Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mixing with deprived children?

329 replies

Thisneedsachange · 24/07/2021 20:04

I’ve changed my name for this but long term mumsnetter. I had a very sheltered but working class background, but mum was a social worker so I was sent to holiday clubs where she was working - with children from very deprived backgrounds and on child protection plans. My life experiences changed when I got a scholarship to private school and it’s been a middle class bubble since then - but I think those early exposures to how tough life can be for some gas the making of me. It’s made me more compassionate, more politically aware and I’ve volunteered since a teen working with deprived children.
My own 5 year old daughter has a very sheltered existence and so I’m thinking of sending her to a free church holiday club at the church I grew up with for a week this summer. It’s free because it’s a very deprived ward. We do have one friend who will go so she will be fine. As a child some things I was exposed to in these schemes aimed at deprived children really shocked me - bad language, bad behaviour, unhappy families..but by my teens I understood what was going on.
Am I unwise to consider this?
I contribute to the funds (although we don’t worship there as not Christian) so not concerned about taking financial advantage, just wondering if I should wait until my daughter is older to have these experiences?

OP posts:
ScrollingLeaves · 24/07/2021 21:04

Five is to young to be randomly placed in a new environment.

scully29 · 24/07/2021 21:03

children from all backgrounds should absolutely absolutely be mixing, but not for a week as a normal thing. And I dont think 5 is too young to mix with anyone I dont see why age is a concern, it should just be proper friendships not visiting.

Thisneedsachange · 24/07/2021 21:02

I’ll definitely not be taking a space from a child who needs it. I’ve been promoting the HAF scheme as part of my volunteer work so in our area (not London but affluent) children who receive pupil premium will be on completely different schemes (quality £50 a day provision, drama, sports, arts) for 4 of the 6 weeks) which is one reason why this free church scheme won’t be full.
My daughter is aware of poverty - we donate her toys, clothes, books , donate to food banks and donate to Christmas toy drives etc. At 5 she isn’t allowed to volunteer at a food bank but she does come with me when we transport furniture for families who are newly housed. She’s kind and generous but she has no idea of the real world. Her school life is a very privileged bubble and whilst we have family friends from my working class background her experiences are so far removed from their children - I want her to see how privileged she is.

OP posts:
lazylump72 · 24/07/2021 21:02

What a fun post ...surely OP Tarquin and Tabetha cannot be away all summer so will be back to entertain your child at some point between lacross and pianoforte recitals? Whilst I agree it would be lovely for you to wait around and have some free entertainment with the have nots,I mean Marcus Rashford could turn up with the packed lunches,just imagine that hey no you couldnt possibly miss out on the education value in that of course you should go,You could teach the kids all about Boden and Joules and the cost of advocardos in waitrose,,,,,there is something so deeply disturbing about your post and choice of language I cannot bear it, Or is it more that you think if it is a free club your taxes will have paid for it and why should you pay 20.00 for your dd to engage with an activity when its been provided free to the others possibly less deserving maybe?? You should be ashamed, Thoroughly ashamed,

30degreesandmeltinghere · 24/07/2021 21:00

Expose your dd? Oh my days...

Pingued · 24/07/2021 21:00

This is so othering

Bagamoyo1 · 24/07/2021 20:58

It’s laughable really - we all want a society in which the challenges faced by some are appreciated and acknowledged by others. We don’t want segregation. We want communities working together, understanding and caring for each other, helping each other out at times of need.
But woe betide you if you try and mix the communities. Oh no - OP must keep her middle class child away from the deprived kids, because it’s patronising to mix with them.

Honestly, I’ve never seen such a load of righteous pompous ranting. Yes 5 is too young, but the principle is good. Children from different backgrounds should have the opportunity to mix. That way they learn how life is for others.

I was a poor kid with a free place at a posh school. Many of my friends had vast sums of money and all sorts of luxuries. But they didn’t see much of their parents, and were palmed off on nannies and guardians. A lot of them were very unhappy about this. I definitely learned a lot from being at that school. And I imagine they learned a few things from me.
That’s what makes us a civilised society, and that is why segregation is wrong.

GloriaSilver · 24/07/2021 20:57

Wow. Just wow. To all of it.

stellaisabella · 24/07/2021 20:56

Fuck me how patronising.
Yes, send your daughter to view the poor kids, like a free day out at a zoo.

Don't take a space from a child who actually needs it, and take a look at what you've written. Those children aren't there to show your child how privileged she is.

GoldBar · 24/07/2021 20:55

Young children value completely different things from adults anyway - who has a cool bag, who is good at football, who gets crisps in their lunch, who gets to play with their friends after school everyday. So your daughter isn't necessarily going to come back with an understanding of how fortunate she is.

viques · 24/07/2021 20:55

@youshallnotpass9

You just had another thread deleted by any chance?
I wondered that, there is something very similar about the style.
Iwastheparanoidex · 24/07/2021 20:54

Deprived children are not a spectator sport learning opportunity . I’m honestly disgusted.

chunderwunder · 24/07/2021 20:53

@Thisneedsachange

Obviously a big no then. I won’t be taking a space from a child who needs it - whilst I don’t worship at this church I volunteer with their children’s outreach and so I know the take up is quite low. I do take my daughter to volunteer with me on other projects but wasn’t planning to volunteer on this one because its discouraged to volunteer on projects your children are attending as it’s unfair on the other children. I spend a lot of time volunteering for children’s social justice projects - didn’t realise I come across as so cringingly patronising so at least this thread has made me aware of that, thanks all
You volunteer a lot, presumably because you want to help children. I wonder if you feel guilty about your privileged upbringing.

If you're serious about both bringing your child up without a sense of entitlement and making society a more equitable place then I assume you're sending your kid to state school?

Because if you're not, you're just perpetuating the injustices you rail against and no one should take any of your hand-wringing seriously.

PinniGig · 24/07/2021 20:53

I sort of / kind of understand what you're trying to do (think anyway) but agree with everyone else it's a bit taking the actual piss to take up another kid's place for the sake of teaching your child about how the poorer people live and it doesn't reflect well on you at all sadly.

Makes me imagine Catherine Tate's Aga Saga Woman having an absolute meltdown over things like the lack of good Brie, frozen food and agency nannies from the North.

My kids grew up like country bumpkins and were horrified to visit my old haunts cos I grew up in a rough ass council estate with no money and I mean – NO MONEY and we lived like scoundrels and little shits basically.

They were lucky to grow up and live in a more affluent area and they understood from a very young age that others aren't so lucky. I wouldn't dream of sending them anywhere to experience what is reserved for disadvantaged or underprivileged kids as a means of giving them a first hand real life horrors of eating smiley faces and spaghetti hoops Shock

I think I get what you mean or where you're going with it.

I don't think it's at all wise to go any further with it though.

Jaguar77 · 24/07/2021 20:53

Couldn't you take her to a " deprived children" petting zoo?

Souther · 24/07/2021 20:53

@Hoppinggreen

“deprived” children are not a learning experience for your child.
This.

It's not a spectator sport

workshy44 · 24/07/2021 20:52

Oh dear .. virtue signaling post gone bad

PicsInRed · 24/07/2021 20:52

If you put your child in, you then wouldn't volunteer, so then they'll suddenly be down a volunteer, which surely means less spaces due to ratios.

Poor people's lives aren't your gratitude journal.

Highfive2021 · 24/07/2021 20:51

@Bagamoyo1

OP you’re not being patronising, you’re being considerate. Ignore the righteous indignation on this thread.
Considerate of who?
Mamanyt · 24/07/2021 20:51

I voted YANBU, but...you are, in the sense that you will be taking a spot from a child who desperately needs it. You are not in that you want to teach your child that others do not have the comfortable life she enjoys. Perhaps there is a soup kitchen where she can volunteer (WITH YOU) one day a month, or some other such endeavor? She'll learn the same lessons, but without making a deprived child even MORE deprived.

AgnesNaismith · 24/07/2021 20:51

I also hope you know how thin the line is between rich and poor. And that money doesn’t make you better than other people.

rattlemehearties · 24/07/2021 20:50

Surely sending your daughter to state school will be enough to give her an insight into a diverse mix?

MichelleScarn · 24/07/2021 20:50

OK op if you are genuine, and want her to experience how 'deprived children live' go to lidl or somewhere with £25, live on what you can buy with that for a week, no treats, no days out for the hols, am sure other people on the thread can give other examples and ideas.

OuiOuiKitty · 24/07/2021 20:50

@Bagamoyo1

OP you’re not being patronising, you’re being considerate. Ignore the righteous indignation on this thread.
Who exactly is she being considerate of?
Bagamoyo1 · 24/07/2021 20:50

@Hellocatshome

For those who are ranting - there’s nothing “experimental” about learning about how other people live. It’s important for all of us to have some knowledge of the challenges faced by our fellow human beings. It helps develop empathy, and makes us a more civilised society.

Yes but a 5 year old going to a holiday club with other 5 year olds is not teaching anyone anything. She will probably just have a lovely time and learn nothing abiut the hardships those 5 year olds are facing.

Yes if you read my other post you’d see I said I wouldn’t send her.