Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DPs ex won't let him meet his child

170 replies

aktion · 24/07/2021 10:34

Name changed.

My DP was in a relationship for 2 years as a teenager. They split up when he was 17/18 as he had a one night stand with someone else and he admitted it to her straight away but she split up with him and blocked him, he knew he deserved it so he didn't try and contact her or her friends again.

About 2 months ago, his mum told him she saw his ex and that her son looks like him, he brushed it off at the time. A few weeks after that, he searched her name on Facebook and found her profile, it was public so he saw the child and he does look like DP. He brushed it off again but I could tell he was thinking about it a lot so he went on her profile and found out the child was about 8, and we worked it out that he was with his ex, 9 months before the child was born. He sent her a message but not a friend request so she didn't see it. This week, he decided to send her friend request and she accepted it and saw the message. She told him that he is the father but to leave them alone as he already has a dad and it'll just confuse him and it's his own fault that he can't be involved, but he didn't even know she was pregnant! DP doesn't know what to do now, he doesn't know whether to leave his son as he seems happy and he probably believes the other man is his father but he also wants to meet his son.

Any advice will be appreciated

OP posts:
schoolmoveworrier · 24/07/2021 11:39

@Pebbledashery

But there is no guarantee of the son wanting to see your dp.. None at all. He could end up resenting him. You also can't force a relationship with him if he doesn't want one.
That doesn't mean he can't try, he should be prepared that this may happen, but it also may not. If he doesn't want to see him, I would do what pps have said and write letters, save up for him etc.
Lovemusic33 · 24/07/2021 11:39

It sounds like it could be a messy situation, the child may think the other man is his biological father and this man may believe he is the father also (she may have lied to them both)? I understand that your dp wants to be involved but this could mean a lot of upset for the child and the possible break up of the child’s parents.

It might be worth dp getting some legal advice? I’m not sure what I would do in this situation, I think he needs more details about what the child knows and what the child’s ‘non biological’ father knows.

Pebbledashery · 24/07/2021 11:38

But there is no guarantee of the son wanting to see your dp.. None at all. He could end up resenting him. You also can't force a relationship with him if he doesn't want one.

Notwavingbutdrowing3 · 24/07/2021 11:37

If DP wants to meet his child and build up a relationship, then it's the child's right to have a relationship with his biological father. He would need to apply to court, stating he has only just been told he is the father . A DNA test can be ordered by court if she disputes it or if he wants to check, which would be sensible given she has seems happy not to honest when it suits her, by not telling him and the ONS around same time.

She may then decide she also wants child maintenance for the boy going forward, if he is going to have contact- although they are unrelated and not dependent on each other. That's her right too , which she probably hasn't done so far as she didn't tell him. It won't be backdated . Only to the date she puts a claim into CMS for with proof he is father (if he disputes it)

It doesn't matter what the mum thinks at this stage, why there she's made a little family with her new DP, the child has a right to know his father and courts would work to build that up if he is the father. They'd be very sympathetic to his position of her failure to tell him.

He can Google how to apply to court for child contact and complete the form- don't need a solicitor (although it can help at the start) her only ne paying for the first court application fees (few hundred). She can't even insist on supervised contact although some introductory sessions would start. Son is old enough to understand and cafcass would work out how best to do this/ a schedule if mother is unkeen and blocking attempts.

FreeBritnee · 24/07/2021 11:35

I would pursue it legally if she won’t allow him to see his child. The child has a right to know his biological father abd the younger the better.

Grapewrath · 24/07/2021 11:33

I disagree that DP should leave this and collude to lie to his child and accept his ex’s wishes. The child may be settled but why should DP miss out on his own son because his ex wanted to live a lie.
I would go through the court to see my child and it would be done sensitively

Bluntness100 · 24/07/2021 11:30

@forinborin

To be honest, I think meeting the child in this case should come together with 9 years worth of child maintenance.
That’s ludicrous, you sound money obsessed. Like it’s all you can think about.
schoolmoveworrier · 24/07/2021 11:29

@forinborin

Yes and I have agreed with that, what I don't agree with is 9 years of "back pay" for a child he didn't know about. A big fat financial reward for his mum being a liar. Don't get me wrong, I think the mum is definitely the bad guy here. There's no excuse for what she has done. The question was, however, about what a biological father is to do.

I just tried to imagine myself in this situation. Well, difficult because women are unlikely to have doubts about whether the children are biologically theirs or not - but I tried my best. If I wanted to suddenly declare myself a "mother" to a 9 year old child happily living in another family - and being a mother does not suddenly start from a specific point in time, the message here is that I have been your mother all this time, and this woman you called mum all your life is actually someone unrelated - then yes, I'd consider a financial contribution for all the years I am now claiming to have been their mother to be the very least I could do.

Bollocks. Absolute bollocks. And if you are telling the truth, then you need to reassess your relationships in all seriousness.
Bluntness100 · 24/07/2021 11:29

He needs to continue to talk to the mum, accept that it’s a complex situation but one day he will need to know the truth. That he wishes to develop a relationship when she thinks the time is right and also to financially support, that he doesn’t wish to go through the courts , doesn’t want to cause pain, but feels strongly the child should know his biological father. That he wants to keep talking to her as they both adjust and find a way through this in the child’s best interests, ask her or her and her partner to meet up.

ImInStealthMode · 24/07/2021 11:27

@forinborin Are you missing the fact that the father in this scenario didn't know of the child's existence? He's not 'suddenly declaring' himself their Dad, or wanting a 'big reveal' after 9 years of not being interested. He didn't know until now!

Agree with PP's that the only way this will go is coming back to bite the Mother in the arse when the kid grows up and finds out he's been lied to. Punishing your child for someone else's one night stand is a strange way to go about life.

ineedaholidaynow · 24/07/2021 11:24

Do you live locally to this woman, I assume your MIL does?

Pebbledashery · 24/07/2021 11:18

As hard as it is to hear this, at that age I would leave him alone. He's known another father his entire like I presume and I would not disrupt that. You have no guarantee he will a) want to see your partner or b) will not take this news badly. 8/9 years old is a significant age to have a life event completely derail you. I would leave him alone.

forinborin · 24/07/2021 11:13

Yes and I have agreed with that, what I don't agree with is 9 years of "back pay" for a child he didn't know about. A big fat financial reward for his mum being a liar.
Don't get me wrong, I think the mum is definitely the bad guy here. There's no excuse for what she has done. The question was, however, about what a biological father is to do.

I just tried to imagine myself in this situation. Well, difficult because women are unlikely to have doubts about whether the children are biologically theirs or not - but I tried my best. If I wanted to suddenly declare myself a "mother" to a 9 year old child happily living in another family - and being a mother does not suddenly start from a specific point in time, the message here is that I have been your mother all this time, and this woman you called mum all your life is actually someone unrelated - then yes, I'd consider a financial contribution for all the years I am now claiming to have been their mother to be the very least I could do.

nocturnalcatfreetogoodhome · 24/07/2021 11:13

Unfortunately, I feel he must respect her wishes.

Why doesn't he get a box and write a letter to the boy - everything he would want him to say/know and then put it in the box. Every time he thinks of contacting him/his birthday/Christmas etc he can 'update him' and write a new letter and store them safely. He could start a bank account for him also - £50 here and there?

That way, when or if, the child comes looking for him or he reaches out when he's older he can give them to him to let him know that he was thinking of him. I feel for your husband/his child in this situation but I think it's best he supports the Mother's wishes.

Gooriddance · 24/07/2021 11:11

The child can easily find out if he has an ancestry dna test when he is older. No point even trying to keep it secret.
He should be allowed a relationship with his biological dad.

RedMarauder · 24/07/2021 11:10

@ineedaholidaynow

Secrets like this very rarely end well.
This.

The boy will be a teenager in a few years and many teenagers question their identity. The boy will also be noticing that he doesn't have certain prominent characteristics and/or mannerisms of either of his parents or their extended families. Other people will have noticed this already.

Your DP needs to write to the mother and politely ask for a paternity test. If he gets no reply or one telling him to get lost then he's going to have to get a family solicitor involved.

yoursfroobly · 24/07/2021 11:08

Also, I would set up a savings account now depositing monthly payments. To cover child support from when he found out. You don't know what will unfold in the future

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 24/07/2021 11:07

@forinborin I don't think anyone is arguing about children costing and if OP's partner was in the childs life then he should have paid maintenance. It's more the fact of not agreeing that the father should pay backdated 9 years when he didn't know the child existed.

ineedaholidaynow · 24/07/2021 11:07

Be interesting to know whether the 'dad' knows he is not the biological father

yoursfroobly · 24/07/2021 11:06

In your DPs position I would take steps to be involved in the child's life.
If as an adult that child turned up on my doorstep asking why I didn't want to be involved when I knew about them then I wouldn't forgive myself. It's so so tough though and I don't know if my approach would be the 'right' one.
How dare she keep this a secret Angry

schoolmoveworrier · 24/07/2021 11:04

@forinborin

Ah so it's pay per view then. Gross. Gross or not, the children cost money, and being a parent usually comes with financial obligations too.
Yes and I have agreed with that, what I don't agree with is 9 years of "back pay" for a child he didn't know about. A big fat financial reward for his mum being a liar.

If you think money is the most important thing here I think you need to reassess your priorities.

forinborin · 24/07/2021 11:01

Ah so it's pay per view then. Gross.
Gross or not, the children cost money, and being a parent usually comes with financial obligations too.

forinborin · 24/07/2021 10:59

Being a Mother has obligations to, like telling a man they are a father.. no?
Yes, but, unfortunately, everyone is responsible only for their own behaviour.

schoolmoveworrier · 24/07/2021 10:59

@forinborin

Do you really. Why is that? As she’s said, he already has a dad and OP’s partner isn’t welcome. Well, that is exactly why. If the child already, for all intents and purposes, has a dad and the biological father wants a big reveal moment now, it is only fair that he actually picks up at least the financial side, no? Of course he won't be legally obliged to, but morally, I think, he should - if he wants to be a part of the picture.
Ah so it's pay per view then. Gross.

I agree that now he knows and if he does hey involved in his life there should be some contribution but I don't agree in paying 9 years worth of debt and I don't think money should be a condition of knowing your own child and frankly anyone who does has huge issues.

Hankunamatata · 24/07/2021 10:59

What a terrible secret. Its not going to end well. Perhaps dp could get some counselling about it so he can decide what to do. In meantime he could start writing letters to his son and keep them just incase everything later explodes.