Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excusing bad behaviour because the child ‘gifted and talented’ and bored

108 replies

WildWestWanda · 24/07/2021 15:53

My sister has a ds who she believes to be ‘gifted and talented’

His behaviour has never been great but he is now 9yo and it is getting worse.

Just before the start of the summer holiday my ds was yet again called into school. This time he has kicked a teacher! Apparently the class were having a maths lesson and he kept getting up and running around the classroom. He was repeatedly asked to sit down and eventually lashed out and kicked the teacher!

My ds believes it was because the work wasn’t challenging him and he was bored! Instead of any kind of punishment she has sympathised with him!

It’s getting to the point where I am losing all respect for my sister! She is now upset with me because when she told me about the latest school incident I refused to accept his behaviour was ok. She isn’t doing him any favours at all. He is losing friends at school because of the way he behaves.

OP posts:
FTEngineerM · 24/07/2021 20:28

Hmm I’m not sure being super smart allows you to do what ever the fuck you want.

There aren’t streams of PhD students going round booting people in the head because they’re bored.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/07/2021 20:22

I was supposedly G&T and was bored as hell.

NEVER did I feel a need to kick a teacher (or anybody else) in the shins, though. My misbehaviour was far more intellectually stimulating - like reprogramming the computer to say rude words, creating cartoon like chain reactions , pointing out spelling errors made by teachers, ploughing through the work and the next month's work where it was textbook based so I could say 'done it already' when they tried to give me extension activities, and sitting at the back of the class drawing pictures of animals.

I was a 100% pain in the arse when I was bored, which was most of the time, but it was never violence, ever; to me, resorting to violence or getting myself into proper trouble rather than being an annoying little smartass was a marker of being the least intelligent person and I was so secure in my 'smartness' (God, I was such a mini dickhead), I never wanted to behave like my mother whose only answer to the many things she couldn't understand was to attack it a thick as mince thug.

The actually intelligent kids would be looking at him in disgust.

hettie · 24/07/2021 20:21

Hmme- well you could suggest that she gets him assessed by an educational psychologist? You could appeal to her ego and her sense that he is gifted as she could then clarify just how 'gifted' he is and the ed psych would suggest some strategies.
For reference, it is generally thought that gifted kids (or adults) will be in the 98th to 99th centile in a Wechsler intelligence test score, so the tope 1-2% of scores (for their age). Thing is a decent ed psych will also pick up on other issues too- dyslexia, possible adhd/attentional issues and will (in the write up of the report) comment on attitude and behaviour (if an issue). So it might also help her recognise if the behaviour is appropraite for age. I'd encourage this if I were you (but it will cost)....

kgov1 · 24/07/2021 20:13

My niece went to primary school with a boy like that. He was clever but no Einstein and his mother constantly justified his bad behaviour as being because he was bored and not challenged.

Last thing I heard he got expelled at 16 for stabbing someone. Your sister needs to stop making excuses and start disciplining her child.

Booboosweet · 24/07/2021 20:01

It sounds like he's a little shit who just needs some proper discipline at home.

1forAll74 · 24/07/2021 19:50

Does this perfect child, get nothing like any proper discipline at home. You can't go around kicking teachers like this. A child being bored,is a rubbish thing to say, he is at school,and supposed to be learning lots of things. It is the parent/parents responsibility to tell the child how he has to behave in any given situation.

pollylocketpickedapocket · 24/07/2021 19:23

@Lemonmelonsun

It doesn't sound like anything to do with being gifted or bored but perhaps having un diagnosed sen??
Or just being a little twat?
Gregwiggle · 24/07/2021 19:07

I think you and your sister are wrong about the cause of the kicking. It doesn't sound like standard bad behaviour or being bored to me.

QuitMoaning · 24/07/2021 19:03

@Gladimnotcampinginthisweather

A friend of mine's son who was definitely gifted also got bored in maths. He sat and occupied himself with his own calculations. He certainly didn't kick the teacher. As far as I remember gifted children are likely to be self motivated.
My son was noted as academically G&T when he started senior school about 13 years ago and they did say that he may get bored and his behaviour may reflect him not being challenged.

He never ever behaved like this. He had no other issues, was NT so not sure if that has any impact but The school worked with me to ensure he was challenged in lessons and was well behaved.

To be honest I didn’t really see any benefit in the label so pleased if it has stopped being used.

warmandtoasty2day · 24/07/2021 19:01

@Littleclue

What is PBF syndrome?
precious first born
MyriadeOfThings · 24/07/2021 18:58

One of mine is definitely bright and was bored at school.
He never behaved like that in primary. What is going to happen when he is a teen and still bored?

Even though if he is still disruptive and not listening he won’t carry on doing well for very long….

Jchina · 24/07/2021 18:55

My eldest is a “very able” child as determined by his school and - they don’t use the term G&T any more. It definitely does cause some behavioural issues, for example he is generally very intense, can be argumentative and has quite poor self esteem and confidence, which sounds counter intuitive but 🤷🏻‍♀️ At times at school he can be difficult to motivate and downright lazy (if you ask me!). There is also a massive disparity between his ability to learn and his maturity which I think causes a lot of issues. I have worked carefully with school to make sure that we are doing the right things for him at home as well.

However it is absolutely not an excuse for something like kicking a teaching and running around. Assuming your nephew is gifted, both your sister and the school need to work together to make sure he’s challenged, motivated and knows how to behave appropriately. “Gifted” children are more than capable of understanding that. Also if he is identified as such by the school they should have a programme in place for him. My son is given “challenge” work to do after after he’s completed the tasks given to the rest of the class, for example. Sounds like something isn’t quite right here…particularly that she defends behaviour like kicking!

Lemonmelonsun · 24/07/2021 18:53

It's horrific that it's not been suggested really but they could be thinking about budgets but if a teacher has been attacked then they need to be sort it.

Littleclue · 24/07/2021 18:35

What is PBF syndrome?

derekthe1adyhamster · 24/07/2021 18:31

My ds was a pain at primary school but we worked constantly with them and backed them. He actually went to a selective school at secondary where he did well, but considering he was in the top 1% in his CATs probably not as well as he should have done.
At the age of 21 he has just got a diagnosis of ADHD. Your sister really needs a educational assessment.

Lemonmelonsun · 24/07/2021 18:29
  • as a very quick example let's say he has asd then his "triggers" would be looked at and managed before he started to run round the room kicking people.
Lemonmelonsun · 24/07/2021 18:28

Op, with the greatest respect, it sounds like non of you suspect sen and it does sound like he has needs that need to be addressed.

Why don't you start to look up asd, adhd etc and see what you think?
Things at least need to be ruled out, perhaps even encouraging her to ask if they feel he is neuro typical?

Lemonmelonsun · 24/07/2021 18:25

What a shilouh, surley as a teacher then you can see straight away this dissent sound like normal behaviour and instead of clamping down, she needs to start thinking "why" this is not neuro typical?.

Soontobe60 · 24/07/2021 18:23

@twitchyyellow

My son is highly gifted and was doing similar things at school which school (were crap about) but went on about it being because he's too smart etc. He was/is autistic (school denied it was SEN) and he's now in a SEN school with a lot more support than they were giving and funnily enough, he hasn't lashed out once in 2 years.

There is a lot of evidence around dysregulation and G&T but it's also highly correlated with SEN. Any attempts to actually have him assessed to ensure everyone is on the right tracks?

I have taught children that sound just like your son. Unfortunately mainstream schools are not designed to mange this type of child effectively as there is not enough funding / knowledge about how to support them effectively. Special schools tend to not accept them if their achievement academically is high. Double whammy!
WhatAShilohPitt · 24/07/2021 18:08

I’ve taught some seriously smart pupils over the years. I used to teach a scholarship class of boys applying to Eton, Harrow etc. Not ONCE did any of those highly intelligent boys misbehave because they were bright and bored. They behaved with absolute respect and used to put their hand up for extension tasks if they finished the work. If any of them had kicked me, they’d have lost their place at the school.

Bored children have no right to become rude, bratty, physically violent and disrespectful, despite what your sister is teaching him.

If she doesn’t buck her ideas up and start clamping down on him she’s going to end up with an obnoxious child who thinks he’s better than everyone else.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 24/07/2021 18:07

"It is only my sister who calls him gifted and talented. School haven’t given any indication that they think he is."

So...... It is possible your sister is onto something the school has missed.

BUT if that's the case she should WANT to have him assessed.
She should be really motivated to solve this puzzle of why his attainment and behaviour at school doesn't match the child she knows.
Wouldn't an IQ test normally form part of an Ed Psych assesment?

If the "gifted" thing only gets trotted out as an excuse for bad behaviour then she's doing him a disservice.

Dontwatchfootball · 24/07/2021 18:05

So smart people dont have to behave? What is wrong with her!

ForeverSausages · 24/07/2021 18:00

@farfallarocks

She should read The Explosive Child and Lost at School. Both extremely interesting and practical. Disappointing to see the usual ‘oh it’s just bad parenting’, give him a wallop nonsense on here.
Definitely meant to quote this comment 🙈😂😂.
ForeverSausages · 24/07/2021 17:59

I should add, he does have SEN too.

ForeverSausages · 24/07/2021 17:59

@TheMoth

A lot of parents use the 'oh they're bored' excuse for poor behaviour. It takes a lot of strength to smile, rather than roll my eyes. Lots of us get bored. Jesus christ, I used to have to go to church every Sunday as a kid. It was mind numbing. But I also knew how to behave. How many jobs in life are really boring?
I've not read the whole thread but thanks for this. I'll have a look. My son is really struggling at school. I don't think he's particularly "gifted" as such but at school they're learning adding to 20 and he knows his prime numbers to 1000 (for context) so it's no wonder he's bored. It was quite upsetting reading a lot of the thread before your post Flowers.