Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ok for people to comment if you’ve put on weight?

188 replies

cooperbug · 23/07/2021 21:53

Would you be offended if family members and other random people had commented that you had put on weight or asked if you were pregnant?

This has happened twice to me this week and I’m so angry and upset by it?

How would you respond?

OP posts:
kowari · 24/07/2021 14:19

Because it says all they care about is your appearance. They could ask anything but when the first thing they say is "you've put on weight" it is shallow. Appearance and changes in appearance are usually an indicator of general wellbeing.

DysmalRadius · 24/07/2021 14:18

Very few people live in a society without internalising some of the values of that society. In a world where fat is seen as bad, in a variety of ways, its not really surprising that commenting on someone's weight also carries with it some value judgement. I don't think that many people have such rock solid self esteem and confidence that they are able to brush off an unprompted negative comment from someone unaffected.

And that's before you get to the mindfield of asking someone if they're pregnant which is never as good idea.

Pingued · 24/07/2021 14:18

If genuinely concerned about people's weight there are ways to have gentle conversations and express concerns. But only if close to that person.

Pingued · 24/07/2021 14:17

@joystir59

Why is it so incredibly hurtful to have someone say you've gained weight or lost weight?
Because it says all they care about is your appearance. They could ask anything but when the first thing they say is "you've put on weight" it is shallow.
PurpleDaisies · 24/07/2021 14:16

@joystir59

My partner actually died of actual cancer a year ago after a dreadful illness. That's painful, that's devastating, not someone asking you if you are pregnant when you are or aren't and not someone telling you you've lost weight or put it on.
Now you’ve told me that my infertility is not painful or devastating, it’s all fine now. Hmm
kowari · 24/07/2021 14:07

If it's out of concern, if there is a change in your appearance that might indicate that you are struggling then I think it's perfectly reasonable to say you have noticed and ask if someone is okay. I've had people concerned when I've lost weight and told me so.

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 14:03

Perhaps our incredible sensitivity about our weight is part of the problem? If the emphasis was on health and not cosmetic appearance perhaps we could have supportive open conversations on the subject.

Montsti · 24/07/2021 13:58

I think it’s very rude and would never say anything. In fact I don’t comment even if it’s fairly obvious someone is pregnant…

One of my friends puts on weight on her tummy and is often asked if she’s pregnant. She’s 52 and so responds by saying she’ll take it as a compliment as they obviously think she looks much younger than she is to be pregnant in the first place!
My 6 year old has asked her before which was so embarrassing and I felt awful. My friend took it well but I cringed..

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 13:58

I've never commented on anyone's weight but plenty of people have commented on mine. I don't get why it upsets people so much.

lljkk · 24/07/2021 13:57

Would you be offended if family members and other random people had commented that you had put on weight or asked if you were pregnant?

no.... I wouldn't be offended.
I guess I'd take it as opinion or factual, not an insult to be x-body-size. If their opinion isn't nice then I don't need to care about their opinion.

I kind of understand people who are offended.
I note there are lots people who are not offended if you say they have lost weight. Or changed hairstyle. Or anything they put effort into doing that they hope looks nicer than previously.

It's a minefield. I'll chat if someone wants to talk about their body parts or size or appearance, but I try not to have native opinions about such things. I might comment if I thought someone was unhealthily underweight or in denial about their morbid obesity. You owe it to people you love to tell them truths you see that they don't want to face.

Dacquoise · 24/07/2021 13:55

@Grapewrath, totally agree with the jealousy comments. My cousin who has been obesely overweight her whole life would make gleeful comments in public if I put on any weight although I have always been fairly slim. I would never dream of mentioning her weight because I knew how sensitive she was about it and wouldn't hurt her feelings like that.

It's rude and personal and designed to belittle.

pooiepooie25 · 24/07/2021 13:52

@joystir59

Why is it so incredibly hurtful to have someone say you've gained weight or lost weight?
Really? You honestly cannot see why someone would be upset by this?
WelliesandWine88 · 24/07/2021 13:51

I'm sorry for your loss.
However, your circumstances do not set the bar for what others are allowed to be hurt or upset by. Nor do they excuse fat phobia.
Its very self centred and small minded to believe that others can't be hurt by things that you deem less upsetting than your own experiences.

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 13:50

So I repeat, why are we so sensitive about our weight? I've been every size from ten to twenty. I'm food addicted, I've got a difficult relationship with food. I look like I'm drowning in my own I'll gotten flesh when I'm size twenty. I look unhappy and unhealthy. That makes strangers uncomfortable and my loved ones concerned. I'm working hard and doing really well at managing to stay a healthy weight. People tell me I look too thin. I'm wrinkly. I've got saggy crepy skin where the weight dropped off. I don't care, they are battle wrinkles. It isn't about appearance, although I absolutely ove being able to wear all sorts of clothes now. It's about being able to move freely without aching, it's about health.

Fairyliz · 24/07/2021 13:48

Wow that’s incredibly rude. I wouldn’t say anything even if I thought someone was pregnant unless they were actually giving birth in front of me.

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 13:45

My partner actually died of actual cancer a year ago after a dreadful illness. That's painful, that's devastating, not someone asking you if you are pregnant when you are or aren't and not someone telling you you've lost weight or put it on.

WeatherForecast · 24/07/2021 13:44

It’s not socially acceptable in the UK.

But it wouldn’t bother me tbh. My weight/size isn’t a reflection on who I am as a person, it’s a reflection on how much I’ve been eating and exercising, and not a moral failing or achievement. Someone mentioning I’d gained weight wouldn’t bother me at all if it was true or if they were mistaken: either it’s a fact and I’m not daft enough to think people can’t tell, or they’re mistaken.

Looubylou · 24/07/2021 13:43

People do this with acne too - very common for comments to be made - as if someone doesn't know their skin looks bad that day. Very distressing, even if the person doesn't show it.

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 13:43

*Needs

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 13:43

Why are we so sensitive about our weight though? Why can't it be talked about because some kind of conversation Edd's to be opened up beyond the jokey crap that's socially acceptable. We don't think it's ok to drink ourselves to oblivion or smoke ourselves to death do we? Fat is an issue that we need to talk about. I saw a family walk down the steps onto my local beach a few mornings ago. They were all overweight and several were obese. They plonked themselve and all of their stuff down right there at the bottom.of the steps. Right where all the dogs pause to make their mark. Ok, perhaps there were health or mobility issues that meant they couldn't walk on. There was a mile of clean pristine beach just beyond the steps. I felt sad- this seemed to be in that moment such a symbol of something- we should want more, better for ourselves than a patch of urine soaked sand or some crappy nasty food engineered for maximum profit at least cost. We deserve more! Better access, better opportunities, and better quality food at affordable prices. We need to take control of our own wellbeing.

Flambola · 24/07/2021 13:42

Personally I don’t mind, it’s usually true (that I’ve put on weight). I come from a SE Asian background though where it’s acceptable. But I would never, ever say it to anyone else. So rude. And I would never ask if they were pregnant!

PurpleDaisies · 24/07/2021 13:37

I think it's ok for MIL/family to ask, they will be naturally interested in whether they're going to have another baby in the family.

It really isn’t. What about waiting until people are ready to tell you?

if you look obviously pregnant, people will ask about it.

What if you’ve just had a miscarriage but still look pregnant? What if it’s your endometriosis that’s stopping you from getting pregnant but making you look like you are?

It's usually a happy occasion and people are happy for you.
If you actually are pregnant and are telling people that. It’s devastating to be asked if you want to be but aren’t.

It’s never ok to ask someone if they’re pregnant.

DysmalRadius · 24/07/2021 13:37

I think it's ok for MIL/family to ask, they will be naturally interested in whether they're going to have another baby in the family. Maybe it would have been better if she discreetly asked your DH but it doesn't change the fact that if you look obviously pregnant, people will ask about it. It's usually a happy occasion and people are happy for you.

No. Its nobody's business if someone else is pregnant unless they want to tell you. Having to explain to some tactless twat that I wasn't pregnant three days after having a miscarriage made the experience immeasurably worse. And I consider that mild. Someone said it to a friend soon after she'd found out she was infertile and she ended up in good of tears at her own birthday party. If someone wants to tell you they're having a baby, let them. Until then, it's none of your business and such a personal and tactless question to ask.

DysmalRadius · 24/07/2021 13:30

My ex fil used to delight in tellling me I’d gained weight when I’d gone from a size 8 to a 12 despite his own wife sitting next to him being several stone over weight

He was rude, but why is his wife's weight the issue? Did she say anything to you? Because its mostly women who are critiqued on their bodies and the idea that he shouldn't comment because you were still slimmer than his fat wife is not much better than him commenting in the first place.

ohthatbloodycat · 24/07/2021 13:30

That's never ok.