Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my house guest is rather rude?

359 replies

dizzyrabbit · 25/07/2021 09:47

We went for a pub lunch yesterday which I ended up paying for. The bill came and he didn’t even bother to look at it. I paid it with my card expecting him to give me some cash towards it but nothing. Then we ordered a takeaway for dinner which we also ended up paying for. He didn’t even offer to contribute. He’s came a long way to visit but I can’t help but feel like it’s taking the mick. I want to say something but don’t know what. I’m too nice for my own good. Vent over.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 25/07/2021 13:45

@ShadowInVain

Hmm, if he's your guest, it's really for you as the host to provide his meals.
No, not necessarily.
Midlifemusings · 25/07/2021 13:41

I think this is a tricky one. If someone invites me their home as a houseguest, I don't usual budget for needing to pay restaurant / take away costs for all my meals. I would want to know that expectation up front as it would factor into my decision to accept or not accept the invitation depending on my finances at the time.

If I am a guest at someone's house and they decide we are eating out, I don't have much say in that. My experience is that usually when the host plans a meal out, they pay. As a guest I would offer to take them for a meal out or something as a thank you but I generally don't expect to be paying for all my meals. If that was the case, I would shop for groceries and just make meals at the house. I do think it is unusual (based on my own experience) to invite someone for the weekend, host them, but expect them to pay restaurant costs for all their meals.

I also think there is a bit of gender role expectation going on here, where men are expected to foot the bill. I feel that if a woman posted that she had invited a female friend for the weekend and then host and husband planned a dinner out when guest arrived and then husband only planned to pay for himself and wife and is miffed at invited guest friend that she didn't jump to pay for her own food, the responses would be different.

JudgeRindersMinder · 25/07/2021 13:40

@ShadowInVain

Hmm, if he's your guest, it's really for you as the host to provide his meals.
I agree with this. I know it was different times but we used to have a fair few houseguests growing up, and my mum was an amazing hostess, they wouldn’t have thought of eating out or having takeaway
Bettysnow · 25/07/2021 13:38

Sounds exactly as a previous poster said in that he knows full well you feel awkward about it so you will pay and won't mention it. That alone would end the friendship for me as realistically it never was a real friendship if that is how he treats people.
Beans on toast for dinner and let him go on to the cinema alone then let that be the last visit ever.
Hopefully he will learn that his little ploys to hang onto his money now means he has nowhere free to go anymore

Highfivemum · 25/07/2021 13:35

That is so frustrating. As you say it is the offer really.

I have a friend like this. She always promises to get the meal next time but never does. Puts me off seeing her to be honest.

Jaguar77 · 25/07/2021 13:34

Is he a fun guest ?

WombatChocolate · 25/07/2021 13:30

When you host, I think you do expect to provide most of the food. If we have guests for perhaps 3 nights, I would certainly cook for at least 2 of them. Often, people have spent quite a lot of money on the journey and as hosts you have avoided that. If we went out for the day, usually we would each pay our own entrance fees. If it was a whole other famiky, they would probably pay for their lunch and us for ours. If it was just a sole person staying, as we are a family, we would probably pay for them.

So the answer isn’t totally straightforward and can depend on how many people visit and if you as the host are a family or just 1 person.

When visiting to stay overnight, I’d always take a couple of items - wine, chocs, flowers. If I was staying a couple of nights or taking the whole family, I’d take more stuff. I would imagine though that our hosts would give us a meal and breakfasts. However, if they suggested a takeaway or going out to eat, I would at least offer to contribute and if we were there several days, probably to for the bill. In fact, if we were there several days I’d offer to get a takeaway in or take them out for a meal to give them a break as hosting is tiring as well as expensive. If I was just staying 1 night or possibly 2, I wouldn’t necessarily do this.

WombatChocolate · 25/07/2021 13:22

Far better to say something g than silently seethe, moan on mumsnet and be a silent martyr.

Yes to ‘your meal is £12 - do you want to pay card or cash’ or ‘shall we get this meal and you get it tomorrow night’ type thing.

Yes, it would be nice if someone offered at least, but people are odd and have all kinds of different expectation and the only answer is the usual one…..communicate clearly and don’t expect people to be mind readers.

ShortBacknSides · 25/07/2021 13:17

"I do appreciate your taking us to the cinema, in return for staying with us, eating our food. It's nice not to feel taken advantage of. So many don't even think about it!"

This response assumes that the "favour" is one-way only ... that the hosts have no pleasure in their guest's company. THat they are being Lord & Lady Bountiful.

As a host, I do tend to assume I'll pay for everything - I am hosting my guests, after all. And I have the pleasure of their company.

But a "good" guest would also wish to offer a treat to her hosts - a gift, a meal out etc etc etc.

MzHz · 25/07/2021 13:17

Re cinema- do NOTHING about it, no research (in front of him anyway, thanks to good to know what choices are filmwise)
No reservations nothing

He will ask about it, or better yet, ask HIM if he’s booked the tickets yet?

If (when) he says no, you say well given we’ve covered pub lunch and takeaway, he can sort the cinema

Oh and he won’t be coming again…

EishetChayil · 25/07/2021 13:16

Why not just say "let's split this"? I am honestly perplexed as to why this would not be your first course of action.

MrsDoctorDear · 25/07/2021 13:16

You are either a giver or a taker. He is a taker and is quite happy to be one.

Taker = CF.

Fifthtimelucky · 25/07/2021 13:13

Depends, I think.

We only have one sheet of friends that we stay with regularly. When we stay with them, they provide all the food. If they decide we will eat out rather than at home, they pay.

Similarly, when they come to us, I normally expect to provide the food. We tend not to go out but if we did I'd expect to pay.

However, I have just had them for 6 days (4 of us and 3 of them). I paid for the food we ate at home and for various activities. They brought lots of drink with them (they drink a lot more than we do), paid for one meal out, two takeaways and a cream tea.

All parties happy with the arrangement!

Ledgeofglory · 25/07/2021 13:10

Tell him you can’t afford to pay for the cinema and see if he offers to treat you

HollowTalk · 25/07/2021 13:10

Who suggested he came to stay?

Have you ever stayed with him? (I'm betting the answer to that is "No.")

How much would he have spent on travel?

SuperMoonIsKeepingMeUpToo · 25/07/2021 13:09

Your guest has been with you just one night and already you've had one meal out and ax takeaway? Have you only done breakfasts at home then? I would expect to provide the majority of meals for guests so unless he asked to go out / get a takeaway I think YABU.

coodawoodashooda · 25/07/2021 13:00

@Bbtotum

Honestly just don’t have him again. It’s rude.

Had a friend who came to stay with kids a few times. Goes on about how skint she is. On the last visit she let me pay for everything again (outings/ food erc) and didn’t even bring some daffs. Whilst proudly telling me they’d just paid off the mortgage on their 500k house.

I realised as it was as she got idiots like me to pay for everything.

I’ve learnt my lesson (and ditched user friends).

A bottle of wine, thanks etc goes a long way. If staying at friends we take drinks, offer to pay for a takeaway etc as standard and pay our own way into attractions.

Yep. I just got caught out in a similar situation.
AhNowTed · 25/07/2021 12:57

I would arrive with plenty of wine and pay for meals out and takeaways.

Some people really are just pisstakers.

Jux · 25/07/2021 12:51

"How kind taking us all to the cinema; we're really looking forward to it!"
"Have you booked the tickets for tonight, or are you doing it when we get there. We're so excited!"
"I do appreciate your taking us to the cinema, in return for staying with us, eating our food. It's nice not to feel taken advantage of. So many don't even think about it!"

WaterBottle123 · 25/07/2021 12:46

As the host, it's your job to provide meals. Lunch out and a takeaway in a single day is extravagant and if I were your guest I wouldn't be expecting to pay for food twice, I'd expect you to cook at least 1 meal.

I'd never expect a guest to pay for a takeaway. Lunch out, it would be polite if they offered but maybe they can't afford it and were hoping you'd offer up a sandwich at home!

Anyusernameleft · 25/07/2021 12:38

Do as PP suggested, tell him to book online for 2/3 (however many there are) & if he asks you for any money then mention he owes you for last night also. Eat at home before you leave so you don't have to go near the snacks at the cinema. If he suggests eating out say you don't normally eat out (do takeaway) two nights in a row as it adds up & ye are tightening belts for new patio/bathroom/any excuse. It isn't on that he is a skin flint & then takes advantage himself.

Bbtotum · 25/07/2021 12:35

Honestly just don’t have him again. It’s rude.

Had a friend who came to stay with kids a few times. Goes on about how skint she is. On the last visit she let me pay for everything again (outings/ food erc) and didn’t even bring some daffs. Whilst proudly telling me they’d just paid off the mortgage on their 500k house.

I realised as it was as she got idiots like me to pay for everything.

I’ve learnt my lesson (and ditched user friends).

A bottle of wine, thanks etc goes a long way. If staying at friends we take drinks, offer to pay for a takeaway etc as standard and pay our own way into attractions.

PerciphonePuma · 25/07/2021 12:32

@ShadowInVain

Hmm, if he's your guest, it's really for you as the host to provide his meals.
Shock No, it REALLY ISN'T! Hmm

CoughCF ALERTCough

ddl1 · 25/07/2021 12:32

Maybe he's going to surprise you with a gift at the end, or reciprocate by having you to his house with all expenses paid? Otherwise, it's a bit rude- the cinema at any rate ought to be his treat to you.

Howshouldibehave · 25/07/2021 12:29

He’s such a skint flint that he will remind you if you owe him a quid.. whereas I wouldn’t worry about an amount so small. That’s just the way he is which is fine but it should work both ways

If he did that though, and always paid his fair share exactly to the pound, nobody would describe him as a skinflint, they’d say he was always precisely fair when it came to money!

You appear to be fully aware you have a skinflint as a friend but are strangely cross when he does skinflint things!