Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ok for people to comment if you’ve put on weight?

188 replies

cooperbug · 23/07/2021 21:53

Would you be offended if family members and other random people had commented that you had put on weight or asked if you were pregnant?

This has happened twice to me this week and I’m so angry and upset by it?

How would you respond?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Numnumcookie · 08/09/2021 22:42

Fed up of people pretending that they comment on your weight because they are concerned for your health. That's utter bullshit.

Will your comment change anything? No.

Do you honestly believe the fat person doesn't know they're fat? Not a fucking chance, people like you like to remind them of that fact every single day.

Will your comment make them miserable and probably send them into a depressing mood which they will then attempt to get rid of by eating their feelings and hence making them fatter? Yes, it will in a lot of cases because a lot of overweight people are so because of emotional/mental health reasons just like those with anorexia.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/07/2021 18:58

I think that's a greatly supportive comment, VanGoSunflower, "I still think you look great anyway...". Who could mind that? I'm going to pinch it!

VanGoSunflowers · 25/07/2021 18:36

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe

VanGoSunflowers definitely. If you mention it then it's obvious that you want it commented on. My point earlier was that people comment without knowing the reasons or whether a comment is welcome and weight loss can be such a sensitive subject. I've been with people in a conference who congratulated somebody for his astonishing weight loss. He was really ill and it wasn't intentional.

I'm of the 'loose lips sink ships' school.

I’m exactly the same as you! I’d be mortified if I had offended someone unintentionally. I don’t even comment if someone, say, complains to me about a partner unless they specifically ask for my opinion!

Going off on a tangent here.

I’m also bad with not knowing what to say if someone complains to me that they have put weight on and feel unattractive.

I don’t want to patronise them and tell them they don’t look as thought they have (unless I mean it) as they know it’ll be insincere.

I try with a ‘well I still think you look great’ or words to that effect.

iwouldlikearefundonmybody · 25/07/2021 18:26

Someone asked me if I was pregnant, when I started on antidepressants. It made me really self conscious. Sad
But as time gone on, I'm happier with my new weight.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/07/2021 18:00

VanGoSunflowers definitely. If you mention it then it's obvious that you want it commented on. My point earlier was that people comment without knowing the reasons or whether a comment is welcome and weight loss can be such a sensitive subject. I've been with people in a conference who congratulated somebody for his astonishing weight loss. He was really ill and it wasn't intentional.

I'm of the 'loose lips sink ships' school.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 17:57

😂 I grew up with "Self praise smells bad" saying so😂
We all have our hangups.
I still believe that if people are not nasty, it should be fine to discuss gain/loss.
Not "omg have you like eaten all the pizza of London?". More like "You gained/lost a bit, didn't you? You ok?" Style.

VanGoSunflowers · 25/07/2021 17:54

I don’t think it’s a bad thing to mention things you’re proud of achieving to your friends/colleagues. Intentional weight loss is something to be proud of!

God I am terrible at showing off about stuff I’ve achieved - even really small stuff! I like to think I do it in an endearing way though but maybe I don’t Grin

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/07/2021 17:51

SchrodingersImmigrant, do you think so? I would feel sad that you didn't feel able to mention it for fear of thinking that I'd perceive you as needy. Weightloss - if you're (general, not directed at you) not ill, have done it on purpose and are happy about it - is definitely to be congratulated, and I would.

I think my hang-up about it goes back to my much-loved nan, on excitedly hearing from me that I'd lost a pound, said, "That's good, Lying, better not to have put it on in the first place though, don't you think?". She loved me dearly, it's just how she thought and I think it was generational. Women are generally more sensitive about weight.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 17:46

The problem is that mentioning own weightloss will look "needy"🙈
Ugh. It's all doomed. Unless you are my DH 😂
He genuinely felt sorry for me so made sure to tell me that it is indeed visible, a lot.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/07/2021 17:40

@SchrodingersImmigrant

My losing weight was harder than my degree
Quite. If I knew you in RL, I'd know whether you wanted a comment about your weight loss or not, so I'd know what to say.

I wouldn't know about your degree just by looking at you (as I would about your weight) so, if you mention your degree to me, I'd congratulate you. If you mention your weight loss, I'd assume you want to be congratulated so I would.

I'd be steered by you, no hurt feelings for anybody. That's my point.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/07/2021 17:38

I agree about the positive comments on clothing, I don't think anybody has been offended by, "That's a lovely dress, beautiful cut/colour/etc," because it's not a personal comment.

Making a comment about somebody's body just is. It ought to be off limits unless you are close to that person.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 17:37

My losing weight was harder than my degree

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/07/2021 17:36

@SchrodingersImmigrant

Maybe we should stop praising people for graduating too. You know. As a society we put too much value to a degree. Or wait. Maybe we are praising the work behind it, innit.

Anyone with half brain knows to come in with "Have you lost weight?" Not "omg amazeballs weightloss" if you aren't sure about why they lost. Then go with the reaction. Happy? Go with that. Sad? Go with that.

I wish we could be more like guys and just say things🙄

Can you really not see the difference between getting a degree and losing weight? People are not judged for academic qualifications but they are for their weight.

In any event, if you don't know whether a person would appreciate the comment, don't make it. That seems sensible to me.

We don't have to be like 'guys' either, just maybe not blurt out every little thing that crosses a synapse.

VanGoSunflowers · 25/07/2021 17:14

This goes for people who have lost weight too, btw.

I’ve been through a very stressful time recently (work issues and divorce) and my appetite suffered as a result. Was still eating but not as much and I did lose a few pounds (I’m already slim)
Had a few people think it was ok to tell me I ‘need to put some weight on’ or ‘whatever you do, don’t lose anymore’ or ‘you need to eat more chocolate’

It’s rude and insensitive and at that point in my life, my appearance was the least of my worries.

VanGoSunflowers · 25/07/2021 17:11

Family/friends - no
GP - absolutely

whoslaughingnow73 · 25/07/2021 17:09

It's rude to make personal comments about other people's appearance full stop. Other than a 'you look nice/that's a lovely dress!' (if you mean it!) type thing then I steer well clear.

But I would also say something if someone commented like this to me at the time because I can't abide rudeness. It's probably the only time the old MN cliche of 'did you mean to be so rude?' would work!

TwoBrownSugars · 25/07/2021 17:05

I'd not make comments like that to people. But to be honest I would notice it. My DSis has put on a lot of weight over the past 5 years. It's very obvious, but I never mentioned it.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/07/2021 17:00

Maybe we should stop praising people for graduating too. You know. As a society we put too much value to a degree.
Or wait. Maybe we are praising the work behind it, innit.

Anyone with half brain knows to come in with "Have you lost weight?" Not "omg amazeballs weightloss" if you aren't sure about why they lost. Then go with the reaction. Happy? Go with that. Sad? Go with that.

I wish we could be more like guys and just say things🙄

MolyHolyGuacamole · 25/07/2021 16:38

But people who've worked hard to lose weigh (as opposed to unwanted weight loss or illness) often WANT you to comment.

If someone says to me 'look how much weight I've lost, how do I look?' Then I'd pay a compliment. But I'm not out here just praising people for weight loss as though they're only worthy if they're thin/thinner. As a society we attach too much value to a person based on looks and size.

Also, a person who's lost a lot of weight quickly might be ill or suffering from an eating disorder. Comments on their size are not helpful in this instance.

I might comment on a person's outfit, 'you look nice today!' But generally it doesn't (shouldn't) matter

Gwenhwyfar · 25/07/2021 16:31

@WhoDidAndWhy

It’s rude, but I’m also of the view that commenting on weight loss is rude too. Another person’s weight is not your concern.
But people who've worked hard to lose weigh (as opposed to unwanted weight loss or illness) often WANT you to comment.
DeflatedGinDrinker · 25/07/2021 16:29

I've gone from a size 12 to a 16 during lockdown and am made to feel like an absolute whale.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 25/07/2021 16:27

A few of my clients have asked me if I'm pregnant, told me I'm fat etc. A recent one was a fat guy who told me I'd put on loads of weight then said.... you don't mind me saying do you, as it's true. I had to say no as I was at work and need to be professional

MolyHolyGuacamole · 25/07/2021 14:52

@joystir59

All I can say is I'd swap a million statements on my thinness or fatness for one day without pan for y love.
@joystir59 I hope you get therapy for your anger and self hatred Thanks
WhatAShilohPitt · 25/07/2021 12:24

No, it’s beyond rude and they need to be embarrassed as much as possible for it since they don’t care much about whether they humiliate or embarrass you. Turn the table. Next time, adopt a look of shocked distress - and look utterly crushed at how awful their comment is. I’m not kidding. Who the fuck do they think they are?!

bythebanksof · 25/07/2021 12:01

In general, I'd never say anything like that. I guess the exception is my DH. He has put on weight while working from home, has done a lot less exercise. Told him I think he needs to lose the 10lbs!

However, even if I don't day it, if a person has put on a lot of weight then I certainly notice it, same as if they had lost a lot of weight.