Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mixing with deprived children?

329 replies

Thisneedsachange · 24/07/2021 20:04

I’ve changed my name for this but long term mumsnetter. I had a very sheltered but working class background, but mum was a social worker so I was sent to holiday clubs where she was working - with children from very deprived backgrounds and on child protection plans. My life experiences changed when I got a scholarship to private school and it’s been a middle class bubble since then - but I think those early exposures to how tough life can be for some gas the making of me. It’s made me more compassionate, more politically aware and I’ve volunteered since a teen working with deprived children.
My own 5 year old daughter has a very sheltered existence and so I’m thinking of sending her to a free church holiday club at the church I grew up with for a week this summer. It’s free because it’s a very deprived ward. We do have one friend who will go so she will be fine. As a child some things I was exposed to in these schemes aimed at deprived children really shocked me - bad language, bad behaviour, unhappy families..but by my teens I understood what was going on.
Am I unwise to consider this?
I contribute to the funds (although we don’t worship there as not Christian) so not concerned about taking financial advantage, just wondering if I should wait until my daughter is older to have these experiences?

OP posts:
chunderwunder · 24/07/2021 21:54

@Tealightsandd

Middle class private school children can be deprived too

Well of course. Any child can be deprived. From any background. I work in education. My specialism is inclusion. I doubt there's anything you could ever tell me about deprivation in childhood.

My point is simply that private school education teaches entitlement. Which it does. That's literally what it aims to do.

Your post seems full of non-sequiturs and not really anything to do with mine.

Raaaaaaarr · 24/07/2021 21:53

What I mean below by not intentional is that my parents didn't try to engineer my friendships and so I made friends with all walks of life so maybe just let your child form natural friendships

PinniGig · 24/07/2021 21:53

I will never forget my then 5yr old daughter nearly breaking her heart and wanting to give her pocket money to the children whose parents own the local Indian restaurant. She just assumed in her innocence and ignorance that all brown children were like those seen on TV and had no money, no food or water and it broke her heart to think of these two going without.

She and both kids ended up quite good friends but that level of empathy, awareness and understanding of how lucky they are was generally made clear to them in a general every sort of sense rather than us having to force or make any issue of it.

Every Christmas morning before they came downstairs we reminded them not to be upset or too disappointed if Father Christmas hadn't been to ours and left presents. They still would have presents from us but he has to give priority to children that don't have parents and aren't lucky to have anyone else that will give them presents.

Neither of them bothered or bitched and even one year when we hid the two bikes they were going mad for and pretended Father Christmas hadn't been able to leave them any, they didn't bother just “It's OK we still have lots more presents and the old bike to share”

Daughter heading over to the Indian kids with her heart shredded though oh fuck me... glad I managed to stop her before she started throwing pennies at them.

Raaaaaaarr · 24/07/2021 21:50

I don't think this was intentional but my parents let me make friends as a child with who ever I wanted and some of those kids came from very poor backgrounds so I naturally saw all sides of life. I would see how other people's home lives might be when I went over to play. I think some sort of forced scenario is not quite right and not sincere. I know you mean well but it's a bit like taking your kid to a soup kitchen for a day. Agree also with others that it takes away a place for a kid who really needs it too.

Namenic · 24/07/2021 21:48

High-five - I meant that there are problems in all circumstances. Nothing wrong with being non-academic. Some may hate school Due to not being engaged and truant. Some academic kids may truant too. I wouldn’t mind my kids being friends with people who truanted - my dad did a bit; but I would want them to truant themselves.

chunderwunder · 24/07/2021 21:48

Someone can be both ignorant and kind though

This is true. I think it might be a fair description of the OP. She's completely tone deaf, obviously, but I do think she genuinely thinks she's helping to alleviate injustice.

I don't think she can help being patronising, she's a product of a private education. She's behaving exactly as she's been trained.

  • Not that much though obviously else she'd take her kid out of fee-paying school.
Tealightsandd · 24/07/2021 21:45

@chunderwunder

What this really demonstrates is privileged people's sheer inability to view anyone as anything other than their wealth or status.

OP literally thinks that poor/working class/deprived people are 'other'.

This goes to the root of why private school is so pernicious. It destroys empathy.

Oh dear. You nearly got it right. And then you had to go and ruin it by showing up your own prejudiced stereotyping.

Middle class private school children can be deprived too. Abuse and neglect might be more hidden (in no small part thanks to ignorant stereotyping) but it can and does happen to children who go to private schools.

OP is a gift (perhaps intentional) to people who love to take any opportunity to indulge in a bit of inverse snobbery.

Badabingbadabum · 24/07/2021 21:44

No, you'll be taking a place from someone who really needs a free childcare place. Plus all the other reasons why its a really stupid idea. I think it is called poverty tourism.

Iwastheparanoidex · 24/07/2021 21:43

That’s a link to a bbc programme where they were re-enacting Victorian slums and tourists came round.

Watch that.

Iwastheparanoidex · 24/07/2021 21:42

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p04cb9wt

Pingued · 24/07/2021 21:41

@Wishingwell75

What a shame there are travel restrictions this summer - otherwise you could have taken your 5 year old to South Africa, India or Brasil - all 3 of these countries have "slum" tours and you could've combined a bit of poverty tourism with some world travel! Never mind, maybe your five year old child will make some friends at the church and she can go round their council house for tea - providing mum's been to the food bank that day of course! Won't you have lots to chat about at bedtime OP, when you recount tales of how nanny used to let you mix with the families she used to work with, yes the popular experiments that qualified csw's were known to do and in no way would've have broken any safeguarding guidelines at all!
I was about to say it reminds me of slum/poverty tourism.
Kanaloa · 24/07/2021 21:40

@ScrollingLeaves

Okay, well she sounds ignorant and with a total lack of empathy. If you think seeing deprived children as a learning experience for her privileged 5 year old is deeply kind then that’s your opinion I guess.

Schnauzersaremyheros · 24/07/2021 21:40

Op, your post reeks of voyeurism Hmm

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 24/07/2021 21:40

I volunteer with their children’s outreach and so I know the take up is quite low

In that case, it's completely fine.

Fwiw: I grew up similar to OP, working class but relatively sheltered and tagging along to play schemes and days out for "deprived" kids because my Dad had organised them or volunteered with them

I'm now "respectable" working class to lower middle class and living on a "deprived" housing estate.
This is not unusual btw. Not everyone on an estate is completely skint. There's more class variation than you might expect.
My kids go to the free summer holiday scheme, they go to to free after school scheme. One year they were the only white kids at the free scheme put on by Sierra Leonian community. Absolutely noone gives a shit.

Sometimes these things are funded with the intention of tackling food poverty or dealing with social exclusion or whatever but they're never described that way to the end user. Or noone would go to them.

And, while you don't want the place overrun with middle class mums, to the extend it puts others off....it's also not helpful if everyone is skint, or known to have problems. Because then it becomes stigmatising and people start avoiding it.

I say crack on OP. Send your kid and donate what you can afford behind the scenes.

Miniestelle · 24/07/2021 21:40

These families do not exist for you and your life. How would you feel if they knew what your plan was? It's so disrespectful to them. You want to engage with them but from a position of power. Not as equal human beings with dreams and ambitions just like you have. If I found out you were doing this at my son's summer club i would feel humiliated, sick and so angry. In fact I would complain to whoever you volunteer with.

Wishingwell75 · 24/07/2021 21:39

What a shame there are travel restrictions this summer - otherwise you could have taken your 5 year old to South Africa, India or Brasil - all 3 of these countries have "slum" tours and you could've combined a bit of poverty tourism with some world travel!
Never mind, maybe your five year old child will make some friends at the church and she can go round their council house for tea - providing mum's been to the food bank that day of course!
Won't you have lots to chat about at bedtime OP, when you recount tales of how nanny used to let you mix with the families she used to work with, yes the popular experiments that qualified csw's were known to do and in no way would've have broken any safeguarding guidelines at all!

Bluntness100 · 24/07/2021 21:39

@Whatwouldnanado

You sound like a deeply kind person who spends a lot of time working for the good of others. Carry on, let your daughter tag along when she can. Her awareness will grow naturally, trust her intelligence. Who knows she may continue with your good work. Some sort of forced situation is wrong on the many levels already explained to you here.
It sounds deeply snobbish to me.
ScrollingLeaves · 24/07/2021 21:38

“Kanaloa

She doesn’t sound ‘deeply kind,’ she sounds totally ignorant.”

Someone can be both ignorant and kind though.

Highfive2021 · 24/07/2021 21:38

when kids are young they sometimes are not that aware/sensitive - so may unintentionally hurt/offend people

Some people never grow out of it would seam, imagine being exposed to peers who are not academic or into gaming Hmm

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/07/2021 21:37

Why am I thinking Edina and Saffy?

Bluntness100 · 24/07/2021 21:37

You want her to see how privileged she is?

She’s five. What you’re posting is abnormal and concerning. It shows a lack of any form of grounding or basis in reality.

2LostSoulsSwimmingInAFishBowl · 24/07/2021 21:37

It makes me very uncomfortable that someone who is an outreach volunteer with any kind of vulnerable people would think that they could or should provide some kind of “learning experience” for their kid. Like a “here’s what you could have won but aren’t you lucky that you were born middle class and therefore don’t swear and misbehave like these deprived children do?”

Ugh Envy

user1471443411 · 24/07/2021 21:36

Actually though I don't think there is anything wrong with putting your child in any holiday playscheme with spaces, it is just the way the op is written that seems a bit off.

RickJames · 24/07/2021 21:35

This has actually got my dander up.

Imagine the OP saying "hmm, I'm not sure i want my kid mixing with Jews or Muslims - maybe she'll hear something I think is icky?"

It's not right, is it?

And I said something stupid in my last comment - I said "well im working class and I'm not poor blah blah blah". That was also wrong. Goodness is, and should always be separated from economic circumstances. I fell into the trap there, sorry.

Money does not equal good qualities.

WildWestWanda · 24/07/2021 21:35

I think you probably started this thinking you’d get a big pat on the back, but you actually come across as a bit of a dick