Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think some people are precious and quite self indulged about their birthdays?

66 replies

ItsAllGettingReallyTediousNow · 24/07/2021 16:45

I’ve never understood why some adults get very upset when their birthday is not acknowledged on a carnival level. I’d be upset if my parents, DH or DC forgot or my siblings didn’t send me a card, but that’s it. I’ve seen some real diva behaviour surrounding birthdays.

For example, my SIL once had a massive strop and banned my MIL from visiting us around her birthday as she wouldn’t be there for hers. She’s a middle age woman. That meant MIL wasn’t invited to my DC’s birthday parties when they were young as their birthdays are days apart and PIL would have had to stay over.

A few months ago my friend announced on SM that birthdays are so important and that she was throwing a big 50th bash and we all had to come to her party and stay the weekend. She didn’t even acknowledge mine, despite others on SM doing so and so I reckon she had turned off my notifications. I said something along the lines of, “yes I know, was my 50th back in March”, and she’s not contacted me since as obviously it was a pop at her.

Finally, the worst one is my MIL. For her birthday she expects weekends away, joint holidays, days out at least, a present and a massive fuss. She expects phone call after phone call acknowledging her birthday from extended family. However when it comes to her own DH, DC or DGC, she does nothing. I’ve rarely had a card off her, never a present. I used to indulge her, thinking she’d catch on that this works both ways, but it didn’t, so I stopped indulging her and she takes massive offence from the perceived slight.

So, what is it about some people that they think their birthdays are really special, but no one else’s are? AIBU?

OP posts:
HappyWipings · 24/07/2021 19:49

I like a low key birthday , I recently had a significant birthday and requested a takeaway , some cupcakes from Lola's and various fabric for sewing. But that's just me , if others are comfortable with all eyes on them and want to get dressed up for multiple events that's okay too. Other people's birthday celebrations can be really fun.

Mansplainee · 24/07/2021 19:43

YANBU, I find it really childish and self-obsessed when adults expect everyone to make a huge fuss of their birthdays. I always make sure to do something nice on my birthday with DH, but don’t expect anyone else to give a shit.

My MIL always expects massive acknowledgment of her birthday and starts talking about it months in advance. She turned 60 a few years back and literally had 12 months of celebrations including parties, multiple meals out and 3 holidays. Every occasion got turned into a pseudo celebration of MIL, including a meal that I booked for my own DMs birthday.

Jerseygirl12 · 24/07/2021 19:43

I always plan lots of treats for myself on my birthday, a party for a big birthday and a 5 star mini break with a whole day of lovely activities for all my other birthdays (except for this year). I like to be made a fuss off because I’m worth it. Some of my friends wait around for their DH’s to plan something for them and then say they want no presents and moan when they get none.

Yuckyfinger · 24/07/2021 19:40

Most people I know in RL would mark their birthday in some way - going out with friends or having a meal with family, or possibly a party or weekend away for a milestone birthday.

Yesterday I went out for drinks for a work colleagues birthday.
On MN if you want more than a Tesco value or card factory card and a bag of pork scratchings you are being an entitled diva!!

Lemonmelonsun · 24/07/2021 19:36

I agree op!
I was most surprised when one nct lady said very matter of fact "every Xmas Dec gets stripped down on boxing day early am for dh bday"..

What planet are we on that a grown man can't cope with Xmas Dec's on his bday GrinConfused

Poor kids!! "

AdoptedBumpkin · 24/07/2021 19:32

In a word, yes. If it's not a notable birthday then I can't make too much of a thing of them.

RoseMartha · 24/07/2021 19:29

I like to spend the day with my dc and my Sister and her family. Sometimes as a day out but not always.

I wouldnt want a big party for a birthday ending in 0. But I dont like fuss and being centre of attention,

I guess everyone like something different

Parttimemostofthetime · 24/07/2021 19:20

I always spoil my loved ones on their birthdays and make a big fuss of myself on mine. I dont expect others to bother with mine though but it's just an excuse to have a day or two doing some of the things I've been wanting to do for a while but haven't got round to due to being busy.

MadCattery · 24/07/2021 19:18

I never understood it, either. Turned 60 last year, and only DH and DS really cared. A card from closest friend. I am always surprised to hear co-workers say they are taking the day off for their birthday. Adults. Whatever. Most of my co-workers don’t have any idea when it’s my birthday and I wouldn’t expect them to.

NoYOUbekind · 24/07/2021 18:54

Well two things can be true at once: your in-laws can be absolutely bat-shit birthday crazy; and people can have a fuss on their birthdays if they want. I definitely fall into the second camp - I like a fuss, never got it as a child (early Jan birthday) and now make sure it happens as an adult. However, I would never behave like your ILs.

Fizbosshoes · 24/07/2021 18:47

My DH has just had a milestone birthday. On the day the only cards he received were from me and our DC. I think FIL phoned the day before, the rest of his family have not acknowledged it. I was pretty gutted on his behalf!

Popcornriver · 24/07/2021 18:47

I don't think your examples are unreasonable at all. But I also don't think there's anything self-indulgent, spoilt or entitled about enjoying your own birthday. Or being upset if it's ignored.

HopeForTheBestExpectTheWorst · 24/07/2021 18:43

Well I love celebrating my birthday! I love picking nice things to do or where to go eat etc but I am absolutely "in charge" of my own day and I don't expect other people to independently give a shit - I invite people to come out or over or whatever because it's my birthday, not at all bothered about birthdays but am ridiculously pleased about anything that I might get (a box of chocolates or a bottle of wine are ALWAYS appreciated)

Macncheeseballs · 24/07/2021 18:43

Birthdays are important, what's so wrong with celebrating a person's existence and making them feel cared for

LuaDipa · 24/07/2021 18:39

I always make a huge fuss of my friends and loved ones on their birthdays. Spoiling people brings me joy and people respond in kind. It’s fine for you to not want a fuss but you really should understand that we are not all the same.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 24/07/2021 18:29

@SmidgenofaPigeon

Yes, but I think I have a chip on my shoulder from having a January 4th birthday- no one cares/is broke after Christmas/is on a diet of off alcohol. So years and years of not being made a fuss of 😂

I don’t care really now I’m older. A friend of mine has a ‘birthday week’ even though she’s 37 which I always thought was ridiculous.

That's nothing. My SIL talks about her 'birthday month' with a completely straight face and genuinely thinks she is being helpful by circulating a wedding registry-style gift list in the months leading up to it Confused
Opaljewel · 24/07/2021 18:28

I'd say people expecting what they don't give out are cfs! However, I also think if someone does want to do an extravagant affair about their birthday or want a bit of attention, then that's up to them. Let people do what they want. If these people who do not reciprocate but expect lots on their days, just ignore it all. Simple as that.

I do like my birthday to be noticed by immediate family (as I always do theirs as I love to make a fuss of them) we are talking my partner, mum and sis. But anyone else is a bonus and I'm grateful if they do. And I always return the gestures as I believe it's a kind thing to do.

AnneLovesGilbert · 24/07/2021 18:23

You say you’re not jealous but this does sound more like it’s you being nose out of joint about people not making enough fuss of your birthdays. Otherwise you wouldn’t bring up how you’ve been overlooked, twice. Or posted about your 50th as an apparent pop at your friend.

If you really didn’t care you wouldn’t care.

Also fine to say you only expect effort from your husband and kids, but not everyone has either and having their friends celebrate them for one day a year means a lot.

dottymac · 24/07/2021 18:20

Mines is 6 jan and I never got a fuss either. Wonder if that's why I'm so anti-fuss as an adult. 🤔

dottymac · 24/07/2021 18:16

Yes I hear you! It's when people proclaim 'its my birthday week'. You get a day! You're not the queen of Sheba, well done for being born. Goes hand in hand with people and their all consuming wedding events - 3 hen weekends and a year of bending over backwards to accommodate their every whim because it's their special time. Nah, off you pop. 👎

ItsAllGettingReallyTediousNow · 24/07/2021 18:16

I don’t think I am jealous. I think it’s childish. Also, I don’t think extended family indulge them out of love. I think they do it because they know they’ll get hit by a toy as it leaves the pram. Also, I’d actually be embarrassed if everyone sat round giving me presents and singing happy birthday. I’m not 4.

I think birthdays are an excuse for my DC and DH to show they care, but more of an intimate day between me and my parents, remembering the day they brought me into the world.

OP posts:
Betsythecheshirecat · 24/07/2021 17:54

I have two friends like this. One rationalised it as she is single and therefore doesn't get a fuss made over her any other day of the year. This year was a big birthday and she had a birthday month as opposed to her usual birthday week.

Once she organised a birthday lunch out and got so cross when loads of people couldn't make it. This year it fell on a work day and she expected people to take the day off work.

I think I'd actually like a bit more of a fuss made about me for my birthday so maybe I am jealous.

Roomonb · 24/07/2021 17:51

YANBU, I like to go to a spa by myself then have a quiet evening. I don’t care much for presents, I buy what I want for myself, I don’t particularly like things I’m meh about cluttering up my living space.

BUT I get that we all care about things and therefore for some people it may be a very important event which for them signals love from their nearest and dearest. However I would expect those people to show the same level of interest in others as they demand from themselves.

SparkyTheCat · 24/07/2021 17:47

I hear you OP. My DM has a December birthday, and as a child would receive combined birthday/Christmas presents. For that I do have sympathy. 70 years later and the offenders all long dead, however, she's still punishing her own family with sulks and tantrums should even the tiniest detail of The Birthday not go to exact plan. Flowers for you OP, it's like dealing with a stroppy toddler.

CrouchEndTiger12 · 24/07/2021 17:47

I'm a bit precious about mine and no one ever made an effort for me in childhood.

My sister got musicals, days out, god knows what. I got nothing arranged. Unequal treatment in childhood really stays with you.

I like to make up for it.