Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people dramatize a story when retelling it?

65 replies

Orangedots · 24/07/2021 15:27

Listening to someone retell an event that a group of us enjoyed together.

They’ve embellished it somewhat and I’m not entirely sure why. To get sympathy? To make it more dramatic?

I mean things like if the journey took 3 hours, they tell everyone it took 4. Waited 30 minutes for food, told everyone It was an hour wait. Hmm

These are just vague examples as don’t want to be outing, but this person does this regularly. When asked about it they deny it or query others accounts.

Anyone else do this and if so, please can you explain why?

OP posts:
ItPearl · 24/07/2021 17:27

I agree that it is a type of people pleasing. There's a buzz from entertaining people. Most healthy secure people wouldn't get that satisfaction from entertaining people with a story that isn't true, but I can see how less secure in their right to be ordinary types might sometimes types embellish a story. There is that need to sing for their supper.' A fear of boring the listener.

These types couldn't just tell a short factual, perhaps mildly humorous account of what actually happened, get one wry supportive smile and move on.

They don't have self-compassion to know that it's ok to be just one in the group, they only feel safe when the group revolves around them. And groups can still revolve around a drama queen, even if she's not well respected, it's a kind of FORCE that draws people in and there is a certain orbit around this type.

The one I know, if only she knew that it's ok to sit there, one member of a group, contributing sometimes but mostly listening and content to listen and connect safe in the knowledge that not every story has to be a Jeffrey Archer. It's ok to just show up and join in.

I read that one cause of this can be parents who re-cast the golden child in the family. One day everybody's listening to you hanging on your every word as you recite your 7 times tables and then the next minute everybody's hanging on your sister's every word. What!

This theory would hold up one of the embellishers that I know.

DrSbaitso · 24/07/2021 16:55

@clarkkentsglasses

I do this. I am also aware I am a complete twat for doing so.

I think mine is a "people pleasing" thing.

I must sound an absolute dick.

What's "people pleasing" about it?
clarkkentsglasses · 24/07/2021 16:53

I do this. I am also aware I am a complete twat for doing so.

I think mine is a "people pleasing" thing.

I must sound an absolute dick.

ItPearl · 24/07/2021 16:51

@DrSbaitso and I did believe her the first time I was told. Then various details didn't match up to what I'd heard before/ what another close friend had been told.

Anyway, I'm going to bow out now. If she is reading, I recognise that you have changed. I think you lie less now and people have noticed. Wine

DrSbaitso · 24/07/2021 16:50

[quote ItPearl]@drSbaitso I'm sure. She told different versions of the same story to different people and I know myself, when an experience is painful every detail is etched in to you forever, so yes, I'm SURE. I'm not participating in a court case where I have to prove that my perceptions about her were correct because the subject matter is ver sensitive. Yes, an edit button would be lovely. I feel sorry for this woman. She might have histrionic personality disorder.[/quote]
She may have felt more comfortable giving the absolute truth to some people than others.

I'm the only one who knows the true extent of one person's pain in that regard. She can't bear for "everyone" to know exactly what she went through.

ItPearl · 24/07/2021 16:48

@drSbaitso I'm sure. She told different versions of the same story to different people and I know myself, when an experience is painful every detail is etched in to you forever, so yes, I'm SURE. I'm not participating in a court case where I have to prove that my perceptions about her were correct because the subject matter is ver sensitive. Yes, an edit button would be lovely. I feel sorry for this woman. She might have histrionic personality disorder.

girlmom21 · 24/07/2021 16:45

@ItPearl

Obviously that's not the bit that wasn't believed. It was that the details changed depending on who she was talking to. I have asked for my post and yours to be deleted because I regret it. If she read it she would recognise herself.
You clearly didn't believe that bit or you wouldn't have mentioned it and now you've realised you're a bit of a nasty person...
DrSbaitso · 24/07/2021 16:45

s/sure you were wrong/sure you weren't wrong. Oh, for an edit button.

DrSbaitso · 24/07/2021 16:44

@ItPearl

Obviously that's not the bit that wasn't believed. It was that the details changed depending on who she was talking to. I have asked for my post and yours to be deleted because I regret it. If she read it she would recognise herself.
Hmm, I certainly got the impression that you didn't believe...that bit. Seems irrelevant to the conversation otherwise.

Well all I'll say is that you were wrong about the house fire so you really can't be sure you were wrong about the other stuff....which is actually more likely.

ItPearl · 24/07/2021 16:34

Obviously that's not the bit that wasn't believed. It was that the details changed depending on who she was talking to. I have asked for my post and yours to be deleted because I regret it. If she read it she would recognise herself.

user1745 · 24/07/2021 16:33

To make it more interesting so they get a better reaction.

DrSbaitso · 24/07/2021 16:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes withdrawn post.

lannistunut · 24/07/2021 16:25

@DrManhattan

Because alot of every day stories are a bit boring and repetitive
This, I like a bit of hyperbole.

I work with someone who talks a lot of bollocks but she's really funny and cheers my day up.

ItPearl · 24/07/2021 16:20

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Dogvmarmot · 24/07/2021 16:14

@Orangedots

Listening to someone retell an event that a group of us enjoyed together.

They’ve embellished it somewhat and I’m not entirely sure why. To get sympathy? To make it more dramatic?

I mean things like if the journey took 3 hours, they tell everyone it took 4. Waited 30 minutes for food, told everyone It was an hour wait. Hmm

These are just vague examples as don’t want to be outing, but this person does this regularly. When asked about it they deny it or query others accounts.

Anyone else do this and if so, please can you explain why?

I think the key issue is : are they making everyone laugh or entertaining them . acceptable in social situations. Not so much giving evidence in court. If not, the problem is they are poor story tellers. leave the room immediately when they begin to tell a story. if totally factual real life events were entertaining, we would all be cranking out best sellers.
the80sweregreat · 24/07/2021 16:12

My late in-laws were also the past masters of the ' embellishment tale'
They looked after ds1 for a day once , he was six months old ( it was a genuine emergency)
This turned into ' a week ' over time.
Dh's sister was potty trained at just 'over a year old ' ! ( yeah , right )
Memories can become vague!!

hellcatspangle · 24/07/2021 16:08

My DH does this all the time. I often hear him telling people about things that have happened to us and he totally over eggs everything and makes it all a big drama. I do pull him up on it though.

the80sweregreat · 24/07/2021 16:08

My mum used to call some stories ' shaggy dog stories'. No idea why!

RedToothBrush · 24/07/2021 16:08

@DrSbaitso

Do you think all memoirs are entirely factual?

It's pretty well known that James Herriot's stories, wonderful as they are, didn't all occur exactly as he related them. And Stephen Katz (not his real name), who joined Bill Bryson on the Appalachian Trail, has described Bryson's book about the experience as "mostly fiction".

And nobody should have been surprised in either instance. It's obvious reading these books and others that things wouldn't have occurred exactly, literally, as they tell them.

But they're a great pleasure to read.

Unless your name is Henry Charles Albert David.

(gets coat)

fairgame84 · 24/07/2021 16:07

My DM does this and I loathe it. Just tell the truth ffs!
It's normal to make it more dramatic as she is a complete drama llama or to make herself look like a victim.
Everyone knows she does it but I'm the only person who calls her out on it, then she goes round telling everyone that I'm mean and horrible.

DrSbaitso · 24/07/2021 16:04

Do you think all memoirs are entirely factual?

It's pretty well known that James Herriot's stories, wonderful as they are, didn't all occur exactly as he related them. And Stephen Katz (not his real name), who joined Bill Bryson on the Appalachian Trail, has described Bryson's book about the experience as "mostly fiction".

And nobody should have been surprised in either instance. It's obvious reading these books and others that things wouldn't have occurred exactly, literally, as they tell them.

But they're a great pleasure to read.

ComDummings · 24/07/2021 16:00

Some people love a bit of drama so embellish

RedToothBrush · 24/07/2021 16:00

Cos most people are dull as fuck

Unlike DH who nearly kills himself at least once a week (true story).

Freddiefox · 24/07/2021 15:58

My ex did this a lot. Everything was over dramatised. If he stubbed his foot, he would say I smashed foot. If food was hot it was absolutely boiling. For him it was to get sympathy, it wa ms tiresome

Lemonmelonsun · 24/07/2021 15:57

To make it more interesting?
Who wants to listen to boring crap about a half hour meal, unless it's a witness statement who cares?