Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ok for people to comment if you’ve put on weight?

188 replies

cooperbug · 23/07/2021 21:53

Would you be offended if family members and other random people had commented that you had put on weight or asked if you were pregnant?

This has happened twice to me this week and I’m so angry and upset by it?

How would you respond?

OP posts:
joystir59 · 24/07/2021 09:05

I've been offered seats on buses due to "my condition" which was mortifying because I was just very fat.

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 09:04

Being overweight or obese isn't a matter of appearance, it's a state of being which indicates an unhealthy relationship with food. We comment on all sorts of matters of concern regarding people we love. Why is this issue so tabboo?
It's only acceptable to comment on another's appearance if it is to be complimentary or point out something the person hasn't noticed eg skirt tucked into tights etc

GlutenFreeGingerCake · 24/07/2021 09:03

Well it is rude but is MiL very hopeful for a DGC and getting carried away. At least she apologised.

PickAChew · 24/07/2021 09:03

@joystir59

Let's face it a huge chunk (see what I did there) of the population are either overweight or obese so I don't see why we can't talk about the elephants in the room
And many people aren't overweight, yet we still have rude people.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 24/07/2021 08:57

It's ok from family, close members, not from random strangers.

Oysterbabe · 24/07/2021 08:55

It's never OK.
All it does it cause someone else upset. Do the commenters think someone hasn't noticed the weight gain? Believe me, they have.

AdelindSchade · 24/07/2021 08:08

Very rude. Tbe pregnant thing has happened to me so I would never ask. They will either tell you or it will at some point become blindingly obvious so what's the need to ask anyway?

Numnumcookie · 24/07/2021 08:03

Rude.

It's only acceptable to comment on another's appearance if it is to be complimentary or point out something the person hasn't noticed eg skirt tucked into tights etc.

NormanStangerson · 24/07/2021 08:00

@joystir59

Let's face it a huge chunk (see what I did there) of the population are either overweight or obese so I don't see why we can't talk about the elephants in the room
Who shat in your sugar-free muesli this morning? Hmm
LonstantonSpiceMuseum · 24/07/2021 07:40

You're going to get a range of answers here. Not everyone places value on appearances or weight. If they don't consider it an important or sensitive thing, then they're less likely to remember it in conversation. Maybe there was an awkward gap in conversation and they couldn't think of anything else.
Or they could come from a culture (even if they are in the UK) where it's acceptable.
If you've grown up with everyone being okay with it, how are you going to know, or remember it?

Personally I wouldn't in the UK because I know that a lot of people don't like it - the only time I may would is if it was asked directly or was extremely clear they wanted a direct answer!

There's a list of UK topics you don't mention - age, finances, looks, miscarriage (yes really this is okay in some other places) whether someone has had plastic surgery, many other things.
These may seem obvious to you, but other people will have a different idea of what's sensitive and what's not.

Of course you'll get the odd person doing it on purpose, but that's rarer than people on here think.

WeWantAMackerelNotASprat · 24/07/2021 06:33

I used to be really thin. (5'7 and 7 stone) so I put on weight and my aunt complimented me!! (Probably needed as I did need to fill out)

I've recently lost half a stone as I ended up feeling (and looking) chunky and am now at a happy weight. (I'm like you and put weight on around my middle)

People just don't think. Sorry they've upset you

Sparklfairy · 24/07/2021 06:25

@joystir59

Yes it's fine to tell a friend or family member they've put on weight. Even random strangers felt it fine to tell me I was getting too thin when I lost weight. The reverse is no different. I'm sick of fat people wailing "don't fat shame me!"
Ouch.

The ONLY time it's acceptable to comment on someone else's appearance is to compliment them.

Have some class.

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 06:23

Let's face it a huge chunk (see what I did there) of the population are either overweight or obese so I don't see why we can't talk about the elephants in the room

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 06:21

Why do people get so upset about someone else's perception of them?

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 06:20

Yes it's fine to tell a friend or family member they've put on weight. Even random strangers felt it fine to tell me I was getting too thin when I lost weight. The reverse is no different. I'm sick of fat people wailing "don't fat shame me!"

Pingued · 24/07/2021 06:16

It's so rude.

yikesanotherbooboo · 24/07/2021 06:12

I don't think it is acceptable to make personal comments .

DysmalRadius · 23/07/2021 23:07

@WhoDidAndWhy

It’s rude, but I’m also of the view that commenting on weight loss is rude too. Another person’s weight is not your concern.
Me too! I never comment on people's weight either way and I hate it when people comment on my body as it feels so judgy whether it's a loss or a gain, a compliment or an insult. It shouldn't be so important to anyone else that it needs commenting on.
WhoDidAndWhy · 23/07/2021 22:56

It’s rude, but I’m also of the view that commenting on weight loss is rude too. Another person’s weight is not your concern.

AgentProvocateur · 23/07/2021 22:53

I live in a country where people from
Far Eastern countries delight in telling you that “you’re so pretty, but so fat” or “you’ve got much fatter since I last saw you”. I’m used to it now 😂

Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 23/07/2021 22:50

Yes, I would be offended and very upset. I would never comment on somebodies figure/looks/clothes etc , unless it was to say something positive, I just don’t get why people say neg things to others unless it’s to make themselves feel better I guess.

1990b · 23/07/2021 22:19

No its not okay.

I was told l was fat and needed to lose weight 2hrs after my wedding.

I had only met my husband's family once ( arranged marriage) so didn't know anyone. His aunt told me that l was fat and should lose weight

Some people can't help themselves

cooperbug · 23/07/2021 22:15

Yes Actually my husband told his mum that I was insulted by her comment and she has since apologised via text but twice in one with with it happening again today at school has given me a complex!

I just ignored the child’s grandmother today as felt like I was going to cry if I had spoken

OP posts:
theheartofthematter · 23/07/2021 22:12

It's funny because I always want to feel that any weight I put on isn't visible but I have recently lost over a stone and want everyone to notice that!

Owlshouse · 23/07/2021 22:09

Asking if I'd put on weight would only be not rude if someone knew I had been trying hard to gain weight due to being underweight or wanting to increase muscle mass. Neither of those will probably ever apply to me so yes I would be annoyed.

Asking if someone is pregnant should always avoided - even if you are correct and the person is pregnant then they obviously aren't ready to disclose it otherwise they would have said so, if they are not pregnant it's either insulting with the suggestion they have gained weight or upsetting depending on the person's personal circumstances