Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bill Splitter

163 replies

Queynte13 · 25/07/2021 12:28

AIBU to think that the person who suggests splitting a bill evenly is usually the person who benefits from it the most?

Went out for a meal last night. I was driving so I wasn't drinking. I've not been very well lately, which means I'm struggling to eat large amounts so I just had a starter and a side dish. Genuinely not a budgetary issue, I didn't even finish all my food.

The others at the table were drinking bottles of Prosecco and pints.

The bill comes and someone says "that's £30 each". Mine came to £10! This person was drinking and I noticed their portion of the bill was the highest out of everyone (others refused to split evenly in the end).

The worst bit was that everyone scarpered and the waitress returned to the table and told me the bill was short!

OP posts:
Brefugee · 26/07/2021 08:29

Shared bottles of wine are easy - if you only drink one, one person pays, the other slios them à tenner or whatever.

Here (Germany) you don't get charged for what you don't order - basket of bread brought automatically? No charge. Subsequent baskets of bread? Treat like the wine. (although I can't ever remember being charged for extra bread unless it's garlic bread or something.

And if you've been out with friends what's all this rushing away before the bill is settled potentially leaving someone to make up the shortfall? Do people really do that? I'm an ancient old crone and I've never experienced that.

burnoutbabe · 26/07/2021 08:23

It's often not easy to split any bill.

Shared bottles of wine. Or a bread service at the start. Or people sharing starters. Plus the service charge.

It's often really not possible to just go to the till and say " I had this 3 items" in a clean way. Unless you all plan from the start that you would all be doing separate bills and ensure no "complicated" items.

So doing a rough split with adjustments for non drinkers is easiest. Make sure you all eat about the same for ease if splitting is your group normal.

Guavafish · 26/07/2021 08:21

You should have said I’ll split the food but I won’t pay for the alcohol as I’m not drinking.

I think it’s unfair they suggested splitting the bill especially if you were not drinking alcohol. My friends won’t do that to me.

Aprilx · 26/07/2021 08:20

To the original question, no In my experience the person that suggests splitting the bill has not done so because they will personally benefit. I cannot imagine any of my friends being so cunning or greedy, do people really have friends like that? In my groups of friends the bill has nearly always been split and there has never been issues over that.

KiwiDramaQueen · 26/07/2021 08:14

What I’m saying is, assuming you’re decent people, it’s perfectly possible to adopt a general split approach that makes a few adjustments to be fair without having to itemise and add up everything ordered.

mafted · 26/07/2021 08:14

I've never really gone out where it's been an issue, I guess I pick friends who eat and drink the same as me!
The big group meals I've been on are usually set price type things, bottomless brunches or themed nights where everyone pays the same.

KiwiDramaQueen · 26/07/2021 08:12

@BarbaraofSeville

I can only assume that you read only a few selective parts of my post because you seem to have missed the bits where I said:

“However you do have to be fair, booze should be split between the drinkers only and you should notice if someone has had significantly less for other reasons and alter the split accordingly…

That said, I don’t have any friends who take the piss and maybe I’d feel differently if I did.”

If you’ve got arsehole friends and colleagues who are ordering lobster and fine wine when you’re having a salad and Diet Coke, then yes perhaps you do need to count every penny at the end.

Plus isn’t this all part of the adult conversation you have with friends when you choose a place to dine? Eg “hey guys I’m on a budget tonight let’s just do somewhere cheap and cheerful.”

Henlie · 26/07/2021 08:10

I don’t know why the UK hasn’t adopted the system of separate bills as standard for a group, the way they’ve done for years in the USA and Canada - and judging by another poster Germany too. I’m guessing it’s a special function on the till that breaks up the table into smaller sub groups and produces multi bills at the end for all. Surely it must be easy to do?

meido · 26/07/2021 08:08

Mind you, it can go wrong the opposite way, too. More recently I went out for dinner, as a group of five. We all agreed to pay for what we had rather than splitting. The problem is that two of us left earlier… so they went to the till and paid for what they had.

Except, of course, they didn’t! They hadn’t thought to pay their proportion of the breads, sides, coffees etc. Plus no tip. So the rest of us had to cover it.

meido · 26/07/2021 08:05

Yes, I know a couple like this. Last time we all went out, there were seven of us. The couple ordered really expensive champagne - fine! They also ordered steak and scallops - fine!

I was a student so didn’t have a starter, had the veggie dish, etc.

Time came and they split the bill. They’re one of those couples who you don’t really argue with so I meekly paid up.

Sting in the tail is that they’re broth on £100k+!

Pottedpalm · 26/07/2021 08:01

@KatherineJaneway

I'm from Canada. The bill comes to the table already pre divided per person with a cumulative total at the end. So there may be 6 small bills numbered throughout with what each has and then the grand total should someone be treating the group.

That doesn't happen in the UK. The bill comes for the whole table, most often including the service charge, and is presented to the person who asks for the bill. It is up to you to split the bill then and tell the server as they go round the table who owes what.

Not always; recent meal we went to the till and told the waitress what we had each had and paid separately. Was very quick. At the end she found one coffee unaccounted for (mine, oops), so I paid that. A couple of us were driving/don’t drink so no one expected equal sharing of the bill.
LemonRoses · 26/07/2021 07:59

@Sparklingbrook

Never encountered any ‘head girl’ types thankfully. Work colleagues and friends all totally normal in that regard.
Gosh, I don’t think I’ve ever been out for a non-shared bill meal where some bossy /organised woman (it’s always a woman) grabs the bill and starts dividing it up and allocating payments.

Luckily our friends are not generally like that, but it’s truly cringeworthy.

BarbaraofSeville · 26/07/2021 07:50

In my mind a meal shared is not just about feeding yourself and paying for what you’ve consumed, it’s an experience shared and you share the cost of that experience. As someone else has said already, if it’s people you see regularly then it all comes out in the wash

It doesn't all come out in the wash because the people who don't drink don't tend to suddenly ordering cocktails and the vegetarians or people with small appetites don't suddenly start ordering steak, lobster and starters and mains too.

What you also have to remember is that many people who get fucked over by the 'lets just split it' system is those who can afford to go out but only if they have a cheap main course and one drink, so that's what they have.

So it's even more galling and unfair to them if they end up paying for 3 courses and a bottle of wine when they limited themselves to a pizza and a coke because that's what they could afford. And no, they shouldn't have to miss out because others want to consume more than they do.

Sparklingbrook · 26/07/2021 07:47

Never encountered any ‘head girl’ types thankfully. Work colleagues and friends all totally normal in that regard.

Luxembourgmama · 26/07/2021 07:46

The Germans invented the answer to this. Everytime they ask you if you want to split the bill and they calculate everyones personal bill. Its genius.

LemonRoses · 26/07/2021 07:35

@Sparklingbrook

There’s absolutely no excuse for writing on napkins. Especially nice linen ones. Everyone works out their total on their phone and swipes their card for that amount.
Invariably there is a shortfall that head girl types try to resolve. Just tedious outside of work setting or youthfulness.
Sparklingbrook · 26/07/2021 07:18

There’s absolutely no excuse for writing on napkins. Especially nice linen ones.
Everyone works out their total on their phone and swipes their card for that amount.

LemonRoses · 26/07/2021 07:11

If it’s for work and we have to reclaim, we ask for separate bills at the outset. It’s not a problem.
Socially, nothing worse than a head girl scrawling on napkins, collecting up odd amounts, seeing if it’s enough to cover etc. It’s somewhat tiresome, to say the least. I understand if it’s students, but we’d usually just have senior male from each family/couple settle up.
Alternatively, if it’s a couple we often go out with, we just take it in turns to pay - it probably balances over time.

NB by senior I mean the oldest male who isn’t elderly and who has highest disposable income. Not someone who makes all decisions or is deferred to.

KiwiDramaQueen · 26/07/2021 07:00

I hate ending a lovely meal with friends only to have to spend the end of it itemising every item consumed. It feels like such a tedious administrative way to end a nice evening and the number of times I’ve done it only for us to find there’s only a few pounds difference.

However you do have to be fair, booze should be split between the drinkers only and you should notice if someone has had significantly less for other reasons and alter the split accordingly.

In my mind a meal shared is not just about feeding yourself and paying for what you’ve consumed, it’s an experience shared and you share the cost of that experience. As someone else has said already, if it’s people you see regularly then it all comes out in the wash.

That said, I don’t have any friends who take the piss and maybe I’d feel differently if I did.

HungryHippo11 · 26/07/2021 06:58

@blobblob

Sometimes though - and this is partly just a devil's advocate point - if youwere to go to a restaurant and order a galss of water and a starter they wouldn't serve you. No restaurant can survive on that. They'll only allow Ms Tap Water and Salad for dinner because the other eight people at the table have spent £40 a head. (Like people who go to dinner with others and bring a bottle of "what I'm drinking" - eg water - and think that's fair while they happily tuck into a prawn starter, steak main and chocolate pudding!!)
No I don't think you're correct about this. Very few restaurants will refuse to serve someone, the bad publicity from that would probably cost them more money than serving the very occasional customer who only has a small meal.

Plus, when you order a tap water and a starter they don't know that's all you're planning to order.

BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 26/07/2021 06:53

@OhNoNoNoNoNo

Why is asking to only pay for the food and drink you had being 'that person' I'd have just said 'I didn't drink so I'm going to just pay for what I had'. You would have to be a weird person to find anything objectionable about that.
I feel like this. I mean, i go to Sainsbury’s with my mum and we share a shopping trolley. Sometimes I buy three items and she fills the thing, sometimes it’s the other way round. We never ‘split the bill’

Because..That Would Be Ridiculous 😂

HungryHippo11 · 26/07/2021 06:33

@fabulousathome

There must be an app to help groups split bills?

You'd all need to have it though. Put your own stuff in and it would work it out.

Yes its called the "calculator"
Cookofcastamar · 26/07/2021 06:25

@Gertie75

Am I the only person who opened the thread to find out who Bill Splitter is?
@Gertie75 me too! I wanted to read about Bill Splitter 😂
KatherineJaneway · 26/07/2021 06:15

I'm from Canada. The bill comes to the table already pre divided per person with a cumulative total at the end. So there may be 6 small bills numbered throughout with what each has and then the grand total should someone be treating the group.

That doesn't happen in the UK. The bill comes for the whole table, most often including the service charge, and is presented to the person who asks for the bill. It is up to you to split the bill then and tell the server as they go round the table who owes what.

VienneseWhirligig · 25/07/2021 20:24

I always feel uncomfortable splitting the bill because I often have something more expensive (like steak or a cocktail) because I can afford it, but others may have a veggie meal which is cheaper, so I hate the thought that they are paying more than their fair share. I always make that point, and offer to pay for mine separately, hoping everyone else will want to do likewise. It just feels so awkward.