Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ok for people to comment if you’ve put on weight?

188 replies

cooperbug · 23/07/2021 21:53

Would you be offended if family members and other random people had commented that you had put on weight or asked if you were pregnant?

This has happened twice to me this week and I’m so angry and upset by it?

How would you respond?

OP posts:
SourAppleChew · 25/07/2021 11:54

Expanding on my previous comment, I think it would still be seen as offensive of a slim/normal bloke insulted his fat friend (unless they had a very open relationship).

However, when a man puts on a few lbs you're definitely much more likely to hear the "who ate all the pies"/"you've put on a bit of timber" comments than if it were a woman.

I think this reflects two things. Firstly, men are less concerned as they aren't judged on their looks as much. However, I do think men are in general more resilient too and more used to competition/hierarchy as a standard interaction.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/07/2021 11:03

@theheartofthematter

It's funny because I always want to feel that any weight I put on isn't visible but I have recently lost over a stone and want everyone to notice that!
It's odd how this subject affects people (women, particularly) in different ways. I never want people to comment on my weight, gained or lost.

I've dropped several dress sizes and lost a bit of weight during lockdown. Partly down to stress, partly down to being busier and partly down to needing to distract myself so I do a lot of swimming now, also training sessions and these have really toned me.

I'm dreading, seriously dreading, meeting up with my office team again. I don't want anybody to comment and I know they will as the difference is quite stark. For me it's not a compliment and I just don't want it acknowledged at all. People can't seem to help themselves though. I cope with it with family and accept it because they love me, I don't like it though.

notacooldad · 25/07/2021 10:18

Me and my friend joke that the generation above us like slim people. ( my mum.and my nan) However, not just slim people, it's always " nice and slim" when describing someone!!
I'm sure my nan modelled herself on Wallis Simpson to be as tiny as possible. At parties she used to refuse food by putting her hand up, to turn food away and saying "I couldn't possibly"

It's fair to say I was a source of disappointment as far as my weight went!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 08:40

@SourAppleChew

It’s ok to tell a bloke but not a woman. That seems to be the case from what I’ve seen.

Heard plenty of blokes say “hurry up you fat bastard” etc, obviously in jest, but I’ve never once heard a woman call her friend a “fat bitch”.

Same with weight loss. I lost 5x more than dh. He got complimets straight away. I actually ended up asking friends wtf? "I would never comment on women's weight". Fuck off. Because I have vajajay doesn't make me that more sensitive than my DH who the person complimented before. I want my fucking kudos😑 Dh was baffled by the fact no one, except 2 people, said nothing. 50 kilo difference!
WeatherForecast · 25/07/2021 05:22

@SourAppleChew

It’s ok to tell a bloke but not a woman. That seems to be the case from what I’ve seen.

Heard plenty of blokes say “hurry up you fat bastard” etc, obviously in jest, but I’ve never once heard a woman call her friend a “fat bitch”.

This is true. Women are certainly held to different and more stringent beauty standards in our culture. The whole topic of weight seems to land differently for women than it does men, as the pressure to be slim is a lot more intense if you’re a woman.

Personally i was amazed at how many people were happy to take a punt and ask me if I was pregnant or when I was due when I was pregnant! From total strangers I walked past to staff in shops to people at work, none of whom knew I was. Soooo many people mentioned it. I mean I was very visibly pregnant, but I did wonder whether they said that to others too and sometimes got it wrong. Personally I’d never mention it unless the other person did, though I would offer someone a seat if I thought they might be pregnant. I’d rather risk upsetting the feelings of someone who isn’t pregnant than sit there and not offer someone who is pregnant some assistance.

Thomasina79 · 25/07/2021 04:32

I was on a bus once which was going quite fast, trying to hold on to a large suitcase with a mind of its own. Random stranger next to me said I would find it easier if I was smaller and then changed seats. This was after I had apologised for bumping into him. I was speechless!

SourAppleChew · 25/07/2021 04:18

It’s ok to tell a bloke but not a woman. That seems to be the case from what I’ve seen.

Heard plenty of blokes say “hurry up you fat bastard” etc, obviously in jest, but I’ve never once heard a woman call her friend a “fat bitch”.

Blankspace4 · 24/07/2021 22:18

I think it’s very rude.

A supermarket check out lady asked me when I was due about a year ago. I wasn’t, and haven’t ever, been pregnant. I burned with shame.

I can tell my MIL judges me for having put on weight (she always tells me I look well when I’m slimmer….and makes a lot of fat phobic comments) which makes me feel very uncomfortable

I’m a size 14

Dogvmarmot · 24/07/2021 22:09

@cooperbug

A one off but she does speak before she thinks, I had my dressing gown on at the time!
hopefully the dressing gown was not at the school gates. You gained 1 stone over lockdown and a global pandemic. It was what you were wearing unless you are only 4ft. people are v sensitive about their weight so I would only mention it if they were clearly 9 months pregnant or I was concerned they had a tumor distending their stomach or a medical issue. Dont be self conscious - everyone's diet has been awful. I may not have 'excess weight' but I have been averaging at least 2 ice creams a day. With chocolate sauce. None of us are in a position to judge.
redcarbluecar · 24/07/2021 21:56

If I asked someone whether they thought I’d gained weight, I’d expect an honest answer. Unsolicited comments, however, would get very short shrift - probably completely blanked. I think it’s really bad manners.

DanniDuck · 24/07/2021 21:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

adeleh · 24/07/2021 18:58

I don’t think it’s ever ok unless you are very close and have good reason to worry about health issues..
My Mum, Dad and sister have all felt free to make comments to me and, now, looking at old photos I realise I was fine - 5ft 7 and size 12. I’m much bigger now, but I wish I’d been able to relax then. It just makes me not want to be around them much, frankly, when that happens.

kowari · 24/07/2021 18:48

@Heartofglass12345
Recent unintentional weight changes in either direction can be a sign that a person is unwell or otherwise struggling. I don't see how it matters if it is a gain or a loss.

Heartofglass12345 · 24/07/2021 18:40

"Would you be offended if family members and other random people had commented that you had put on weight or asked if you were pregnant?"

@kowari the OP asked specifically about weight gain. I have put on a lot of weight over the past couple of years and I know I have, I don't need other people pointing it out pretending to be concerned

Winterwoollies · 24/07/2021 18:27

I didn’t put on a lot of weight during pregnancy and my baby was very small. I had to have a lot of intervention with St George’s foetal medicine. I lost the small bit of weight quickly and when I saw a certain friend about two weeks post my ELCS, she ‘jokingly’ told me to fuck off repeatedly for being slim again. She went on and on and on to everyone who would listen. I felt utterly humiliated as everyone we were with turned their attention to my healing, recently pregnant body. Awful. I felt exposed.

I also used to suffer with terrible periods, and particularly bloating in the run to it. My MIL once grabbed my stomach completely randomly to see if I was pregnant. I leapt away from her, utterly horrified. It was like she couldn’t help herself. Fucking awful.

The shape of my body, nor anyone else’s body, is up for discussion, criticism or judgement.

Mickarooni · 24/07/2021 18:00

One must be really lacking in empathy, sensitivity and imagination if they genuinely can’t understand why a comment about weight might be very difficult for some people. (Caveat - I know some cognitive conditions e.g. dementia affect the way people process and deliver information.) Even if it isn’t the case that you’d feel upset, it’s a normal human thing to try to put yourself in another person’s shoes. Hmm

Quite a few people negatively commented on my appearance (skinny limbs but bloated belly and face from high dose steroids) following several weeks on life support in a medically induced coma. Those shitty comments really were the icing on the cake.

Anjo2011 · 24/07/2021 17:09

Not ok. But in my experience, family members think it’s acceptable to pass comment.

kowari · 24/07/2021 17:06

@Heartofglass12345

No it's not ok, fat people know they are fat, we don't need to be told by other people. It's really insensitive Sad
The OP was talking about weight changes, not people who are underweight or overweight or obese but whose condition hasn't changed. Usually if someone's appearance has changed for the worse then something is not right. I was grateful that people noticed when I wasn't well and expressed their concern. Yes, I already knew I was dangerously underweight, but they were showing that they cared.
PickAChew · 24/07/2021 16:31

@joystir59

I've never commented on anyone's weight but plenty of people have commented on mine. I don't get why it upsets people so much.
My weight has tended to fluctuate a little, over the years. When I've put weight on, I bloody know I've put weight on and don't need someone to tell me about it.
Grapewrath · 24/07/2021 15:42

@DysmalRadius

My ex fil used to delight in tellling me I’d gained weight when I’d gone from a size 8 to a 12 despite his own wife sitting next to him being several stone over weight

He was rude, but why is his wife's weight the issue? Did she say anything to you? Because its mostly women who are critiqued on their bodies and the idea that he shouldn't comment because you were still slimmer than his fat wife is not much better than him commenting in the first place.

The fact the because he didn’t like me, he commented on my weight whereas his own wife had gained several stone and he never mentioned it. Therefore his comments had very little to do with weight and more to do with spite
Heartofglass12345 · 24/07/2021 15:23

No it's not ok, fat people know they are fat, we don't need to be told by other people. It's really insensitive Sad

joystir59 · 24/07/2021 14:58

Alright.

PurpleDaisies · 24/07/2021 14:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DysmalRadius · 24/07/2021 14:54

Well, that was a poorly timed cross post and I apologise because your kind words to Purple Daisys were very gracious.

DysmalRadius · 24/07/2021 14:53

It is realistic to expect only to hear kind words or no words, at times

Especially when you seem to have such trouble dispensing them.