Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To loathe organised sport and what it does to children?

396 replies

AssemblySquare · 24/07/2021 23:29

There is a back story to this but it’s long and boring. I’m just sick and tired of sport being held up as this wonderful thing that brings people together, but all I have ever seen and experienced is divisiveness, bullying and meanness. I’m so done with it all, especially at grass roots level and at school where most kids seem to get shouted at by PE teachers and coaches taking out their own frustrations that they weren’t quite good enough to make it.

OP posts:
Bryonyshcmyony · 25/07/2021 08:02

@SamusIsAGirl

You absolutely can teach callisthetics and body weight lifting.
Yes you can teach it, and dd does it, but she does it in small groups of 10 kids where the teacher can check their form. Very hard and a bit dangerous to do it with a group of 32 not doing it properly.
tttigress · 25/07/2021 08:00

Why doesn't you son try another sport, might be late for football, but early for something like cycling, clay pigeon shooting, golf, Lacrosse, snooker, certain martial arts

Bryonyshcmyony · 25/07/2021 08:00

Team games are an easy way of involving a big group of kids if you have 32 kids of mixed abilities. There is a lot of emphasis on diversity in physical education for teachers now but in practice it's just impossible to do.

sharksarecool · 25/07/2021 08:00

I'm sorry you've had bad experiences. However, as someone who plays organised sport on teams alongside teenagers, I've seen there can be many positive effects for young people. Most adults on thr pitch or tge coaching bench want to encourage young people, but you're right that sometimes problems are caused by parents on the sideline shouting unhelpful, discouraging nonsense. If your DCs like sport, do some research and find a nice club/team (not always the same as thd highest performing ones). Alternatively, encourage them to a different sport: rugby, hockey and cricket all seem to have a much nicer atmosphere and tend to be more nurturing rather than pushy

SamusIsAGirl · 25/07/2021 07:59

You absolutely can teach callisthetics and body weight lifting.

newnortherner111 · 25/07/2021 07:59

My view is that there needs to be a range of sports, the choice of clothing can make a difference to participation and enjoyment, adequate time and facilities for changing help, and perhaps parents should not be able to watch on occasions.

As for exercise more generally, I wish there were ways to disincentivise the short school run.

Kazzyhoward · 25/07/2021 07:58

@AssemblySquare

There is a back story to this but it’s long and boring. I’m just sick and tired of sport being held up as this wonderful thing that brings people together, but all I have ever seen and experienced is divisiveness, bullying and meanness. I’m so done with it all, especially at grass roots level and at school where most kids seem to get shouted at by PE teachers and coaches taking out their own frustrations that they weren’t quite good enough to make it.
Sadly I agree. I suffered years of bullying at my crap comp and a lot of that originated in team sports. All this "team work" crap only works for the sporty kids - the non sporty ones are automatically excluded from working as a team - that breeds resentment among the sporty kids as they don't want the non sporty ones ruining "their team". It also spills over into academic lessons where the "games" teachers also does other subjects - once a teacher has labelled you as being lazy or fat or whatever, they keep that mentality in the classroom too and learning can suffer.

Thankfully, I ended up with a really understanding games teacher for the last 2 years. We should have taken turns going swimming, but he took me aside and asked if I'd prefer to go all the time to avoid the team sports - I jumped at the chance and it did me a world of good - it was something I could do and I got a sense of achievement going through the award scheme.

Bryonyshcmyony · 25/07/2021 07:58

You can't teach kids to lift in the average state school pe lesson.

Northernparent68 · 25/07/2021 07:58

It should n’t be compulsory at school, some people simply can’t play sport

SamusIsAGirl · 25/07/2021 07:57

There is an overfocus on team sports and little focus on basic atheletacism - which would actually boost team sports for those who want to.
I am someone who lifts, does callathetics and is a competent endurance runner and swimmer - but was I any good at school PE - nope. It favours the tall, early developers and popular kids, not the uncoordinated, neurodiverse ones.
It didn't put me off exercise - I am a very physical person who like movement but I still give team games a swerve.

School sport is but a tiny and rubbish selection of all the ways you can move and the fetishization of team games as the one true way is damaging to all.

HeadNorth · 25/07/2021 07:57

YABU to want to ban it because a few kids don't enjoy it.

Did they OP say they wanted to ban it? There is a broad spectrum between something being compulsory and being banned.

Bryonyshcmyony · 25/07/2021 07:55

@NakedAttraction

There are other ways of keeping fit and healthy, therefore I do not believe PE should be a compulsory subject.

Yes there are. But unfortunately too many kids wouldn’t get any exercise at all if they weren’t made to do some PE at school.

This.
SuperCaliFragalistic · 25/07/2021 07:55

I'm not at all sporty. I hated PE at school but I struggled through. The teachers were pretty awful but I guess I'm robust enough that it hasn't left any lasting damage. Some people hate maths or spelling tests but there are some things in life that we just have to put up with. Not every experience is going to be life affirming and fulfilling. My DB loved sport and it was absolutely his favourite thing to do growing up - football, cricket, badminton, anything. My DC have tried a few things, some that they love, some not so much. It can have huge benefits if you allow your children to get into exercise and team games. YABU to want to ban it because a few kids don't enjoy it.

NakedAttraction · 25/07/2021 07:55

There are other ways of keeping fit and healthy, therefore I do not believe PE should be a compulsory subject.

Yes there are. But unfortunately too many kids wouldn’t get any exercise at all if they weren’t made to do some PE at school.

Bryonyshcmyony · 25/07/2021 07:55

Oh and there are kids at the private school who are "crap at sport". Dds best friend is totally uncoordinated and can't catch a ball to save her life but she can cycle so does that instead.

If it's true that all the parents with kids on here that "loathe" team sport really are doing mountain climbing and gymnastics out of school then fine. My experience is thst kids who do ANY sport out of school are usually fit enough to be on school teams even if its not the A team. Kids I knew that hate state school sport normally do absolutely nothing out of school either.

Eatingsoupwithafork · 25/07/2021 07:54

I think healthy competition is important and kids need to learn that they may not win everything- my DN cries if he loses anything and I mean anything because all healthy competition has been cut out at school and he doesn’t do anything extra-curricula to promote healthy competition. It’s just unhealthy and I think in the long run very detrimental.

Trethew · 25/07/2021 07:53

As I child I played tennis, cricket, netball and hockey because that’s what we did at school, and I loathed every single minute. It cast a shadow over my school week and I lived in dread of every games lesson, every match, every minute spent in the changing rooms and showers. I cannot tell you how miserable it made me.

I did not have a particular reason or difficulty, and I was not lazy. I just hated sports. I still do. It was the best thing to come out of lockdown - no sport in the newspapers or radio or tv.

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 25/07/2021 07:51

I like sport. I think it teaches kids discipline, listening, team work and resilience. As well as being physically good for them and getting them outside.

allwrongitsallwrong · 25/07/2021 07:50

@ThePlantsitter

Competitive sport encourages people to give up if they're not good enough to win. It's a crap way to tackle obesity. I'm with you OP. People can do it if they like obvs but I wish there were properly supported alternatives.
This.

The problem is not team sport itself, but that kids are forced to partake in it. Its like anything, its niche and suits some and not others.
If you are not good at competitive sports its bloody awful. Its worst than being awful at something else, as you are forced to be awful publicly, to be labelled by your team mates as 'awful' and to feel social shame and know that you are letting everyone down. So it makes you think ' 'well exercise and activity are not for me.' .

There are loads of ways of being active but this obsessive focus on sport puts off kids who could otherwise have found an activity they like. My son is better than most of his peers at climbing. balance and scrabbling about in nature as we do a lot of it. Sports day though exposes him as 'physically shit' as he is tiny so trails in everything. It really upsets him.

YANBU OP

lljkk · 25/07/2021 07:49

:( your son isn't enjoying footie, OP. It probably is the most competitive team sport he could have chosen, in terms of being good enough to make the starting line up. I hope he finds a different sport to enjoy instead. There really is a huge selection out there of other organised sports to try.

kin432 · 25/07/2021 07:48

I'm saying YABU to loathe it. I can understand that the less sporty kids can find it a negative experience. If possible, I'd say the key is to keep looking for the right club and coach if a child wants to play. It's a lot more fun when you're at the same level as your team mates and opposition. Particularly in rugby when the level of physicality can be so different. We're a sporty family, both my children love team sports and play county/regional level in two. My son was on a performance/regional tennis program but decided to leave when he was 9 partly because it wasn't a team sport. It was also very expensive and I hated the tournaments with crying kids and pushy parents.

Upsides are that it gets them active, they like the team camaraderie and it's a natural outlet for the stress of working hard and exams. Their best memories of school are sports related.

Downsides are that we have no free weekends due to school sport on Saturday and club/county on Sunday, and my husband and I are driving all over the place. Cricket is my least favourite sport they play as it's so long (the adult games are 100 overs/8 hours) and your involvement is dependent on whether or not you get to bowl or bat, whereas you're more involved in hockey and rugby. There's been a few coaches I haven't liked but I'd move clubs or programs in that instance (not the case for school teams).

Bryonyshcmyony · 25/07/2021 07:45

When dd was at state school they rotated sports every half term. She hated the zumba and yoga terms - sexist too, as the boys did martial arts and running for their non team sports. Some girls really enjoyed them. It seemed intrinsically wrong to me to clip a sporty girl's wings in this way so we moved her to private school where she can play football and do athletics and swim every single day and slob around in her pe kit as much as she wants. I feel for state school PE teachers, dd said every lesson was half taken up with the kids that didn't want to do it/ the parents emailing saying that they didn't have to /forgetting their pe kit/just refusing to join in. Must be an absolute nightmare for the teachers. Sport everyday at the private school and you are just expected to do it so they do.

MrsBede · 25/07/2021 07:40

Obviously there are massive benefits to physical activity and sport can be a massive part of that, but it can go horribly wrong as described. I was put off doing any activity by poor PE teaching at school, which just seemed like ritual humiliation to me. I struggle to motivate myself to exercise now and I wish we had done less competitive things. Even something like high jump, though not a team sport, seems pointless and potentially damaging. I can remember being totally unable to do it and would run up and just stop, which was obviously embarrassing. Why did I need to do that though? Surely there are better activities that are easier to succeed at that are more like to promote a love of physical activity - like dance/zumba etc.

Ds1 plays cricket in a team and has struggled with the parents to be honest. When he was captain he got loads of hassle from pushy parents, and now someone else is, their dad, who is also coach, just let his own dc and small number of others dominate every game. It got ridiculous and we were spending hours at places just for ds and others to neither bat nor bowl, at all. A few other parents spoke out and it's a bit better now, but it shows it does bring out the worst in some people. Not all, but some. Then we are told how grateful we need to be to these volunteers. Yes, I appreciate it wouldn't run without them but they should be able to do it in a fair way otherwise it becomes totally toxic and you begin to question the worth of it carrying on for the majority of the kids. Now he's old enough to play for the 4ths, which has a mix of adults, older kids and kids his own age and he says he is enjoying it more than ever as there are no pushy parents and he has found everyone really supportive. No doubt kids' teams can be a nightmare due to the attitudes of some parents.

And it's not just adults who can be awful. I think the kids at cricket have all been fine, though because his club is quite successful lots of private school boys with no links to the area have joined and aren't particularly friendly. That takes away the joy as well - when they are winning and these kids don't give a toss about the club itself. That's a problem with our club though, and not a universal one I know. Ds was also put off playing football at primary school because one of the older kids was allowed to coach and was utterly nasty and hyper-critical. As I said, it can bring out the worst in people and, while that can be managed and isn't a universal thing, it's annoying the way people harp on as if sport is an unfailing force for good that makes everyone resilient and caring and team-focussed and that simply isn't necessarily the case.

As a teacher, I also get irritated at the obsession with sport at school and rewards etc being dominated by those who have done well at sport and every other achievement more or less ignored. Our rewards system has a function where PE teachers can award 50 point, yet everyone else can award a maximum of 5 at any one time! Why can't I recognise an extraordinary essay/ expressive reading etc now and again? Why is it only sport that can be worthy of such a reward? And, yes, I have complained. I appreciate it's not like that everywhere, but it can be and it does more harm than good for those who aren't naturally sporty in terms of promoting a love of exercise.

Velvian · 25/07/2021 07:40

The trouble is @MissyB1, that team sport is one of the best ways for children to exercise, they don't even realise they are exercising, they are having fun and being part of a team. You can push yourself much harder when you are playing as part of a team and training means that you are 'exercising' with your friends.

There are people of all abilities that can get so much out of it.

Insert1x20p · 25/07/2021 07:36

My kids are both ‘B team heroes’ so like playing sport and get involved and always up for a kick about, but definitely not the best players. They both get a lot out of it. For DD in particular, she now has a very diverse friendship group and is not reliant on school for friends, and I have found it limits ‘mean girl’ behaviour as the dynamics of each group is different- the school Queen Bee is usually not also the rugby or gymnastics Queen Bee, especially when the age groups for sport span more than one school year. The netball age groupings cover 2 years and the older girls really mentor and encourage the younger ones.

Maybe we’ve been lucky- the clubs they go to are very encouraging and there are often kids coming in new to the sport at quite late ages. I think soccer is the one where that’s more difficult because it seems to be an outlier in terms of how much kids train at an early age.

In rugby, clubs get fined if parents are dicks to the refs or kids.

At school there is no team picking- they unofficially stream by putting the kids who play outside school together and then the kids who don’t together so people can play at their own level.