Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New man sees spirits and it freaks me out. AIBU?

184 replies

iseedeadpeoplehelp · 25/07/2021 06:00

New guy, very sweet and kind, good job, interesting and sincere.
But he tells me he sees spirits and if he stays in an old house/building they can keep him awake. I don't like anything woo and it's making me uncomfortable. Thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChaToilLeam · 29/07/2021 12:50

I’d be wary, OP. Could be unwell, could be attention seeking.

My opinion? It’s all made up, the thought of spirits hanging around may be comforting or terrifying but I’ve never seen any convincing evidence. As with all woo, superstition and religion in general. Should convincing evidence ever become available, I’d be happy to reconsider.

onelittlefrog · 29/07/2021 08:29

@CutePanda

Hmm interesting how quick people are to say “spirits do not exist,” but they won’t tell a Christian, Buddhist, Muslim etc that their Gods, angels and prophets do not exist. I bet they attend church funerals to pay respect to the dead. I bet they Christened/baptised their DC. Bunch of hypocrites!
You know you can believe something yourself without forcing that belief on other people?

I could state "Spirits don't exist" on here as my own belief.

At the same time, I can accept that other people believe something different, I can even celebrate that!

Their belief is their reality and their experience of the world - and that is absolutely fine. Actually quite awesome that we're not all the same. I'd love to learn more about it.

Tolerance and acceptance.

onelittlefrog · 29/07/2021 08:21

@iseedeadpeoplehelp

He doesn't mention it often and it took him a while to mention it at all. He is not an attention seeker, I would spot that a mile away but I'm not sure about his history re drug use. He is lovely in every other way, it's just this that concerns me.
Yes I would be a little concerned too, mostly about his mental health and potential for hallucinations.

Doesn't mean it's a dealbreaker because only you know him and your own boundaries/ tolerance levels.

Why not fish him out a bit more on it and have some longer conversations about it? It's concerning if he is having hallucinations but again, not necessarily a reason to not be with him, it all depends on what you are able to cope with and if you like him in every other way it could be absolutely fine.

Terhou · 29/07/2021 07:53

@PartridgeFeather, I'm not sure you know what "patronising" means.

PartridgeFeather · 28/07/2021 10:30

@Terhou "Religious types" 😂. Patronising much?

Nextlevelnonsense · 27/07/2021 20:15

@SmileyClare

I used to "see" a tall man in my peripheral vision

It turns out I had accurately described his deceased uncle

Sorry but that's a bit of a reach Grin

I'm sure it gives people comfort to think their dead relatives are still around in spirit but I can't help laughing a bit at "woo" anecdotes.

It's probably more open minded to consider other explanations?

That said, some of the woo threads on here are fairly harmless and comedy gold Wink

Paraphrasing isn't helpful, unless your intention is to mock for entertainment.

I didn't describe the entire situation, or my description.
To elaborate slightly, my BF is 6ft 5. The man that I saw was visibly taller than my BF. That is significant, and prompted me to mention it.

Quantum theory provides some very rational explanations for paranormal events. Marcus Chown is a great author for the uninitiated.
Fear is the usual response, but it's very lazy to denounce anything that you haven't personally experienced.

FittedSheet · 27/07/2021 19:56

@Chikapu

Why am I picturing him as Margaret Rutherford?
GrinGrin
isuckathousework · 27/07/2021 19:49

@iseedeadpeoplehelp

Yes it does frighten me, because I have an open mind about these things. Just because there isn't an explanation doesn't make it untrue as such. For me he may be telling his truth but I tend to think a bit rationally but without dismissing it completely.
Happy to hear this about you OP.

Rest of the people who are outright denying the possibility of such things is mind boggling.

The mindset - "only what I see can exist" Before the scientists discovered microbes, these type of people would have scorned at those who spoke of possible microbial beings. Unbelievably closed minded!

On your question - it really depends, if the relationship is otherwise solid, this is not necessarily a deal breaker unless it will make you too uncomfortable, then it is.

Chikapu · 27/07/2021 19:33

Why am I picturing him as Margaret Rutherford?

FittedSheet · 27/07/2021 19:22

@CutePanda must be new here. I don’t know anyone of any religious faith that isn’t perfectly aware that I think their religion is a human carrot-and-stick construct made out of a combination of ‘them and us’ and fear of the unknown and mortality, and that, despite being from a devout Catholic background, I haven’t baptised my child, and have sent him to a secular school where kids are taught about religions, but not catechised in any faith.

It’s hardly a radical or unusual position.

Terhou · 27/07/2021 19:18

@picklemewalnuts

Given that synesthesia exists, why dismiss someone perceiving things differently from other people? Some people do experience things that most people don't. They then have to come up with an explanation for it.

There was a bloke researching whether it was due to unusual sensitivity to subsonic sound.

There's really no need to be sneery.

I don't think anyone has an issue with people perceiving things differently. The problem lies with people insisting that what they perceive is real.
Terhou · 27/07/2021 19:15

@CutePanda

Hmm interesting how quick people are to say “spirits do not exist,” but they won’t tell a Christian, Buddhist, Muslim etc that their Gods, angels and prophets do not exist. I bet they attend church funerals to pay respect to the dead. I bet they Christened/baptised their DC. Bunch of hypocrites!
I'm perfectly happy to discuss with religious types the fact that there is no evidence for their respective gods should the issue arise, and my children were not christened. I don't boycott church funerals despite my lack of belief, because that doesn't go against my conscience - it's not my fault that that is what the deceased or their relatives have chosen and I can't see that there is anything hypocritical about it; I can pay my respects whilst keeping silent during prayers and hymns.
Terhou · 27/07/2021 19:08

Sorry can't help you

My point precisely, @seashells11. If spirits were real, for sure someone would have produced some decent evidence by now.

CatsArePeople · 27/07/2021 14:57

is it his hobby? Paranormal stuff?

EmeraldShamrock · 27/07/2021 14:52

Hmm I'm not sure how I'd feel.
My DGM was very woo and superstitious she predicted death twice, she told my dad when he was 20 the neighbour died, he did not but he died the next day.
She'd read tea leaves for the adults not sure if she was taking the piss.
I know I was terrified of a banshee growing up from her woo stories.
I now know a banshee isn't real. Grin

WouldBeGood · 27/07/2021 14:44

I agree @seashells11

seashells11 · 27/07/2021 13:25

I believe in God and I never try and force my beliefs on people. I think that's so wrong to do that. I equally think it wrong that those that don't believe try to convince the believers that they have it all wrong and that they're not right in the head. It's pointless and unnecessary.

Ifailed · 27/07/2021 09:37

I get that some people take comfort from believing in God(s), angels, etc. and so long as they don't try and force their believes on me or use them against me some way, it's none of my business.
OP is writing about some who claims to see 'spirits', not just believe in them. As many PPs have pointed out, there has never been a verifiable case of a 'spirit' being recorded, and no evidence to suggest they exist.
There's a big difference in believing in something and claiming to be able to see it. The latter suggests lies or some physical/mental disease.

EastWestWhosBest · 27/07/2021 09:13

@CutePanda

Hmm interesting how quick people are to say “spirits do not exist,” but they won’t tell a Christian, Buddhist, Muslim etc that their Gods, angels and prophets do not exist. I bet they attend church funerals to pay respect to the dead. I bet they Christened/baptised their DC. Bunch of hypocrites!
I don’t tell them that to their face because that is rude. But nope, they don’t exist either. And as an atheist why would I christen children? If I attend church weddings of funerals it’s because that person believed.

I’m not a hypocrite thanks.

WouldBeGood · 27/07/2021 09:00

I’m not into all this stuff, but wouldn’t sneer at people who are.

SmileyClare · 27/07/2021 08:56

I used to "see" a tall man in my peripheral vision

It turns out I had accurately described his deceased uncle

Sorry but that's a bit of a reach Grin

I'm sure it gives people comfort to think their dead relatives are still around in spirit but I can't help laughing a bit at "woo" anecdotes.

It's probably more open minded to consider other explanations?

That said, some of the woo threads on here are fairly harmless and comedy gold Wink

CutePanda · 26/07/2021 22:35

@Qwerty789 you sound really triggered. You okay? If people want to believe in ghosts, parallel worlds, time slips, angels watching over them, life after death… then leave them be.

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 22:01

@Nextlevelnonsense

Well......when I was first with my bf, I used to 'see' a very tall man standing hunched in his hallway. In my peripheral vision. It happened a few times, and made me feel odd. After a while, I mentioned it to him. He asked me to describe the man, so I did. Along with the feelings that accompanied it. I had accurately described his deceased uncle, who had been an important part of his life.

I'm glad I told him, and he's glad I explained.
We don't talk about it often.
Since he moved, it hasn't happened.

He didn't explain anything, and you did not see his deceased uncles ghost. You aren't 5 years old, its time to move on from the magical thinking.
Nextlevelnonsense · 26/07/2021 21:34

Well......when I was first with my bf, I used to 'see' a very tall man standing hunched in his hallway. In my peripheral vision.
It happened a few times, and made me feel odd.
After a while, I mentioned it to him. He asked me to describe the man, so I did. Along with the feelings that accompanied it.
I had accurately described his deceased uncle, who had been an important part of his life.

I'm glad I told him, and he's glad I explained.
We don't talk about it often.
Since he moved, it hasn't happened.

Qwerty789 · 26/07/2021 21:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread