2021 16:31

@Sparklingbrook

Why are you all sitting there with calculators

Well it's phones in my case but because it's quicker for 12 people to add up their bill than one server to add up 12 bills. Speed mainly.

Yes I agree, I wonder what is wrong with people who are baffled by the mechanics of calculating bills. You pass the Bill down the table or you have a the person who is beat at maths to say "Sandra owes £13, Steve owes £22" etc
FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 25/07/2021 16:28

@KatherineJaneway

If you only want to pay for your own dishes, you need to say this at the beginning of the meal in my experience. That way no one gets upset or pissed off or thinks you'll pay for their steak and champagne while you have salad and water.
Sorry but the onus is on the champagne and steak consumers to not be dicks and get a cheaper meal.
Winemewhynot · 25/07/2021 16:27

@Queynte13 I think being sober would spur me on to say’ sorry but no, I’ve not been drinking, I’ll just pay for what I’ve had thanks’

I get it being awkward with it being someone you don’t know but I wouldn’t let a stranger take advantage of me.

Stormyseasallround · 25/07/2021 16:22

@MeadowLines

Why are you all sitting there with calculators? When you ask for the bill or go up to pay, you ask to pay individually. You may have to tell them what you've had, but then the server tells you how much you owe. I dont understand all this clutching pearls and overpaying. I am generally the less well off person, or one of then, and I dont want people subsidising my meal or paying for it all because they dont have the patience to wait an extra minute for a individual bill. You may be able to afford it, but I am not a charity case that needs an affluent friend to pay and cover up any awkwardness they create because Im not willing to pay for some of their meal!!
Again, that’s they dynamics of your friendship group not mine. None of us would see the kindness of a friend as awkward or a charity case. I’ve been the poor one, especially when my children were small and I was on yet another maternity leave, and my friends often treated me to lunch or dinner. Now that I have spare money again, I’ll happily pay for theirs. But then we’ve paid for each other to go on holiday before, and would happily do so again. We see money as something lovely to be able to spread around. 🤷🏼‍♀️
OnTheBoardwalk · 25/07/2021 16:21

I'm liking the app ordering we are doing now on the back of the Covid restrictions. Makes it so much easier to pay for your own food and drink

I always split equally unless I have a steak or something and I’ll put a few quid in extra although it tends to get given back to me so gets added to the tip

I did have dinner a few times with a couple I’d known for years. Bill (him again) came and I was asked for x amount. I thought bloody hell that’s expensive. 2nd time I thought the same again

On the 3rd time (over many months) I asked to see the bill. Turns out for them 2 and me they were charging me 50% of the total. They really couldn’t see this was wrong. I had a chat with them 🤣

Rtmhwales · 25/07/2021 16:20

I've always found this strange when I was living in the UK TBH.

I'm from Canada. The bill comes to the table already pre divided per person with a cumulative total at the end. So there may be 6 small bills numbered throughout with what each has and then the grand total should someone be treating the group. Or you can easily work it out by couple. No awkwardness. When they type it in the system they just type it under Person 1, Person 2 etc. No extra work.

Seems fairer in my opinion?

Tigerstripe20 · 25/07/2021 16:13

Yep, got stung like this a few years ago one of our table was drinking wine like water had one of the most expensive steaks on the menu and then said let's split the bill...I spoke up and said its ok we can pay for our own ,one lady who I never met before was pg and only spent £7:50 .
I ended up bending to pressure and forked out the £15 extra, and was made to feel like crap the rest of the night...never seen them since despite texts of 'we must get together again" bugger that !

HelloDulling · 25/07/2021 16:10

So many times I have been for a meal where there has been shared bread/wine/olives or whatever, and the same couple every time conveniently forget they had any of that, or just add on £2 for two glasses of wine when the bottle was £20. Then we’re short at the end and everyone has put in another couple of pounds. I hate it, the going over the bill down to the last penny spoils the meal for me.

Queynte13 · 25/07/2021 16:08

@Winemewhynot

I’m happy to pay individual or split, but money isn’t an issue. What I hate is when people agree to split and then quietly seethe and come ranting on here about it, if you’re happy use you’re mouth and speak up! Stop being such a passive Polly!
When I've seen similar threads, I've always thought I'd speak up. I'm not passive usually. But when you're in the situation, completely sober, and a stranger is telling you you owe £30, it's not that easy to say no. I didn't want to cause a fuss on my friends night, in front of her friends and family.
OP posts:
Anonymous48 · 25/07/2021 16:07

Whenever I go out with friends we always get separate bills. That's so much easier than splitting the full bill or trying to work out who ordered what. I'm in the US - I don't know if giving everyone in a group their own bill is more common here.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 25/07/2021 16:04

@KatherineJaneway

If you only want to pay for your own dishes, you need to say this at the beginning of the meal in my experience. That way no one gets upset or pissed off or thinks you'll pay for their steak and champagne while you have salad and water.
I've always found found opposite. If you want to split equally its mentioned at the beginning. Otherwise you'll get some ordering steak and some ordering salad.
ChocBeforeCock · 25/07/2021 15:59

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe

ChocbeforeCock, I wasn't intentionally getting at anybody, sorry if it came across that way. Read though MeadowLines' posts at 13.35, it explains the point I was making.

The thing is, we've got no idea of anybody's situations when they post, we all have our own experiences and those are in mind when we respond. I've had the whole gamut from orderers-who-over-order-but-want-to-split-because-they-benefit - and also others who pointedly put in a bit more to subsidise the 'less fortunate' - and everything in between. I'm sure you don't do the 'lady bountiful' routine when you eat out but, others do.

In mainland Europe, separate bills are so commonplace that it's never an issue - nor is it an issue for whole bills to be paid by one person - but in the UK, it seems to be a vexed issue for many. Bill-splitting isn't something that I'd want to do now, it's too fraught with difficulty.

Apologies though if my post was unfair, it really wasn't intended that way although I can see how pointed it was.

Thanks lying, I totally understand what you’re saying and it’s a fair point.
HunterHearstHelmsley · 25/07/2021 15:55

I only ever split with one friend as we have similar tastes and tend to order pretty similarly.

Generally, everyone should pay for what they have had. It always makes me laugh when those who insist on splitting call those they don't tight, miserly etc. They're the ones trying to get someone else to subsidise them!

Doingtheboxerbeat · 25/07/2021 15:53

Threads like this make me think that I was switched at birth because there is no possible way I would let my natural British politeness allow people to mug me off Grin.

Winemewhynot · 25/07/2021 15:40

I’m happy to pay individual or split, but money isn’t an issue. What I hate is when people agree to split and then quietly seethe and come ranting on here about it, if you’re happy use you’re mouth and speak up! Stop being such a passive Polly!

Hankunamatata · 25/07/2021 15:30

I love PayPal. We all pp one person and they pay the bill. So much easier.

roarfeckingroarr · 25/07/2021 15:18

I always split unless I know my part will be higher, when I'll pay the difference. It's polite.

Nohomemadecandles · 25/07/2021 15:02

I usually try and set out my stall early these days. As we sit down. "I'm going to be ordering wine and I'm starving so let's pay for what we have or you'll be out of pocket!"

Unless
a) I'm out with a particular friend and we take turns and I've known her 30 years
b) it's my mum or MIL in which case we fight over who gets the card machine first
c) I'm driving.

Over paying bothers me less than people thinking I'm a CF!!

Tealpink · 25/07/2021 15:01

If I know I’ve ordered more alcohol than others I always refuse to split evenly and pay a greater share. But the offer is always rejected by those I’m dining with. So I make sure I cover the tip instead

Bollindger · 25/07/2021 14:54

She thought it was a table bill. Non of us are poor, we have always just paid our own way. We always paid for our rounds of drinks as we ordered, as knew it was unfair on those who had children.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 25/07/2021 14:40

@Bollindger

I always say before I even sit down, that I don't drink so want my own bill. Friends are fine with this. We also have a large family , think 25 including children , everyone went to the bar and paid their meals and food as they ordered, my SIL opened a tab. We got to the end of the meal and she goes on shall we split the bill by 6 as there are 6 families we all smiled and said no. Your bill is just your drinks, she was livid as she had been getting nice wine and cocktails. Her bill was £100 ours was £25.
Im shocked someone suggested splitting her own tab. Ridiculous! 😂😂