Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable asking for child maintenance

406 replies

Bri102 · 25/07/2021 09:31

First time writing a post and it's a bit long so apologies.

I fell pregnant with my son during lockdown, bit of a surprise as I was on birth control. The father straight away said I should get an abortion due to the fact he was unplanned, im so grateful everyday I didn't as my son is a beautiful funny little 6 month old now. The dad has never met him and had changed his mind a few times about meeting him but this has come to a head and he now says it's impossible for him to meet my son, due to the fact I have asked for child maintenance, my maternity leave is ending soon and it is going to cost £600 a month for nursery fees alone.

Whilst I was pregnant I reached out to the father's mum to ask if she wanted a relationship with my son, she jumped at the chance and we have been seeing each other frequently since I was pregnant. Shortly after my son was born she said if she was me she would go for child maintenance, as her son should take some sort of responsibility for my son. However, she came to see my son yesterday and told me im morally wrong to ask for any maintenance as her son did not wish for me to continue the pregnancy and it was my decision and mine alone, he did not have any choice in the matter. She said I should not have continued the pregnancy if I could not financially support the baby myself. I can support the baby and my other son but after the nursery fees, we will not have much left for food and everyday needs. She asked me if I would drop the case as her son has given her the ultimatum of him and her other 2 grandchildren or my son and she is going to chose her son the babys dad, and she is prepared to walk out of my sons life. I'm devastated for my son not only will he feel abandoned by his father but now by his family also. My sons father has also never met his dad and recently tried to contact him and his dad didn't want to know him and denied having a son, it has apparently really effected him, but he is willing to do it to his own son which I cannot understand. Don't know if it's worth noting he already has two other children who he sees twice a week and pays child maintenance for to his ex.

I just want to know if I am in the wrong and should just drop the child maintenance and basically walk away from the family before my son is old enough to remember his nan and aunties who are willing to walk away if the dad is adamant on the ultimatum.

Thanks for reading and any advice, sorry it was long.

OP posts:
TheWeeDonkey · 25/07/2021 18:49

@Lostandlonely94

Men are fertile all the time and a vasectomy comes with so many more risks.. a woman is fertile when the egg is released so during the ovulation period.

Maybe every woman should be made to track this regularly so that when they are close to the ovulation time of the month they abstain.

How does this work for women who's peroiods aren't regular?

How does this work for women in sexually coercive relationships?

How difficult is it for a man to wear a condom?

How does policing when women are allowed to have sex prevent the spread of STDs?

Who do you keep going for the most difficult complicated solution when condoms are easily available and fairly straight forward to use?

Lostandlonely94 · 25/07/2021 18:49

I’ve already said childbirth is risky so why would a woman choose to go through that alone knowing they may be bringing a baby into a world where that baby ends up with no one.

Labours are traumatic and I say that as someone who has experienced two.. the second one all I could think was what happens to my DD if I die, I’d of left her without a mum however my son did not cross my mind at that time but if he had survived and I did die I’d be leaving them both.

If I didn’t have my fiancé to support them and raise them I’d be royally screwed especially when most women don’t have wills and they don’t have things in place for children if something did happen to them.

frazzledasarock · 25/07/2021 18:47

I personally have never heard of any woman in my friend/social circle getting pregnant ‘accidentally’ on purpose.

I know of a few men who had vasectomies when they decided they wanted no more children.

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 18:47

[quote Lostandlonely94]@QueenBee52- at least I’m giving ideas that mean men aren’t just left with this is all your fault so you should pay for it solution.

I’m not going to change my view that men should not be forced to pay for a child they did not want!! How in human nature is that bloody fair?! If money wasn’t a thing (say it didn’t exist) the woman would be accepting that they would be raising the baby alone without support and I bet they would not be any conversation for the two of them to have again.

I don’t think CMS is fair and we can’t all say that we’ve not heard of women abusing contraception because they wish to have a child etc. so sorry if I feel men are hard done by.

They can’t win… they want the baby (tough shit mother doesn’t and has an abortion) and the father doesn’t want a baby (tough shit the mother does so she is keeping it)

Also think men should get the 9 months of maternity/paternity leave like mothers do as well because some dads do want to spend that time with their babies.[/quote]

Do you intend on sharing your views that 'men rule the female body' with your Daughter ?

dolor · 25/07/2021 18:46

Awww. Poor fella can't handle responsibility so he sent his mum to sort you out.

take him to the fucking cleaners

As in

CLAIM.

P.s the apologists in this thread - you're disgusting.

frazzledasarock · 25/07/2021 18:45

If men don’t want to pay for their children.

They can stop having PIV sex

They can use condoms

They can have vasectomies

They can abstain from sex entirely

They have the choices right there. There’s no poor menz suddenly shockingly became fathers completely unaware of how it happened.

ILoveYou3000 · 25/07/2021 18:43

@Lostandlonely94

Men are fertile all the time and a vasectomy comes with so many more risks.. a woman is fertile when the egg is released so during the ovulation period.

Maybe every woman should be made to track this regularly so that when they are close to the ovulation time of the month they abstain.

You've over-egged it a tad now, but go on for fun I'll bite.

Vasectomy comes with so many more risks compared to what? Female contraception? Pregnancy? Childbirth? Your source for this?

You're now saying you want to completely absolve men of any responsibility for birth control. You want it to be solely the responsibility of women, and that it's up to us to abstain from sex rather than expecting a man to wear a condom.

You're a woman you say? 🤔

Lostandlonely94 · 25/07/2021 18:42

@QueenBee52- at least I’m giving ideas that mean men aren’t just left with this is all your fault so you should pay for it solution.

I’m not going to change my view that men should not be forced to pay for a child they did not want!! How in human nature is that bloody fair?! If money wasn’t a thing (say it didn’t exist) the woman would be accepting that they would be raising the baby alone without support and I bet they would not be any conversation for the two of them to have again.

I don’t think CMS is fair and we can’t all say that we’ve not heard of women abusing contraception because they wish to have a child etc. so sorry if I feel men are hard done by.

They can’t win… they want the baby (tough shit mother doesn’t and has an abortion) and the father doesn’t want a baby (tough shit the mother does so she is keeping it)

Also think men should get the 9 months of maternity/paternity leave like mothers do as well because some dads do want to spend that time with their babies.

mbosnz · 25/07/2021 18:41

I had two carloads of boy and girl racers pull up outside our house one, and went out to give them an earful about their noise and rubbish, and ended up going out, having a wine, letting them use the loo, and really talking with them. Once they'd cleaned up the broken glass.

The young women went away with my contraceptive mantra ringing in their ears, which once they stopped laughing they said made very sound sense, and the young men went away looking a little bit sulky that it turned out that they were most probably not getting any that night.

BrandNewHeretic · 25/07/2021 18:41

@toocold54

All very similar and relevant.

But then the father chose to be involved as you said spending his time and money. That’s completely different.

My point, which you are deliberately missing, is that telling me he didn't want a baby after getting me pregnant does not absolve him of his responsibility - that ship had sailed. Asking me to get an abortion after getting me pregnant does not absolve him of his responsibility - an abortion is not contraception, its not something he can dictate or issue ultimatums on. If he didn't want a baby, the time to make decisions and take action on that was before getting me pregnant.

He chose to contribute to the child he made because it was the right thing to do, under the exact same circumstances that OP is in, because he was equally responsible for OP falling pregnant accidentally.

Are you being deliberately obtuse?

frazzledasarock · 25/07/2021 18:40

@Lostandlonely94 or men can use condoms.

Even tracking your fertile days women can still fall pregnant if they have sex on ‘safe’ days, sperm can hang around in a suitable environment for up to five days. And outside factors can affect ovulation. It’s not an exact science hence why women using the rhythm method have a high incidence of falling pregnant.

Why is using a condom so terrible or difficult for men? And instead suggestions are thrown back to put the onus back on to women or even ffs suggestions that proceeding with a pregnancy should be based on a legal contract 🙄 obviously the only one undergoing pregnancy or an abortion and losing bodily autonomy in any of these suggestions is the woman.

HelenHywater · 25/07/2021 18:39

@BasicDad

A lesson to all men (and mothers/fathers of men)

If you want to avoid boilers that "say" they are on the pill (or would magically want to have a baby despite being on them)...wear your own protection. If you meet a woman that tells you it's OK, she's on birth control (anecdotal, but huge %), then insist on condom or leave.

It's like getting in the passenger seat of a car with no seat belt. You have no control.

That's just bollocks.

A message to all men, including my sons, will be to take responsibility for contraception. It's the same message I give to my daughters.

Bollindger · 25/07/2021 18:38

Every Comment comes down to this.
Man, has sex. Congratulations your a daddy.
She said she was on the Pill, , Congratulations your a daddy.
I wore a condom, Congratulations your a daddy.
I din't wear a condom. Congratulations your a daddy.
I don't want it. Congratulations your a daddy.
I didn't have sex. Congratulations your NOT a daddy.

mbosnz · 25/07/2021 18:35

Or alternatively, men can take responsibility for their fertility issues, and wear a condom, or not have PIV sex if they're not prepared for any and all potential consequences.

I'm fucked if I'm going to be made, or my daughters made to track my fertility cycle, so the lazy buggers can be even lazier.

QueenBee52 · 25/07/2021 18:35

@Lostandlonely94

Men are fertile all the time and a vasectomy comes with so many more risks.. a woman is fertile when the egg is released so during the ovulation period.

Maybe every woman should be made to track this regularly so that when they are close to the ovulation time of the month they abstain.

seriously .. STOP

you are just embarrassing yourself ...

ILoveYou3000 · 25/07/2021 18:34

stop projecting!

🤣🤣 pot meet kettle.

You're correct in that you haven't said our children shouldn't exist. I mixed you up with someone else there and I apologise for that comment.

However, you have said that it's wrong to apply for CSA in these circumstances, did you not? That if we chose to continue we should allow the man in question to absolve all responsibility? That he's nothing more than a sperm donor?

Lostandlonely94 · 25/07/2021 18:32

Men are fertile all the time and a vasectomy comes with so many more risks.. a woman is fertile when the egg is released so during the ovulation period.

Maybe every woman should be made to track this regularly so that when they are close to the ovulation time of the month they abstain.

pointythings · 25/07/2021 18:31

@toocold54

All very similar and relevant.

But then the father chose to be involved as you said spending his time and money. That’s completely different.

So once again you are saying that it's all on the woman and the man just gets to walk away.

Thank goodness the law says otherwise. Most men are better than this, you know.

toocold54 · 25/07/2021 18:29

All very similar and relevant.

But then the father chose to be involved as you said spending his time and money. That’s completely different.

toocold54 · 25/07/2021 18:28

But in your view it's her and I that are in the wrong and our children shouldn't exist because he chose not to wear a condom.

WTF where have I ever said you and her are in the wrong and your kids shouldn’t exist! I’d be talking about myself too if that was the case - stop projecting!

mbosnz · 25/07/2021 18:17

By crikey, if I were his Mum, I'd be giving him an earful.

Herecomesthesun70 · 25/07/2021 18:15

I don't see how telling his mother to choose will change things. He'll still have to pay whether she sees your son or not.

BrandNewHeretic · 25/07/2021 18:14

@Lostandlonely94

Legal as in a legal contract because the sperm is taken out of equation with day to day sex. Sperm is stored away for every man to release (however method sperm donation uses) when a woman and man want a baby together (50:50 decision) They both sign to release the form and have equal right and responsibility over any child which is conceived and that is that. Hopefully medically there will be might be a pill or something that men can take to stop sperm being created until he wants to store more. The woman would need to have insemination for the fathers sperm though.

Then sex becomes for fun and fun alone and procreation becomes more of an organised procedure.

Obviously I am making an illogical idea… it might make life easier though 🤨

Surely it would just be easier for men to wear condoms or have a vasectomy if they don't want children. You know, take responsibility for their own reproduction the way women have to?
ILoveYou3000 · 25/07/2021 18:13

No I didn’t miss it I was trying to say that unless you have been in OPs situation you can’t say what you would have done. You can say what you probably would have done but it’s completely different actually being in that situation.

I've been in OP's situation. I went to the CSA. As did the woman he got pregnant and abandoned after me. But in your view it's her and I that are in the wrong and our children shouldn't exist because he chose not to wear a condom. He wanted all the fun with zero consequences when my contraception failed. My child deserved better. As it was he proved to be a prince among men, quit work and started his own company while claiming benefits so my child received a whopping £2.50 per week while their dad wore a Rolex, drove a BMW with personalised number plate and had three foreign holidays a year. Karma got him in the end.

BrandNewHeretic · 25/07/2021 18:11

@toocold54

Love how you haven't been able to reply to any of my valid points.

Lol sorry I didn’t realise you wanted me to reply to every single thing you said.
My point is that you said you are/were in the same situation as OP - but you’re not so it’s irrelevant.

  1. Used contraception because I didn't want to get pregnant - partner didn't use anything
  2. Fell pregnant after my contraception failed.
  3. Partner told me he didn't want a child, wanted me to get abortion.
  4. I couldn't go through with termination and continued with the pregnancy.

All very similar and relevant.