Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be honest with him that I was disappointed?

290 replies

honestjon · 24/07/2021 16:19

(Not in the U.K. so it's gone midnight where I am)

I've been dating a man for a while and we spent the first overnight together last night. Not, by any means, the first time we'd had sex. But the first time we'd physically slept next to each other.

There was absolutely nothing in the course of the interaction that indicated it was anything but a positive experience on both sides. We left on great terms this morning. All great.

However, I've not heard from him since. Very unusual as we usually keep in touch a lot.

Both of us were busy today but he's gone to play golf with a friend, so when we parted ways this morning, I said 'enjoy golf, let me know whether you win!'.

It's so trivial and possible insignificant but also very very unsettling to have not heard a thing. We've certainly not gone a day without talking before in the 3 months we've known each other.

I'd like to communicate to him that I felt this was a bit disappointing after spending the night together. I am not looking to tell him off, rather just to tell him honestly that it felt a bit disappointing/unsettling after spending the night together.

My logic is that either he has gone off me, in which case whether I say it or not is irrelevant (and may open the door for him to be honest) or he simply didn't realise it was important, in which case raising it should surely be part of good communication about my expectations.

And, of course, the obvious thing is that I've not contacted him either. However, I feel like as women there's an expectation to wait for a man to come to you, so it doesn't seem needy etc. Similarly, I did leave him on the 'let me know how your golf game goes!' note, which I felt opened the door for him to contact me if he wanted to.

My gawd I really hate dating sometimes!!!

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 26/07/2021 19:36

@MillicentMaritime

I think a lot of PPs are making out your BF to be behaving a lot worse than he actually is. I just think he's undecided.

From what you've written I'm wondering if he really liked you but wanted to see where things went. Then maybe you texting a lot made him think you thought he was more decided than he was. So he's cut back on communication a bit as a signal that maybe you should too, for now anyway.

I wouldn't automatically give up on this, as so many PPs are advising.

That sounds like game playing to me. And it wasn't one-way messaging. So stop making out that the op is somehow non stop texting and overwhelming him. She said it was mutual.

He just needs to shit or get off the pot. Suddenly going cold on someone without notice is game playing bullshit. If he's not that into her then he needs to say so. Not give mixed messages.

LimeRedBanana · 26/07/2021 19:32

[quote Funk2funky]@LimeRedBanana Communicate that you can’t stop thinking about someone and analysing their every action or non action, not giving them one day to text you. I’d rather be breezy!
Having said that they’ve been going out three months and should have communicated if they were exclusive a long while ago.[/quote]
Not sure whose actions you’re describing but it’s not the OP’s.

She wasn’t ‘not giving him one day to text’, she noticed a change in the way they mutually communicated the day after he spent the first full night.

She’s also not spending every minute ‘thinking about him and analysing his every action or non action’. Confused

There’s no point making stuff up.

Funk2funky · 26/07/2021 19:29

@daisychain01

This early on it should be hot and steamy, not light and breezy!

Just saying!

🤣🤣
MillicentMaritime · 26/07/2021 19:28

But a lot of PPs are expecting the BF to behave as if they're in an established relationship. They're just starting out, so yes, hot and steamy but also breezy and keeping it cool and not anxious IMO.

daisychain01 · 26/07/2021 19:22

This early on it should be hot and steamy, not light and breezy!

Just saying!

Funk2funky · 26/07/2021 19:15

@LimeRedBanana Communicate that you can’t stop thinking about someone and analysing their every action or non action, not giving them one day to text you. I’d rather be breezy!
Having said that they’ve been going out three months and should have communicated if they were exclusive a long while ago.

LimeRedBanana · 26/07/2021 19:11

Some of the dating advice on this thread is risible.

The way to sustain a meaningful long term relationship is by being ‘breezy’. Oh, and don’t forget ‘sassy’.

Do not by any means do the one thing actually proven to sustain meaningful long-term relationships: communicate.

Grin

FML.

MillicentMaritime · 26/07/2021 19:02

I think a lot of PPs are making out your BF to be behaving a lot worse than he actually is. I just think he's undecided.

From what you've written I'm wondering if he really liked you but wanted to see where things went. Then maybe you texting a lot made him think you thought he was more decided than he was. So he's cut back on communication a bit as a signal that maybe you should too, for now anyway.

I wouldn't automatically give up on this, as so many PPs are advising.

todaysdilemma · 26/07/2021 17:17

OP, ignore any comments about you being needy. Communicating with your partner regularly is NOT needy. But there are people who like their relationships in a box, where they only deal with it on the designated days, and you don't exist outside of it. I would not date someone like this, because if you can keep in touch with your work regularly, and your friends, you can do it with the person you're considering sharing a life with...

He would be a big fat red flag for me. Thinking that messaging you the day after you were intimate is too 'needy'? Telling you how his golf game was is 'too much contact'. He can get to f*k frankly. This is his way of managing down your expectations by already prepping excuses why this won't progress to anything serious. When human beings like each other, messaging every day is NOT a chore - it's fun and exciting and you enjoy doing it. And even if it's not his natural style, if he likes you enough and knows a simple text a day would make you happy, he wouldn't mind doing it.

I would let this one go, OP. You should never adapt your style of communication to suit someone (unless you're a known stalker and even friends/family have all commented on it as excessive). Dating is finding someone compatible with you and your needs. The sort of man who thinks it's a chore to message his date is the sort of man who will not make you happy or emotionally fulfil.

He isn't for you. Don't let him make you feel like you're too much, too needy or need to change. Billions of people in different countries and cultures and of different sexes, communicate with their loved ones everyday. Best to find someone who thinks about these things like you do, or certainly doesn't try to shame you for thinking how you do.

QueenBee52 · 26/07/2021 17:08

I'm not convinced by his reasons either tbh... sounds a bit text book brush off but dragging it out kinda thing...

I do hope I'm wrong OP.. and will glad to be proven so... Flowers

HellonHeels · 26/07/2021 16:54

@MillicentMaritime

Everyone is insecure at the start of a potential relationship with someone they really like.

I just think it's a good idea to keep those feelings hidden (and I thought this was what most people did).

This guy is still making his mind up and what's wrong with that? If the OP really likes him and plays her cards right I think he'll fall for her.

Or she can walk away.

who can be arsed 'playing their cards right' though?

Makes relationships turn into some kind of political strategising activity. Personally I get enough of that at work. OP wants a nice straightforward approach to dating and I totally get why.

She's not doing anything wrong.

VelvetSpoon · 26/07/2021 16:53

But if the other person is being genuine, and consistent, you won't feel insecure. I found that with my partner - as opposed to every other bloke I'd met through OD - I never felt worried or concerned, he called and texted when he said he would, and vice versa, and if he didn't then I felt I could bring it up without judgment or fear, as did he. We were both totally honest right from the start and that lack of game playing was a bloody relief and far more in line with pre online dating experiences back in simpler times!

Funk2funky · 26/07/2021 16:53

I think it depends , if you’re on date 3 and you sleep with him and then start interrogating about lack of communication the next day and then again the next day - that’s too intense for anyone!
Op you’re three months in, you should have some kind of honesty but then he’s never mentioned being exclusive. You’ve had sex with him before, this is just the first time you stayed over. It just sounds like fwb to me. Unless you have that exclusive conversation and come off OLD together then it’s really not a relationship. Therefore, you can’t have the expectations of a relationship or chastise his behaviour. Any way you have called him out now and he’s let you know he hasn’t fallen for you and he can’t maintain the contact levels you expect. I would just leave it now and if he doesn’t contact you again you know the score. Did he reply to your last text btw?

FloFlower · 26/07/2021 16:47

@MillicentMaritime - but then the OP will have to alter authentic self in order to please the man.

I don’t think that this is a realistic foundation for a lasting relationship.

Yes be on your best behaviour but if the person your dating is upsetting you after a few weeks/months and you’re expected to modify your behaviour to accommodate this, then that’s no good for me. I’d be walking away

DoubleNegativePanda · 26/07/2021 16:45

@Calvinlookingforhobbes

Just give it time and seen how he responds. Don’t be needy but also don’t be treated badly. Give it space to see what transpires
I don't necessarily agree with "don't be needy". Just because your needs exceed someone's expectation doesn't invalidate them, and communicating your needs clearly is the only way to have them actually met. If you tell someone you're sad or disappointed that communication had dropped off and they take that as needy and it puts them off, then your needs would have been routinely unmet. I'd rather know we weren't matching well in the beginning rather than after I'd been married for a few years.
MillicentMaritime · 26/07/2021 16:43

Everyone is insecure at the start of a potential relationship with someone they really like.

I just think it's a good idea to keep those feelings hidden (and I thought this was what most people did).

This guy is still making his mind up and what's wrong with that? If the OP really likes him and plays her cards right I think he'll fall for her.

Or she can walk away.

VelvetSpoon · 26/07/2021 16:39

And this is why the current world of dating is such a headfuck.

If it's not men dicking you about, it's other women trying to knock you down and tell you that you need therapy for just wanting a bit of respect from someone you've been dating.

VelvetSpoon · 26/07/2021 16:37

@GreenWillow

There is nothing remotely controlling or needy about a woman having expectations. If he's not meeting them, she can move on, which she's doing

Op’s not simply moving on though (I agree this would be the best idea).

She’s harassing him into spelling out to her that he’s not interested.

He’s allowed to not be interested, he’s allowed to behave like a dick. It’s poor conduct, I agree, but people are just generally a bit rubbish sometimes.

If OP appoints herself as the Dating Police, committed to holding men to account like this, it hardly enhances her allure, does it?

But this guy was never the right one, as he's demonstrated.

If he was genuinely interested, he either wouldn't have behaved as he did in the first place OR when called out on it by the OP he would've given a genuine and sincere apology/ returned to his previous 'keen' behaviour.

I've never known a man who is ACTUALLY wanting to progress a relationship to be put off by a woman appearing too keen or calling out discourteous behaviour. The ones who say that's offputting - they're just using that as an excuse to hide behind because they never had any genuine intentions in the first place.

When I met my partner 7 years ago, we were on the same page right from the start, agreed we were exclusive and not seeing anyone else from the second date. He was the first man I'd met through OLD who was upfront and honest about what he wanted from the start and after years of nonsense and hundreds of dates with pretty much every category of fuckwit that OLD has to offer, it was a refreshing and pleasant change.

CandyLeBonBon · 26/07/2021 16:22

Harassing? Really @GreenWillow. The op's actions are so very far from harassing it's quite laughable.

honestjon · 26/07/2021 16:18

@LizzieW1969

I don’t think this OP needs reassurance at all. She just wants to know where she stands with this man, and doesn’t want to waste her life waiting around for him to get in touch. Which suggests to me that she actually isn’t at all needy.

She’s already made other plans for next Saturday when they were going to meet up.

Correct. This describes me to a tee. I wasn't looking for reassurance, I was looking for clarity. I'm a confident enough person to handle rejection. What I can't handle is being left hanging!
OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 26/07/2021 16:13

I don’t think this OP needs reassurance at all. She just wants to know where she stands with this man, and doesn’t want to waste her life waiting around for him to get in touch. Which suggests to me that she actually isn’t at all needy.

She’s already made other plans for next Saturday when they were going to meet up.

TatianaBis · 26/07/2021 15:57

@MillicentMaritime

I literally dropped a polite note to say he'd been very quiet and said that in my experience, that tended to indicate less enthusiasm to keep dating.

I can only advise from my own experience, but a partner asking for reassurance early on, no matter how attracted I was to them, really negatively changed my opinion of them.

Conversely though, someone being aloof at the start and me not quite knowing where I stood with them has led me to falling madly in love.

For this reason I don't think you should walk away OP - if you just act like you don't care as much, I think you may turn this in your favour!

She’s not asking for reassurance she’s just asking him if he’s into it or not.

If you like dicking around with mind games that’s up to you. I cba personally.

TatianaBis · 26/07/2021 15:51

@Greenwillow completely missed the point of @CandidaAlbicans2’s post.

She just said she’d much rather have a direct conversation than messing about interpreting things which she doesn’t the patience for.

bathsh3ba · 26/07/2021 15:40

I don't understand why everyone is saying she was pushing the guy. She asked a question, got an answer. What's the problem? Why's everyone so hostile? If she wants to be picky about who she dates, let her be.

daisychain01 · 26/07/2021 15:18

Conversely though, someone being aloof at the start and me not quite knowing where I stood with them has led me to falling madly in love

If you like a good dose of manipulation and control, then that's fine, but the OP sounds like someone who doesn't want this charade. She just wants honesty and sincerity. That's fine too. If you get into mind games this early in a relationship, it often sets the tone for the future.

I'm with the OP on this, my DH hasn't ever bothered with all the playing hard to get and neither have I, and it enabled us to know early on where we stood. He certainly wouldn't ghost me after us going on a date. Why spoil the positive feelings, unless you're a timewaster....