Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be honest with him that I was disappointed?

290 replies

honestjon · 24/07/2021 16:19

(Not in the U.K. so it's gone midnight where I am)

I've been dating a man for a while and we spent the first overnight together last night. Not, by any means, the first time we'd had sex. But the first time we'd physically slept next to each other.

There was absolutely nothing in the course of the interaction that indicated it was anything but a positive experience on both sides. We left on great terms this morning. All great.

However, I've not heard from him since. Very unusual as we usually keep in touch a lot.

Both of us were busy today but he's gone to play golf with a friend, so when we parted ways this morning, I said 'enjoy golf, let me know whether you win!'.

It's so trivial and possible insignificant but also very very unsettling to have not heard a thing. We've certainly not gone a day without talking before in the 3 months we've known each other.

I'd like to communicate to him that I felt this was a bit disappointing after spending the night together. I am not looking to tell him off, rather just to tell him honestly that it felt a bit disappointing/unsettling after spending the night together.

My logic is that either he has gone off me, in which case whether I say it or not is irrelevant (and may open the door for him to be honest) or he simply didn't realise it was important, in which case raising it should surely be part of good communication about my expectations.

And, of course, the obvious thing is that I've not contacted him either. However, I feel like as women there's an expectation to wait for a man to come to you, so it doesn't seem needy etc. Similarly, I did leave him on the 'let me know how your golf game goes!' note, which I felt opened the door for him to contact me if he wanted to.

My gawd I really hate dating sometimes!!!

OP posts:
honestjon · 26/07/2021 09:58

@CrouchEndTiger12 harassing him??? I literally dropped a polite note to say he'd be very quiet and said that in my experience, that tended to indicate less enthusiasm to keep dating, and was that the case, just so everyone was clear where they stood.

I don't see how on earth that's harassing someone! I was hardly outside his door demanding answers.

OP posts:
Funk2funky · 26/07/2021 09:58

You aren’t getting clarity though. He’s just saying things are fine, then doing it again. As others say, look at his actions and not his words.

Funk2funky · 26/07/2021 09:56

When you need to start a thread on this and defend your actions etc etc just throw this one back

CrouchEndTiger12 · 26/07/2021 09:56

I have never once had a man tell me I need more contact that they can give. Not once.

That means leave me alone and you really should.

honestjon · 26/07/2021 09:55

@allycat4

Don't you see though - it shouldn't be this much effort!
Of course! But for me it's less effort to ask and get clarity, than to spend days wondering where he is.

Even if you were to say 'well keep busy, don't wonder'....we all know this isn't how such things work. I'm constantly busy, have a ton of friends, my kids and many hobbies (and I'm dating others) and I'd still have had this at the back of my mind.

OP posts:
BigButtons · 26/07/2021 09:55

@RadandMad I had pretty much the same thing happen at the start of my relationship now.
@honestjon you can be sure that he is finding the time to make other texts and calls. People make the time if they want to. It takes seconds to send a text. He is choosing not to contact you. Let this one go now and retain your dignity and self respect.
Best of luck to you🙂

CrouchEndTiger12 · 26/07/2021 09:55

If he is scared off by my asking why he went from 100s of messages per day to basically none, I don't want to date him. I hate the thought of just putting up and shutting up for the sake of keeping someone interested.

Well he isn't interested and if you need him to tell you that instead of you leaving him the hell alone then it's really quite embarrassing.

You don't want to date him, he's gone off you. Fgs stop harassing him just because you want to force it out of him. There is nothing nothing be gained by this.

allycat4 · 26/07/2021 09:53

Don't you see though - it shouldn't be this much effort!

dottiedodah · 26/07/2021 09:52

I dont think you were "needy" at all.Most people ,used to a certain level of contact ,would be surprised not to have a message even if to say they are OK . Maybe he is being brutally honest by saying he isnt "head over heels" but wants to carry on seeing you.If he has been hurt previously then he may be wary .When you are younger there is much more urgency to settle down with "The One" . I think you are doing the right thing to keep your options open .If it does work out well and good ,if not you havent kept all your men in one big basket!

honestjon · 26/07/2021 09:52

@HeartZone

Have you thought, maybe he’s married? First over nighter, then he disappears for a while?
He is 100000% not married. I've spent tons of time at his house. He has flatmates.
OP posts:
honestjon · 26/07/2021 09:51

@CrouchEndTiger12

We all have different opinions and approaches. Personally I wouldn't want to give them the opportunity to reject me and tell me they aren't interested.

I'd rather keep my dignity and therefore they will always remember I couldn't care less they stopped contact.

A guy goes quiet and you want to force them to tell you they don't want you. OK.

We'll definitely have to agree to disagree. The fact that dignity is linked to caring about something or having a feeling about something/someone treating you a certain way, is (in my view) again fairly patriarchal and I don't understand the basis of it.

That said, I don't disagree that the 'playing it cool' approach works better for keeping men some men interested. I think that kind of man is one to avoid though.

If he is scared off by my asking why he went from 100s of messages per day to basically none, I don't want to date him. I hate the thought of just putting up and shutting up for the sake of keeping someone interested.

OP posts:
HeartZone · 26/07/2021 09:50

Have you thought, maybe he’s married? First over nighter, then he disappears for a while?

MsVestibule · 26/07/2021 09:45

This is the absolute worst bit about dating. It took me about 20 years to work out that not a single one of my 'successful' relationships (i.e. those that went on to be boyfriend/girlfriend) ever started with this shit.

He explained the cause (life suddenly getting way busier) and apologised. I know later in the thread you've said this is justified, but really? The day after you spend the night together, his life suddenly gets so ridiculously busy that he can't send you a single text in a day?

Presumably you're doing OLD? What do you want to achieve? Lots of fun dates, or a LTR?

LindaEllen · 26/07/2021 09:43

I've never understood why people play these games. You shouldn't sit stewing wondering why he hasn't text you. If you wanted to talk to him, all you needed to do was text and say 'Hey, how's your day been? Did you enjoy golf? x' instead of leaving it, working yourself up, and then having a go at him over it. Relationships shouldn't be this hard, and if they are, what's the point in them? Text when you want to talk to him. It's as easy as that. If you're not happy with the level of effort/contact then sure, let him know - and it's up to you to decide whether you can live with it or not. But what is the actual point in sitting there wondering why he hasn't text you, when you've not text him either? Imagine if he was thinking the same thing - where the hell would you be then?! Would you just both sit looking at your phones until one of you died?

RadandMad · 26/07/2021 09:41

@WeatherForecast

He’s not that into you tbh, and whether you messaged him first and broached the topic or not wouldn’t have changed a thing in that regard.

In the early weeks of seeing DH I felt like he wasn’t putting in enough effort into planning to see me, didn’t seem super keen to get the next date in the diary kinda thing, so I messaged him and said I could sense things cooling off a little, that was fine and I was happy to be friends and had had fun.

He rang me within seconds of seeing it, asked to see me that night, took me out for drinks and the minute we sat down in the pub gave me a little speech about how he was head over heels for me but hadn’t wanted to scare me off as he knew I was only recently single, he didn’t think he’d have a chance with someone like me and was trying to rein himself in and be a bit cool so as not to ruin it. And that he was sorry as he’d obviously been a bit too cool!

I was pretty taken aback and figured it might just be hot air but true to his word after that conversation where we both said we really liked each other it was plain sailing forevermore. Lots of effort, couldn’t wait to see me, taking me out all the time, making it official etc.

Your guy responded to a very normal need for reassurance with a ‘sorry, I can’t meet even that baseline need of yours’. He isn’t afraid of losing you or scaring you off, he’s letting you know that he won’t give you what you’re saying you need and setting your expectations really really low. If you continue to see him it’ll be on his terms and won’t lead anywhere imo.

I think anyone with any level of empathy recognises that when you’ve spent the night together it feels a bit different to a coffee date, you’ve been vulnerable with that person and it’s normal to feel a bit uneasy the next day without the person getting in touch, especially when it’s been an intense period of contact previously. If he had a genuine reason then it wouldn’t have happened a second time. When we met DH was a busy A&E doctor but still made time to message, call, and plan dates. Everyone uses the bathroom and can send a text, it takes seconds.

Be proud of yourself for speaking up for your needs, you avoided further days of angst wondering what was going on. In your shoes now I’d write it off and maybe send one last message saying you don’t think it’s a romantic match, it’s been nice to hang out and best of luck with the future, and then block so you’re not tempted to keep messaging.

You’ve done everything right here, he just isn’t into you, and you shouldn’t be into him either with this ‘you’re needy and I can’t meet your requirements and here’s another couple days of radio silence’ behaviour.

Have you ever read the book ‘he’s just not that into you’? It’s actually excellent. Not usually one for dating or self help type books but it’s absolutely spot on. Saves you a lot of pining!

Agree with every word.
CrouchEndTiger12 · 26/07/2021 09:38

We all have different opinions and approaches. Personally I wouldn't want to give them the opportunity to reject me and tell me they aren't interested.

I'd rather keep my dignity and therefore they will always remember I couldn't care less they stopped contact.

A guy goes quiet and you want to force them to tell you they don't want you. OK.

TatianaBis · 26/07/2021 09:36

I don’t actually think OP is wrong to be upfront and to want him to be upfront.

There’s no law that says if a guy cold shoulders you you can’t ask him to admit it.

It may be a bit embarrassing and I would want to be cooler than that but there’s no right/wrong way to go about it.

TatianaBis · 26/07/2021 09:33

@WeatherForecast

People tell you a great deal with their actions. More than they do with their words.

He isn't messaging you: he doesn't want to message you. Wild horses don't get in the way of a man contacting a woman he's really into.

He's already letting you know where you fall in his pecking order/how much he's thinking about you. You just need to listen instead of pushing him to give you that same info in a way you find easier to digest.

Yes.
TatianaBis · 26/07/2021 09:33

The line that you may need more attention than he can give is very telling. If he texts all the time and then stops texting after sex that’s a fairly big message. He’s setting a bit of distance between you.

WeatherForecast · 26/07/2021 09:32

People tell you a great deal with their actions. More than they do with their words.

He isn't messaging you: he doesn't want to message you. Wild horses don't get in the way of a man contacting a woman he's really into.

He's already letting you know where you fall in his pecking order/how much he's thinking about you. You just need to listen instead of pushing him to give you that same info in a way you find easier to digest.

ForeverSausages · 26/07/2021 09:31

I also disagree, I'd much rather be told someone is no longer interested. Always. You can have respect for someone even if you no longer see them romantically. You've done nothing wrong OP.

CrouchEndTiger12 · 26/07/2021 09:29

I'm afraid I don't agree. I much prefer someone to tell me. I've been on both sides of it before and find it much more civilised to discuss it than to have one person left wondering.

Yes well he doesn't share your views and you can't make him.

It is also counterproductive. Assume for a second he is telling the truth and something has happened. You push push pushing him to talk to you is just going to piss him off and you'll ruin any chance he will come back around.

HaveringWavering · 26/07/2021 09:29

Unfortunately you preferring to just be told doesn’t help if he prefers not to say!

DrManhattan · 26/07/2021 09:28

I'd take the hint

HaveringWavering · 26/07/2021 09:28

If I were doing this to a man, I'd be glad they were instinctive enough to reach out and ask if there was an issue and would take the opportunity to be honest that I wasn't really feeling it.

The problem is that most men are conflict avoidant and would rather respond with “oh no it’s all great, I’m just busy” than admit outright they’ve gone off you. Then they ghost you instead. So your approach probably won’t change the outcome, it will just give you false reassurance. Have you read the book I mentioned upthread?