Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To loathe organised sport and what it does to children?

396 replies

AssemblySquare · 24/07/2021 23:29

There is a back story to this but it’s long and boring. I’m just sick and tired of sport being held up as this wonderful thing that brings people together, but all I have ever seen and experienced is divisiveness, bullying and meanness. I’m so done with it all, especially at grass roots level and at school where most kids seem to get shouted at by PE teachers and coaches taking out their own frustrations that they weren’t quite good enough to make it.

OP posts:
CrazyNeighbour · 25/07/2021 14:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CrazyNeighbour · 25/07/2021 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

igelkott2021 · 25/07/2021 14:47

@EwwSprouts

From my experience with DS it depends on the sport. Football is the only one I've heard parents swear at their own children and children on either team and at the referee. That just wouldn't be tolerated at cricket or hockey.
As I mentioned in my post above, we've had bad experiences with football.

It wouldn't be tolerated in athletics either, although you get the odd entitled yummy mummy (doesn't tend to be the dads) who argues with officials. I would disqualify their child but they don't deserve to be punished for their stupid parents.

igelkott2021 · 25/07/2021 14:46

They either want someone else to be picked last/finish last or for there to be no picking/no teams sports. You cannot say you want there to be team sports but it can’t be that someone is picked last/has to be on the bench/doesn’t make the squad. They go hand in hand

not being picked for a school team is one thing. If you are crap at sport you generally realistic enough to know you won't be.

What I don't expect is for teachers to facilitate bullying by allowing those good at sport to choose their team members in lessons. It doesn't a lot of thought to come with less nasty system, like simply saying everyone is A or B and then saying all the As are in one team and all the Bs in another. And then putting anyone who moans about "I don't want crappy Igel in my team" in detention.

EwwSprouts · 25/07/2021 14:44

From my experience with DS it depends on the sport. Football is the only one I've heard parents swear at their own children and children on either team and at the referee. That just wouldn't be tolerated at cricket or hockey.

igelkott2021 · 25/07/2021 14:43

I've not read the full thread but we've had bad experiences with football and good experiences with athletics.

I think ds had an ok experience with school sport because he wasn't bad at it.

I had the usual being picked last for teams and being moaned at by PE teachers because I didn't already know what I didn't know. I think PE teachers rely too much on kids doing sport outside school and learning techniques etc. A pp said PE teachers get a hard time - well I think some of them deserve it, as they only seem to see lessons as crowd control, don't actually "teach" and don't like the kids who don't have natural talent (ditto art and music).

Junior parkrun is a wonderful thing. Actually parkrun in general is a wonderful thing, but junior parkrun is obviously aimed at kids and is as inclusive as it gets.

TheCrowening · 25/07/2021 14:42

@Rege

Slightly off topic but I think Pilates should be mandatory in all schools.
Yes, I think I’d have done well at this, or Zumba, aerobics or any kind of relaxed dance type activity. I remember doing a half term of gymnastics including dance and ribbon/floor activity and I liked it so much I asked my mum to buy me a ribbon which I practised with at home. Then it was back to the usual athletics/netball/rounders and being shouted at.
GalacticDragonfly · 25/07/2021 14:37

@Fizbosshoes

YABU - not all sports - or coaches - or parents are the same. My DS did junior parkrun this morning. No one was unpleasant, some parents shouted encouragement at their children, it wasnt overly competitive.
Parkrun has been like that since the beginning, both the adult and child events. It’s a shining example of how inclusive sport and exercise can be if inclusion is made the priority. Having been there close to the beginning (when it was still the Bushy Park Time Trial, there were no barcodes and runners names were kept on a paper list), it makes me so happy to see how much it has grown.
Fizbosshoes · 25/07/2021 14:21

YABU - not all sports - or coaches - or parents are the same.
My DS did junior parkrun this morning. No one was unpleasant, some parents shouted encouragement at their children, it wasnt overly competitive.

RampantIvy · 25/07/2021 14:18

@Rege

Slightly off topic but I think Pilates should be mandatory in all schools.
I agree.

What a nasty post @CrazyNeighbour Hmm

MissyB1 · 25/07/2021 14:18

[quote TheCrowening]@CrazyNeighbour you sound like my PE teacher.

You’ve completely missed the point of this thread, again.

It isn’t being shit at sport that was the issue for me (and many others). I was shit at quite a few things at school and been unaffected by it. It was the bullying and belittling that went alongside that.

I don’t blame my PE teacher for “not having a ski piste”. I do blame them for mocking me loudly in front of my classmates, for telling me I was useless, for telling me if I didn’t stay fit and healthy I’d never have babies, and for numerous other similar things.

It’s really no wonder I didn’t want to get on with it, when “it” consisted of two hours of verbal abuse and being made to feel ugly and hopeless.[/quote]
It still goes on in some schools. We moved our ds out of a school last year, one of the reasons was the sports coaching. Ds was in the “C” team, I overheard the coach moaning to the kids “why do I have to coach you losers”.

Mintjulia · 25/07/2021 14:15

I'm glad you'll never be anywhere near my dcs @crazyneighbour, your inability to empathise with those who don't agree with you is worrying.

The whole issue could be solved simply by offering non-competitive exercise at primary school, rather than destroying what little confidence the non-sporty kids have.
In the end, if a small child comes away from a class openly talking about killing them self, I'd say that constituted a problem with the curriculum, wouldn't you!

CrazyNeighbour · 25/07/2021 14:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Rege · 25/07/2021 14:12

Slightly off topic but I think Pilates should be mandatory in all schools.

TheCrowening · 25/07/2021 14:06

@CrazyNeighbour you sound like my PE teacher.

You’ve completely missed the point of this thread, again.

It isn’t being shit at sport that was the issue for me (and many others). I was shit at quite a few things at school and been unaffected by it. It was the bullying and belittling that went alongside that.

I don’t blame my PE teacher for “not having a ski piste”. I do blame them for mocking me loudly in front of my classmates, for telling me I was useless, for telling me if I didn’t stay fit and healthy I’d never have babies, and for numerous other similar things.

It’s really no wonder I didn’t want to get on with it, when “it” consisted of two hours of verbal abuse and being made to feel ugly and hopeless.

Quirrelsotherface · 25/07/2021 13:34

It's football I think you're probably referring to. It has the ability to bring out the absolute worst in people..in coaches and parents and ultimately it's the kids who suffer. For some it's just a massive power trip and yes, a way to constantly push their own kid forward.

CrazyNeighbour · 25/07/2021 13:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Fishkettlesgalore · 25/07/2021 13:29

I feel that PE teachers are getting a bit of a hard time on this thread. Many of them are dealing with trying to organise lessons with very limited resources and infrastructure, increasing time limitations within the curriculum, and let's face it, quite a few pupils (usually teens) who use sport as an opportunity to muck about and try it on a bit.

It is harder trying to instill discipline in pupils in a sports hall or field than in a classroom, and there are more safety aspects to consider too.

Many of these factors may contribute to an individual PE teacher's level of shoutiness and sometimes teaching sport can be a very thankless task if not supported by the school head.

Also, sorry, but at one of my teen's schools, the girls would make up any excuse to avoid PE lessons given the opportunity, and this was in the context of a fairly well resourced sports department that offered climbing, archery, dance, fencing alongside more traditional sports. There truly was something for everything but the PE teacher had to be a bit strict to ensure that teen girls did get their weekly exercise and didn't bunk off!

HighNetGirth · 25/07/2021 13:05

That article quoting John Amaechi is exactly right: organised sport is neutral in itself, good if you have good people and values, bad if you don't.

My DS did karate for a while before we moved house. The ethos of the group and the promise they had to make about not using fighting ability for bad reasons were very good. DS can still recite the credo by heart. Also, having a mixed ability class helped to prevent it becoming too much of a hothouse.

But my experience has been that a lot of organised sport is bad at accommodating different ability levels in a positive way, or at all.

RampantIvy · 25/07/2021 12:57

@Fountainsoftea

I think sometimes, the problem with pe teachers is that they, obviously, were good at sport and probably were on teams all the way through. Idon't think they always get that some kids aren't good at/ don't enjoy sport or don't want to be in teams. Kids in teams tend to have a collective sense of worth and that they are better than others. Ds has a phenomenal vocabulary and impressive grasp of structure and plot when writing. But who gives a shit? He's not part of any teams, so is tolerated by the other lads in his class but also looked down on cos of his lack of football ability.

I'm also not convinced kids who are good at sport work hard in their other subjects. Sometimes it's quite the opposite. Especially those who think they're going to make a career out of it.

Excellent post @Fountainsoftea. I also think some parents don't "get" that some children hate any kind of aport. DD found the set 1 PE kids at her school very cliquey, as were the set 1 PE types in my school 50 years ago. Basically if you were poor at sport you weren't worth talking to.

YABU because there's are coaches and PE teachers who truly inspire and support children through the sports they facilitate

Pity none of them worked at DD’s school. She hated her PE teachers.

I tend to find sporty kids are actually more emotionally resilient and often harder working

Or maybe the harder working more emotionally resilient kids are more sporty? It works both ways. DD was very hard working and has achieved very well academically. She just isn’t sporty, and her lack of enthusiasm was further killed off by the PE teachers at her school.

School PE has been gifting ammunition to bullies for generations, and anyone who blithely assumes it’s harmless is lacking empathy

Sadly, I think this is true in many cases.

Children who are bad at team sports won't be picked for teams. They're constantly the ones being picked last or left sitting on the sidelines. They're not included in matches or games because they're not good enough, so they miss out on friendships and the social aspect of it.

This is true. The more sadistic PE teachers still use this method of team picking. A great way of making someone with low esteem feel even worse about themselves.

Having said all this DD enjoys a game of rounders because she is good at hitting the ball.

Rosebel · 25/07/2021 12:55

It depends. My DC2 has this when she played football and was basically bullied in to leaving.
Never had this at the football where she plays now. She does other s sports (kickboxing and swimming) and there is none of that atmosphere there. So I think it just depends.

CiderLolly · 25/07/2021 12:54

The problem with school PE is that it is far too focused on the traditional team games. My DS wasn't interested in these and therefore the PE teachers had zero interest in him or getting to know him. His school report stated that he needed to take more of an interest in physical activities to make any sort of progress in the subject. They just didn't know he walked miles every weekend in preparation for his Duke of Edinburgh or that he was part of a youth cycling group and climbing group.

Kazzyhoward · 25/07/2021 12:45

@CrazyNeighbour Nothing will toughen you up like sport: if you cannot cope with the fastest runner being the winner when it’s not you, then actually that’s a character flaw in you that you should be addressing not trying to prevent other people from experiencing winning.

Wow, this thread has gone way over your head hasn't it? To repeat what lots of others have said. Kids aren't struggling with the "not winning", they're struggling because people around them are ridiculing them for them not being good at sports, and somehow that's acceptable.

user1497207191 · 25/07/2021 12:40

@CrazyNeighbour You're missing the point. It's isn't not being good at sport that's the problem. It's the way you get ridiculed/abused/bullied because you're not good at it. Most kids can handle not being picked for the school team, just as they can handle not being good at other school subjects, not winning an audition for the school play, not being good enough for the school choir or orchestra. The huge difference with sport is the way that the other pupils (and sadly some teachers) treat you because you've let them down in a competitive school sports game. No one ridicules a pupil for not getting a leading part in a school play, but you're "team-mates" can make your life a living hell if you let the team down! Can't you see the difference???

TheMoth · 25/07/2021 12:40

And 'practising'. In the UK.

Swipe left for the next trending thread