Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why MN is so unpleasant about SAHMs?

978 replies

crinklyfoil · 25/07/2021 07:39

While I know there are cases when women aren’t married and don’t own property and are in a vulnerable position, I’m not talking about posters who are concerned about women.

I’m talking about posters who believe that SAHMs have no say in finances, should ‘get a job’ and are somehow lazy.

A FT childcare place costs around £800 a month. If you have more than one child, realistically for many women, ‘getting a job’ will mean working at a loss. Not to mention problems with shift work at the lower paid end of the spectrum (retail work and care work.)

Is it really so awful that having a SAHM might just work really well for some families? That some women might thoroughly enjoy it and that it’s part of a mutually beneficial relationship in the context of the whole family?

Or should everyone just get a job, regardless of how miserable and poor it makes the whole family?!

OP posts:
Benjispruce5 · 25/07/2021 20:56

DH would’ve loved to share that time at home but it wasn’t possible back then. DD1 is now at university so things may have changed now.

cosima8 · 25/07/2021 20:55

“And after the age of five children are at school six hours a day. Once you have a school-aged child being "there" is irrelevant as the child isn't "there".”

Well yes, kind of true. But if you have 4 DC like I did (at one point they were in 3 different schools), what you do find is that the school holidays are often slightly different across the schools. Also, if one gets sick, they tend to all get it one after the next - so can end up being at home more than you might expect. It was no good me asking DH to stay home - he was often abroad. Never once did he change his work plans for unexpected sick days or that sort of thing. I didn’t need him to anyway.

The time they are in primary school tends to fly by because that’s when you get on top of everything so you’re not doing it in the evening. The time after 3.30 pick up was hectic and non-stop - especially if they had various activities on or whatever. We’re in London so the traffic was often bad (though I guess it is everywhere). What I mean is, the schools were not five mins down the road. I could easily be 60 mins in the car in the mornings and then again in the afternoons.

There is no way a nanny could have done all the pick ups from various schools; made dinner for everyone; helped with the homework and made sure it was done to a high standard; ferried 4 kids to different clubs or friend’s houses; sensed when there was an emotional drama brewing (the school run is often the key time this sort of thing comes out and it was a vital time in my experience). It would be unreasonable to ask someone to do all that - I only did it because I’m their mum. There are some excellent nannies for sure, but ultimately its always going to be just a job for them at the end of the day. They’re not going to go the extra mile in the way mums do for their own kids. Plus, if I have to manage a nanny, it’s just another thing to deal with. I’d rather do it myself.

imamule · 25/07/2021 20:55

Men need to be held to account for doing their fair share of childcare while women the earning.

I think things are slowly changing. DHs firm increased paid paternity leave from 2 wks to 3 months & it's becoming more common. It was great for all of us to have that time together.

Benjispruce5 · 25/07/2021 20:54

The nursery was part of the primary school.

Benjispruce5 · 25/07/2021 20:53

I think they did a couple of mornings (9-11)a week at nursery in the summer term to prepare for school.

pinkfanman · 25/07/2021 20:53

Because nothing changes if nothing changes. If you're expecting to be kept by your partner, when you're perfectly capable of working, then you're not equal. There's an imbalance of power and understandably the earning partner gets resentful being treated like a cash cow. Really does depend on the man - my dh was happy to go to work and happy to see photos we sent him went we were having lovely days out - his family having fun made him smile and feel good. Resentment is not an emotion my dh embraces - there is no imbalance of power in our relationship. (I wouldn't allow it) Wink

StressyWoman · 25/07/2021 20:51

I’ve never seen any negativity towards SAHM’s on here but have towards SAHD’s. I applaud any stay at home parent, I was one for 2 years and wouldn’t do it again!

imamule · 25/07/2021 20:50

@Benjispruce5 So you wouldn't agree to take the universal free 15 hours before school as that would mean not being there?

Benjispruce5 · 25/07/2021 20:48

I went back to work once they started school.

pinkfanman · 25/07/2021 20:46

@vivainsomnia

As a previous sahm I wouldn't say I've sacrificed my career at all Just to be clear, my comments are only aimed at women who claim that their husband earn a lot because they have sacrifice their own career to facilitate theirs, which is oddly a very common statement on MN.

If one partner earns a lot, and the other was too before giving it up, surely they had enough to pay for a nanny.

My dh earns a lot - if he had to share childcare with me he would earn less - I didn't sacrifice my career to facilitate his - I didn't enjoy my career and wanted to be at home with my kids, we had enough money, so it suited us both. What suited me, suited his career. And we both make financial decisions about our future - I am not subservient, he is not bitter and stressed about working. I do not have to request permission to spend, my pension has been sorted, we have a strong marriage...we suited ourselves and our circumstances isn't that what everyone should do?

What's it to you?

thepeopleversuswork · 25/07/2021 20:46

@Benjispruce5

Yes ok working parents can be in two places at once. Happy?
No-one's saying this - you seem to be going out of your way to miss the point.

The relevant points are:

a) that a child spends far more time on a net basis with the parent than the childminder/nursery and remains in the care of the parent after stopping being in the childcare setting
b) that the contact with the parent is far more intimate than with the childminder/nursery - it is a lifetime relationship
c) that once a child starts school (and they are there for the majority of their childhood) there is no additional benefit to the child in having a parent at home, beyond the fact that there is someone on hand to pick up more of the domestic work and admin.

Benjispruce5 · 25/07/2021 20:46

I was a sahm when my children were at home. I worked when they went to school. I chose to do that because I believed it to be best at that young age and we planned our choices accordingly. Disclaimer before I get flamed/ others think working and childcare is best.

LittleBearPad · 25/07/2021 20:45

@Benjispruce5

Yes ok working parents can be in two places at once. Happy?
For someone who says they are past caring you seem to care quite a lot.
sst1234 · 25/07/2021 20:44

@Treacletoots

Agree with *@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland*

This isn't the 1950s. If we want to be treated as equals, we need to behave like equals, by not expecting our partners to keep us.

Also agree that some of us work full time and still manage to do the above. Hobbies, children's hobbies, community activities, allotments, dog walking and so on.

But then I actually thought looking after DC full time was harder than any paid job and was relieved to go back to full time work. So I don't think they're lazy, but I do think they're part of the reason women are still the ones who give up their jobs, who earn less and ultimately suffer if the relationship goes to shit. Because nothing changes if nothing changes. If you're expecting to be kept by your partner, when you're perfectly capable of working, then you're not equal. There's an imbalance of power and understandably the earning partner gets resentful being treated like a cash cow.

Exactly. Funny how this element of feminism escapes scrutiny in this debate. You cannot pick and choose between aspects of equality, especially ones which have taken a long time for women to acquire. Men need to be held to account for doing their fair share of childcare while women the earning.
FTEngineerM · 25/07/2021 20:44

You’ve missed the point, obviously people can’t be in two places at once.

Just because a parent works it doesn’t mean they can’t drop work whenever the dc needs it.
If nursery let me know he’s not acting like himself today I’ll go get him, if I see on the app he hasn’t eaten like he usually would or hasn’t slept like he usually would I ask and they tell me. Neither work nor nursery is prison..

imamule · 25/07/2021 20:43

but @Benjispruce5 if the dc are in school why does it matter if you're at home or at work as either way you can't be in school with them?

Benjispruce5 · 25/07/2021 20:41

Yes ok working parents can be in two places at once. Happy?

FTEngineerM · 25/07/2021 20:40

If you’re at work you’re not there

Erm, well yeah, but is it totally beyond the scope of your understanding that if nursery were to call and say ‘your dc isn’t themselves today’ for the parent to just drop work and go pick them up?

You can still be there for them when they need it.

HappyMeal654 · 25/07/2021 20:39

Hi, my husband does more and childcare would take up everything I earn. You're correct it's a joint expense, but we also treat our whole income as joint, therefore there will be months where it may actually cost us for me to be at work. I don't particularly want to be a SAHM but it works best for our family right now, and I want whatever is best for us.

thepeopleversuswork · 25/07/2021 20:37

@Benjispruce5

If you’re at work you’re not there. Unless you’re Mr Claypole!
But you are there before and after childcare and at weekends. You're "there" far more than you're not.

And after the age of five children are at school six hours a day. Once you have a school-aged child being "there" is irrelevant as the child isn't "there".

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 25/07/2021 20:36

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

Childcare costs are joint and known before having children so not an excuse to not work.

Education teaches children to aim high and study hard in order to prepare for adulthood, supporting yourself and giving back through taxes.

I don’t subscribe to the old fashioned view that men work and pay for everything and women opt out of all work and financial responsibilities. It’s perfectly possible to work, run a home and parent, millions do it.

I can’t imagine not working and needing someone else to pay for absolutely everything I need. Nor expecting my partner to pay for his own gifts and bear the responsibility for it all alone. I’d not be impressed if he thought it was perfectly ok to opt out of working and leave his costs to me so wouldn’t expect the same in return,

DH is 67, works a physical job part time because that's all he can manage, we get WTC. If I work more than 10 hours a week, they start taking the extra income off WTC. I can't find a job for so few hours.
Benjispruce5 · 25/07/2021 20:28

If you’re at work you’re not there. Unless you’re Mr Claypole!

imamule · 25/07/2021 20:28

@cosima8 my dc are still young but I would say at our prep the vast majority of SAHMs have a nanny or au pair. And the vast majority of mothers actually work albeit p/t. Maybe it's a generational difference? Although the vast majority aren't married to multi millionaires but very good earners so maybe it's that.

BrandNewHeretic · 25/07/2021 20:22

@Benjispruce5

I meant it in every sense.
I'm there for my children all the time in every sense at the minute too as a SAHM, to the point where it's driving me insane, I can't even take a piss on my own. It certainly doesn't make me a superior parent. If anything, I was better parent when I was working because I was MORE emotionally available when I was back home. My DH was the SAHP for 2 years and now we've swapped - he hasn't stopped being there for his kids because he's working again. What nonsense.
imamule · 25/07/2021 20:19

But then I'll complain that I miss them!

We go away every year for a few days without them (last time was Feb 2020) but always end up missing them after a few days. It's annoying!

Swipe left for the next trending thread