Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to speak to FIL when at DSS wedding

116 replies

Loyalorstupid · 24/07/2021 10:48

OK, so name change for this as might be outing.

My FIL, who has always been very selfish and uncaring to both my DH and SisIL, will be going to my DSSs wedding, taking his second wife (who is same age as SisIL) with him.

His 1st wife (mother of DH and SisIL) died earlier this year after being in a care home with alzheimers for 3 years.

FIL had moved the now 2nd wife into marital home 2 years before first wife died, which none of the family approved of. He also took other actions regarding her that were, in the family's view, completely inappropriate. As a result both DH and SisIL cut contact with him.

Also, before going NC with his DF, DH borrowed money from FIL to finance something they both knew I would strongly disagree with if I knew about it. I have dealt with DH about that, and the matter is settled between us, but I am still absolutely incensed that FIL lent this money, and kept it a secret, even though he knew how totally this would damage mine and DHs relationship.

For reference this was potentially a marriage breaker but DH has worked hard to apologise, regain my trust and get our relationship back on a good track. So all good there now.

So, DH is now saying that he will have to speak to his DF and the 2nd wife when at the wedding for the sake of his son and bride, which I totally get. If he wants to do that it is his choice, I won't try and stop him doing that.

But ... AIBU if I still refuse to speak to either FIL or 2nd wife as I am still massively upset at how he behaved re late MIL, and still furious he aided DH in deceiving me which could have ended my marriage.

I adore my DSS and his future bride, and won't cause any scene at the wedding, but I just cannot imagine even bringing myself to even be coldly polite to such a complete * (fill in the word here, you get the gist!).

Give me the benefit of MNs wisdom please ..

YANBU = Don't speak to the FIL and 2nd wife
YABU = You should speak to them for sake of DSS and his wonderful bride to be.

Third option would be I get conveniently "quarantined" the day before the wedding, but I would hate to miss it as I do love DSS dearly.

Help!

OP posts:
Wjevtvha · 24/07/2021 11:45

The money thing isn’t your fil fault and I suspect you’re transferring your feelings of anger about it to him so that you can move past it with your DH.
In terms of his actions around the new partner then if your DH can be polite and talk to him then you can too; at my wedding we had a similar situation and we seated both people at different tables but they did talk for our sake as they felt the day was about us and not them; I think you’re risking damaging your relationship with your DSS and hai wife if you refuse to.

AndSoFinally · 24/07/2021 11:44

I don't think you really have forgiven DH. You just recognise that if you continue to direct your anger towards him indefinitely then your marriage will be over.

Therefore you've subconsciously switched your vitriol to FIL who is a safer, non-marriage ending target.

I would re-examine my feelings towards DH if you want to resolve this in any lasting way.

Ozanj · 24/07/2021 11:41

@Loyalorstupid

It wasn't something he bought, like a physical item, it was to pay rent for a flat I knew nothing about and which someone else was living in.
If your dh cheated on you then how is it his dad’s fault?
Theunamedcat · 24/07/2021 11:40

Be cool polite step away from them if they try to engage with you just excuse yourself and go to the bar or speak to someone else

Loyalorstupid · 24/07/2021 11:39

I am not sure it is a common enemy thing. DH went NC with FIL because of the disrespect he felt FIL showed towards his DM by moving OW in when she wasn't dead. Also, through the marriage DH witnessed FIL often being disrespectful towards his DM and this final thing pushed him to NC.

Once I told him about the various acts of disrespect FIL had also shown to me behind DHs back, he then also understood why I was so furious with FIL too.

But, setting that aside, I am going to take the good advice here and will be polite at the wedding, and will do all I can to make sure it is a perfect day for DSS.

OP posts:
MaryBoBary · 24/07/2021 11:38

@SW1amp

So your DH had an affair and wanted to move his OW in to a little shag pad, but didn’t have the money, so his dad subbed him the cash to have somewhere for the OW to live?

And you found out about it and have forgiven your husband for having an affair, having repeated sex with a other woman, setting her up in a flat, visiting the flat for sex, lying to you about it and exposing you to STDs

But you don’t want to forgive your FIL for the loan and not telling him no, you shouldn’t be putting your OW up in a flat..?

If you forgave the situation, you forgave the situation
(Which is probably your mistake)
You can’t hold a grudge against the person with 1% involvement but forgive the person with 100%

The 2nd wife thing is a distraction
If the family was that outraged, he wouldn’t be invited to the wedding

GrinGrin someone's got an active imagination! What a ridiculous number of assumptions to make with such conviction!

OP, IMHO you need to get over these issues. It's not worth spoiling your DSS wedding day over in the slightest. Your anger towards FIL over the money is misdirected and should be 100% on your husband. With regards to your annoyance about second wife - it's not really your business. It wasn't your spouse who suffered with dementia. It's not your place to judge.

Glittertwins · 24/07/2021 11:36

I wouldn't be seeking him out to talk to and would subtly keep my distance but be polite if I absolutely had to as I would not want to be responsible for any upset at the wedding.

Pingued · 24/07/2021 11:36

Does DH have feelings towards this mister? Seems an extreme thing to do for a mate.

Anyway if you let him off having a secret flat I don't think you can be angry at FIL for helping him.

I can see why the family don't approve of the way the 2nd wife came about (but it is complicated clearly) but she is family now and your role is to support your DH. If he feels he needs to talk to them don't make it more difficult for him.

pinkyredrose · 24/07/2021 11:35

Wasn't a mistress, but someone DH had agreed he wouldn't see (male friend who was a very bad influence

This sounds a bit controlling. In what way was the friend a bad influence? Is your husband easily lead or something?
Agree that your anger is misplaced.

Micemakingclothes · 24/07/2021 11:34

You can’t literally refuse to speak to him because that could cause a scene, but you can avoid prolonged conversations.

Hoppinggreen · 24/07/2021 11:33

You are cross at the wrong person
BUT you have every right not to like someone and as long as it doesn’t spoil the wedding for the B&G do what you want

LagunaBubbles · 24/07/2021 11:33

I dont think you are as over what happened with your DH as much as you say you are. Which is why your projecting all your unresolved feelings onto your FIL.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 24/07/2021 11:32

Dh was the one who made the choice to still be friends with this guy, then go behind your back, ask for a loan from FIL, then give it to this guy. All FIL did was hand over money to his son.

It sounds like your misplacing your anger at dh here.

It was your dh that caused the entire problem and you've forgiven him for it, now he's agreeing with you because it gives you two a common enemy to blame rather than face up to the fact your dh can blatantly lie to you and sneak about.

MichelleScarn · 24/07/2021 11:31

@Fullofglee

Having worked with people with dementia often or not they say the person they were died well before they physically died, that's not to say he didn't love his first wife however in his eyes she died long before her body did,she was no longer there in spirit and mind. Regarding money issue that's on your dh your married into the family it's not up to you to take issue with your fil actions that's completely down to your dh and his sister. You can have an option and voice it to your dh but that where its stop its a wedding its unfair to the bride and groom to create tension and a hostile environment by ignoring them both.
Very very sadly agree with this, its a horrible illness.
ineedaholidaynow · 24/07/2021 11:30

If your FIL has tried to break up your marriage, again I would find it very hard to forgive your DH for not trying to do something about that, rather than going to his father to ask for money for a friend of his.

Loyalorstupid · 24/07/2021 11:30

Yes, am now definitely going to just try and avoid them, but can absolutely promise I would never do anything to spoil DSSs big day ... love him far too much for that.

OP posts:
harverina · 24/07/2021 11:28

I feel your anger is misplaced. DH presumably asked his DH for money, his dad gave it to him. Your DH is responsible 100%.

You’ve either moved on from it or you haven’t. I would suggest you haven’t and that you are still angry - this needs to be addressed with your DH not your FIL.

Ok. So you don’t like the man - but if it were me I would make an effort to say “hello and how are you” - basic chat for the sake of DSS. I actually it will take less effort than ignoring them completely - once it’s over with you can all enjoy the day. By ignoring him it will be on your mind all day and dominate the wedding. Plus if your DH speaks to him and you don’t, it will be really obvious given it’s a small wedding.

Don’t understand why the new wife wasn’t invited initially either - it’s not really her fault that her husband moved on so quickly and if DSS wants FIL there he needs to accept that his nee wife is a part of his life.

Sceptre86 · 24/07/2021 11:28

@SW1amp interesting story you've written there. Did you not read the thread!

If you love your dss then you need to grin and bare it. Ignoring them reflects on you negatively and has the potential to distrupt their day. You can air your grievances on another day. For now do your best to behave, you don't have to go out of your way to make conversation but likewise don't need to blank them either.

SheABitSpicyToday · 24/07/2021 11:27

I think yabu.
It’s ok for people to live their life and his loyalty is to his son not you.

Loyalorstupid · 24/07/2021 11:26

I think the reason I find it harder to forgive FIL is because this money thing was just one item in a whole list of things he has done to totally disrespect me, and to try and break up my marriage to DH. Which DH sees now, and understands why I find it so hard to forgive FIL when I did forgive DH.

OP posts:
Loyalorstupid · 24/07/2021 11:22

But, I do see what everyone is saying, and I agree, I am just going to have to do it and be cool but polite for sake of lovely DSS

OP posts:
RedMarauder · 24/07/2021 11:21

As long as you are not on the same table as your FIL then just go to the wedding. Don't make a big issue.

If you come across him the first time say "hello, how are you?" and if he tries to engage you in conversation make up a reason why you can't stop to talk to him. Then politely acknowledge you have seen him when you see him again but make up an excuse of why you can't stop to talk to him every single time.

It's not exactly like he can follow you in to the ladies toilet unlike if you didn't get on with a female relation.....

ineedaholidaynow · 24/07/2021 11:21

Why have you forgiven your DH but still not speaking to your FIL about giving money to this person? If DH didn't ask for the money I assume the FIL wouldn't have given the money direct to that person.

WeHaveComeSoFar · 24/07/2021 11:21

@Loyalorstupid

Just to repeat, no mistress, a male friend who always brings trouble and who always scrounges of DH because he knows DH is a soft touch.
So you forgave your DH over this, but your FIL is totally off limits?

Right ...

Loyalorstupid · 24/07/2021 11:19

Just to repeat, no mistress, a male friend who always brings trouble and who always scrounges of DH because he knows DH is a soft touch.

OP posts: