Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think society judges the most about others?

203 replies

AnnaBellaCruella · 24/07/2021 17:36

Is it race, religion, status or lifestyle? In my experience it’s how one parents. What’s your experience?

OP posts:
humadum · 25/07/2021 09:28

This country's obsession with class often amuses me, until I realise again that there are deep-seated inequalities based on social stratification.

In fact, recently, I completed that old BBC 'What Class Are You?' quiz. I trusted that it would be relatively unbiased and quite reliable, because it was from the BBC. I filled it in (reasonably accurately) and came out as a 'Pleb'! '

'What the F*!' sorry, 'Oh Dickens!' I thought, 'How can this be?'. So, I did it again, but just altered the earnings category (because I identify as being rich, and I should respect that). I came out as 'Elite'.

Obviously, the quiz is nonsensical, but according to recent reports, Britain is the fifth most unequal country in Europe (in terms of economic equality), and in a Capitalist society, money if the commodity that can get us all those things upon which we may be 'judged' (private dentistry for great teeth; lovely clothes to flatter our body shape, top class education, property and so on). So perhaps, indirectly, all our judgements are made on the basis of perceived and possible wealth.

MarcusRashford · 25/07/2021 09:26

I have two examples where the class argument is proved in my opinion.

The area I now live is home to some exceptionally wealthy people, in homes worth circa £15m +. I am not one of them! I clean for them. They educate their children at Eton and think nothing of throwing 6 figures on a party. They are truly horrible people, they believe they ‘own’ their staff and they believe we are not free to be employed elsewhere. One former employee was bullied to almost breaking point because they resigned - she worked her notice because she believed it to be the right thing but I’m not sure how she did it. They believe they are a higher form of human!

Another example is a former colleague. He was from a working class background. He got a good job that enabled him to buy a Jag on PCP and get a new kitchen on HP. He now tells everyone he’s middle class.

I hate the class in our society but anyone who says it doesn’t exist is deluding themselves. It’s mostly around money.

Blossomtoes · 25/07/2021 09:11

@EspressoDoubleShot

Oh do stop all the faux naïveté. Posting What’s class?who am I? It’s Tiresome and contrived I note you mentioned “professional qualifications and earn six figures” why? If you’re classless why’s that matter? Unless you’re suggesting class ascendency
You’re absolutely obsessed with class. Get rid of that chip.
MrsMillhouse · 25/07/2021 08:50

@EspressoDoubleShot you’re a bit fired up over what someone else says their class is.

Anyway, i don’t think it is always clear what class people are: different tools have different results for many people.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 08:44

I hesrd somewhere that you can't change class from what you were born. Hence people in very high paod professionals jobs talking about being WC?
I know someone who never forgets to mention they are WC and got to uni and got to do x and y as WC so omg because of WC. I am baffled by that tbh

toolazytothinkofausername · 25/07/2021 08:40

Weight and appearance.

thecatsabsentcojones · 25/07/2021 08:39

@StripyGiraffes I agree with you. The whole class concept is bullshit, we desperately need to get over it as a nation.

And you’re right, is it latter accomplishment and money that defines you or where you came from? If you’re brought up working class but earn well in a professional career have you then transcended to middle class? Would that stand if that person still has the perceived as working class accent? If they use the wrong words or have too many tattoos?

It’s not a simple categorisation as you say.

Mummadeze · 25/07/2021 08:39

I judge people with right wing views. I can’t help it.

Onlinedilema · 25/07/2021 08:36

I think initially it’s appearance. Then other factors such as behaviour.

Ajl46 · 25/07/2021 08:29

Written language skills (ie correct use of grammar etc on social media).

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 08:28

That was reply to the first post about class beibg like a religion

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 08:27

@StripyGiraffes I am woth you on that. It's also bit of a self fulfilling prophecy mixed in. "I am wc so I can't just go to uni/do x job/do y". I said it once here. If I grew up in UK my brother and I would be fucked because of this.

MondeoFan · 25/07/2021 08:25

I'm going to say
Teeth - people judge if you don't have nice teeth
Dogs - what breed of dog you have
Shoes - it's still a thing
Car - i never noticed until I got a much nicer expensive car now I've seen how people treat me differently

MondeoFan · 25/07/2021 08:23

@MarcusRashford yes it's like that where I live too. Wealthy Area - small village. I Own 2 cars both bought outright. Lots of people in huge cars probably on pcp look down their nose at me, seemingly because I work. Lots of mums at the school don't appear to work.
My child dresses nice, they still look down on me.
Even down to dogs. Everyone has Cavapoo, Cockapoo type dogs that they think are making them better than you when they are a crossbreed.

SourAppleChew · 25/07/2021 04:25

Definitely appearance.

Almost every age group judges by appearance, whilst teenagers for example wouldn’t give a shit how you parent.

StripyGiraffes · 25/07/2021 04:10

@EspressoDoubleShot

Persist as you wish, with the assertions you don’t have a class *@stripy* Interesting to note you spontaneously volunteered your 6figure salary and professional qualification. Both markers of class. But no you don’t understand class….ok if you say so
Which were achieved later in life after an abusive childhood following by years of grinding poverty with no heating, electricity cutting off regularly, often no food and then sometimes homelessness. Those parts you wish to ignore because due to your political take on it all you want to fit people into separate cateogories but it's not as black and white as you imagine. Lots of people's lives move between these financial situations, upwards and downwards - it's not a one way street. There but for the grace of God I go again.

So is it just about money to you then? When you say "class" what you mean is money? That's what your posts imply. Then people change class as they get more or less money?

Genuinely, I do not get what you mean by "class". To me it is meaningless as people, their attitudes, their jobs, the circumstances and their finances can change a lot over time so if there is some immutable "class" that isn't any of those things please define it.

Megasausagehead · 25/07/2021 03:15

I judge judgy people.

Not actual Judges.

People who consider themselves above x, y, z because blah, blah, blah.

I judge myself for being intolerant of judgy types too. Except where based in arrogance.

Guineapigbridge · 25/07/2021 03:12

Weight
Class

EspressoDoubleShot · 25/07/2021 03:09

Persist as you wish, with the assertions you don’t have a class @stripy
Interesting to note you spontaneously volunteered your 6figure salary and professional qualification. Both markers of class. But no you don’t understand class….ok if you say so

StripyGiraffes · 25/07/2021 03:05

@EspressoDoubleShot

You’re very contrived. No I won’t tell you what class you are. You figure it out Look at your own prompts,see where that leads you 6 figure salary Professional qualification Your background
Aha. Ok. So you pick the bits you want to see and ignore the rest.

All clear now.

That stuff was all done in later life. So in your opinion upbringing, abuse, poverty etc aren't relevant if you later manage to drag yourself out? So class changes when you get qualifications and more income? What does "class" actually mean then, what you end up earning and nothing to do with background at all?

This is why I don't understand it. People will use the word one way when it suits them and another way another time, so to me, it is meaningless these days as life isn't fixed into groups like that anymore.

TravelDreamLife · 25/07/2021 03:03

Everything. It doesn't matter what you look like, how you parent, how much you earn, where you live, where you holiday, people will judge you for it.

Why? Because they're a snob, they're projecting their own feelings of inadequacy or ego, jealousy or boredom. Or whatever controversy is highlighted in the news.

StripyGiraffes · 25/07/2021 03:02

Is it based on upbringing, poverty in childhood, access to experiences, money, occupational status, educational level, accent, what? My point is that for many people these are not all one way and also change over time, so your categorisation of people is meaningless as well as offensive and naive.

EspressoDoubleShot · 25/07/2021 02:59

You’re very contrived. No I won’t tell you what class you are. You figure it out
Look at your own prompts,see where that leads you
6 figure salary
Professional qualification
Your background

StripyGiraffes · 25/07/2021 02:58

@EspressoDoubleShot

Oh do stop all the faux naïveté. Posting What’s class?who am I? It’s Tiresome and contrived I note you mentioned “professional qualifications and earn six figures” why? If you’re classless why’s that matter? Unless you’re suggesting class ascendency
Because you were asking me to say what "class" I am from. I am saying IMO "class" is a nonsense notion from another century so I've described by circumstances in answer to your questions and said what class am I then? What's it based on?? It's pathetic, trying to divide people into groups like that. They make no sense these days.
StripyGiraffes · 25/07/2021 02:56

And yet when I was little we had lovely foreign holidays, I've travelled all over the globe etc. But then I've known real hunger. A PP mentioned her mother searching down the back of the sofa in 70s/80s to look for coins to buy bread and said people wouldn't believe it yet I was doing this as a teenager alone in the '90s! So you tell me, what "class" am I, according to you? The whole thing is nonsense and a horrible way of dividing people. It's totally incomprehensible to people from most other countries and people in the UK really need to get over it IMO and move on to dealing with our actual socio-economic issues that have nothing to do with these outdated prejudices.