Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable asking for child maintenance

406 replies

Bri102 · 25/07/2021 09:31

First time writing a post and it's a bit long so apologies.

I fell pregnant with my son during lockdown, bit of a surprise as I was on birth control. The father straight away said I should get an abortion due to the fact he was unplanned, im so grateful everyday I didn't as my son is a beautiful funny little 6 month old now. The dad has never met him and had changed his mind a few times about meeting him but this has come to a head and he now says it's impossible for him to meet my son, due to the fact I have asked for child maintenance, my maternity leave is ending soon and it is going to cost £600 a month for nursery fees alone.

Whilst I was pregnant I reached out to the father's mum to ask if she wanted a relationship with my son, she jumped at the chance and we have been seeing each other frequently since I was pregnant. Shortly after my son was born she said if she was me she would go for child maintenance, as her son should take some sort of responsibility for my son. However, she came to see my son yesterday and told me im morally wrong to ask for any maintenance as her son did not wish for me to continue the pregnancy and it was my decision and mine alone, he did not have any choice in the matter. She said I should not have continued the pregnancy if I could not financially support the baby myself. I can support the baby and my other son but after the nursery fees, we will not have much left for food and everyday needs. She asked me if I would drop the case as her son has given her the ultimatum of him and her other 2 grandchildren or my son and she is going to chose her son the babys dad, and she is prepared to walk out of my sons life. I'm devastated for my son not only will he feel abandoned by his father but now by his family also. My sons father has also never met his dad and recently tried to contact him and his dad didn't want to know him and denied having a son, it has apparently really effected him, but he is willing to do it to his own son which I cannot understand. Don't know if it's worth noting he already has two other children who he sees twice a week and pays child maintenance for to his ex.

I just want to know if I am in the wrong and should just drop the child maintenance and basically walk away from the family before my son is old enough to remember his nan and aunties who are willing to walk away if the dad is adamant on the ultimatum.

Thanks for reading and any advice, sorry it was long.

OP posts:
toocold54 · 25/07/2021 17:18

She's entitled to CMS .. the Law says so ☺️

The face is unnecessary. The child is not a meal ticket for you to get one over on the man.
If OP wants to go for maintenance she should but not just because the ‘law says so’.

BrandNewHeretic · 25/07/2021 17:18

@toocold54 I am one of the women who have actually been in the situation. I got pregnant while having the implant. We broke up before I found out I was pregnant. The father expressed his view that he would rather not have a child, but I could not put myself through having an abortion. I didn't go through CMS to claim maintenance, because DDs father is a decent man who accepted his joint responsibility, and provides for the child he helped to make, both in terms of time and money without me having to chase him for it. Because our child is the consequence of both of us having sex. Not just me. He could have worn a condom, or had a vasectomy, or just not had sex with me knowing that no birth control is 100%. But he did, and in doing so committed himself to whatever consequence came of that!

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 17:16

I just don’t think it is fair for men to be forced into paying when they have made it perfectly known that they do not want to be involved.

the Law says different

TheWeeDonkey · 25/07/2021 17:15

@pointythings

He didn't want a baby.

But chose not to wear a condom.

So he can't turn around now and act like he wasn't aware of the risks.

Exactly. Lots of men didn't want HIV but chose not to wear a condom and they don't get to walk away from their bad choices. All these hand wringers whining about women expecting men to step up.

You do know an unplanned pregnancy is not the worst outcome of not taking a responsibility for your sexual health?

Honestly I have no time for feckless men who leave a trail of destruction everywhere they go.

pointythings · 25/07/2021 17:14

If men don't want to be involved, they should not have PIV sex. Men are also allowed to say no.

belle40 · 25/07/2021 17:14

Sorry OP. You must be exceptionally disappointed in the father of your baby. What a scumbag and shame on his mother for condoning his actions. My ex is similar in that he has three older children who he 'adores' but he won't acknowledge our child. He does pay maintenance though and this is essential. You must claim CMS. If you don't 'need' the money, put it in a bank account for your baby. I don't know if you are aware but grandparents have no legal rights to their grandchildren. I would be inclined to cut his mother off. I would be concerned that her manipulation would continue. Good luck and congratulations on your baby.

Lostandlonely94 · 25/07/2021 17:12

I agree @toocold54 that they had the discussion about babies quite regularly by the sounds of it so if she knew his thoughts then she could be managing this pregnancy and little boy on her own.

I can see why my OH’s friend jumped to the conclusion that I had “trapped” him when there seems to be so many cases of intentional or unintentional trappings going on. I told them numerous times that he had been the one to decide we should carry on with the pregnancy and he told them the same but they didn’t believe him. It may have been because they all knew of cases where women have chosen to keep the babies and then starting requesting support even when the father didn’t want to be involved. My OH ended up cutting them out of his life because he couldn’t change their thoughts on me and our DD but what can you do.

I just don’t think it is fair for men to be forced into paying when they have made it perfectly known that they do not want to be involved.

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 17:11

@ChunkySloth

But you could say if op wasn't willing and able to raise a child by herself, then she should have been on the pill and had a diaphragm in 🤷‍♀️

She chose to continue with the pregnancy after he said he didn't want the baby. Its on her after that point.

the Law says different

ChunkySloth · 25/07/2021 17:10

But you could say if op wasn't willing and able to raise a child by herself, then she should have been on the pill and had a diaphragm in 🤷‍♀️

She chose to continue with the pregnancy after he said he didn't want the baby. Its on her after that point.

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 17:09

@toocold54

You can't have it both ways

You don’t need to keep writing every other word in bold.
He didn’t want a baby and she knew that and she made her decision knowing that. I’m sure they even spoke about it during their relationship.
She can’t turn around now and act like he hadn’t been upfront with her about it.

doesn't matter..

She's entitled to CMS .. the Law says so ☺️

toocold54 · 25/07/2021 17:08

just because you made your choice, that doesn't mean OP has to make the same choice.

I’m not saying she has to make the same choice I am giving my opinion which is what these threads are for Confused

I am not the only one on here who was in OPs situation and didn’t go for maintenance.

If you decide to have a baby knowing full well you will be a single parent with no help from the father then that is the decision you make. I’m sure OP thought long and hard about it before going through with it knowing she would be doing it alone.

pointythings · 25/07/2021 17:08

He didn't want a baby.

But chose not to wear a condom.

So he can't turn around now and act like he wasn't aware of the risks.

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 17:08

@MadCattery

It’s different here in the States. YOU don’t have a right to child support, but your child has the right to be supported by both parents. So, even if the mother doesn’t want it, in a divorce for instance, she cannot waive the right of the child to be supported by both. It’s statutory, and the amount is also statutory and if he does not want to pay, it will come out of his pay. If he quits his job to work off the books, he can lose his drivers license and any professional licenses. The father must kick in, rather than asking the mother and taxpayer to support his own child!
it also affects your passport 🌸
Merryoldgoat · 25/07/2021 17:07

I can’t bear this thread. What the fuck is happening?

BrandNewHeretic · 25/07/2021 17:07

@toocold54

He assumed... You know what they say about that: assume makes an ass out of u and me.

He. Chose. Not. To. Wear. A. Condom.

OP chose to have sex with him knowing that contraception is not 100% so she could have said wear a condom or I’m not having sex with you if she was so against having an abortion. But she didn’t she took that risk knowing he didn’t want to have a child.

What happens if he wore a condom and the condom split? People would still be saying the same because men can do no right on here.

Why not listen to the women who’ve actually been in this situation.

My god, the hypocrisy!
toocold54 · 25/07/2021 17:06

You can't have it both ways

You don’t need to keep writing every other word in bold.
He didn’t want a baby and she knew that and she made her decision knowing that. I’m sure they even spoke about it during their relationship.
She can’t turn around now and act like he hadn’t been upfront with her about it.

pointythings · 25/07/2021 17:04

toocold54 just because you made your choice, that doesn't mean OP has to make the same choice.

You let a man off from his responsibilities. And since we're all free to have an opinion, mine is that that was a poor choice. Good men take responsibility for the choices they make.

MadCattery · 25/07/2021 17:04

It’s different here in the States. YOU don’t have a right to child support, but your child has the right to be supported by both parents. So, even if the mother doesn’t want it, in a divorce for instance, she cannot waive the right of the child to be supported by both. It’s statutory, and the amount is also statutory and if he does not want to pay, it will come out of his pay. If he quits his job to work off the books, he can lose his drivers license and any professional licenses. The father must kick in, rather than asking the mother and taxpayer to support his own child!

updownroundandround · 25/07/2021 17:00

@toocold54

You can't have it both ways !

Either He didn’t wear a condom because she was on birth control, meaning that she had taken steps to prevent unwanted pregnancy and SHE asked HIM to wear a CONDOM ! Which HE refused, thereby ignoring HIS shared obligation to prevent pregnancy !

Just because she was on birth control, doesn't absolve him from his responsibility to prevent pregnancy ! And unless he's an imbecile, he already knows that no birth control method is 100% FFS !!

And your idea that He assumed that as she was trying to stop herself getting pregnant then if the worst was to happen she’d get the morning after pill or abortion pill is frankly ridiculous !

He assumed, so he never asked, and he didn't think it important enough to check or confirm this ??
But the idea that he assumed that she would once again be the only one of them to take action to prevent the birth of a baby Hmm. That he should take no further interest in whether or not his refusal to wear a condom had any consequences ?

Why is it that you think he needn't bother his tiny little head about worrying about an unexpected pregnancy, even after refusing to take his share of responsibility CAUSED by that refusal but you still think it's all down to the woman not wanting to have an abortion ?? Confused

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 16:59

Claim your CMS OP 🎉

toocold54 · 25/07/2021 16:57

He assumed... You know what they say about that: assume makes an ass out of u and me.

He. Chose. Not. To. Wear. A. Condom.

OP chose to have sex with him knowing that contraception is not 100% so she could have said wear a condom or I’m not having sex with you if she was so against having an abortion. But she didn’t she took that risk knowing he didn’t want to have a child.

What happens if he wore a condom and the condom split? People would still be saying the same because men can do no right on here.

Why not listen to the women who’ve actually been in this situation.

BrandNewHeretic · 25/07/2021 16:53

@toocold54

So, according to you, women are always to blame, regardless of their birth control efforts, but men are never to blame when it happens ?? Regardless of their total lack of ANY protection taken at ALL ????

FFS they are both to blame but he chose not to go through with the pregnancy and she chose to.
He didn’t wear a condom because she was on birth control. He assumed that as she was trying to stop herself getting pregnant then if the worst was to happen she’d get the morning after pill or abortion pill. If she wasn’t on birth control then he would be as responsible as he is choosing to have sex with someone who doesn’t care if they get pregnant or not but he had sex with her knowing she was on birth control and therefore knowing she didn’t want to get pregnant.

Both parties are responsible for their own reproduction. She took precautions for hers, he didn't, knowing that no birth control is 100% - despite being asked to and refusing. It is not solely the responsibility of the woman. She did her part, it was the man who let the side down, but is him trying to get out of it by issuing immoral ultimatums. Get an abortion or do it alone. Stop going for maintenance or I'll stop my mother seeing her grandchildren.

Aiming to prevent pregnancy, and terminating a pregnancy, are emotionally and physically 2 different things. They are not the same.

pointythings · 25/07/2021 16:49

He assumed that as she was trying to stop herself getting pregnant then if the worst was to happen she’d get the morning after pill or abortion pill.

He assumed... You know what they say about that: assume makes an ass out of u and me.

He. Chose. Not. To. Wear. A. Condom.

He pays. Wanting to get your dick wet can get very expensive - men need to remember that.

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 16:43

He uses condoms when we have sex. And amazingly nobody has fallen pregnant.

and it's an actual miracle 😂 Who'd have thought it 🤣

🌸🌺🌸

toocold54 · 25/07/2021 16:43

So, according to you, women are always to blame, regardless of their birth control efforts, but men are never to blame when it happens ?? Regardless of their total lack of ANY protection taken at ALL ????

FFS they are both to blame but he chose not to go through with the pregnancy and she chose to.
He didn’t wear a condom because she was on birth control. He assumed that as she was trying to stop herself getting pregnant then if the worst was to happen she’d get the morning after pill or abortion pill. If she wasn’t on birth control then he would be as responsible as he is choosing to have sex with someone who doesn’t care if they get pregnant or not but he had sex with her knowing she was on birth control and therefore knowing she didn’t want to get pregnant.